CHAPTER XVIII.



MISCELLANEOUS


A Duel in Adams County—Fourth of July Celebration 1825—Scourge of

Asiatic Cholera—The Oldest House in Ohio—Trial and Execution

of David Beckett—Lynching of Roscoe Parker—Treason

Trial in Ohio—Anecdote of Judge Thurman—The Iron

Industry—Fugitive Slaves and the Underground

Railroad—A Blue Eyed Nigger—Postoffices

in Adams County.


A Duel in Adams County.


By DR. A. N. ELLIS.


I have been requested to prepare a sketch of the only duel that was ever fought on Adams County soil. To me it is a very interesting subject, for that fight took place on the farm where I was born and in the presence of a number of my blood-kin. From my earliest childhood I have heard the affair discussed by all of the old people of our neighborhood, especially by my father and mother, while away back yonder when I was a wee small boy I often saw the two principals in the affair eating And drinking and talking and enjoying themselves in my grandfather's 'hospitable home. Before going any farther permit me to gratefully acknowledge the assistance I have received from Mr. Hixson at the city library in looking up names and dates and details, and the kindness of may venerable friend Mr. John G. Hickman in placing in my hands a long and very interesting letter sent to the Cincinnati Commercial more than a score of years ago, by Col. Thomas M. Green, of Danville. Everybody in this section knows what a charming and accomplished writer Col. Green is. His former residence in Maysville and his long editorial connection with The Eagle admirably fitted him to collect and preserve all to data connected with the Marshall family, for he is a blood kinsman of the illustrious house.


The very spot where the encounter took place is hallowed by some of the sweetest and saddest associations of my childhood years, for within a stone's throw my brother Henry lost his life by drowning in the river, while a few hundred yards across the field toward the hill is our family

cemetery where rest my beloved parents. The trees under which the duel was fought have long since disappeared, and gone too is the river bank, swept away by as remorseless current as that other tide that is carrying us all away into the utter oblivion of death and forgetfulness!

Right here permit me to say that I am sorry that the task of putting the record of this historical duel into permanent shape was not committed to


(365)


366 - HISTORY OF ADAMS COUNTY


an abler pen than mine. Once I heard Senator John Sherman say in a public address before the old settlers of Southern Ohio, that there was more of the heroic, the tragic, the poetic and of the melo-dramatic in the history of this border land than in any of those old storied lands beyond the sea.


The bill now pending in the Ohio State Legislature empowering the commissioners of each county to spend as much as $500 in the matter of the presevervation of public records and private memoirs for the use of the future historian is a step in the right direction. By and by some great and gifted writer like Sir Walter Scott will arise in our midst and taking these broken links of individual and family history, personal ex- periences, records of daring deeds by flood and field, frayed out strands of men's fortitude and women's patience and suffering, will blend them all into one glorious warp and woof of authentic history—a book that will be read by all men and find a place in every home and school room.


In looking over the strange and eventful lives of Tom Marshall and Charley Mitchell it will be well to remember that their earlier years were spent in a time when the code duello was looked upon as a christianizer and ciyilizer, when there was a superabundance of whisky in every house, when schools and churches were few and far between, when the rule of might was the law of the road, when danger lurked in every fence corner when the courts were powerless to protect the helpless or to punish th guilty, when the conditions of life were so hard that men and worne grew old and gray before their time and when the black flag of slave obstructed the sunshine and threw its ominous shadow across the pat way of the Republic.


The Mitchell family came from Charles County, Maryland, and settled in Mason County, just after the war of the revolution. Ignatits Mitchell married a Bourbon County widow by the name of Mildred Mc Kee. They lived on a fine farm of coo acres some six miles below Mays ville and directly across from Charleston bar. From this marriage catm eight children, five of whom reached maturity. The eldest son, Richards became a distinguished officer of the navy and served throughout the w of 1812 with credit. Unfortunately he killed a brother officer in a des- perate duel, which led to his resignation from the service and cast a d gloom over his later years.

Charles Mitchell was born in 1792. From his earliest childhood he gave indications of the traits which afterward deYeloped into marked characteristics. He could brook no restraint and rebelled at all authority; defiant, proud, revengeful he struck at once at any and everyon who impeded the path he had worked out for himself or who he fancied assumed any superiority over him. For some imaginary slight he had received at home at the age of thirteen years, he swam to a passing flat- boat and worked his way to Natchez, where lived an uncle with whom 111 stayed three years. Becoming dissatisfied there he came back to Ken tucky, but too proud to go back to the home from whence he had fled h sought and obtained the position of deputy in the office of the Clerk ( Bourbon County. Next we hear of him, aS working for a merchant i Maysville, where he stayed till the breaking out of the war of 181 brought him the opportunity he had always longed for—the career of a


MISCELLANEOUS - 367


soldier ! He at once offered his services and was appointed an ensign in the regular army.


Captain Thomas Marshall, youngest brother of Chief Justice John Marshall, migrated from Virginia to Kentucky in 1790, settled in Mason Couy and married the sister of Wm. Kennan, uncle of the late Griffin ,Taylor of Cincinnati, and noted as one of the most intrepid of men of blood and iron who offered their bodies as ramparts for the defense of the white women against the tomahawk and scalping knife of the Indian! Among Capt. Marshall's sons were Gen. Thomas Marshall of the Mexican war and Col. Charles A. Marshall of the Sixteenth Kentucky Regiment of the war of the Rebellion.


Young Tom Marshall was from his cradle a born fighter and aristocrat and from the very beginning could not brook the thought that there was his equal in blood, brains and prowess in all the country around. Hence it will be readily seen that Mason County was too small for two such men as himself and young Mitchell, both of whom aspiring to be considered the "cock of the walk," in any company in which they were thrown.


Mitchell was about twenty years old, six feet high, raw boned, light hair and great big gray eyes—eyes that looked you full in the face with a gaze that told you plainly that here was a man who was bent on fighting his way through the world, though an enemy should be, found at every step.


Marshall was about a year younger than Mitchell, black haired and eyed, six feet in height, very small hands and feet and, a model of symmetry and manly beauty. Mitchell had long practiced with a pistol to be in readiness for such emergencies as were almost certain to arise, unti1 he could at twenty paces hit a swinging grape vine an inch in diameter two shots out of every three. Marshall was an expert with the rifle.


They had eyed each other askance for some time, but neither cared to give the other the choice of weapons. The ill feeling originated in the assumption, as Mitchell fancied, of social superiority on the part of Marshall, which he very bitterly resented. A, length, on account of same remark attributed to Marshall in reference to the commission in the army given to Isaac Baker and Charles Mitchell the former challenged Marshall, sending the message by the hands of the latter, which was promptly accepted and a meeting arranged. Baker's father and old Tom Marshall, who had been fellow soldiers and intimate friends during the war of the revolution soon put their heads together and resolved that their children should not fight, and so, soon adjusted the whole trouble in terms mutually honorable and satisfactory. But this termination was a sore disappointment to Mitchell, who cherished an ardent desire to figure in an affair of the kind, determined to balk the peace makers. It was not long before he embraced an opportunity of using language exceedingly offensive concerning the younger Marshall, which, being reported to the elder, disclosed to his mind a determination to force his son into a duel or degrade him in public estimation. He at once took proper steps to bring affairs to a focus. A challenge was at once addressed to Mitchell and delivered by the hand of James Alexander Paxton, a first cousin of Alex. K. McClung, who afterwards figured in Miss-


368 - HISTORY OF ADAMS COUNTY


issippi. The challenge was immediately accepted, the next morning named for the meeting. the weapons the old flintlock smoothbore dueling pistols, the distance ten paces, the place on the Ohio side, three miles above Aberdeen, on the farm of Washington Fllis. John Bickley was the second of Mitchell, Isaac Baker declining to act on account of the quarrel that had just been settled between him and Marshall. On the field, in attendance of Mitchell, beside his second, were John Chambers, afterwards aid to General Harrison and Governor of Iowa; James C. Pickett, distinguished as a publicist. Secretary of State under Govern Desha, Secretary of Legation to Columbia and Minister to Bolivia; Isaac Baker, distinguished for bravery at the River Raisin and other bloody engagements in the war of 1812.


Everyone knew that Marshal was almost certain to fall. After th ground was measured and all the details arranged Mitchell came cantering up on a little bobtail pony, the last man on the ground. Telling second that he did not intend to kill, but only to wound his antagonist, he took the position assigned to him as coolly as if sitting down to break fast. The word was given, both pistols were discharged, but Mitchell was the quickest and Marshall fell with a shattered thigh, struck exa where Mitchell said he would send his ball. Marshall, finding that could not stand, asked to he placed in a chair and to be allowed snot chance, but the seconds would not agree to this and the affair ended,


The following is tne formal announcement published by the seconds:


Maysville, Ky., April 19, 1812


"Mr. Thomas Marshall and Mr. Chas. Mitchell met this day, agreeable to their appointment in the State of Ohio, where the gentlemen took their stations and exchanged a shot. Mr. Mitchell, when the word was given, being quicker than Mr. Marshall, shot him in the hip, which extracted Mr. Marshall's fire.


" Both gentlemen acted with great firmness and bravery, as well as good conduct.

" James A. Paxton,

" John Bickley."


Old Capt. Marshall had arranged for a signal to be given by the party bringing his son, in case he should be hit, as every one expected and on hearing it turned to his wife and said : "Fanny, they are bringing Tom home !" which was the first intimation she had that her son was in peril. In a few minutes he was brought to her, stretched upon a board. He wrestled for some time with death, but lived to win a commission in the war. His second, Paxton, was afterwards aid-de-camp to both Gen. Harrison and Gen. Shelby. Marshall afterwards became identified with the Democratic party, and represented Lewis County twelve years in the Kentucky legislature, one term of which he was speaker of the house. During the Mexican war he was a brigadier general, and served with distinction and great address under both Generals Scott and Taylor. He was a prominent factor that led to the displacement of Gen. Scott by Gen. William 0. Butler in the presidential campaign of 1848, when Cass, of Michigan, headed the ticket. He had a fine estate of 2,000 acres in Lewis County, where he dispensed a royal and free-handed hospitality to all of his old friends and visitors. Finally he was treacherously murdered by one of his tenants by the name of Tyler, in 1853. His remains rest by the side of


MISCELLANIOUS - 389


his parents in the Washington Cemetery. Peace to his ashes! No one that ever met him could forget him.


Ensign Mitchell was promoted for gallantry to a first lieutenancy of rifles, and served with distinction during the war, during which time he fought two duels, the first with a lieutenant by the name of Bayless, the other with a captain whose name is unknown to the writer of these lines. In both of these encounters he came off without a scratch, but inflicted serious damage on both of his opponents.


In 1819, while in Cynthiana, Ky., he got into a fight with a Dr. McMillen, whom he left for dead in the street and fled to Texas. On his way to that part of the country—on the gulf between New Orleans and Galveston--the vessel was wrecked on an island, and almost all on and board perished. Mitchell was washed ashore and came near dying from hunger and starvation. Little is known of his life in Texas, as he would never talk about his ups and downs there. Hearing that Dr. McMillen was not dead, he returned to Kentucky, and soon got into trouble with his brother-in-law—a man by the name of Materson. They fought in a hotel in Ripley, in a room all to themselves—with knives. When the thing was over,. Mitchell had only a few cuts, while Masterson was almost dead from the wounds he had received. The floor and walls of the room looked like a slaughter pen. The next fight he had was with a great big man by the name of Stephen Lee, who –quietly and quickly picked him up and threw him down a stairway—a ,,Alistance of some twelve or fifteen feet. He struck on his head and 'was so badly hurt and stunned that he was not able to get out his favorite pistol. This also took place at Ripley. Mitchell was chosen as second by William H. McCardle, of Vicksburg, in the fight that did not come off between him and the late R. H. Stanton, of Maysville.


Gen. Tom Marshall was "the friend" of the latter. This brought the two old chaps together, and over a bottle of Madeira they made up, and afterwards lived on terms of friendship.

In 1844 John M. Clay, of Lexington, the youngest son of the great orator and statesman, was challenged by a Philidelphian named Hopkins, and both proceeded to Maysville to fight. Clay had a letter from his father to Mitchell, who at once proceeded to put him in training. The next morning Clay remarke'd to Mitchell that were it not for his age and probable unwillingness to participate in such an affair, that he would prefer him as a second to any one living.


"Oh, no," said Mitchell, firing under his left leg and peeling a two- inch sapling at twenty yards, "By Gad, sir, not too old yet to enjoy life." This idea of enjoying existence was quite a novel one to young Clay, whose blood ran cold at the suggestion. Hopkins withdrew his challenge, and the fight did not come off.


In his later years he was sent to the legislature from Mason County and served one term. He died in June, 1861, of heart disease. He rwas a strong Union man, and his last days were spent in lamenting that 'he was not at Fort Sumter with Major Anderson and been buried bet ,neath the ruins. He wanted to die amid the storm and whirlwind of -battle instead of on a bed of a painful and lingering disease.



370 - HISTORY OF ADAMS COUNTY


Upon his return from Texas, Col. Mitchell married a lady by the name of Fowke, by whom he had a number of children, and one of whom, Richard—evidently a chip off the old block—got into trouble with a man in Ripley by the name of Tomlinson, whom he killed oft the spot. Tomlinson was a prominent newspaper man, and a relative of the Wylies, of Brown County. The bloody affair took place on the very night thit John Morgan escaped from the Ohio penitential. Tomlinson's son, the Hon. Byers Tomlinson, late a member of the Ohio state legislature from Lawence County, is now publishing the Highland Register at Hillsboro.


Fourth of July Celebration, 1825.


The Village Register, then published by Ralph M. Voorhees, co tamed the following account of the Fourth of July celebration held West Union, in 1825:


The Fourth of July was celebrated in this place in a very handsome and becoming manner by Captains McClain's and Cole's corn and a large collection of the county and village.

The military, after going through the necessary forms and ades, marched into the court house, where the Declaration of Independence was read, and a very appropriate oration delivered by D. Wilkins, Fsq. After which the procession marched to Browning' Inn, where they partook of an excellent dinner prepared for the occasion. Major J. L. Finley, a revolutionary patriot, acted as presides and Col. John Lodwick, as vice president of the day. After the cloth was removed the following toasts were drank :


The Day We Celebrate.

The Constitution of the United States.

The Heroes and Patriots of the Revolution.

The Memory of Washington.

Literary Institutions.

The President of the United States.

The Congress of the United States.

The Army of the United States.

The Navy of the United States.

Agriculture. Internal Improvements.

Domestic Manufactures.

The Americas Fair.


Volunteers.


By A. Hollingsworth—Ohio River and Lake Frie—May they soon roll their floods together, inviting population to their banks, and cheering commerce to their crystal wharves.


By John McDaied—The memory of General Pike

By James Rodgers—Bolivar—The champion of South American Independence.

By Benjamin Paull—Gen. Andrew Jackson—The favorite of the friends of American Independence—the terror of those who would destroy the purity of our political institutions.


MISCELLANEOUS- 371


By D. P. Wilkins — Major J .L. Finley, president of the day — Among the last of the revolutionary patriots.


By John Lodwick—The brave Major Croghan and his companions in arms, 183, who defended Fort Stephenson against the British _and Indian army of 1,200 men, commanded by Gen. Proctor and Col. liott.


By G. W. Sherrard—American Freemen—May they appreciate their liberty and perpetuate their freedom.


By A. McIntire—The Representatives in the next State Legislature—May they at the critical period discharge their important trust.


By H. K. Stewart—The Fiftieth Year of American Independence -May this be a year of jubilee to the oppressed sons of Africa, and may slavery be expelled from the nation before the next fourth of July.


By Robert McDaied—May the members of the West Union Light Infantry feel that fire of patriotism, and that just pride and honor which fills the bosom of every true republican.


By John Patterson—The Citizens of the United States—"Behold how good and how pleasant it is for brethren to dwell together in unity.”


By A. Cole—D. P. Wilkins—The orator of the day.


By Henry Steece—The Goddess of Liberty—May the smile of her countenance be the Polar Star, to direct the weary traveler to the mansion of rest.


By John Fisher—The Second Tuesday of October next—In the on election of officers may the citizens of Adams County consult their best judgements, and not be influenced by clerical, medical, or political knaves and quacks.


SCOURGE OF ASIATIC CHOLERA.


Cholera in West Union in 1835.


June 28, 1899, was the sixty-fourth anniversary of that first awful scourge of Asiatic cholera in West Union. At that time West Union was an inland village of scarcely four hundred people. Then, as now, it was the county seat.


To show the flight of time and the passage of events, we note the public officers and some of the prominent citizens. Robert Lucas was then governor of the state, and Thomas Morris, of Clermont, and Thomas Ewing, of Fairfield, were the United States senators. Thomas L. Hamer, of Brown, represented the county and district in congress. Gen. James Pilson, of Brown, was state senator, and John Patterson was a member of the house of representatives from Adams. Hon. John W.. Price was the presiding judge of the court of common pleas, and Robert Morrison, Samuel McClannahan, and Joseph Fylar were the associate judges. William Kirker, Jacob Treber, and Seth Van Meter were the county commissioners. Gen. Joseph Darlinton was the clerk

of the courts. James Smith was county recorder. Leonard Cole was county auditor, and James Hood county treasurer. Joseph W. Lafferty was postmaster, and kept the office on the corner of Mulberry and Cherry streets, where James Moore formerly resided. Rev. John P. Vandyke was the minister of the Presbyterian Church ; Rev. James


372 - HISTORY OF ADAMS COUNTY


Caskey of the Associate Reformed Presbyterian Church, and Rev. John A. Baughman and Maxwell P. Gaddis of the Methodist Church. Rev- Dyer Burgess was residing in West Union at that time, in what is now the Palace Hotel. The village had but one physician. Dr. William B. Willson, who resided on the lot where Jacob Nam-inner now lives; but he had a medical student, Dr. David M. McConaughy, lately of Manchester. Dr. T. P. Hamilton, a son-in-law of Mrs. Jane Armstrong,. was there as a physician, but left when the cholera appeared and went. to Ripley. The lawyers of the place were the Hon. Nelson Barrere.- later of Hillsboro : George Collings, afterwards common pleas judge, and father of the present Judge Henry Collings; James Keenin, whose subsequent history is unknown to the writer; and Daniel P. Wilkins, who was one of the victims.


Alexander Woodrow and William Carl were undertakers and made coffins. The only newspaper published in the town was the Free Press, owned by Recorder James Smith and Robert Jackman, and was edited by James Carl. John Sparks was then conducting the West, Union Bank. The merchants of the village were Wesley Lee, Samuell McCullough, and James Hood. The grave digger at that time was Samuel Ross.


Of those named as citizens of West Union sixty years ago. all have passed away. There are only nine persons now residing in West Union who were living in 1835. These are Joseph Hayslip, Samuel Burwell, Sarah Boyles, Margaret Darlinton, Louis and Mary 0. Johnson, Mrs. Caroline Worstell, and William Allen and wife. Of those there during the scourge, but now residing away, only one is surviving at the date of this article, David Sinton, of Cincinnati, who is in his ninety-first year.


The cholera had ravaged Maysville, Ky., in 1832, and had7been in Cincinnati. Many citizens of Maysville and Cincinnati had spent the summer in West Union, and in the country, believing that the cholera would not come there. While, therefore, the citizens dreaded the cholera, and regarded it as a visitation of God, they hardly expected it to appear in their village. The people, however, had cause to apprehend its visitation. In 1833 Miss Sallie Sparks (nee Sinton), wife of John Sparks, the banker, had died at Union Landing. On the fourth of June, 1835, Alexander Mitchell, father of R. A. Mitchell, of Portsmouth, Ohio, and of Mrs. Samuel Burwell, had died of it at Maysville, Ky. His widow is now living at Portsmouth, Ohio, at the age of 0, and is in good health. Mitchell was only thirty years of age; and left four children. He was a miller on Brush Creek. He died at Maysville, Ky., on his way to Cincinnati. Dr. William Voris, who was with him when he died, a young man of 33 years, living at Brush Creek Forge, went on to Cincinnati, and was there taken with the dread disease, and died on June 7. He left a widow, the daughter of Col. John Means, and three young children, daughters. Both Mitchell and Voris were well known, and their tragic deaths created a profound impression:, on the village of West Union. There were many sad forebodings. The spring was backward and cold; there was much damp weather;! the weatherboarding of the houses collected an unusual amount of


MISCELLANEOUS - 373


green moss on the northern sides. The spring birds came as usual, but the martins departed before the cholera came.


Thursday before it appeared—June 25, 1835—there had been a heavy rain, the hardest ever known. Heavy wintry looking clouds hung in the sky. On Saturday afternoon Daniel P. Wilkins noticed an ominous looking cloud, and on going home at evening remarked to his

Wife that the cholera had come, and the strange cloud was its portent.


The Methodists had a quarterly meeting appointed for Saturday and Sunday. They held their meeting on Saturday and Sunday morning, but after the morning meeting. all fled. In an experience meeting on Saturday. Mrs. Hughes, who lived on the Robert Ellison farm, arose and stated that she did not fear man, cholera or the devil—all of which those who knew her believed to be strictly true. The connection in which she made this statement has not been eserved. The inference is that she did fear God, and Him only The presence of the dread visitant was known on Saturday morning at 10 o’clock. It was known at that time that Mrs. Prudence Woodrow, a young married woman, the wife of Alexander Woodrow, a cabinet maker, as he was then called, had the disease. She was the first one to be attacked. She suffered all night, and died the next day, the fateful Sunday. She was buried at 5 P. M. Sunday. Mrs. Rebecca Moody was the only woman who attended her interment.


Hamilton Dunbar, aged 53, the father of the now venerable David Dunbar, of Manchester, Ohio, was taken sick late in the evening, and died about 4 o'clock the next (Sunday) morning. He was buried that afternoon in the Lovejoy graveyard. His body was taken out in a wagon, and those who attended the funeral followed behind on foot. This was the usual custom at that time, when hearses were unknown. Hon. Nelson Barrere was one of those who followed the wagon containing the body.


Hamilton Dunbar's was the first death that day, though Mrs. Woodrow was the first one attacked. Mrs. Woodrow was the second one to die. She left four young children, Henry, Edgar, Andrew, and Prudence, all of whom lived to maturity, but the last three named have passed away. Henry is still living in Cincinnati. Samuel McCullough, aged sixty, who came from Rockbridge County, Virginia, about 1816, was keeping a store in a frame building where Miller's and Bunn's drug

store now stands. He had lost his wife the February previous, after a long illness of consumption, and was lodging in the rear of the store-room. He, too, was taken sick in the night. Cyrus Fllison, late of Ironton, was with him all night, and ministered to his needs as well as he could. Samuel McCullough was the father of the late Addison McCullough, of Ironton, and William McCullough, of Sidney, Ohio. He died at 5 A. M. on June 28, and was taken for burial to Tranquility, Ohio, the same day.


John Seaman lived outside of West Union about two miles. On the twenty-seventh he was at work for Abraham Hollingsworth, excavating the cellar of the house where Miss Caroline Hollingsworth formerly resided. He went home Saturday afternoon, expecting to resume work again Monday morning. He was in the prime of life, and


374- HISTORY OF ADAMS COUNTY


the father of the late Franklin Seaman. He was attacked in the night, and died on the twenty-eighth.


John Hyde was a young man from Maysville, Ky. He was visiting in Adams County at different places. On Saturday afternoon, the twenty-seventh, he went to the residence of his brother-in-law, the late John Loughridge, four miles south of West Union, to spend Sunday, He was in excellent health and spirits, and sat up late that evening talking with the family. He retired as well as any one At 2 o'clock on the morning of the twenty-eighth the cholera attacked him, and he began vomiting and had the most severe cramps. The rice-water discharges appeared at once, and he suffered until to o'clock in the morning, when he died. He was buried that evening on the Loughri farm. We have the account from the late John Loughridge, who resided in Manchester, and who was with him on that memorable day.


John Sinton, the father of David 3inton, of Cincinnati, was 71 year of age. He was taken with the disease and died on the twenty-eight. David Sinton, his son, was then at Union Landing. He was sent for by a messenger overland, but did not reach West Union until two days after his father had been buried. John Sinton was buried on Sunday evening in the village cemetery.


Rebecca Cluxton was a young married woman, 19 years of age. She was the wife of Jedediah Foster, and the handsomest woman ib the village. She was taken at noon on the twenty-eighth, and died that day, and was buried in the village cemetery. Her husband was engaged in the manufacture of chairs in the village. They were made at that time principally by hand, and not by machinery. Mrs. Foster was buried in an unstained poplar coffin at 9 A. M. on Monday morning, the twenty-eighth. Her body was hauled to the cemetery in David Bradford's wagon. Mrs. Nancy Hollingsworth was with her from her attack until she died. She left a seven months old baby, a daughter who grew to maturity and married Jedediah Foster. Her husband is living at Chester, Ky.


John H. Thomason, a boy aged 14, was taken with the disease and died on the 28th. The Thomason boy ate his dinner on Sunday and was taken sick right away. He died towards evening and was buried before dark on the same evening.


Thus, eight persons died that Sunday when the disease appeared and all within six or eight hours from the time they were attached. The village was at once shut up; no one went in and no one came out except the Armstrong family, whose members went to Ripley. The country people would not come to the village for their mail or anything else. The citizens, as much as possible remained in their homes and did not go out, except to minister to the sick, or to bury the dead. They would eat no fruits, believing if they did, they would be attacked with the cholera. They lived chiefly on bread and milk. There was one notable and noted exception; this was Rev. Dyer Burgess. He went everywhere and told the people that slavery was worse than the cholera. He circulated his abolition tracts right along, and wherever he could nurse the sick, or pray with them, or minister to their needs in any way, he would do so, and it made no difference whether the persons ministered to were friends or enemies. He alone, of all the


MISCELLANEOUS - 375


people in the village, ate all the fruit he wished ; and to show his contempt for current theories during the scourge, he sat in his front door and ate publicly, a whole dish of sliced cucumbers, which, at that time, were believed to be sure death. Rev. Burgess had defied public sentiment so long and so vigorously as to slavery and masonry, that it was no difficulty with him, to defy it as to cholera.


On June 3oth, Levi Rogers died. He was a farmer northwest of the village. He had been a chair-maker in West Union. He was buried in the Kirker Cemetery. On July 1st William McGovney died.


On July 7th, Susan Hollingsworth, a girl of twelve years, the daughter of Abraham Hollingsworth, died. She was sick only eight hours. During the pestilence, the father and mother visited all the sufferers and ministered to them.


On July 11th, Daniel P. Wilkins died, aged thirty-seven. He was one of the lawyers of the village, and the father of Mrs. John Fylar, and the grandfather of Mr. John A. Eylar, of Waverly. He was attacked at ten o'clock in the morning of July 11th. Dr. Willson was called but failed to arrest the course of the disease. Rev. Dyer Burgess called at eleven o'clock, but did not remain because he saw no prospect of a favorable termination of the case. The victim's pulse ceased to be noted at the wrist one hour after he was attacked. At 3 P. M. there were several standing around him and he remarked that "A regiment of men could not console a dying man at such an hour as this.”



He continued to sink until 8 P. M. when he died.


On the following day, July 12, Roland Dyer died at the age of thirty-two. He was a stage driver and a single man. On July 13th, Col. John McDade died; he was a well known citizen and had been sheriff of the county.


Death then rested from his labors until July 29th, when he took Mrs. Sarah Armstrong. At the beginning she had gone to Ripley to escape the disease. After the death of Col. McDade, she came home, opened her house and died.


On August 3rd, Captain John Vance died. He was the last victim and the sixteenth one who died; and at this point the scourge was stayed.


Those were the primitive days. All of these victims were buried with their feet to the east, in shrouds, made of white jaconet. Mrs. Wm. Killin made the most' of them. The family in which the death occurred purchased the material, and the usual price of making was one dollar, a great sum in those days. No person in West Union was buried without a shroud, till in 1849. Wesley Lee was the first person in West Union ever buried in a suit of clothes.


Alexander Woodrow, William Carl and Robert Wood were coffin makers of that day. The coffins were all made to measure after death; were usually made of walnut, and plain, waxed or polished as parties ordered.


 Coffins were not lined and hearses were unknown at that time; but even then the custom of carrying the corpse on a bier borne on men's shoulders, had ceased. The dead were hauled to the cemeteries in a common road wagon, and the mourners or friends, walked be-


376 - HISTORY OF ADAMS COUNTY


hind. The cholera funerals were attended only by a sufficient number to make the interment,—usually three to four, and there were no religious exercises whatever.


There were two persons in the village, reckless dissipated men, who at this time showed themselves heroes. They were David Bradford and Samuel Ross. They went everywhere, ministered. to the sick and dying, and attended the funerals. They did not hesitate to expose themselves in any manner to the risk of the disease. They vied with the Rev. Burgess in their good offices in every family which had the disease. There were no paid or trained nurses in those days, and the nursing and care of the sick was a voluntary matter. These three persons came forward and made themselves the cholera nurses of that time. Samuel Ross dug most of the graves. The latter has been forgotten but his good deeds are no doubt preserved by the Recording Angel.


Oblivion is fast claiming the record of the time. No one contemporaneous wrote it up, and in searching for information, I have been met on every hand by failure and disappointment. Most of the old people, who could at one time, recollect it, have their faculties so affected by the infirmities of age, that they cannot recall it ; and those who might have recollected, have forgotten, and the facts here presented, were obtained only after the most long continued and faithful research.


The Cholera of 1849.


In this year, the cholera prevailed in three places in Adams County; in West Union, in Jefferson Township and in Wayne Township. It had been fourteen years since the epidemic of 1835, and the people felt safer, In this case, as in that of 1835, the disease was brought from Cincinnafi, Adam McCormick was one of the most prominent citizens of Adams County. He had married Margaret Ellison, the daughter of Andrew Ellison. He resided in the brick house, now the Palace Hotel. Hi owned numerous farms in Adams County and real estate in Cincinnati He was a member of the Baptist Church in West Union, the most prominent layman in it, and superintendent of its Sunday school. He ha come from Ireland, a penniless youth and acquired a fortune. He had been to Cincinnati to attend to business relating to his property the He came home about July 1st. On the second he took the cholera, early on the morning of the third, he died and was buried the same da The Rev. Allgood, a Baptist minister, conducted his funeral servic Dr. William F. Willson was then practicing medicine in West Uni as was Dr. David Coleman, and they were in partnership. They tended him. He was 65 years of age and his death was a great loss the community. Robert S. Willson attended his funeral on the third. At 9 A.' M. on the fourth, he was taken violently ill, and suffered extremely until 8 P. M., when he died. Dr. William F. Willson attend him, but was unable to give any relief or save him. He was 61 years age and left a large family of sons and daughters. He was buried the next day in the village cemetery, and Rev. John Graham, D. D., th pastor of the Associate Reformed Presbyterian Church attended the funeral. On the 13th, Rev. Graham was taken sick with the cholea and died with it on the 15th. He had a very severe case and suffered


MISCELLANEOUS - 377


tensely. At the time he died, his son David, was lying seriously ill with the disease too sick to know of his father's death. The son, however, recovered. Rev. Graham had lived in West Union since 1841. He was of the brightest type of Christian character and was much beloved. He

left a widow, two grown sons and three daughters. He received a public funeral and was buried in the village cemetery. On July 17th, the cholera broke out in Jefferson Township. James Scott, aged 61, died that day. Mary A. Mason died July 21st, David Mason died July 26, Margaret Mason died July 28, aged 27 and Samuel Mason died July 29th. These were in the eastern part of the township. John Edminston brought the disease front Cincinnati to Cedar Mills. He had an

attack of the disease as soon as he returned from the city and he recovered, but three of the members of his family died. Then the widow Beatty and daughter had it. They both recovered. John Nichols and his child then took it. He recovered and the child died. Then three of Madison Bradney's children took it, but all recovered. Samuel Wallace, his wife and child had it. He and his wife died. His child recovered. J. M. Fisher had an attack and recovered. There were two

cases in the same vicinity in 1852. Isaac Smith brought it from Cincinnati and died July 19th. James N. Fisher, who recovered of it in 1849, died of it July 20, 1852. Dr. David Coleman attended all the cases at Cedar Mills in 1849 and 1852 except that of Isaac Smith.


The epidemic was brought to the vicinity of North Liberty in the summer of 1849. The germs were brought in the body of Samuel F. McIntire, who had visited Cincinnati. He was the son of Col. Andrew McIntire. He was 29 years of age. He took the disease and succumbed in a few hours. His father, Col. Andrew McIntire, aged 63, died of it the next day, and his mother, Elizabeth McIntire, aged 62, died of it within thirty minutes from the death of her husband. Three more of the McIntire family had it, but recovered. They were S. Dyer McIntire, Jane McIntire and L. Lindsey McIntire, two sons and a daughter of Col. Andrew McIntire.


John F. Wasson resided on an adjoining farm to that of Col. McIntire. He and his wife and sons and daughters attended the family of Col. McIntire during their sickness of cholera. Samuel H. Finley and Margaret Wylie, a maiden lady, neighbors, were at the house of Col. McIntire during his sickness and on the occasion of his death. About August 10, 1849, the two latter each took the cholera and died. Finley was aged 22 years and Miss Wylie, about 40. Samuel C. Wasson, aged 45, a brother of John F., took the cholera and died August 11th.. His wife, Jane, aged 42, died of it on the 14th. John F. Wasson and his wife Rebecca, both had it about August 10. 1849, and both recovered. James Park, a neighbor, also had it and recovered.


The course of these cases would prove clearly that cholera was propagated by germs or bacilli, and that the period of incubation is from a week to ten days. From F. McIntire's visit to Cincinnati until his , attach was about ten days, and those persons who took it from the epidemic in the McIntire family took it about ten days after their exposure to the disease at Col. McIntire's residence. No precautions were taken at that time to destroy the germs or prevent the spread of the disease. It is remarkable that there were not more cases in the vicinity


378 - HISTORY OF ADAMS COUNTY


of Cherry Fork. Had the facts upon the subject now known, been known then, Col. McIntire’s family might have been saved and if that could not have been done, the lives of all the others who died in that vicinity, would certainly have been saved.


The cholera also prevailed at Jacksonville (Dunbarton P.O.)in August 1849. Dr. Cephas Little died of it. He was about the age of 60. Dr. Wheaton, about the same age, also died of it. Samuel Ellison, about the same age, died of it. Abraham Wisecup, an aged man, also died of it: Samuel Thomas, aged about 60, died of it. William Thoromon’s wife died of it. These deaths all occurred within a period of a few weeks. The victims were all buried within a few hours after death. Dr. Andrew Barry Jones went to the village after the death of persons above named. There were several cases after he came , but all recovered.


THE CHOLERA IN WEST UNION IN 1851.


At that period, the pestilence was looked upon as the visitation of God. People dreaded it as such and felt helpleSs before it. They felt prepared to die when it attacked them and many died from fear of the disease. Had the people in West. Union known what we know now, they could not only have prevented the scourge, but have stayed it after its outbreak. In 1835, in 1849 and in 185t, it was in each instance brought from Cincinnati. West Union then, as now, had. no sanitary

regulations. It was built on a hill and its entire soil, below a few feet, is underlaid with solid limestone. There is no way to drain the town except by surface draining. The vaults are nowhere over three to four feet deep and their content can drain into the wells and may do so. The writer believes that all cases of typhoid fever in the village might be traced to this scource. Just before St. John's day in 1851, Francis Shinn, then auditor of the county, and one of the most prominent

popular men in the county, went to Cincinnati to procure supplies for a Masonic celebration which had been planned for that day. Wilson Prather also went at the same time. The weather had been sultry and rainy for some time before the outbreak and during the pestilence it rained frequently and torrents poured down. The Masonic celebration was held June 24, 1851 in the court house yard. Mr. Shinn had exhausted himself in his trip to Cincinnati and in his work on the day, of celebration. He at that time resided at the southeast corner of W and Market streets in the property afterwards used by J. W. Lafferty for carding machines. He went home on the evening of June 24th, tired and worn out and that evening was attacked with cholera, the first case

in the village. A great many people rushed in to see him and to tender their sympathies and services. This continued until his death, early in the morning of June 26th and until after his death and funeral, the people of the village flocked to his house. It was arranged that he should have a public Masonic funeral on the 27th, which was given him. Mrs. Margaret Buchanan remained in his home from the beginning of his sickness until his funeral. Then she and her husband and child drove overland to Chillicothe, Ohio, and remained there until July 9th when they returned home. There was no further case of the disease until July 1st, when George Shinn, the father of Francis Shinn, who had been


MISCELLANEOUS - 379


at his son's house on a visit, when the latter was taken sick and had remained over until after his son died. The father was sick but. a few hours and died in the early morning hours of July 2d. On July 6th, Mrs. Elizabeth Lytle, mother of Mrs. Frances Shinn, and who had been visiting here, there, took sick and died. On the 7th, Francis A. G. Shinn, a son of Francis Shinn, took the disease and died. Thus four persons died in the same house.


On July 9th, Horatio Cole, who lived at the foot of the hill on the Decatur road, whose system had been weakened by the free use of liquor, was attacked in the afternoon. He was taken to the Marlatt Tavern, and died at 8 o'clock that evening and was buried that night. On the evening of the 9th of July, Mrs. Margaret Lee Buchanan and her husband, John Buchanan and their child returned from Chillicothe, Ohio, where they had been staying for some days. All of them were feeling quite well, but on that evening Mrs. Buchanan was attacked by the disease in its worst form. She suffered the most extreme agony for a few hours and then died Mrs. Minnick attended her as a nurse and physician and said that no other case in West Union suffered as she did. She was only sick about six hours. On the 11th, Mrs. Mary Lafferty, an aged lady, died, and on the 12th, John Buchanan, husband of Margaret Buchanan, died. On the 13th of July, Thomas Prather, a boy, son of Wilson Prather, died, and on the same day, Ann Olivia Prather, a beautiful girl of fifteen years, his daughter, died. Thus eleven had died within fifteen days and in four families only, but many more had been sick with bowel disease and what they believed to be cholera. The principal physician of the place, Dr. David Coleman, had been busy all the time and was almost exhausted. He had attended nearly all the cases, Dr. Sprague having left and gone to the house of his friend, Oliver Tompkins, on Gift Ridge, just after the outbreak of the pestilence. Mrs. Barbara Minnick acted as nurse and physician both during the epidemic and did most unremitting work. Both Dr. David Coleman and she earned their crowns and harps from Heaven, during the scourge, and are doubtless enjoying them now. It is a great pity that they did not each write out and leave behind them their experiences. During the fifteen days the disease first prevailed, the volunteer nurses were David Graham, Frank Hayslip, Porter Marlatt, Michael Mider, John and William Holmes. The undertakers were George M. Lafferty, Joseph Hayslip, Alexander Woodrow and William Carl. Lafferty and Hayslip were partners. Alexander Woodrow and William Carl had separate shops. They made all their coffins after receiving orders, except Mr. Woodrow who aimed to keep seven or eight ahead, but all were made of walnut by hand. Thomas H. Marshall and James R. Oldsen were the grave diggers at that time. Nelson B. Lafferty then a boy of thirteen went everywhere, carrying messages keeping off flies, doing errands etc, He exposed himself everywhere among the sick and dying and was untouched. It is largely due to his excellent memory that this article is as full as it appears.


After the funeral of Francis Shinn, there were no more public funerals of the cholera victims, and no religious exercises at them, except in case of Gen. Darlinton when Rev. Vandyke repeated a prayer at the grave. The only attendants at the funerals, subsequent to those of


380 - HISTORY OF ADAMS COUNTY


Francis Shinn, were just sufficient to make interment. Many left the town after the 54th. Fdward P. Evans and his wife had both been sick, and on the 15th, they took their son Wiley, and Mrs. Fvans' mother, Mrs. King, and went to Decatur. Ohio, where they remained till after the plague was abated. When the disease broke out a second time on July 24th, there was a general exodus of the inhabitants and this by the advice of Dr. Coleman. About June 28th, David Graham went to Chillicothe, when his sister Ellen (now Mrs. Gowdy of Des Moines, Iowa) was teaching and remained a considerable time. Mrs. Minnick went to Chillicothe about the 28th of June and returned at the same time with Mr. and Mrs. Buchanan. David Graham told his sister, Fllen, on his arrival at Chillicothe, that if he took sick with cholera to send for Mrs. Minnick, then in the town, for she had been very successful with her little pills.


The family of Col. Cockerill went to his father's at Mt. Leigh. Mr. and Mrs. McCauslen, just married the winter before, went to Aberdeen. Judge Smith's family went to Yellow Bud, and many others went into the country near by. Alex. Mitchell, then eighteen years of age, was an apprentice working for Lafferty and Hayslip, and saw much of the epidemic. Joseph W. Lafferty and his family did not leave, nor were they attacked by the disease, though persons died all around them. This can be attributed to the fact that as soon as the disease appeared Mr. Lafferty consulted Dr. Coleman, obtained a number of remedies and kept them at hand. He fixed a diet for his family and all lived up to it. At the slightest appearance of any symptoms of bowel disease, he began giving remedies and as a result, he and his family all came out unseathed when their neighbors died. On July 24th, the cholera deaths beagain and continued for nine days. On that day, Mary B. Prather, a daughter of Wilson Prather died. On the 26th, George Grant, her mother's brother died. On the 27th, Miss Margaret McCauley, Lewis Sanders, William Santee and Miss Caroline McCauley all died, last three being young persons. On the 29th, Miss Caroline Lafferty (whose grandmother had died on the 11th) and Miss Alice Brooks Prather died. On the 30th, there were four deaths, Mrs. Jane Crawford, Mrs. Mary Hitchens, Francis M. Hayslip and his sister Margaret. The two latter died within five minutes of each other.


On the 31st of July, Andrew Haines died. On the first of August Miss Cornelia Santee died. On the 2d day of August, Gen. Joseph Darlinton, Mrs. John Sanders and Robert Jackman, the postmaster and publisher of the West Union Intelligencer died, and there the disease stayed.


During the prevalence of the disease in the village, the following persons died in the vicinity: Parker Young, Miss Mary Young, Miss Eltzannah Owen, Arthur McFarland and Wilson Crawford. After the burial of Francis Shinn, all the victims were buried, within four hours after death Gen. Darlinton died about 7 A. M. and was interred at 11 A. M. But our persons attended his funeral, Geo. M. Lafferty, the undertaker ; his son Doddridge ; his grandson, Edward, and the Rev. John P. Vandyke. Four of the victims were buried by night ; Horatio N. Cole, Mrs. Hitchens, Jane Crawford and Robert Jackman. Mrs. Hitchens was taken sick, in the morning and died in the evening. Between the 20th


MISCELLANEOUS – 381


of July and the zd of August, all places of business were closed. The most of the inhabitants had fled. The grass grew rank in the streets, except certain spots where great fires had been built and tar barrels burned for the purpose of purifying the air. The country people would not come into the village for any purpose, but would open the fields adjoining and go around it. James Hood gave the key of his store to Dr. Coleman and told him of a barrel of brands, in his cellar and of the contents of the store and to help himself and others to any and all of it, and then left the town. Doctors Shackelford of Maysville and Vanmeter of Ecksmansville, each spent one day among the cholera patients est Union. During the disease, fruit and vegetables were avoided and the people subsisted on ham, bread, butter and tea. Mutton was thought to be a suitable diet in that time and was freely used. Mr. Abraham Hollingsworth undertook to and did supply mutton and motton broth to the families having cholera cases, and he was a ministering angel during the disease. There was a feeling of gloom, of sadness and awe pervaded the community during the epidemic. Men and women moved about in silence. Each one lived every hour as though he or

she expected the next call from the Fell Destroyer. Business not thought of. In fact, there was not business except to attend to the sick and dying and to bury the dead as quickly as possible.


The fact that Joseph W. Lafferty and his family of five persons, breathed the same atmosphere and drank the same water as the cholera patients and remained through the entire thirty-seven days of the epidemic without being attacked, speaks volumes for the virtue of precaution. Dr. David Coleman has left the statement that there were premonitory symptoms of the attack from 12 to 24 hours before the disease could he pronounced cholera, and that if the patient sought medical aid and relief at the very outset of the symptoms, he could be relieved in nearly every case,. but if he waited until he had a well developed case. the disease was more likely to prove fatal. The fact is that most of the victims would not apply for medical assistance until the disease was fully developed in them. Another fact was that many of the patients, when attacked, gave up at once to lie and then died. Had every one taken precautions, there would have been but few deaths, but in those days, cholera was looked upon as a deadly disease and those attached, at once gave up all hopes.


Gen. Darlinton had dreaded it since 1835. When attacked he at once succumbed. His great age, however, was a factor against him. However, while no age was spared, the young people furnished the greater number of victims. Dr. David Coleman went everywhere among the cholera patients. For ten days or longer of the plague, he was the only physician. He was not attacked, neither were any of his family. Mr. J. W. Lafferty, who took all the precautions suggested by Dr. Coleman, prevented his family from any attack. There is no doubt but that those who died, neglected precautions and preliminary symptoms until the disease was fully developed in them and then it was too late. We now know that cholera is a germ disease. That by proper sanitary precautions both by the community and the individual, its attacks can be prevented. It is a disease which can only flourish where there is neglect of the proper preventives. No com-


382 - HISTORY OF ADAMS COUNTY


munity in the state ever suffered with cholera as did West Union. For a long time after the epidemic of 1851, the whole town was depressed. It was thought that if cholera ever again visited the United States, West Union would be first to be scourged. Real estate, for several years after the cholera, was sold remarkably cheap, and it took years to bring the values back.


But we now know that the experience of the town of 1851 need never be repeated and that cholera can never scourge the community again, unless the people fail and refuse to take the precautions which will surely keep the disease at bay. That they will do, and so the story of the cholera in 1851 will go down to posterity as a chapter that will never be repeated in the history of the town. There is no doubt the cholera germs were brought there by Francis Shinn and Wilson Prather from Cincinnati. There is no doubt but that the whole town was infected by the attendance at the house of Francis Shinn during his sickness and after his death, until his funeral, and by neglect to burn the dejections from the cholera patients. It was also fostered and helped by neglect of those taken sick to be treated in the earliest symptoms of the disease, and many died of fear, believing the disease, once fully developed, was necessarily fatal. It will be noted that of the volunteer cholera nurses who devoted themselves without stint to the sick and dying, only one died, Frank W. Hayslip, and none but he took the disease.


If ever West Union should erect a monument to the memory the victims of the scourges of 1835, 1849 and 1851, there beside names of the victims should appear the names of Dr. David Coleman*. Mrs. Barbara Minnick and the volunteer nurses, David B. Graha William Holmes, Porter Marlatt, John Holmes and Michael Mider, None of them considered their lives in their labor. No greater hero is was ever shown anywhere than by these persons. When most of th population left, they remained and did their work regardless of the consequences to themselves.

And may their heroic services be remembered as long as the to exists.


The Oldest House in Ohio.


There is a spot on the Ohio River four miles above Manchester whose natural beauty attracted the admiration of the untutored savages who roamed the primitive forests before they had ever met the white men. There they visited and there they maintained an outlook up and down the Ohio River and over the adjacent country. There they buried their distinguished dead, whose graves are known to this day. But the Indians were not the only ones whom the spot impressed with its beauty. The first white man who ever visited it was so charmed by the natural beauty of the situation and surroundings that he immediately took steps to and did secure it as his own.


Gen. Nathaniel Massie visited this place in 1791, and so delighted was he with it that he proceeded to locate it as his own. It is a high, almost level plateau of land, even with the tops of the river hills around it, bounded on the south for a half mile by the Ohio River on the east and west by the valleys of two small tributaries of the


MISCELLANEOUS - 383


Ohio River, Donaldson's Creek, and Ellison's Run, and connecting at the north with Gift Ridge, a long and wide stretch of table land, parallel with the Ohio River for some miles. The southeast corner of this plateau affords a most magnificent view up the Ohio River, and valley for ten miles and over the fertile farms in Kentucky opposite. The view is much finer now than it was in 1791. Then there was nothing but forests everywhere, with the sparkling waters of the Ohio, like a silver thread amid the solid emerald; but besides the view up and down the river and across into the rich valley lands in Kentucky, there is now a view of the ridges, table lands, and forest covered hills to the north that is as entrancing as the views to the east, to the south and to the west.


Gen. Massie built a cabin of buckeye logs here on the southeast corner of the plateau and called it Buckeye Station. Here he came to hunt, to enjoy the grand views, to rest and recuperate himself. To secure his choice location from the Indians he took up the entire Gift Ridge to the north of it for four or five miles, with military warrants, and gave the land to those who would settle on it and thus placed a cordon between him and the hostiles. Massie was a brave man but he liked company when the Indians were expected. So captivated with his place was he that, notwithstanding the fact that he laid out Chillicothe in 1796, and then took up a fine body of land on Paint Creek, in Ross County, in the summer of 1797, he proceeded to erect a frame house on this place, when the erection of a frame house was a remarkable undertaking. The house is located about ten rods back of the cliff on the south, overlooking the Ohio River and about five rods from the bluffs on the east overlooking Donaldson's Creek, where on April 22, 1791, Israel Donalson was captured by a band of Indians. The timbers and boards for the inside and, out, and for the floors were sawed out by hand with whip saws, and every nail in it was made by a blacksmith on an anvil. The house is but one story, but has two marvelously fine chimneys, one single and one double. Those chimneys were built most substantially. They stand ay as perfect today as when, one hundred and three years ago, the mason gave them the last stroke of his hammer and trowel.


The front of the house is to the south, with a side front to the east. Two rooms face the east, looking up the Ohio, and between them is the great double chimney. To the west is a wing with a hall and one large room, with the other stone chimney at the west end. The hall fronts the south, and besides the door on each side are two windows to enable the inmates to inspect a guest before his admission. After entering the hall, there is a door on each side, entering the east and west rooms. Entering the east room from the hall, we find a window to the south and another to the east, with very small panes of glass. The walls of this room and the other two were lined with wide, primitive boards and ceilings only were plastered. The floors were made of wide old-fashioned boards, such as are now no longer seen. The fire-place, in the east room is a feature. It is four feet high from the hearth to the arch and eight feet wide. To the left of this fireplace, as one stands before it, is a closet under the stairway from the north room. To the right is a door leading into the north room.


384 - HISTORY OF ADAMS COUNTY


Entering that we find a door and window to the east and a door and window to the west, the latter opening into a porch in the reat of the hall and west room. The fire place in this room was as capacious as that in the room north of it. The right of the chimney in the north room was a stairway leading to two attic rooms, sided and ceiled with hoards over the north and south rooms. These rooms were quite small and no doubt had been used as sleeping rooms for guests. Tha porch to the north of the west room extended along it and the south end of the hall. The west room had the long stone single chimney and over it an old-fashioned wooden-mantle of walnut, carved an figured, which, when the home was built, was the pride of the proprietor and the envy of his neighbors. The spaces between the outee weather boarding and the inner ceilings of the room had been fill with mortar. The floor boards, though very wide, were tongued an grooved and the weather boards were put on pointed instead of ove lapped. It is probable there had been additions to the house, but the were gone when we visited it. The grounds about the house were one time tastefully laid out, and traces of the vanished beauty wer still apparent. Two locust trees, the largest the writer ever saw, sta in front of the house to the south. They are each at least ten in circumference and not less than 100 years old. Between them stood a monster cherry, and the trunk, prone on the earth, spoke of grandeur when alive. At the northwest of the house, about ten yards distance, stands a living black heart cherry tree which measures thirteen feet, six inches in girth. Its spreading limbs, projecting horizontally, are as large as ordinary trees of its kind.


While this house overlooks the one great highway, the Ohio River, and the other great highway, the Chesapeake and Ohio Railroad, with all boats and trains in view for miles, it is now one of the most inaccessible spots in the state. The hills in front descend sheer into the Ohio River without any shelf or bottom land within nearly a mile on either side of the property. It is only approachable by a road coming through farms from Gift Ridge in the rear and it is two miles from the station over the roughest and most primitive of roads, over stones and up and down hills to the nearest turnpike, or public highway. In early days when roads were of no consequence, it had a direct road to and from Manchester. The fact that the home is so out of the way has perserved it. Had it been upon a public highway, it would have been destroyed by fire, or torn down years ago. There are seven fine springs flowing from the hill sides near the residence.


In a military point of view it is strategic. A fort on this property would command the Ohio valley up and down for miles, would command the Kentucky hills to the south and the Ohio hills to the north Fort Thomas, near Newport, Kentucky, should have been located here, and whenever it becomes necessary to have forts along the Ohio border, there will be one here.


At this place, Gen. Massie dwelt occasionally for the five years from 1797 till 1802, but the shades of oblivion are so fast darkening the history of this hardy pioneer that little can be learned of his residence at that time. Gen. Massie's wife was Susan Meade, of Chau-


MISCELLANEOUS - 385


merie, Kentucky, formerly of Maycox, Prince George County, Va. Her sister married Charles Willing Byrd, Secretary of the Northwest Territory, succeeding Winthrop Sergeant and United

States District Judge for Ohio from March 3, 1803, until August 11, 1828. Judge Byrd bought this property, 600 acres, in 1807, of his brother-in-law, Gen. Massie, for $3,100, and moved there in June, 1807. He was then thirty-seven, and his wife was thirty-two, and his children were Mary, aged nine; Powell, aged 6 ; Kidder Meade, aged five; William Silonwee, aged two ; and his daughter Evelyn, was born there in August, 1807. Judge Byrd had been born and reared at the

princely estate of Westover, seven miles from Williamsburg, Va., and his wife on the large estate of her father, Col. David Meade, at Maycox, right opposite Westover. Both had been reared in all the luxury that the times of their childhood knew. From 1799 to 1807 they had resided in Cincinnati, then an insignificant village, and why Judge Byrd wanted to bring his young wife, and babies to this wilderness, no one can now conjecture. Here he and his family saw the first steamboat descend the Ohio in 1811, and here his patient wife went to her evert lasting reward on the 31st day of February, 1815, and was buried under a walnut tree some 200 yards from the house. Her grave is shown to this day,


That must have been a mournful procession of the Judge and his family, he then forty-five, Mary seventeen, Powell sixteen, Kidder twelve, William ten, and Fvelyn eight, accompanied by his neighbors, bearing the fair daughter of Virginia, who had graced its best society and seen and known as the father's friend, the immortal Washington, to her last resting place, in the then primitive Ohio forest. There her remains have reposed for seventy-nine years, and though, in that

time, the whole face of nature about the spot has changed, and wilderness and forest have yielded to plains and fertile fields and pleasant homes, yet if it is aught to the dead as to the scenery about the place of their last repose, there are no finer views anywhere on earth, horizon or sky, than surrounds this hallowed earth, and no fairer place for the fulfillment of the decree of "earth to earth" on the mortal part, could have been selected.


After this, the place being intolerable to Judge Byrd, and craving human society, he moved with his sons to the village of West Union, which had been laid out in 1804, and sent his daughters to Chamerie, Ky., to be reared by their grandfather, Col. David Meade. He sold the station to John Ellison, son of Andrew Fllison, of Lick Fork, for $4,000. John Ellison resided there from 1818 to 1829, the time of his death, and here most of his large family was born. His wife was Annie Barr, whose father, Samuel Barr, had been killed in a battle between Kentuckians under Maj. Simon Kenton, and Indians under Tecumseh in March, 1792. Here all but the two eldest of John Ellison’s children were born. Andrew was born in 1808, in Manchester, and spent a long life there. Sarah, the second child, was born in 1818 in Manchester, but was married at the station to the late Thomas W. Means, of Hanging Rock. There John Fllison's daughter, Mary K., was married to William Fllison, her distant cousin, and there her sister Esther was married to the late Hugh Means, of Ashland, Ky.


386 - HISTORY OF ADAMS COUNTY


Jane Ellison, another daughter was the wife of David Sinton, of Cincinnati. She was born there, but was married to Mr. Sinton at the home of Thomas Means, at Union Landing. She died in Manchester, Ohio, in 1853, and is buried there in the Presbyterian churchyard. Her daughter is the wife of Hon. Charles P. Taft, editor of the Times Star.


Here the late John Ellison, the banker of Manchester, was born, and here he spent a happy childhood and boyhood, whose joys he never tired of recounting among his friends. While the Ellison’s resided there, the Station had many distinguished visitors from Cincinnati, Maysville, Hanging Rock and other points. Among others, Mrs. John F. Keyes, nee Margaret Barr, a daughter of Samuel Barr, before mentioned, spent the summer of 1832 here and remained till after the frost to escape the dread pestilence, the Asiatic Cholera, then prevalent. She returned to Cincinnati after the first frost in the fall of 1832, and was at once taken with the cholera and died within a few hours. The pioneers who knew this place, who had many joyous meetings here, and their natural foes, the Indians, are all gone to the shadow land, but the beauties of the landscape and of the natural scenery which charmed the untutored savage, the hardy pioneer and the deer hunter, the early settlers, still remains to produce, like sentiments in those who choose to look upon it.


THE TRIAL AND EXECUTION OF DAVID BECKETT.


The most noted case in the annals of crimes in Adams County is that of The State v. Beckett. This is so, not from the fact alone that it records the first homicide committed within the county after its organization, nor from the fact that the trial resulted in the only legal execution of the death penalty ever imposed in the county; but, the circumstances under which the crime was committed, the brutality of the act itself, the inexplicable conduct of Beckett after committing the deed, the momentous questions of law raised by the attorneys for the accused on his trial, and the scenes and incidents attending the execution of the condemned, all conspire to make it the most int interesting and sensational criminal case in the history of the county.


History of the Crime.


In the autumn of 1807, David Beckett in company with John Lightfoot, started down the Ohio River in a craft called a pirogue, for the purpose of trafficking with the settlers and hunters along the way exchanging salt, some primitive articles of household, powder and 1ead for grain, whiskey and pelts. The trip promised to be a prosperous one, and the prospect of gain so aroused Beckett's covetousness, that he determined to kill his companion and possess himself of the craft and its cargo. On the evening of the 5th day of October, the pirogue was moored to the Ohio shore at "Cook Jennie" bar at mouth of Aleck’s Run, on the farm now owned by A. G. Lockhart, in Green Township and after partaking of a hearty meal of broiled vension, and indulging frequent droughts from a demijohn of whiskey set aside from the stock for the occasion, the traders retired to the boat for the night. Beckett had designedly urged Lightfoot, his companion, to drink copiously


MISCELLANEOUS - 387


of the whiskey in order to stupefy him before making the contemplated assault. In the night while Lightfoot lay in a drunken stupor, Beckett arose, seized an ax, or large tomahawk conveniently near at hand, and dealt Lightfoot a murderous blow with the sharp edge of the instrument on the side of the head, sinking it into the brain up to the eye. Then seizing the limp and bleeding form of his victim, he dragged it to the side of the boat and rolled it overboard into the river. Having disposed of the body of his victim and whatever articles there were bearing evidence of the bloody deed, in and about the boat, Beckett determined to go to Limestone some miles below, at that time one of the principal landings and marts on the Ohio for western emigrants, and there sell the boat and cargo and flee the country. However the following day, while on the way to Limestone, he stopped at the residence of William Faulkner who kept a sort of inn and trading establishment near the mouth of Brush Creek. To him Beckett disposed of the possessions taking as part pay a horse which he immediately mounted and rode away. Shortly after this, the body of Lightfoot having been discovered, and Faulkner being found in possession of the boat and cargo, he was accused of murdering the traders, arrested and thrown into jail, although protesting his innocence of the crime. About this time, the horse which Beckett had ridden away, escaped from him, and he supposing that it had returned to its former owner, came back to the vicinity in search of the missing animal. He was accused of being implicated in the murder of Lightfoot, placed under arrest and taken to the jail at West Union, then recently made the permanent seat of justice of the county. This was in the latter part of October, 1807, and at the sitting of the grand jury of the county, the following month of November, an indictment was returned against Beckett for murder in the first degree.


The Indictment.


As fully illustrating the form, and character of such legal documents of that day and age, the indictment is here given in full, verbatim et literatum.


State of Ohio, Adams County, Court of Common Pleas, November term, 1807, Adams County, ss.


The grand jurors empaneled and sworn to enquire for the body of the county aforesaid, in the name' and by the authority of the State of Ohio, upon their oath present, that David Beckett, late of Green Township, in the county of Adams, aforesaid, Yeoman, not having the fear of God before his eyes, but being moved and seduced by the on instigation of the devil on the fifth day of October, in the year of our Lord, one thousand eight hundred and seven, with force and arms, at Green Township, aforesaid, in the county aforesaid, in and upon one John Lightfoot, in the peace of God and of the said state, then and there being, feloniously, wilfully, and of his malice aforethought did make an assault ; and that he, the said David Beckett, with a certain the ax, of the value of fifty cents, which he the said David Beckett, in both his hands then and there had and held, the said John Lightfoot, in and upon the left side of the head of him, the said John Lightfoot, then and there feloniously, wilfully and of his malice aforethought, did


388 - HISTORY OF ADAMS COUNTY


strike, giving to the said John Lightfoot, then and there with the ax aforesaid, in and upon the above said. left side of the head of him, the said John Lightfoot, one mortal wound of the breadth of three inches, and of the depth of two inches, of which said mortal wound, the said John Lightfoot then and there instantly died, and so the jurors aforetsaid, upon their oath aforesaid, do say, that the said David Beckett, the said John Lightfoot, in manner and form aforesaid, feloniously, wilfully, and of his malice aforethought, did kill and murder, against the form of the statute in such case made and provided, and against the peace and dignity of the state of Ohio.


James Scott,

Prosecuting Attorney, A. C.


His Arraignment and Plea.


State of Ohio, Adams County,

Court of Common Pleas,

November Term, 1807.


The grand jury having returned to the court an indictment against David Beckett, for the murder of John Lightfoot, the said David Beckett was set to the Barr and having heard the indictment aforesaid read, and it being demanded of him whether he was guilty of the murder aforesaid or not guilty, he said he was not guilty, and made his election to be tried by the Supreme Court next to be holden within and for the county aforesaid. Whereupon the said David' Beckett was remanded back to the jail of Adams County.


Joseph Darlinton,

Clerk Adams County.


Delay of the Trial.


Through the efforts of his counsel, Henry Brush and William Creighton, Esquires, the trial of Beckett was delayed for one year from the finding of the indictment. The most important question raised by the defense for the consideration of the court, was whether the court had jurisdiction over the place where the crime was committed. Since Lightfoot was killed on a boat upon the Ohio River, the learned counsel for the accused contended that the place of the crime was not within the jurisdiction of the State of Ohio, basing their argument in support of the contention on the language of the deed of cession of the Northwest Territory by the State of Virginia to the United States: "The territory situate, lying, and being to the northwest of the river Ohio." This raised the question of what constitutes the Southern boundary line of Ohio; whether the bank on the north shore of the river, low water-mark on that shore, or the middle of current of the Ohio? As the question had not been judicially determined till that time, the court took the question under consideration for future decision. [This question was again raised by counsel for

the defendants and fully discussed by Hon. Samuel Vinton in the case of the Commonwealth of Virginia v. Peter M. Garner et al, before the General Court of Virginia in 1845.] At the next sitting of the court, was announced by the court, it that inasmuch as the evidence disclosed


MISCELLANEOUS - 389


the fact that the boat upon which the crime in question was committed, was fastened by means of a rope to a tree on the Ohio bank of the river, the place of the crime was within the State of Ohio, and that the court had lawful jurisdiction of the offense, and would proceed to the trial of the accused. So accordingly at the October term, 1808, the Supreme Court of Ohio, western division, held in the town of West Union, the Hon. Samuel Huntington and the Hon. William Sprigg sitting, David Beckett was put on his trial for the murder of John Lightfoot, as the following record will show :


State of Ohio, Adams County, ss. The state of Ohio to the sheriff of Adams County : You are hereby commanded to summon thirty good and lawful men of the county aforesaid (in addition to the standing jury of the present term) forthwith to appear before the Supreme Court now sitting within and for the county aforesaid, to make a jury well and truly to try the prosecution now depending in the said court against David Beckett, and have there this writ. Witness the Hon. Samuel Huntington, Chief Judge of the Supreme Court of the State of Ohio, this seventeenth day of October, 1808.


Joseph Darlinton, Clerk S. C. A. C.


The above named persons I. have summoned to attend as within directed.


Serving $2.00.

John Ellison Jr., Sheriff, A. C.


The Venire for Thirty Jurors.


Needham Perry, David Robe, Joseph Keith, John Fllison, Sr., Moses Baird, Job Dinning, Eli Reeves, David Means, John McColm, Neal Lafferty, William Armstrong, John Finley, George Harper, David Bradford, Andrew Boyd, Daniel Collier, Alexander Campbell, James Allen, Samuel Milligan, David Hannah, Robert Anderson, David Thomas, Levin Wheeler, John Kincaid, Thomas Lewis, Joseph Currey, Simon Fields, Simon Shoemaker, William McIntyre, Isaac Edgington.


From the above venire and the standing jury for the term, the following named persons were selected as


The Trial Jury.


David Means, John Wickoff, Daniel Collier, Job Dinning, Andrew Boyd, Eli Reeves, Samuel Milligan, George Harper, David Robe, John Campbell, David Thomas, David Bradford.


The Trial.


The prosecuting attorney, James Scott, himself an able and pains taking lawyer, assisted by John W. Campbell, a bright young attorney who had recently located in West Union, and who afterwards became a United States judge, convinced of the guilt of Beckett, spared no effort to bring about his conviction. On the other hand, the attorneys for the accused, Henry Brush, one of the learned members of the


390 - HISTORY OF ADAMS COUNTY


bar at that day, and afterwards judge of the Supreme Court of Ohio, and the brilliant young advocate, William Creighton, the first Secretary of State of Ohio, believing the earnest protestations of innocence made by the accused to be true, and urged on by the hope of victory in a contest so widely observed by the people, and in which the stake was not alone fame and reputation—but a human life—met every assault of the prosecution during the trial, steel clashing with steel.


Scores of witnesses were called and examined and the many single subpoenas that were issued during the progress of the trial indicate. the earnestness with which the contest was waged. A theory of the defense was that William Faulkner was implicated in the murder of Lightfoot to the extent at least of guilty knowledge of the crime. And public opinion was divided as to the guilt or innocence of Faulkner, even up to the day of the execution of Beckett. After consuming nearly a week in the trial of the case, it was given the jury, which after due deliberation, reported the verdict through its foreman, David Bradford, "Guilty in manner and form as charged."


Thereupon the court pronounced the death penalty to be imposed upon the prisoner at the bar. His attorneys filed a motion in arrest of judgment and for a new trial, which on consideration by the court was overruled, whereupon the following order was directed to the sheriff having the prisoner in charge:


October term of the Supreme Court sitting in and for the County of Adams, in the State of Ohio, in the year of our Lord, one thousand eight hundred and eight.


State of Ohio, Adams County, ss.


The state of Ohio, to the sheriff of Adams County ; whereas at the aforesaid term of our Supreme Court, sitting in and for the county aforesaid, David Beckett was convicted of the murder of John Lightfoot and thereupon received judgment to-wit; that lie be taken to the place from whence he came and from thence on the tenth day of December next to the place of execution, and that he be then and there hanged by the neck until he be dead. Execution of which said judgment yet remains to be done. We therefore require and by these presents strictly command you that on Saturday, the tenth day of December, next, you convey the said David Beckett now in your custody in the jail of Adams County, to the place of execution and that you do cause execution to be done upon the said David Beckett in your custody so being in all things according to the said judgment. And this you are by no means to omit at your peril. Witness the honor able Samuel Huntington, Chief Judge of our said court, this twenty second day of October in the year of our Lord, one thousand eight hundred and eight, and of the State of Ohio, the sixth.


Joseph Darlinton, Clerk S. C. A. C.


The above bears the following indorsement: "Executed, John Fllison, Jr., Sheriff, Adams County."



MISCELLANEOUS - 391


Scenes and Incidents at the Execution.


On Saturday, December , 1808, at the town of West Union, gathered the first of the three notably large assemblages of the people in the history of the county. They came in wagons, on horseback, and afoot, from every section of this county and those adjoining, and from the region of Kentucky opposite along the Ohio River. It was a wonderful, outpouring of the people, not only to witness the execution of the condemned, but to see and hear that eccentric and sensational

itinerant preacher, Lorenzo Dow, who it was said, would be present to try his wonderful powers on the doomed man to elicit from him the facts as to the guilt or innocence of William Faulkner, accused of complicity in the murder of John Lightfoot. By noon of that memorable day the straggling village of West Union was literally swallowed up by as motley a crowd as ever gathered in the state. Backwoodsmen, boatmen, traders, merchants, mechanics, lawyers, preachers, women and children, all formed a surging mass, now crowding through the court house; and now engulfing the jail in which Beckett, in irons, was being prepared for his last hour on earth ; now scrutinizing the rude and barbarous gibbet from which the condemned would soon swing by the neck ; and now listening with bated breath to the words of his awfu1 confession as they fell from the lips of the doomed man.


The gibbet, consisting of two huge upright timbers firmly planted in the ground, with strong connecting cross-beam at the top, stood to the north of the northeast corner of the public square, near the present site of the Christian Union Church. Here was erected a rough platform from which Lorenzo Dow, Rev. William Williamson, then in charge of the West Union Presbyterian Church, Rev. Abbott Godard, and Rev. Robert Dobbins, then residing in Adams County, addressed the people preceding the execution. In the biography of Rev. Robert Dobbins, it is stated that he and Rev. Dow on the morning of the day of the execution went to the cell of the condemned man to elicit the truth from him as to another being implicated in the crime for which he was about to suffer. "Rev. Dow first interrogated the prisoner, and being dissatisfied with his answers, left. the cell. Rev. Dobbins then conversed with the prisoner and urged him to tell the truth, and spoke of the awful consequences of appearing before his Judge with a falsehood upon his soul. He finally succeeded in eliciting from the prisoner the fact that the implicated man was not guity."


The condemned was then made ready, bound, and placed in a vehicle bearing his coffin, and driven to the place of execution. Here the Rev. Williamson preached a sermon from the text,

"Oh! Israel, thou hast destroyed thyself, but in me is thy help."


Rev. Dow then delivered an address from the words, "Rejoice, young man, in thy youth, and let thy heart cheer thee in the days of the youth, etc.," after which Rev. Abbott Godard delivered an exhortation, and then Rev. Dobbins addressed the people.


"The prisoner then made a confession three-quarters of an hour , long and exhorted the young people to avoid the paths of vice. He said that intemperance, gambling, and base company had been the cause of his downfall."


392 - HISTORY OF ADAMS COUNTY


Liberty Hall and Cincinnati Mercury of January 5, 1809, contained the following: "On Saturday, the tenth ult., was executed in the town of West Union, Ohio, between the hours of two and three o'clock, in the presence of about fifteen thousand (?) people, David Beckett, for the murder of William (John) Lightfoot.


" Season return ; but not to me return.

" Day on the sweet approach of even or morn."


"At twelve o'clock he was conducted by a strong guard to the place of execution, where a solemn address was delivered by Lorenzo Do1. He was succeeded by two other gentlemen, after which the culprit arose and addressed himself to the surrounding multitude for the space of twenty minutes. His countenance was mild; his manner and speech free and unembarrassed. He appeared about the age of twenty-five the flower of youth glowed in his face, even to the last moment. During his address he made the following confession : "I can not say I am innocent. I am guilty of the crime laid to my charge ; these hands deprived William (John) Lightfoot of his life. These are stained with his blood, for which I freely resign my life, and hope in a few minutes to meet him in a happy eternity." He also said that George (William) Faulkner was innocent of all charges laid to him respecting said murder."


At the close of his thrilling appeal, the noose dangling from the gibbet was adjusted about the neck of the condemned, the black cap was drawn over his eyes, the cart in which he was standing beside his coffin was driven from under him, and the murder of John Lightfoot was avenged.


Lewis Johnson says that his mother, then a girl, told him that she stood with others of her family on the high porch that used to front the house where he yet resides, and saw Beckett hanged, and that the gallows stood near where the old log jail used to stand, at the northeast corner of the present court house yard.


Beckett was buried in the Lovejoy graveyard near West Union.

The following are some of the items of cost in this celebrated case".


John and William Russell, assisting to commit Beckett $1 28

Charles O'Connell, attending jury .25

Gaurds for jail 130 00

Witnesses in Beckett case 142 00

Jury in same 48 00

Bolts made by McComas .25

Samuel Smith and David Kendall, guarding Beckett to jail. 2 00

John M. Wallace, smith work on jail 6 00

David Bradford, boarding Beckett 101 25

John M. Wallace, making bolts for Beckett's hands .50

Rope, cap, and digging grave 1 62

Coffin 5 00

Execution 8 00


MISCELLANEOUS - 393


Lynching of Roscoe Parker.


On the waters of Elk Run something more than a mile to the southeast of the town of Winchester, in Winchester Township, in 1893, lived Luther P. Rhine, or "Pitt" Rhine, as he was generally known and his wife Mary, whose maiden name was Mary J. Farquer. They had resided on a little farm, their home, for many years, and had reared a family there. They were at this time old and feeble, the husband past eighty and the wife upwards of seventy, and were living alone. With the help of a man or boy occasionally, these old people managed to grow enough on the farm to keep them in fairly comfortable surroundings, and to save enough to pay taxes and their dues to the church at Cherry Fork of which they had been faithful members all their lives.


Living in the vicinity of the Rhine home was a family of colored people named Parker. The family consisted of the mother and several children, the eldest of whom was a boy, Roscoe, at this time about sixteen years of age. He and his mother often assisted the Rhines at odd jobs of work, and were familiar with the affairs and surroundings of the old couple. About the middle of December in the year above named, this boy Roscoe, assisted Mr. Rhine to drive a calf to Winchester where it had been sold to a butcher, for thirteen dollars. Roscoe saw the money paid to Mr. Rhine, and spoke of the amount as he accompanied the old man home. On the Sunday following, December 17th, the old people were seen about their premises alive the last time. On Tuesday, the l9th, they were found by a neighbor in their home brutally murdered. They had been assaulted while asleep with bludgeons, and then with the family butcher knife, having their throats cut from ear to ear. The motive had been robbery. The person or persons had been covered in the act. A struggle followed, and to avoid exposure of the attempt to rob, brutal murder had been committed.


Upon discovery of the crime, the greatest excitement prevailed among the citizens. The Parkers were suspected and a search of their premises was made. Some stockings, the property of the Rhines, were found. A five dollar bill was discovered hidden in a bed. Roscoe's clothing had blood stains on them. He was arrested and a preliminary examination had before Squire Gilbert, of Winchester Township, in the town hall at Winchester. The people clamored for young Parker's life. He was secretly taken from the hall and placed in a closed carriage by Constable Bayless, who drove with all speed to West Union, pursued by a mob where the accused was placed in jail.


Sheriff Greene N. McMannis learned that on a certain night a mob would come from Winchester and vicinity and take the prisoner from jail. He gave out the word that the prisoner would be removed to Georgeton, but instead of going there, he drove overland to Portsmouth, and confined the prisoner in the jail at that place. In the meantime, the newly elected sheriff, Marion Dunlap, had been inducted into office, and it being near the time of the sitting of the grand jury, on the 10th of January, 1894, he brought Roscoe Parker from Portsmouth and confined him in the West Union jail. That very night a large mob over powered the sheriff and his deputy, James McKee, hammered down the doors of the old jail, and removed Roscoe Parker to the vicinity of his home and hanged him to the limb of a tree.


394 - HISTORY OF ADAMS COUNTY


Parker fought in his cell like an infuriated beast, and disfigured the countenances of several of the mob before he was overpowered. It was a stinging cold night, and he was driven in his underclothes, from West Union to a point a half mile beyond North Liberty toward Winchester a distance of ten miles, where he was hanged, yet it is said he perspired as in the heat of summer, such was his mental agony. He was swung up twice and then let down, in hope that he would make a confession but he refused. He was sullen and stolidly met his fate. On the morning of the t 1th of January, the body of Roscoe Parker, riddled with bullets, was discovered hanging from the limb of an ash tree that stands in the corner of a piece of woodland just on the right of the Winchester pike, just across the little wooden bridge beyond North Liberty. The curious have about stripped the tree of its branches.


After an inquest had been held by Coroner Robe, there was much dispute among the authorities as to the disposition of the body, but finally on the 13th, it was buried in the old northwest corner of the cemetery at Cherry Fork. It was probably exhumed that night by medical students, and it is said Parker's cranium is in the possession of a well known physician of Adams County.


The place where Roscoe Parker was hanged is almost directly opposite the old Patton homestead at a point where a path from the colored settlement northeast of North Liberty leads down to the pike to Winchester. Before daylight on the morning of the lynching Parker, old Leonard Johnson, a former slave, ignorant and superstitious, who does chores for the villagers of North Liberty, came from his home in "the settlement" along this path and passed directly under the body of Roscoe Parker hanging from a limb above. A grain sack that had been placed over Parker's head by the mob lay in the path beneath his lifeless body, and Johnson picked this up and carried it to North Liberty before he learned of the lynching of Parker and the purpose for which the sack had been used. Then he feared the dreaded "hoodoo," and never since has he traveled that portion of the path to his home. And the other persons of "the settlement" no longer climb the fence at the bridge and take the path through Patton's woods, but very prudently avoid the "hoodoo" by traveling the public highway, and in the daytime.


TREASON TRIAL IN OHIO.


By JAMES H. THOMPSON, Hillsboro, 0.


Edward L. Hughes, the defendant, was an Irishman, of large size and great bodily strength, of marked character in his mental and normal endowments, characterized by bravery and common sense, and self confidence in his control over men, and who, after a long experience in contracts and jobs on the public works of Ohio, had settled down and purchased a valuable farm near Locust Grove, in Adams County, Ohio, on which he had resided for many years, aid brought up a large and highly respected family, and which homestead was well stocked at the time of John Morgan's raid, with good horses.


The news of the approach of the invaders, having carried on the wings of the wind eastward to the neighborhood of the accused, he affected great indifference, on the ground that, being a man of high repute


MISCELLANEOUS - 395


and a warm opponent of the war, his property would not be disturbed ; but on the morning of the 16th of July, 1863, John Morgan and his is were heard in the distance moving northward from Jacktown over the old Limestone road, and suddenly they arrived and halted at Locust Grove for breakfast, and while the General and his soldiers were enjoying all the good things prepared by the frightened people for their repast, the squad of scouts constantly out by the orders of Basil Duke as the wings of a bird, closed in also to the main body for lunch, and along with the detachment they led two very fine horses, the property of Mr. Hughes. He made an appeal to Gen. Morgan for the return of his horses ; but he soon found out that the General was no respecter of persons in an enemy's country, and thereupon he instantly concluded he would join in and pilot Morgan, and thereby induce him to give up his horses. Accordingly Hughes installed himself as one of the commander’s chief of staff, and from his knowledge of the country, became General Morgan's efficient aid-de-camp, and led the front van down Sunfish Valley, across the Scioto River, through Piketon on to Jackson Court House, where becoming boisterous and unruly from drink, he was cashiered by his high captain and left to the mercy of the enraged populace and the pursuers of Morgan under General Hobson, who, corning up in close pursuit, had Hughes arrested for treason, and immediately sent, to the jail of Hamilton County. Ohio, there to await an examination by the proper authorities, into the charge for the high crime.


The son and the son-in-law of Mr. Hughes hearing that he was imprisoned in Cincinnati, visited me at once and retained me as his longed trusted counsel, without any stipulated fee, to extricate him from his of peril of apprehended loss of life by the civil tribunals or a military court martial, and immediately I went to Cincinnati and visited the prisoner in the jail.


As soon as we met, he, realizing his situation, exclaimed: "Thompson, I am in a bad fix—likely to be hung for the loss of two horses, and this all my crime. You know all I wanted was to get my horses back, and that d—d rebel has taken them and left me to suffer the possible forfeiture of life and property." I calmed him Sown by the statement that the chances of the future were in every man's favor, and the certainties of the law were the dew-drops of mercy in behalf of a criminal; and that he must stand up manfully, and when I had heard the witnesses as he knew we might possibly find out some way of escape.


Immediately after this consultation, the prisoner was brought out before Hugh Carey, U. S. Commissioner, for an examination into the charge, and the testimony of the witnesses of the government having been partially heard, the case was continued for further examination until August 27, 1863, and the accused was admitted to bail for his appearance at that time.


On the partial examination, one Mike Nessler was examined as a witness in behalf of the government, and as his testimony is a sample of what was expected to be proved, I give it from memory, after a lapse of twenty years, accurately as if on yesterday it had been heard, because

of its indelible impression on my memory, then heated by my anxious attention.


396 - HISTORY OF ADAMS COUNTY


Uncle Mike Nessler as the whole bar of this region of country called him, was a facetious, kind hearted, thrifty old German landlord, whose pleasant, varied and patient manners had been moulded and finished by his long association with and his attention to the distinguished members of the bar of Jackson, Portsmouth and Chillicothe, and occasionally from the country around who attended the courts at Piketon; and he also was gifted with a twinkling eye, beaming from a jolly face, and a tongue with pleasant, soft speech; and, thus eminently qualified, he

kept the chief tavern in the center of that village at the intersection of its main streets, in a large two story frame house, with its porches over the pavement, which was always stored with good things to eat and good liquors to cheer, and Hughes knew it. The commissioner asked Mr. Nessler to tell him what he knew about the charges against the prisoner for piloting John Morgan and his army through the country.


"Vell, 1 was just standing in the front door of my tavern in Piketon. looking out for Gen. Morgan, who was coming, as our scouts said, and I sees a man whooping and galloping down the street, and he never stop until he was on my pavement with his horse's head inside my front door

and then he hollow out: 'Surrender, you d—d old Hessian!' Says I, 'Who is you, Ned Hughes?' 'I'll let you know I am Major Ned Hughes, chief aid of Gen. John Morgan, who has been installed

Governor of Ohio, and is now crossing the Scioto River and commands to have your house prepared for his headquarters during his tarry in your village. So unlock your cellar, roll out your barrels of the best, get him a splendid dinner, open up your parlors, Send after mint and ice, call all the servants and have julips ready for him and his staff, count out all your money on his table, and if you are lively, I will try to keep him from carrying you a prisoner of war into the Confederate States." Says I, 'Anything more?' and just as I said them words, here they come cloud of dust, and a tall, fine-looking fellow on a sorrel mare, and a little man on a bay, ride up to my house and light on my pavement ; and Ned Hughes ran up to them, catching me by the ar.a and dragging me along and say: 'Governor Morgan, this is Mr. Nessler, the landlord, who 1has his orders and will have all things ready.' He then turn me 'round and say: Mr. Nessler, this is Mr. Basil Duke, the immortal Captain of cavalry !' Says I, with a bow and a Smile, and a big lie on my lips "Governor Morgan, you and Captain Duke are heartily welcome to my house. I am honored by your call, and will serve your every order. Please walk into my parlor as your headquarters, and order.' 'As we walked in, the governor Said he would take a little something, and having seated them, I hurried out and come back with ice and mint, and the best in the cellar, and say : 'Merry times to you gentlemen. Will you have your dinner in the judge's room, or in the public dining room ?” And one of the aids say : Dinner for the governor and his staff in private, and let that Hughes shift with the boys.' And I tell you he was shifting like a lord in tapping my barrels and handing 'round' the drinks to the boys. Call me here, call there, call me everywhere. I

say to myself : 'Biggest court day I ever see but I takes care that the governor and his party are served the best beef, chicken and pie, and didn't care for anybody else, but the old woman say that she fed all that called, with Major Hughes at the head of the table. After dinner the


MISCELLANEOUS - 397


governor say to me : 'Is this fellow Hughes to be trusted?' 'Oh, yes,'says I, 'he is on your side and one of your best friends. I tell you the truth."I believe you, old man,' says that little Basil Devil—you call it Basil Duke—and he says : 'You shall not be hurt, old man, and we will remember your tavern and call again when in these parts.' `Thank you,’ says I, 'and I hope next time to be better prepared.'


"And with that I goes out into the back yard, and as I passed along one young fellow says to me: 'This chap talking to me wants to pull up all the old Dutchman's cabbage, and throw them around for fun; but as all the wine, beer, and whiskey, about the house is drunk up, I tell you if you will give us your private bottle he shall not do it.' Says I, ‘Go around the chimney corner there, and I fetch him.' I run in the house and turn up the bed tick of the old woman's bed, draw out my quart bottle, and take it to the young chaps. They takes what they a called a stirrup drink, makes me take a taste, then they jumps over the fence, mounts their horses, sounds the bugle, and I hear Major Hughes parading and hallooing up and down the streets, 'To arms, boys, to arms! and now for Jackson Court House !' And away they all go over the hill, and them two young chaps with my bottle. But I fool 'em already. All my money was hid around under the cabbages in the and patch I find him all right when they left, and hand the bags to the old woman, and this is all I know about Ned Hughes."


Cross-examined—"Was Mr. Hughes drunk?"


“No; not when he came, but he rode away with from a quart to a half gallon of my whiskey under his sword belt, with his sword in hand as a general, and you can judge."


Nothing more, Mr. Nessler."


After the continuance, Mr. Hughes, his bail, and other friends, with myself, boarded the train for Hillsboro, through which travel leads to Locust Grove, and on the way held a consultation and made out a list of our witnesses, and all agreed to be present again on the twenty-seventh of August next ensuing, then and there to hear what further the government would prove, and to determine on our future policy.


That day afterwards came and went, but not the accused. He had his taken his own defense, without my knowledge, or consent, into his own hands assisted by his feet, and having conveyed all his property to his bail to indemnify them (in the interim), he had fled the country and up his taken up his abode at Montreal, under Queen Victoria's flag.


Oh the receipt of the information I indulged for the first time since the continuance in sound sleep, and did not think or care for old Mike Nessler, or the constant nightmare of his testimony. But my rest was soon afterwards disturbed by the call of his only son, who informed me that it had become so hot around his father's, at Locust Grove, that he had concluded it was safer to seek a colder climate, and that all his rty was left in my care to do the best I could for my protection, hat of his bail and family, against all confiscation proceedings. Not appearing, the bail bond was forfeited by the commissioner, and thus matters rested until the October term, 1863, when suit was commenced to recover the amount of the forfeited bail bond, and the witnessesing having been summoned and sworn and sent before the grand jury, and by them examined, an indictment for treason against Edward L. Hughes


398 - HISTORY OF ADAMS COUNTY


was found and returned into court at that term with two counts. And so in October, 1863, I found myself confronted with a suit on the bail bond, threatened proceedings for confiscation of property, and this formidable indictment pending against my client, a fugitive from justice, and bitter excitement against hint in all the belt of country through which John Morgan's army had passed; without one ray of hope or light as to my future professional course in the case, although I sincerely believed that the accused was not morally guilty of the crime charged against him.


I demurred to the declaration on the forfeited bail bond for various good reasons, and walked out of court in black darkness, why I could never tell. My whole duty had been performed, and my client, without my advice, having chosen his own mode of defense, and thereby, for the moment at least, having secured his life and liberty, I could not conscientiously tell why I should fret so much, until one night Professional Fame, attired in glittering costume, appeared to me in a dream and said at my bed side : "You will win me still." And when I awakened in the morning I asked of the Goddess : "HOW?" No statutes, no forms of law, no teachings of books, could tell me, but some weeks thereafter having passed away, on one bright, winter day the mail brought the publication in one of the newspapers of the amnesty proclamation of President Lincoln, of December 8, 1863. I read it with general interest, then re-read it with special interest in its bearings on my case and classified the persons who could claim its benefits, and at last m dream changed into reality, and the thought flashed upon me that m friend Hughes could avail himself of the pardon by a plea in bar puis dariem continuance, having carefully examined all the authorities, advised his friends of my convictions, and that they might write to him to come home, and if I did not acquit him, we would go to the gallows together and be hung from the same scaffold. After considerable correspondence and explanation, Mr. Hughes, trusting to my opinion, returned to his home, and thereupon, on the first day of March 1864, we appeared in open court and took and subscribed the oath required in the proclamation, and filed the same in the court, and Judge Leavitt, holding the Circuit Court of the United States, than who there was no purer or more patriotic minister of justice, and Mr. Ball, the district attorney, than whom there had been none more competent, seeing Hughes present in court, and hearing from me that had come to rest under the shadow of the wing of the Presidents proclaimed pardon or be hung, consented to set aside the forfeiture of recognizance, and respite the same for our appearance at the October term, 1864. At this term we promptly appeared, after having been good behavior and patriotic conduct during the spring and summer and filed the ordinary plea of not guilty, and this novel and origi special plea : (Being very lengthy, it is here omitted.—Fd.)


To this special plea, on which I had staked the liberty and life of my client, a demurrer was filed by the district attorney, and thereupon an animated argument was had, bristling throughout with vivid. objections as to whether the proclamation was to be construed as operating north of Mason and Dixon's line, whether it was not merely the act the president in his military capacity as commander-in-chief, and there-


MISCELLANEOUS - 399


fore could not be intended to operate in civil proceedings ; whether the accused before conviction could claim its benefits, and whether he was among the class of persons who were entitled to its protection ; which, on being concluded, the judge very blandly remarked, "that inasmuch as Mr. Hughes had taken the oath of allegiance, and had in fact by submitting himself to trial, showed a disposition to return to and assume the discharge of all his duties as a loyal citizen, he felt inclined to suggest to counsel to impart and agree to some liberal settlement," and thereupon after several imparlances under the sanction of the judge, it was agreed for the public peace, safety, and good example that the demurrer pro forma should be sustained, and that Mr. Hughes should give his own recognizance for future fidelity to the government, which he then and there did, and the record states : "Thereupon (on the twenty-first day of November, 1864,) came the attorney for the United es for the district on behalf of the plaintiff, and made known to the court that he is unwilling further to prosecute the indictment herein to said defendant. It is therefore considered by the court that as 'd indictment said defendant go hence without day."


Thus terminated the treason trial Mr Hughes returned to his home, and lived many years the life of a patriotic citizen, and died several years past in the west.


The outcome of this memorable case as to fees and compensation professional services rendered as stated on the quantum mercuit principle, will interest the profession, if the report of the case be of any interest. Being at the termination of the case engaged in agricultural pursuits, and being vigorously engaged in professional labors from the same motive which impelled the distinguished Ben Hardin, of Kentucky after three score years and ten of age, to continue his practice, as he said to me when I remarked to him that I supposed he had accumulated enough to retire, "Why," he scornfully answered, "I have a farm, an old saw mill, and forty niggers, and I am compelled to work harder than I ever did in my life to pay expenses and support them all." Just so I was situated, except free labor was employed. Meeting Mr. Hughes one day (between whom and myself nothing had been said to my fee), he addressed me : "I am told you are farming and have plenty of corn." "Yes, sir, that is my condition." "Well, I have seven mules, and if you will take them and square the docket between us, you may send after them. Feed them up awhile, and they will bring you $700." "Agreed," said I, and the mules were driven to my farm fed until my fences would not keep them at home, and I sold them to an army contractor for the Potomac service, and the best and last act count I had of them was that they were in the battle of the Wilderness.


Anecdote of Judge Thurman.


"Colonel"William T. Moore, whose figure has been silhouetted thousands of times on the walls of the composing rooms of every newspaper office in West Union, since "way befoh the wah," relates with feigned pride the fact that he once drove Judge Allen G. Thurman, at that time a United States senator of Ohio, from West Union to Portsmouth, via Cedar Mills, Wamsley, and Red Bridge, over the old Portsmouth road, in landlord Crawford's carriage, drawn by the famous match


400 - HISTORY OF ADAMS COUNTY


black ponies "Doc" and "Pomp." It was in the campaign of 1879, and Judge Thurman had spoken at West Union, and had to meet an appointment at Portsmouth, and the river being low and boats uncertain, he chose to make the trip overland. This was before the building of the C. P. & V. Railway through the county. After getting beyond Cedar Mills and beginning the descent to the valley of Turkey Creek, the judge spoke of the fact that at a certain point beyond there was spring by the side of the road at which he desired to stop and get drink of cool water. He seemed familiar with the country through which he passed from Cedar Mills to Bear Creek, and would frequent' stop the carriage to view the country from advantageous points, an would comment on the beauty of the hills covered with forests in th gorgeous dress of an October day. Upon inquiry as to the source his knowledge of this region, the judge said he had carried on hors back from Chillicothe the tickets down into that region of country f the election in Jackson's campaign in 1832.


THE IRON INDUSTRY.


The early land surveyors discovered iron ore in the region composing Adams County, and at its organization in September, 1797, one of the six townships into which the county was divided was named Iron Ridge. This township included the ore fields of the present territory of the county. But nothing was done in the manufacture of iron in these fields until about the year 1811, when our relations with Great Britain became such as to foreshadow war with that country. This

greatly stimulated the iron industry in Pennsylvania and eastern Ohio, as elsewhere throughout the country, and set on foot the movement to work the ore in the Adams County fields. The first furnace built was what was called Brush Creek Furnace on Cedar Run, about two miles from its mouth, in what is now Jefferson Township, and at a point now known as Cedar Mills. This furnace was erected by Paul and McNichol in 1811. It was later operated by James Rodgers & Company; they were succeeded by the Brush Creek Furnace Company, and they by James T. Claypool & Company, who were succeeded by James K. Stewart & Company, the last operators of the furnace.


The second furnace erected was the old Steam Furnace, near the present village of Peebles, in what is now Meigs Township. It was erected by James Rodgers, Andrew Ellison, and the Pittsburg Steam Engine Company. This furnace was named "Steam Furnace" from the fact that up to that time the power to propel the machinery of furnaces and forges west of the Alleghanies was derived from water by means of dams and races. The machinery of this furnace was propelled by means of a steam engine, and hence the name, Steam Furnace. In later years a man by the name of this Benner became the proprietor of furnace.

 

The third furnace was erected on the east fork of Ohio Brush Creek, south of the Great Serpent Mound, in what is now Bratton Township, and named the Marble Furnace, from the beautiful white limestone from which it was constructed. This was in the year 1816 and Governor Duncan McArthur and Thomas James, of Chillicothe, were the original proprietors. Henry Massie, the founder of the town

 

 

 

MISCELLANEOUS - 401

 

New Market, in Highland County. and a brother of General Nathaniel Massie, was also interested in this furnace. There was a foundry at the Marble Furnace, and quite an extensive industry in connection with the furnace was carried on here until 1834, when the furnace and 1,200 acres of the furnace lands was purchased by Jacob Sommers, who abandoned the furnace in 1835.

 

There was a small furnace in connection with old "Bull" Forge, on the lower waters of Ohio Brush Creek, which was erected and managed by a Mr. Kendrick about the year 1818.

 

There was a forge at old Steam Furnace, and one, Brush Creek Forge, on Ohio Brush Creek, near where the Forge Dam Bridge now spans that stream at Satterfields'. (See Brush Creek Forge.)

 

These all were what is known as the cold-blast, charcoal furnace, with water power, except the Steam Furnace, and produced from one to two tons each of iron per day. They were kept in blast from seven to ten months in the year, and gave employment to hundreds of men in the various divisions of the industry. Competition in the Hanging Rock, Youngstown, and Pittsburg fields, with better means of transportation of the product, together with more extensive ore beds, and the use of coke and coal in place of the more expensive charcoal to make the blast, caused the abandonment of the Brush Creek iron fields.

 

It is said that the quality of iron made here was of the very best. The ores lie in basins of limited extent, and irregular form, in the cliff limestone capping the hills in the region of Brush Creek. The natives speak of the "top hills" as being the place of deposit of the ore. "The ore seems originally," says Locke, "to have been pyrites in huge nodules, and collections of nodules in the rock. Where these become uncovered and exposed to the influence of water, and the lime, which is more or less intermingled, a decomposition ensued, the sulphur was abstracted, and the hydrated peroxide of iron remained. Wherever the ore is covered by stone and the agency of water excluded it is still nodular pyrites, somewhat decomposed. In one instance a drift was made into an ore bed, under the rock at Brush Creek furnace, and plenty of heavy, beautiful, gold-like ore procured, but so full of sulphur that it could not be worked.

 

Marble Furnace.

 

The valley of the east fork of Ohio Brush Creek has long been celebrated for its beauty of scenery and fertility of soil. In the early pioneer days, Massie, Lytle, O'Bannon, and others risked life and limb to make entries and surveys of these very valuable lands. The Shawnees, who had wrested the region from savage rivals long before the coming of the whites, held this valley as one of the richest fields for the chase, while the stream now known as Fast Fork afforded an abundance of fish of the finest and gamest kinds, as it does to this day, even against all the destructive influences and cunning inventions of civilization. In the bottom to the north of the site of the old furnace there was a Shawnee village, and there the land had been cleared; there under de cultivation of the patient and industrious squaw, the lazy warrior saw the broad acres of maize to supply the wants of hunger, flour-

 

402 - HISTORY OF ADAMS COUNTY

 

ish and grow as of magic. While along the narrow valleys and up the broad hillsides the sugar maple (acer sacharinum), grew native monarchs of the soil. This was in every sense of the term the Indian's paradise. He esteemed it as such, and defended it against the encroachments of civilization to his utmost endeavor. Here, as late as 1805, remnants of Shawnee families, whose ancestors had resided in the valley, came to fish and hunt and take a last farewell at the graves of their forefathers. The white man's ax had even then so marred the forests as to make scenes once familiar unknown. It may properly here be remarked that in this valley a race of people, nothing of whom was known to the Indians, once flourished, who builded enduring monuments to the memory of their rulers, and constructed as an altar of worship to the Great Being that most remarkable effigy, the study and wonder of civilized man, the Great Serpent Mound.

 

While surveying in this valley, Massie discovered iron ore of very fine quality on the bordering hills, and later Thomas James and Duncan McArthur, afterwards governor, built the furnace known as Marble Furnace, and began a great industry, which was carried on for years. This was in the year 1816, and the furnace was in full operation in that year. The name "Marble" was given to the furnace from the fact that the stack was built from a fine white limestone quarried near by, which, when dressed and bush-hammered, had, at a distance, the appearance of white marble.

 

The stack of the furnace stood on the lot now owned by Charles Miller. It was so located that from the cliff to the rear a kind of trestle bridge was constructed, over which trucks were propelled carrying charcoal, limestone, and iron ore to the top of the stack. The power to supply the blast was furnished by a canal or race leading from the creek above.

 

There were here at times from 400 to b00 men employed in the various divisions of the work, including wood-choppers, colliers, fur4 nace men, ore diggers, teamsters, and so forth. The pig-iron w hauled overland to Benner's forge on Paint Creek, to Chillicothe, or the Ohio River at Manchester, via West Union. While the holl ware made at the foundry was distributed throughout the settlement for miles about. One of the prominent characters at the furnace f many years was Robert Ivers, a kettle moulder. Afterwards Pet Andrews and others built the cupola and molded stoves, kettles, pots and dog-irons. Among the wood choppers Fred Griffith, Mathew G man and Abraham Wisecup were unequaled. It is said that either theSe persons could cut seven and one-half cords per day, a feat nev performed by any other person of the hundreds of choppers w worked at the "coalings." Twenty-five cents a cord was the price in those days. David Gardner was overseer of the ore diggers, w received from thirty to forty centS per day in "Furnace Scrip. ' The was a double log cabin on the lot where the old frame building n stands, which was in early days a famous boarding house. Just ac the creek from it stood Joseph Thompson's cabin, where whiskey sold, and many a foot race, wrestle, or fight has taken place on the hi toric spot for a quart of Thompson's "old Monongahela," made up

 

MISCELLANEOUS - 403

 

some one of the spring branches that flow into Brush Creek. Labels were a deception then, as now.

 

About the year 1830 work at the furnace ceased, from the fact that charcoal can not compete with stone coal, that ox teams can not compete with more modern means of transportation, and limited supply of ore can not compete with supplies almost inexhaustible. In 1834 *Henry Massie, one of the proprietors of the furnace, sold his interest to McArthur and James, and they disposed of 1,200 acres of furnace d, including the old furnace, to Jacob Sommers, then a resident of Middlebury, Loudon County, Virginia. Here in December, 1835, he came with his family and moved into the old brick house built by Henry Massie, where now resides Captain Urton, a son-in-law of Mr. Sommers.

 

Brush Creek Furnace.

 

This furnace stood on Cedar Run, about two miles from its confluence with Ohio Brush Creek. It was erected in the year 1811 by Paul and McNichol, of Pittsburg, and furnished employment to several hundred men for a period of twenty years. Paul and McNichol were succeeded by James Rodgers & Co.' and they by the Brush Creek Furance Company, who conducted the business until 1826, when James T. Claypool & Co. became the proprietors. In November of this year the company advertised for fifty or sixty wood choppers, "to whom prompt and liberal wages will be given." "Also ox drivers and ore diggers. Ox drivers will be given $28 a month, $5 of it in cash." The company advertised "Hollo-ware, pig-metal and castings of every description, suitable to the wants of the country." This company conduced a general store at the furnace, at which the furnace hands and there families were compelled to purchase their goods and groceries. Corn oats, wheat, and farm products were taken in exchange for goods from the store, or for the products of the furnace and forge conducted connection therewith.

 

Claypool & Co. were succeeded by William K. Stewart & Co., in 1834-5. At this time the supply of ore in the vicinity was thought to be exhausted, and operations at the furnace had cased. But the new proprietors opened new beds of ore and carried on a profitable business for several years thereafter, until competition in other fields became too great to realize profits in the Brush Creek fields. In the year 1838 Mr. Stewart, with twelve laborers, in a period of 120 days made a blast which produced over 200 tons of pig-iron.

 

Brush Creek Forge stood on the west side of Brush Creek, near the present "Forge Dam" bridge, at Satterfield's. The old dam across the creek was constructed to furnish power to propel the machinery at the forge. The pig-iron from the furnace was here made into wrought iron blooms. John Fisher, a prominent character of the county in those days, was proprietor of the forge and a member of the furnace company. During the flood of 1832 the back-water from the Ohio river rose in Mr. Fisher's dwelling, which stood in the bottom, back from the forge.

 

* It is said that the only son of Henry Massie is buried near the old brick residence built by him in 1825, and now occupied by Captain Urton. Mr. Massie's wife died here, but was interred at Chillieothe. The Stone from which the Sarcophagus over her grave was built, was quarried at Marble Furnace and hauled by ox teams to Chillicothe.

 

404 - HISTORY OF ADAMS COUNTY

 

"Bull Forge," so called from the fact that the power to drive its machinery was had from a great tread-wheel forty feet in diameter,. propelled by oxen, or "bulls." This forge was on Ohio Brush Creek,. near its mouth, on what was known as the Wilson farm. It was owned by a Mr. Kendrick, from Chillicothe. A small furnace was also built an operated here—the ore being dug on the creek hills in the vicinity.

 

FUGITIVE SLAVES AND THE UNDERGROUND RAILROAD.

 

The ordinance of '87 contains among other things the well-know provision with reference to Negro slavery: "There shall be neither slavery nor involuntary servitude in the said (Northwest) territory otherwise than for the punishment of crimes whereof the party shall have been duly convicted." This forever prohibited slavery in Ohio and the other states carved out of the territory for the government of which the ordinance was framed by the second continental congress but it contained a provision recognizing the institution of slavery in the other states and territories, providing "that any person escaping into the same (Northwest Territory), from whom labor or service is lawfully claimed in one of the original states, such fugitive may be claimed and conveyed to the person claiming his or her labor or services as aforesaid. And the constitution of the United States afterwards adopted contained the provision that no person held to service or labor in any one state, under the laws thereof, escaping into another, shall in consequence of any law or regulation therein, be discharged from such service or labor, but shall be delivered upon claim of the party to whom such service or labor may be due."

 

Upon these basic principles of our organic law, the owners of slaves pursued such of them as escaped into free territory, and if apprehended carried them back into slavery. There were persons and communities in the free states that lent assistance in secreting fugitives and in assisting them to escape from their pursuers to the English provinces—particularly the Dominion of Canada. In these days such violators of law would he condemned as "Anarchists," and perhaps “enjoined" by the federal courts from such acts of violence, and in cases of bloodshed, as often occurred, would he hanged, as was Parsons and his associates in Chicago in recent years.

 

The Virginia Military District in Ohio, including Adams County was largely settled by persons from the slave-holding states, particular early Virginia and Kentucky; yet a majority of these opposed Negro slavery—or at least the extension of it—and all opposed for a period of years the agitation of the questions on social, religious, and constitutional grounds. Many of the early settlers of Adams County had freed their slaves in the south, but brought with them Negro servants. who remained here in about the same status with reference to their former masters as while in slave territory.

 

In the old records of the Court of Quarter Sessions, September term, 1799, we find that "Nathaniel Massie's Mike appeared in court to claim his freedom. The court ordered him (Mike) home and stay until next court, to he confronted by his master."

 

MISCELLANEOUS - 405

 

Mike seems to have obeyed the court and stayed at home until the December term, 1800, when it appears on the record of the court that "On the motion of Mike, a Negro man, the court rule he shall be heard after the prisoner, McGinnis." And, later, "Mike came before the court and pleads for his freedom, whereupon the court rule and order him to have his trial at the next term, and that the sheriff give Nathaniel Massie clue notice thereof." Said notice was, "that, whereas, Mike, a Negro man, has been repeatedly before the court in making complaint of his being held in bondage contrary to law ; and the court has ordered him on to trial at our next Court of General Quarter Sessions at Washington in and for said county in March next." John Beasley was presiding judge of this court, Nathan Ellis sheriff, and George Gordon clerk. The court also directed the sheriff to "summon Thomas McDonald, if he may be found in your bailiwick, to personally appear before the court * * * on the second Tuesday of March next, then and there in our said court to give evidence and the truth to say on the behalf of Mike v. Nathaniel Massie, in a Plea of Freedom." Joel Bailey was also summoned as a witness for Mike.

 

A the March session, 1801, the case was disposed or as shown by the records, and closed with the following entry : "The rule of the court in this suit is to proceed no further therein, and order said suit dismissed from the docket, which is accordingly done."

 

It is said that many of the wealthier families in the early days of the county held Negro servants practically in bondage. The Early family had three Negros, brought from Kentucky as slaves, one of whom, a little boy, remained in the family until he became of age. The Means Family had a number of Negro servants, as late as 1835.

 

Jeremiah Pittinger came to Adams County from the State of Maryland, in 1825, and brought as a servant in the family, Dinah, a negro woman, who lived with the family during his lifetime. She then went with a daughter, Julia, the wife of John Morrison, of Fckmanville and served in his family until her death in 1878, at the age of 106 years. The old cherry chest in which she brought her worldly longings from Maryland, is now in the possession of Mrs. Alexander, a daughter of Mr. Morrison.

 

The following certificate of manumission given Dinah by John Schley, father of the popular admiral, the hero of Santiago, is worth preserving. State of Maryland, Frederick County, ss. I hereby certify that the person to whom this is given, named Dinah, a black woman, about thirty years of age, five feet eight inches tall, has a scar on lower part of the left ear, and has a mole on left side of her face near the nose, and has a scar on her left cheek and is the identical negro Woman heretofore manumitted by John Campbell and Elizabeth Campbell on or about the eleventh day of April, 1805, as appears by said manumission on record in my office, and the affidavit of John Pittinger on file in my office.

 

In testimony whereof I have hereunto subscribed my name and affixed the seal of my office this twentieth day of June 1824.

 

John Schley, Clerk of Frederick County.

 

406 - HISTORY OF ADAMS COUNTY

 

The newspapers of that period carried advertisements like the following, from The Village Register, West Union, Ohio, April 27, 1824:

 

100 DOLLARS REWARD

 

RAN AWAY from the Kenhawa Salt Works, on or about the twenty-eighth of December, last, a bright mullato man, about three-fourths white, named William, the property of William Brooks, of Franklin County, Virginia. He is about twenty-nine years old, nearly six feet high, his head woolly, and inclined to be yellow ; he is a raw boned stout fellow, tolerably thin visage, straight built, the middle finger of his right hand is cut off at the first joint ; very fond of spiritous liquors, and when drunk, inclined to misbehave. The above reward will be given to Any person who will return him to the subscriber at the Kenhawa Saline ; or fifty-dollars if secure ,1 in any jail so that I get him again. Joel Shrewsbury.

 

There was but little abolition sentiment in Adams County until about 1840. The Covenanters about Cherry Fork and the Brush Creek settlements were, from principle, opposed to Negro slavery. At this time a few "agitators" like Rev. Dyer Burgess who had stirred up dissensions among the people of the county over the question of Free Masonry began to discuss publicly the question of Negro slavery. These "agitators" were very abusive of those who counseled obedience to th law, and denounced the "government as a covenant with hell.' Th passage of the Fugitive Slave Law gave the "agitators" renewed opportunity for vituperation, and the slave hunters legal sanction to their many revolting acts of cruelty toward captives taken in free territory There were, as there would be today, men in every community without reference to creed or political affiliations, who for the sake of rew would at the risk of life, pursue the fugitives to captivity for the ho of gain. A party of these pursuers from the vicinity of Clayton, h by James Taylor, Godard Pence, and Harvey Beasley, in 1851, caught sixteen negroes near Thornton Shelton's, in Sprigg Township. Ta lor, a powerful man himself, knocked one negro down time and again with a handspike before Pence a desperate character could secure if with ropes.

 

William Gilbert was shot and killed by a fugitive whom he pursued over the county line into Brown County, at the crossing Brushy Fork near the old store . The negro was captured the day near Clayton by some of the Martins and a posse from Maysville. This was in 1850, and John Laney informed the writer that he old Dr. Norton, of near Decatur, who was accompanying Laney answer a sick call, as they approach the crossing at the creek, h the shot, and the sound of voices. On near approach, William P and others were stooping over Gilbert who was mortally wound Dr. Norton whose house was an "under ground station" refused attend Gilbert but rode on to Laney's house. Gilbert survived th days after removal to his home.

 

On the other hand, there were individuals in every commune who from "broadness of mind and bigness of heart" would render as-

 

MISCELLANEOUS - 407

 

sistance to the fleeing slave and help him on to a place of security from pursuers.

 

A powerful negro named Ned Abney had by working overtime purchased his freedom from his master in the south : He came to Adams County in the vicinity of Cherry Fork and labored at any kind of work to secure money to purchase the freedom of his wife and child left behind. In time he had accomplished the task of freeing his wife who joined him where he had secured a domicile in the vicinity of Red Ook, in Brown County. But there lay before them the task of now accumulating enough to purchase their child in the far south land of slavery.

 

"Pony" Joe Patton, as he was familiarly known from the fact that be imported and bred Canadian ponies, learning the story of Abney's life resolved to secure the child and deliver it to its parents. He accordingly fitted up a light wagon and started south to sell lightning rods. He traveled into Tennessee, found the master who held Abney's child became intimate with his household, and after due preparation stole the child out at night, and drove until daylight directly south. Then he rested his pony and while so doing cut down the bed of his wagon and covered the "boot" of it with canvas. Under this he stowed away the child, and then by a circuitous route turned to the northward to the point of his destination in Ohio, which he reached in safety after three weeks travel, where he delivered his protege to its delighted parents. The old gray pony made many a trip over the underground route from Red Oak to stations across Adams County carrying fugitive mothers and children to safety and freedom, but this "incursion into the enemy's country," as Patton termed it, was the greatest and most trying of all.

 

After the passage of the Fugitive Slave Laws it became necessary for the sympathizers with the runaway slaves to use the utmost precaution in assisting them to places of safety. The runaways who crossed the river in the vicinity of Ripley would be piloted by some one after night to Red Oak or Decatur in Brown County. From there some conductor, "Pony" Patton, old Johnny Thompson, of Cherry Fork, or old Jim Caskey, of Grace's Run, would take them to Daniel Copples in Liberity Township, Adams County, known as "Station Number 2" or to Gen. William McIntyre's, on Grace's Run, in Wayne Township, known as “Station Number 3" : and thence to the vicinity of Sinking Springs in Highland County, "Station Number 4."

 

This was the so-called "underground railroad" across Adams County, although other persons besides those above named frequently sheltered and fed the weary fugitives.

 

On Grace's Run about midway between Cherry Fork and Youngville was the residence of Gen. William McIntyre whose wife was Martha Patton, familiarly known as "Patsey" McIntyre. She was a large strong-minded woman, and from her observations and experience in Virginia where she and her husband had been reared, she had learned to detest the institution of slavery, and had allied herself with those active in assisting fugitive slaves across the border. The home of Gen. McIntyre was known as Station Number 3," as above recited, and many a fugitive has found shelter and protection under the roof of the old red

 

408 - HISTORY OF ADAMS COUNTY

 

brick known as the abode of "Patsey" McIntyre. Tradition says, and the fertile imaginations of unscrupulous writers have added largely to tradition, that upon one occasion "Patsey" met a party of slave hunters from Kentucky at her door who had sworn with terrible oaths that they would enter and search the house for runaways, with a teakettle of boiling water and stood them off until a pitchfork from the loft could be procured for her, when she defied the pursuers and drove them from the premises.

 

The widow of the late George Patton, of Harshaville, a daughter of "Patsey" McIntyre, related to the writer that many slaves had been sheltered in her father's house, and that persons had made inquiry for them, but never threatened such violence as above narrated. She said that once a party of Kentuckians among whom was a Col. Marshall, a brother of the learned barrister Judge James H. Marshall, of Hillsboro, from whose facile pen the story "Treason Trial in Ohio," in this volume comes, came to her father's house and inquired for runaway slaves. They had been in the neighborhood a day or two searching for fugitives and it had been noised about that the negroes were secreted in her father's house, and neighbors and friends anticipating that there would be an attempt to search the premises, gathered in soon after the coming of the Kentuckians. Gen. McIntyre assured the hunters that no fugitives were in the house, and the Kentuckians insisting that there were, "Patsey" McIntyre told them that if they did not leave, she would scald them—the parties then being near the spring back of the house, where Mrs. Patton, then a girl, and her sister were washing clothes. The Kentuckians then went to West Union and got out a warrant to search the premises for "clothing secreted," neither the "clothing" but nor any fugitives were found.

 

A Preacher that Didn't Materialize.

 

It must not be imagined that all the "sympathizers" were of the "Pony" Joe Patton class—for they were not as a body different from other men. They perhaps did sympathize with the fugitive blacks and would give shelter, raiment and food in exchange for much hard labor. Illustrative of this, the writer was informed by an intelligent old negro who ran away from slavery, that when he came to the vicinity of Cherry Fork he was sheltered by a good man in sympathy with the movement to free the blacks, who at the end of a hard year's work, dressed him up in an old pigeon-tailed coat and a bell-crowned fur hat and insisted that the object of his sympathy and charity receive them in consideration of services rendered, assuring him that with such an outfit he might cease manual labor, and live in elegance and ease as a minister come to lead the fallen of his race in the way of glory and righteousness. "But” said the old negro, "When I look in de glass and sees de tail of that cost and that hat only held off'n my shoulders by my ears, I said, 'No,' I can’t preach—you may pay me de cash !"

 

"The Blue Eyed Nigger."

 

Typical of the times in the days of the Fugitive Slave Law, and the "underground railroad," the following anecdote was related to the writer by Mr. Zedekiah Hook, proprietor of the village hotel in Cherry

 

MISCELLANEOUS - 409

 

Fork. Mr. Hook was living at the time of the occurrence on a farm near Clayton in Adams County. There resided in that vicinity at the time a man nemed Lindsey and another by the name of Ambus who with their families had recently come into the neighborhood from some place in Kentucky. Dave Dunbar, now of Manchester, as that gentleman is familiarly called, was at that time a young man working at the harness trade in Vincent Cropper's shop in Clayton. A few days before the incident herein narrated, Lindsey and Ambus had caught away slave and returned him to his master across the Ohio, and received for their services the sum of fifty dollars each, as a reward. This created quite a sensation in and about Clayton, and the loungers who congregated nightly in Cropper's harness shop, grew enthusiastic on the subject of "Nigger Catching" and awarded themselves large sums in the near future from that pursuit. Dave Dunbar listened in silence and resolved to have some sport at the expense of these would-be slave hunters.

 

One evening after supper he dressed himself in a ragged old suit of clothes, and having carefully blacked his face and hands, made his appearance in the village in the guise of a runaway slave. He hurried along the road leading toward Decatur, one of the underground stations, some miles away, seeming to avoid contact with those who saw him. In a few minutes the word was passed around that a fugitive slave had just gone down the Decatur road, and soon the would-be catchers set out in hot pursuit. They were accompanied by a great Newfoundland dog that now and then would scent the fugitive's track and bark encouragingly as the pursuers urged him on. Coming to a turn in the road, they saw beyond, the object of their pursuit hastily climbing a rail fence, and then making off with all his speed across a pasture field toward a piece of woodland some distance away. Now the chase began in earnest, over fences, through fields, across hollows, down hill and up hill, the pursuers shouting and clapping their hands to urge forward the dog to overtake and seize the fugitive, who, when near the crest of a hill he was ascending, from sheer exhaustion came to a halt and threw himself down upon the ground. The pursuers seeing this tried to recall the dog then close upon the fugitive, fearful that he would be torn to pieces by the savage brute before they could interpose. But to their astonishment the dog ran up to where the fugitive lay, wagged his tail in a friendly manner and sat down upon his haunches to await the coming of the pursuing party. To their disappointment and great chargin upon approaching, they found the supposed runaway slave to be Dave Dunbar, rolling upon the ground convulsed with laughter had at the sport he had at their expense.

 

Now the whole party entered into the spirit of the affair, and it was agreed that Dunbar should make his way alone across the fields to the residence of Lindsey and inquire the way to Dr. Norton's, an "underground" station, near Decatur some miles distant. He did so, and Lindsey fearing to seize him single handed, in order to get the aid of Ambus, told the supposed fugitive that he could not direct him as requested, but that a neighbor near by could, and he would accompany the inquirer there to obtain the desired information. They found Ambus at home and were invited into the house, but no sooner had they entered

 

410 - HISTORY OF ADAMS COUNTY

 

than Lindsey locked the door, and he and Ambus seized the supposed runaway, and informed him that they would return him to his master in Kentucky. The wife of Ambus threw the bed upon the floor in order to get the cord off the bedstead to secure the fugitive. While this was taking place, Lindsey's wife, who had put in an appearance, got into a serious altercation with the Ambus woman as to the share of the reward each should have, the one accusing the other of getting a silk dress out of the last reward, while she got but a calico gown.

 

After the fugitive had been securely bound he was taken before old 'Squire Bryan for identification. Lindsey testified that he knew the captive to be the property of a Mr. McKee near Washington, Kentucky. That he had worked as a laborer for McKee the year previous, and saw this negro daily. That his name was William, and that he was positive this was the same person for he was the only "blue-eyed nigger he had ever seen."

Then Dunbar, to the amazement of the court and witness, disclosed his identity, and was speedily unbound and discharged. Lindsey and Ambus took their departure amid the jeers and shouts of the spectators, and soon afterward removed from the county.

 

* Postoffices in Adams County.

 

Beasley Fork 6

Beaver Pond 23

Bentonville 5

Blue Creek 15

Bradyville 10

Buck Run 20

Cedar Mills 10

Cherry Fork 10

Dunbarton 11

Dunkinsville 6

Eckmansville 16

Emerald 18

Fawcett 10

Grimes 12

Harshaville 10

Hills Fork 7

Jaybird 22

Locust Grove 16

Lovett 21

Lynx 10

McCullough 15

Maddox 10

Manchester 10

May Hill

Mineral Springs 18

Osman 5

Peebles 13

Seaman 15

Selig 20

Stephens 14

Stout 27

Tranquillity 17

Tulip

Vineyard Hill 8

Waggoners Ripple 10

Wamsley 20

West Union

Wheat 8

Wilson 14

Winchester 14

Youngsville 14

* Names in black letter are Money Order offices. Figures following, indicate distance West Union.