CHAPTER I FIRST YEARS AS A CITY. The original incorporation of the Borough of Columbus was effected by act of the General Assembly passed March 3, 1834. By that act, which will be more specifically referred to in a later chapter, `1 so much of the county of Franklin " as was comprised within certain specified boundaries was declared to be a city, and the inhabitants thereof were created a body corporate and politic, with perpetual succession, by the name and style of the City of Columbus." From the passage of this act dates a new era in the political life of the capital, which, for the sake of convenience may be denominated the Intermediate Period. New phases of commercial, industrial and social activity following the building of the National Road, the opening of the Canal, the establishment of a solvent and safe system of State Banking, the discovery and practical application of the Magnetic Telegraph, and finally, the advent of wheeled transportation by steam, were contemporary and also nearly conterminous with that period. Under special topics a portion of the incidents attending these economic changes have already been narrated ; our present task shall be to note the general course of miscellaneous events in the history of the capital down to the time when its political and business life assumed a metropolitan type. In other words, we shalt now endeavor to bridge the historical space lying between the first active development of commerce by canal and the commercial, industrial and social metamorphosis produced by the utilization of mineral resources which followed the opening of the Hocking Valley Railway. Prior to the construction of the National Road and the Ohio Canal the growth of Columbus, notwithstanding its advantages as the seat of government, had not been rapid. In 1831 the town contained about three hundred and fifty dwellings, fifteen general stores, four printing offices, one bank, a markethouse, four churches—Presbyterian, Methodist, German Lutheran and Episcopalian—five clergymen, ten lawyers, five regular physicians, and a total population of 2,434 inhabitants. Such was the capital when the opening of the canal brought it into direct commercial connections with the East, and imparted a fresh stimulus to its development. In consequence of that stimulus several new additions to the town were laid out and sold,-and so many new families arrived that a portion of them were obliged to go away again for want of houses to dwell in. This progress received a serious check from the cholera outbreak of 1833, but was renewed after [3] 4 - HISTORY OF THE CITY of COLUMBUS. that epidemic had passed, and received an additional impetus from the completion of the National Road. At the time the Borough was incorporated as a city in 1834, its 11 official, professional and business men and houses," according to Martin, were as follows :2 United States Officers.—Clerk of the United States Courts, William Miner; Marshal of the District of Ohio, John Patterson; District Attorney, Noah H. Swayne; Postmaster, Bela Latham;' Superintendent of the National Road, Henry Brewerton; Engineer and inspector, ditto, David Scott; Indian Agent, John McElvain. State Officers.—Secretary of State, Benjamin Hinkson ; State Treasurer, Henry Brown; State Auditor, John A. Bryan; Chief Clerk in State Auditor's Office, Timothy Griffith; Keeper of the Ohio Penitentiary, William W. Gault; Superintendent of New Penitentiary, N. Medbury; State Librarian, Zachariah Mills; Adjutant- General, Samuel C. Andrews; Quartermaster - General, Christopher Niswanger. Practising Lawyers.—Gustavus Swan, Orris Parish, Noah H. Swayne, P. B. Wilcox, Lyne Starling, Junior, M. J. Gilbert, Mease Smith, John G. Miller, Samuel C. Andrews, John D. Munford. Practising Physicians.—Samuel Parsons, John M. Edmiston, M. B. Wright, Peter Jackson, Peleg Sisson, Robert Thompson, William M. Awl, N. N. Miller, S. Z. Seltzer, J. S. Landes, P. H. Eberly. Officiating Clergymen.—James Hoge, D. D., Presbyterian; William Preston, Episcopalian; L. B. Gurley, Russell Bigelow, Thomas Asbury and Jesse F. Wiscom, Methodist, Mr. Gurley being a stationed preacher and Messrs. Bigelow, Asbury and Wiscom, Temperance Agents; George Jeffries and Edward Davis, Baptist. Merchants.—In dry goods and groceries, L. Goodale & Co., Buttles & Matthews, Stewart & Higgins, D. Woodbury, J. & S. Stone, A. P. Stone, John Greenwood, D. W. Deshler, McCoy & Work, John Brooks, Reuben Brooks, David Brooks, T. Peters & Son, Saunders & Frye, Bond & Walbridge, Burr & Gregory, M. Northrup, Brotherton & Kooken, Joshua Baldwin & Co., Lemuel Reynolds, Olmsted & St. Clair, Robert Russell & Co. ; auction store, C. W. Kent; wholesale druggists, 0. & S. Crosby, Sumner Clark, J. S. & D. Landes; booksellers and stationers, I. N. Whiting, B. & J. Turnbull ; tin and hardware, W. M. Kasson & Co., W. A. Gill & Co.; shoes, William W. Blake; jewelry, William A. Platt; wholesale grocers, Sherwood & Gregory, Finley & Hanford; grocer and liquordealer, John Young. Taverns.—National Hotel, John Noble; Franklin House (Southeast corner High and Town), J. Robinson & Son; Globe Hotel, Robert Russell; Lion Hotel, Jeremiah Armstrong; Swan Hotel, Christian Heyl; Eagel Hotel, David Brooks; White Horse Wagonyard, Amos Meneely; Farmers' and Mechanics' Tavern, T. Cadwallader; Boarding House, Ira Grover. To this list should be added some leather stores and small factories. The first theatre, of which a more particular account will be given in another chapter, was opened in the autumn of 1835. FIRST YEARS AS A CITY - 5 One of the most interesting features of life at the capital at this time was the attendance of distinguished lawyers at the sessions of the courts. On this subject we find the following interesting sentences in one of the Jewett letters heretofore quoted : United States Circuit Court closed its session a short time since. At the bar was quite a concentration of western talent. Judge McLean presides with supreme dignity. He is revered as a judge, and is very popular as a man. His bearing is such as would not ill befit the Chief Magistracy of the United States, and as for strong and commanding power of mind, the most jealous concede te him a mere than erdinary share. The celebrated lawyer Doddridge, ef Virginia, appeared at the bar.. . . His constitution is of iron, and dissipation, with late hours, have not been able te weaken it.. . . He is a signal instance of the weakness of moral united with the strength of intellectual power. Mr. Ewing, our United States Senator, was also on the carpet. A selfmade man, at twenty years ef age he was an inferior laborer at the Kanawha Saltworks in Virginia. Behold him now! He is distinguished for unraveling the Gerdian knots of the law. Mr. J. C. Wright was opposed to him in several cases. The sparring of the Judge and the Senater was kept up with wonderful spirit. Of the general prosperity and prospects of the capital in 1836 we have the following contemporary statements :4 Our citizens have, as it were per force, yielded acquiescence to the gradual, and, because gradual, almost imperceptible rise in real estate in this vicinity. . . . In the meantime the National Road has been completed to this point from the East, and is rapidly progressing West; the Sandusky and Columbus Turnpike has been completed, and numerous important and feasible projects for railroads, turnpikes, &c., are in embryo, proposing to connect our city with the Lakes, the Ohio River South and East of us, and with the Mississippi in the Far West. The consequence of these things, added to the privileges we enjoy from the Ohio Canal, the rapid increase of our city population (100 per cent in five years) and the high prices which everything consumable bears in our market, has gradually, but certainly and surely enhanced the value of real estate in this city and the country adjacent. . .. It is rumored, and we believe with truth, that some eastern capitalists have recently turned their attention to us. . . . In regard to city property it should be borne in mind that we are situated not only in the center and at the capital of ene ef the richest and most fertile States of the Union, but that we are enjoying and about to enjoy extended privileges which no ether inland town can possibly partake of. Who does not perceive that a canal or railroad will in a very few years connect us by a direct route through the Scioto Valley with Lake Erie ? Who doubts but the Baltimore & Ohio Railroad will in five years reach the capital of Ohio ? Whe doubts but that the great projected Railroad from Charleston te Lake Erie will be completed in ten years, and pass directly through Columbus towards Cleveland? If any, surely no one can doubt but that in less time a Railroad or M'Adamized road will extend from this direct te Cleveland on the East and Cincinnati on the West. Leok which way you will, it is apparent that Columbus is, and from its situatien must be, a radiating centre from and to which innumerable sources of wealth and prosperity will continue to flow. Five years since, it contained about 2,500 inhabitants; now about 5,500. Five years hence its numbers may not he less than eight — perhaps ten thousand. The financial troubles which culminated in 1837 put a blight upon these fine prospects. Real estate and general prices declined, and for several years business remained in a disturbed or languid state Nevertheless Columbus must have been an interesting town, and withal a pleasant place to live in. The editor of the Wheeling Times, who visited the place as a delegate to an editorial convention in 1839 wrote of Ohio's capital : 6 - HISTORY OF THE CITY OF COLUMBUS. It is new the prettiest town we have seen in the western country. It is prettily situated, and contains private residences exhibiting a high degree both of taste and wealth. There is an easy and comfortable air, a manifestation of learning, good morals and refinement, in all parts of the city, and a most secial and agreeable manner evinced, so far as we could judge, in its inhabitants. The so called Michigan Boundary dispute, which culminated in February 1835, produced an episode of considerable local interest. The origin of this dispute may be briefly sketched. The Ordinance of 1787 authorized the formation of one or two states from that portion of the Northwest Territory lying " north of an east and west line drawn through the southerly bend or extreme of Lake Michigan," and the enabling act of Congress under which Ohio was admitted to the Union as a State described her northern boundary as " an east and west line drawn to the southerly extreme of Lake Michigan, running east after intersecting the due north line from the mouth of the Great Miami until it shall intersect Lake Erie, or the territorial line, and thence with the same line through Lake Erie to the Pennsylvania line." Perceiving that a line drawn due east from the southern extremity of Lake Michigan would probably not intersect the Maumee Bay at all, but fall south of it, the convention which framed the first constitution of Ohio put into that instrument a proviso that, should this apprehension be confirmed, then, with the assent of Congress, the northern boundary of Ohio should " be established by and extend to a direct line running from the southern extremity of Lake Michigan to the most northerly cape of the Miami Bay, after intersecting the due north line from the mouth of the Great Miami [Maumee] River aforesaid; thence northeast to the territorial line to the Pennsylvania line." In 1817, the line thus constitutionally defined was surveyed, under national auspices, by William Harris, and in 1818, it was formally adopted by the General Assembly of Ohio as the northern boundary of the State. Meanwhile the Territory of Michigan had been formed with the southern boundary defined in the same paradoxical terms which had been used by Congress in the enabling act fixing the northern boundary of Ohio. Thus a sort of Schleswig-Holstein question was raised on our northern border, and it was not long in assuming a serious aspect. Congress undoubtedly intended to assign to Ohio a boundary substantially identical with the Harris line, but the territorial authorities of Michigan were not disposed to acquiesce in that view. These authorities claimed and proceeded to exercise jurisdiction over all the territory north of it line due east and west from the southern extremity of Lake Michigan, thus assuming to take from Ohio a triangular tract over which she had hitherto held undisputed sway, and which extended from Lake Erie to her western boundary. This strip was about ten miles wide at its eastern extremity, and included the present site of the city of Toledo. On February 12, 1835, the Legislative Council of Michigan passed an act asserting control over this tract, and on the twentysecond of the same month the General Assembly of Ohio, acting in pursuance of a special message from Governor Lucas, passed an act identifying the northern boundary of the State with the Harris line. Thus the issue was joined. Stevens T. Mason, acting Governor of Michigan, officially announced that an armed collision was inevitable FIRST YEARS AS A CITY - 7 and marshaled his militia forces to meet the crisis; Governor Lucas, equally determined, appointed a commission to definitely locate the Harris line, and directed John Bell, Major-General of the Seventeenth Division of the Ohio Militia, to meet him at Perrysburg, April 1, with a force sufficient to protect the commissioners in the discharge of their duties. Pursuant to this command General Bell assembled a force of about five hundred men on the frontier, but the intercession of a peace commission from Washington prevented an actual outbreak of hostilities. Nevertheless nine members of the Ohio surveying party were seized by the Michigan militia, and the boundary commissioners were obliged to fly to Perrysburg. Thereupon Governor Lucas summoned the General Assembly to meet in extra, session beginning June 8, and directed his Adjutant-General, Samuel C. Andrews, to ascertain what number of volunteer cavalry and mounted riflemen could be raised and equipped who would be willing to march out at a moment's warning to defend the rights and honor of the State to sustain our civil authorities in the discharge of their duties, and to protect our citizens within the constitutional limits of the State. Responding to the recommendations of the Governor, the General Assembly passed acts to “prevent the forcible abduction of citizens of Ohio ;" created, in part from the disputed territory, the county of Lucas, with Toledo as its seat of j justice ; appropriated $300,000 for war purposes, and authorized a loan of $300,000 more if needed. In harmony with these measures, Adjutant-General Andrews reported that he had a force of ten thousand men ready for action. Public opinion fully sustained the Governor and the war feeling ran high. “Our citizen soldiers," said the State ,Journal of August of 28, "are prepared to turn out en masse." Meanwhile Governor Lucas dispatched Noah H. Swayne, William Allen and D. T. Disney to Washington to present the Ohio case to President Jackson, who, without assuming to exercise other authority in the matter than that of mediator, exerted such influence as prevented further aggressions from the Michigan side. On June 29, 1836, Governor Mason was removed from office, and in June, 1836, Congress formally confirmed Ohio's claim, but, as an indemnity to Michigan for the loss of disputed territory on her southern border, presented to her the great mineral and timber region now known as the Northern Peninsula. For a long time after this trouble was allayed, the adventures of the " Michigan War" were favorite themes for popular jest and raillery. In the General Assembly this disposition to make merry over the matter found vent in various prosposed amendments to a bill, pending in 1837, to organize and discipline the state militia. Among these amendments was the following humorous preamble offered by Mr. Quinby: Whereas, our warriors, in days of yore, Went forth from peaceful scenes To try the tug of furious war Among the Wolverines; And whereas, most villanous traps and snares Were then prepared to catch them; 8 - HISTORY OF THE CITY OF COLUMBUS. Black swamps to swallow them unawares, And briars and thorns to scratch them ; And whereas, most wonderful feats of arms, And legs, were then performed, Whilst raging owls sang forth alarms And the brambly battle stormed ; Therefore that we may emulate These deeds of chivalry, And equal glories perpetrate, Let it enacted be. On January 26, 1838, the General Assembly passed an act for the erection of a new statehouse. Full particulars as to this measure, and the structure for which it provided, are reserved for the chapter on the history of the Capitol. Present reference to the subject is made because of its relations to a formidable effort soon afterwards put forth for the removal of the seat of government. Antecedent to the formal manifestation of this effort an expectation seems to have taken root in various towns in Central Ohio that after expiration of the period for which the State was bound by contract with the Starling syndicate to keep the capital at Columbus, a chance would be offered for its location at some other point. As early as 1837 signs of this expectation assumed the form of open suggestions of removal, coupled with various labored allegations as to the shortcomings of Columbus. One of the most conspicuous accusations with which that inchoate city was railed against was that of putting on “metropolitan airs." To this insinuating charge was added the assertion that the framed "high bank opposite Franklinton " was, in fact, one of the most unhealthy locations that could have been selected, besides being, as was alleged, too far from the geographical centre of the State. These and similar tales were beginning to produce some impression upon public opinion when an incident took place which gave them sufficient force to precipitate a crisis. During the legislative session of 1839-40 Samuel Medary, the State Printer, was blamed by certain political antagonists for having appropriated to his own use as a perquisite the outside quires —casse or "quasi " quires, as they were called — of each ream of paper purchased for the State. In the House of Representatives charges that the Public Printer had sold as his own a quantity of broken quires or,, quasi paper" were referred to a special committee of which R. P. Spalding, of Portage County, was Chairman. This committee reported justifying the Public Printer in appropriating the casse quires, on the ground that such paper was "not suitable for the Public Printing " nor “for any other printing of an ordinary character," and that it had "long been an established usage among printers to appropriate it to various subordinate and incidental uses about the office, and to consider it as one of the perquisites of their calling." The discussion of this subject elicited proposals for the execution of the State printing on contract at lower rates than were then being paid. These proposals were presented to the Senate and there referred to a select committee from which FIRST YEARS AS A CITY - 9 majority and minority reports were made, the first declaring that the public printing was being done more cheaply in Ohio than in other states and as cheaply as it could be properly done; while the minority report took the opposite view and condemned the perquisite of the caste quires as an abuse which should be discontinued. All this nettled Mr. Medary, who lost no time in making things interesting for his persecutors. As a means of giving these gentlemen something else than the case quires to think about, charges were brought against one of their party associates, William B. Lloyd, member of the House of Representatives from Cuyahoga County, of having surreptitiously altered certain accounts against him which had been assigned to a third party. By a partisan vote, Mr. Lloyd was pronounced guilty of these charges, and a motion for his expulsion was made, but failed to receive the votes of two-thirds of the members, and was therefore lost. Thereupon a friend of Mr. Lloyd's drew up the following paper, which was circulated in the town for signatures: COLUMBUS, February 13, 1840. William B. Lloyd, Esq., DEAR Sir: — The undersigned. convinced beyond doubt that the charge lately circulated against yourself is totally unsustained by the testimony relating to the matter, and the act charged one of which it is impossible you should be guilty, beg leave respectfully to assure you of our undiminished confidence in the integrity of your character and to express to you our sincerest wishes for your future happiness and prosperity. On the evening of February 17 the State Journal published this document with sixty-three names attached to it, among the signatures being those of such well known citizens as George M. Parsons, William A. Platt, Alfred Kelley, J. N. Champion and James Kilbourn. As is usual in such cases, most of the names had been signed thoughtlessly, without intention to give offense, yet such was the resentment provoked by it, and by Mr. Lloyd, reappearance in the Rouse of Representatives, accompanied to the lobby by some of his partisans, that on the following morning, eighteenth, a bill to repeal the act providing for the erection of a new statehouse was reported from the Judiciary Committee by Mr. Charles B. Flood, member from Licking County; and Mr. R. P. Spalding, member from Portage County, presented, a few minutes later, the following resolution : That a select committee of five be appointed to inquire into the expediency of removing the seat of government of the State from Columbus, in Franklin County, to Newark, in Licking County. Delaware, in Delaware County, or Mt. Vernon, in Knox County, and that said committee report by bill or otherwise. The proceedings which followed are thus reported in the State Journal: Mr. Spalding wished to have the seat of government removed to some place where the members of the legislature could be free from insult and interference. Mr. [C. B.] Flood moved to amend the resolution so as to instruct the committee to report such a bill. Mr. [Moses B.] Corwin [Champaign County] defended the citizens of Columbus from the imputation cast upon them by the mover of the resolution. Mr. Spalding maintained that the subject should be inquired into. A bill had been introduced to repeal the act authorizing the erection of a new statehouse, which would unquestionably pass the houses. It was time to take this course before it would be too late. 10 - HISTORY OF THE CITY OF COLUMBUS. The New Statehouse had not progressed so far that inquiry or loss would occur to the State by the removal of the seat of government. The people had talked about the matter. Mr. S. remarked that the people of Columbus had already received enough from the hands of the government of the State. They had hung like leeches upon the body politic, and were filled to surfeiting. Mr. S. alluded to the " loving satellites of the lobby," but the drift of the remark was not perceptible. Mr. [Alexander] Waddle [Clark County], who thought the object of the resolution was to manifest a vengeance against the people of Columbus for daring to express their opinion, made the following amendment: And that said committee be instructed to report a bill prohibiting the citizens of Ohio from expressing their opinions on the proceedings of the legislature in other terms than of unqualified approbation. Mr. Lloyd asked to be excused from voting, as he had just come in, and did not understand the question fully. The House refusing to grant him leave, he voted, remarking at the same time that such legislation was above his comprehension. Mr. Lloyd moved to amend the amendment of Mr. Waddle by inserting the following: " And that said committee be instructed to report also a bill for the removal of the Penitentiary." Mr. [Andrew H.] Patterson, of Delaware, moved also to insert "the Lunatic Asylum." Mr. Lloyd observed that he would suggest in the most polite manner possible to the gentleman from Delaware that this institution was one in which the gentleman had no kind of personal interest, for, said Mr. L., to those to whom the Almighty, in his wisdom and benevolence had denied preception, such an institution would never become necessary, and would never need the benefits of a Lunatic Asylum. Mr. Patterson said he could not reply to the remarks ef the gentleman from Cuyahoga, uttered either here or elsewhere. Mr. Lloyd begged the gentleman from Delaware not to be alarmed, as they were not now on the other side of the Ohio River. Mr. Patterson moved to add the following: And that the members of the legislature shall first consult the citizens of Columbus upon all natters of importance that may be presented for their action, at least so far as the expulsion of a Whig member may be concerned. Mr. Waddle moved to strike out "Columbus," as possibly the legislature might sit hereafter at Delaware. Mr. [Samuel] Reed [Ross, Pike and Jackson counties] moved to ]ay the resolution on the table 'till "the House should get cooler." The amendment offered by Mr. Flood was lost by a tie vote, 32 to 32, the Speaker (Thomas J. Buchanan, Clermont County) voting in the affirmative. The amendments of Messrs. Waddle and Lloyd were both lost by a vote of three yeas to sixty nays. The resolution offered by Mr. Spalding was then adopted, without amendment, by the following vote : Yeas—Messrs. Bartley, Blair, Downes, Fisher, Flood, Hanna, Henderson, Hite, Hoagland, Hubbard, Jenkins, Johnson of Monroe, Johnson of Jackson, King, Leedom, Leonard, Lepper, Lloyd, McAnelly, Mitchell, Moore of Hamilton, Morris, Purviance, Ravenscraft, Reed, Riblet, Rogers, Shideler, Shreve, Spalding, Warner, Way, Welch of Seneca, West, Whittlesey, Wilson of Perry and Speaker-37. Nays - Messrs. Ackley, Adams, Baskin, Bliss, Carpenter, Casad, Comstock, Corwin, Davis, Dunham, Everhard, Godman, Harrison, Howe, Miller, Moore of Guernsey, Morse, Patterson, Pollock, Powers, Scott, Sellers, Smith of Stark, Spencer, Waddle, Wilson of Wayne and Worth-27. FIRST YEARS AS A CITY - 11 The Flood bill repealing the act of January 26, 1838, providing for the erection of a new statehouse was passed by the House February 25, and by the Senate March 10, l840.5 It therefore became a law, notwithstanding the fact that over forty thousand dollars had already been expended in the construction of the new capitol building. It set back the erection of a new statehouse nearly a decade. Immediately after this repealing act was passed the advocates of capital removal renewed their agitation of the subject, and obtained its reference in the General Assembly to a joint select committee. The report of this committee, submitted to the House on the thirteenth and to the Senate on the sixteenth of March, arguedthat a removal of the capital would not be a breach of faith, inasmuch as the act of February 1.4, 1812, by which the seat of government was fixed at Columbus, expressly provided that the legislative session should continue there until May 1, 1840, " and from thence until otherwise provided by law." The report concluded by recommending the adoption of the following resolutions: 1. That the Governor be requested to issue his proclamation setting forth that the period has arrived for the permanent establishment of the seat of government, that all portions of the State may have an opportunity of offering such inducements as they may deem proper for the permanent location at such point as may be designated. 2. That all propositions for the permanent establishment of the seat of government at any point in the State be sealed and directed by the persons making the same to the Governor by the first day of August next, who shall open and communicate the same to the next General Assembly. In the House, on March 14, these resolutions were adopted by a vote of 34 to 20 ; in the Senate, on March 16, they were referred, together with the report recommending them, to the standing committee on Public Buildings. A majority report adverse to the resolutions was presented from that committee by its Chairman, Hon. John L. Green, March 20, and was laid on the table. The report thus disposed of makes an elaborate review of the legislative history of the act of February 14, 1812, locating the seat of government at Columbus, and makes numerous citations from the records to prove that the location was intended to be permanent. Referring to the clause in the locating act which provides that the legislative sessions shall continue to be held at Columbus until May 1, 1840, and "thenceforth until otherwise provided by law," the report states that this clause was added by way of amendment after the bill had been engrossed for third reading, and also subsequent to the execution by the proprietors of their penal bond. Unfortunately for this argument, the amendment referred to was not attached to the bill until after the proprietors had submitted their supplementary proposition pledging themselves to comply with the terms of their bond, then already executed and delivered, provided the capital should remain on the lands offered by them until 1840. In his History of Franklin County, lion. William T. Martin says that neither the advocates nor the opponents of capital removal stern to have been aware of this supplementary proposition, and accounts for this by stating that the document had somehow got lost from the files of the State Treasurer's office. This well timed accident--if such it was --Mr. Martin thinks, "was possibly the means of' saving the seat of government to Columbus." 12 - HISTORY OF THE CITY OF COLUMBUS. The following paragraph from the report of the committee is still pertinent It is said that the City of Columbus and the County of Franklin have derived great pecuniary advantages from the location of the seat of government here. This is true to some extent. But it is also true that the real property of the city and county has been assessed higher, on this account, by at least a million and a quarter of dollars. On this increased assessment the people of Columbus and of the County of Franklin have been compelled for years to pay taxes as well for state purposes as for corporation and county purposes. In support of these allegations the report makes the following citations from the annual report of the |
Counties. |
Number Acres. |
Value. |
Value of Town Property |
Total in each County |
Franklin Licking Muskingum Fairfield |
337,410 418,360 404,293 320,256 |
$1,839,174 00 1,746,542 00 1,279,003 00 1,389,327 00 |
$1,255,969 00 459,520 00 799,040 00 487,727 00 |
$3,065,141 00 2,106,062 00 2,078,043 00 1,877,054 00 |
While partisan resentment and expectation of profit from the seat of government seem to have had much to do with the repeal of the act providing for the erection of a new statehouse, the repeal was doubtless due in a much larger degree to the monetary stress then prevailing. The problem of providing the means necessary for continuance of the work was a serious one to a state treasury already fearfully embarrassed. In another chapter the financial depression which prevailed during the last of the thirties and first of the forties has been described, and the tact and resolution by which the State was saved from the disgrace of repudiation have been referred to. The condition of the state and general finances in 1841 is thus portrayed in a private letter written by Colonel Noah H. Swayne to a correspondent in the East: I am greatly alarmed by what you say in regard to the prospect of raising means to pay our interest. Stocks dull at 75! The London Agents forbidden to make advances! The banks pressing for the payment of their temporary loans! Money tight beyond example, panic and paralysis universally prevalent, everything covered with gloom and despondency, and tending downward to the lowest point. It is a crisis calculated to quail the stoutest heart. That the construction of the new capitol should have been suspended at such a time is easy enough to account for aside from the complications of contemporary partisanship. That the repealing act went farther than merely to suspend the work is true, yet evidences are not wanting that a strong disposition to renew the work as soon as circumstances would permit still lingered in the General Assembly. On February 20, 1841, Mr. Probasco reported from the standing committee of the House on Public Buildings a bill to provide for the erection of a new statehouse. After rejecting a proposed substitute appropriating $1,500 to put a new roof on FIRST YEARS AS A CITY - 13 the old statehouse, the House passed this bill, March 10, by a vote of 34 to 25. On March 15 the Senate postponed it indefinitely by a vote of 20 to 15. Of the efforts to remove the seat of government from Columbus we hear nothing more until the legislative session of 1842-3, when the matter was brought up again by reference of a memorial praying for the removal to the Senate standing committee on Public Institutions. The memorial thus referred was that of a meeting of citizens of Licking County held at Newark, and was presented to the Senate by Mr. Parker, December 20, 1842. It was accompanied by proposals to erect public buildings without expense to the State provided Newark should be selected as the seat of government. The members of the committee to which the memorial was referred were Senators Nelson Franklin, of Pickaway and Fairfield; Samuel Lahm, of Stark; and James Parker, of Licking. A majority and a minority report were made from the committee, the former by Messrs. Franklin and Lahm, the latter by Mr. Parker. The majority report reviews the legislative proceedings germane to the location of the capital in 1812, and bases its argument almost exclusively upon such facts as support the theory that the location was intended to be permanent. "In the face of all this," concludes the report, Could the legislature make a removal without a manifest violation of the faith of the State, and a direct outrage upon the rights of the citizens of Columbus? A majority of the committee think not ; and believing, as they do, that the honor of the State is of more importance than the paltry sum in dollars and cents which it is believed by some could he saved by a removal, they here express their decided disapprobation of any legislation designed to accomplish that object. The minority report, like that presented in the House by Mr. Flood, of Licking, in 1840, lays great stress upon the limitation of time inserted into the locating act of 1812, but neither Mr. Parker's report nor that of the majority refers to the voluntary acceptance of that limitation by the original proprietors. In the course of his argument, Mr. Parker puts forth this appeal The time is not distant when the present dilapidated and inconvenient Statehouse must be replaced by one more commensurate with the wants of the legislature, and consistent with the rank and importance of the State. Indeed, so obvious was this a few years since, that the legislature commenced preparations for building a new capitol on a scale of princely magnificence which was only prevented from adding one or two millions to the burden of the State debt which now oppresses us, by the offer, on the part of some other town, to erect the public buildings at their own expense on condition of becoming the seat of government, and the increasing wants of an exhausted public treasury. The minority of your committee doubt whether at any time the erection of a palace, at the expense of millions to the people, is consistent with the genius of that people or the simplicity of our institutions. But he submits, that at a time like the present, with a people already borne down by taxation and debt, as our people must necessarily be for years to come, they will not be inclined to submit to an addition of a million er a million and a half to their already oppressive burdens, to beautify and adorn the city of Columbus, particularly when other places as conveniently situated for the interests of the State are willing and have offered to erect all the buildings necessary for the proper accommodation of the different departments of the government, free of expense to the State. The report concludes by recommending passage of the resolutions quoted in a preceding part of this chapter which were presented and recommended by the 14 - HISTORY OF THE CITY OF COLUMBUS. Joint Select Committee of 1840. On March 6, 1843, these resolutions were adopted by the Senate, yeas 18, nays 16.6 On March 7 they were taken up in the House and rejected, yeas 29, nays 36.̊ This decisively adverse vote of the House of Representatives gave to the capital removal project its final quietus. From that hour to this no such scheme has again been seriously broached. NOTES. 1. Jewett Letters. 2. History of Franklin County. 3. The Postoffice was at that time located in one of the Buckeye Exchange buildings, on West Broad Street, where it had been since its original establishment, and where it remained until it was removed to East State Street. 4. Ohio State Journal, February 2, 1836. 5. In the House the vote stood: Yeas.—Messrs. Bartley, Baskin, Blair, Downes, Dunn, Filson, Fisher, Flood, Henderson, Hite, Hubbard, Jenkins, Johnson of Jackson, King, Leedom, Lepper, McAnnelly, Mitchell, Moore of Hamilton, Morris, Purviance, Ravenscraft, Rea, Reed, Riblet, Rogers, Shideler, Shreve, Smith of Montgomery, Spalding, Warner, Way, Welch of Seneca, West, Whittlesey, Wilson of Perry, and Speaker-37. Nays.—Messrs. Ackley, Adams, Bliss, Carpenter, Casad, Comstock, Corwin, Davis, Dunham, Everhard, Ford, Harrison, Hoagland, Howe, Lake, Miller, Moore of Guernsey, Morse, Patterson, Pollock, Powers, Scott, Sellers, Smith of Stark, Waddle and Worth-26. Senate : Yeas.— Messrs. Allen, Bissell, Brady, Craighill, Aran, Holmes, Hough, Humphreys, Hunt, Ihrig, Mathews, Mitchell, Patterson, Shideler, Spangler, Stadden, Thompson and Utter—? 8. Nays.—Birch, Glover, Green, Harlan, Henderson, Hostetter, Lord, Nash, Perkins, Shannon, Smith, Thomas, Tod, Tracy, Vance and Speaker-16. 6. Senate, March 6, 1843. Vote on resolutions reported from the Standing Committee on Public Institutions: Yeas.—Messrs. Aten, Clark, Harris, Hazeltine, Johnston, Jones, Koch, Leuden, Miller, Mitchell, McAnelly, McConnell, McCutchen, Parker, Ritchey, Robbins, Wolcott and Speaker —18. Nays—Messrs. Barnett, Denny, Ford, Franklin, Fuller, Henderson, Jackson, Lahm, Latham, Newton, Nash, Ridgway, Stanton, Updegraff, Vanvorhes and Wade-16. 17. House March 7, 1843: Yeas.—Messrs. Baird, Brush, Brown, Dyington, Cahill, Clark, Douglass, Green, Gruver, Henderson, Humphreys, James, Kilgore, King, Larwell, Martin of Columbiana, Martin of Stark, Meredith, McConnell, McNulty, Okey, Pilcher, Rees, Reid, Spindler, Steedman, Warner, White and Wilferd-29. Nays.—Messrs. Ackley, Atherton, Baldwin, Bowen, Campbell, Chambers, Chenowith, Converse, Curry, Counts, Dike, Fisher, Fudge, Fuller, Gallagher, Hauseman, Johnson, Kelley of Cuyahoga, Kelley of Perry, Larsh, McClure, McFarland, Olds, Pardee, Probasco, Robinson, Ross, Seward, Schenck, Sharp, Smith, Tuttle, Wakefield, Webb, Woodbridge and Speaker-36, CHAPTER II. SECOND WAR EPISODE. Passing the events of the earlier forties which have been or will be treated in other chapters, we arrive at an epoch which for convenience may be termed the second war episode in the history of Columbus. On February 28, 1845, the Texas Annexation Resolutions were passed by Congress, and on March 1 they were signed by President Tyler. Three (lays later James K. Poll, was inaugurated as Mr. Tyler's successor, in the National Presidency. Texas was at this time an independent republic, claiming territory as far west as the Rio Grande. Mexico, also a republic, claimed as far east as the river Nueces. On June 18, 1845, the Texan Congress gave its unanimous assent to the terms of annexation proposed by the United States and summoned a convention to assemble July 4 to frame a constitution for the new State of Texas. By direction of the War Department, General Zachary Taylor, then commanding in the Southwest, sailed in July from New Orleans with fifteen hundred troops, and with this force landed early in August at Corpus Christi and took his position on the line of the Nueces. Here he was reinforced with twentyfive hundred men and remained unmolested during the ensuing autumn and winter. On March 8, 1846, he advanced by positive orders of the President into the disputed territory, crossed an arid, unpeopled region to the Rio Grande, and erected Fort Brown on the left bank of that river, opposite Matamoras. The Mexican General Ampudia, commanding on the right bank, addressed a note to Taylor demanding that he should return immediately beyond the Nueces and there remain until the pending question in relation to Texas" should be adjusted. Acquiescence in this demand being refused, General Arista, who had succeeded Ampudia, crossed from Mexico a few days later with a force six thousand strong and attacked Taylor May 8 at Palo Alto, a few miles east of Matamoras. The Mexicans were defeated, renewed the battle next day at Resaca de la Palma, were again defeated and were driven across the Rio Grande. On May 11 President Polk sent a message announcing these events to Congress, which responded two (lays later by the passage of an act calling for 50,000 volunteers and appropriating $10,000,000 for the prosecution of the struggle. The call for troops was enthusiastically responded to in the South, but not so ardently in the North, where the war was regarded with deep disfavor as an aggression for the aggrandizement of slavery. Besides, in Ohio, as generally in the [15] 16 - HISTORY OF THE CITY OF COLUMBUS. James Spurgeon, private. Daniel Shetler, private. Lemuel Northern States, military ardor had become almost extinct. Militia service was considered a nuisance, and its musters and parades were subjects of ridicule. An attempt to assemble the militia officers of the State in a general encampment at Columbus in 1842 encountered such hopeless indifference that, after much effort, it was abandoned. The finest company of citizen soldiers which had ever been organized at the capital prior to the outbreak of the Mexican War was that known as the Columbus Guards, which had been disbanded some four years earlier. The Cadets, another fine company, had also been disbanded. Almost the sole remaining military interest in the city was confined to its German born citizens, by whom two excellent artillery companies had been organized and kept in training. But notwithstanding the laxity of militia organization and the popular dislike of conquest for the extension of slaveholding, Ohio sent more troops to the field than any other northern state. Her enlistments for the volunteer service numbered 5,536, from which were organized four regiments and three independent companies. Besides these the State furnished 2,321 recruits, during the war, for the regular army. The first call to meet the militia requisitions of the President was Issued by Governor Mordecai Bartley May 20, 1846, as follows It has been declared by the Congress of the United States, and announced by the President, that war exists between the United States and the Republic of Mexico. Every day's mail brings intelligence that hostilities have commenced and are now in progress on our southwestern frontier. The blood of our countrymen has been shed, and hostile demonstrations are making by Mexico to prosecute the war. Patriotism and fidelity to our country call upon us to fly to the rescue. A requisition has been received from the President of the United States at this Department calling on Ohio for three regiments of infantry or riflemen to repair as speedily as possible to the theatre of war. Under these circumstances I now appeal to the gallant and spirited sons of Ohio to come forward in this emergency and promptly meet the expectations of the General Government. Let it not be said that when our country appeals to the courage and patriotism of the citizen soldiers of Ohio for aid that that aid was not properly rendered. Whatever may be the diversity of views, it is now sufficient for us to know that war exists on our borders, and that it is our duty to exert every effort to secure a speedy and honorable termination. This event in the history of Ohio will afford her sons an opportunity of devoting themselves to the cause of their country ; they are therefore confidently relied on to give a hearty and cheerful response to this call. General Order Number One, issued May 20, 1846, by Samuel R. Curtis, Adjutant-General of Ohio, contains the following passages : The number of volunteers should be carefully enrolled and the number forthwith reported by the brigade inspectors to this office. From these volunteers the requisite number will be detailed, and they will therefore be directed to hold themselves ready to march at a moment's warning.... A principal rendezvous will be selected at or near Cincinnati, and temporary depots will be established at Zanesville and Columbus for the purpose of organization and mustering in the service of the United States. The act of Congress providing for enlistment of the volunteers required there to serve for a period of not less than six months, at the discretion of the President; and to furnish their own clothes, " and if cavalry, their own horses and horse equipments." They were armed at public expense. While in actual service, they were placed on the same footing as to clothing and pay as the troops of similar corps in SECOND WAR EPISODE - 17 the regular army, and were entitled to receive in money a sum equal to the cost of the clothing of the soldiers in regular service. A general order issued by the Adjutant-General of Ohio May 25, 1846, stated that companies would be permitted to continue the use of whatever styles of uniform they had adopted, but prescribed a style for general use, and concluded with the following suggestions The cost of the articles must vary, and it is therefore impossible to determine at the present what allowance will be made for this clothing. A cheap, strong article of cloth for dress coats and jackets is best for the service, and for overcoats a coarse article of gray cloth would be best adapted to the occasion. Several of the articles, and especially a great coat, are not immediately required. The volunteers will consult their own convenience by dispensing with every unnecessary burthen. Recruiting began in Columbus immediately after the issue of the Governor's call. The Washington German Artillery declared its readiness for service, and the two old independent companies known as Guards and Cadets were reorganized, the first under the name of Montgomery Guards, Captain George E. Walcutt. Captain William A. Latham commanded the Cadets. Directly an entirely new company known as the Columbus Grays was announced. Its commissioned officers were Captain J. W. Mulligan, First Lieutenant J. G. Dryer, Second Lieutenant A. P. Stone. Recruiting was greatly stimulated by General Taylor's preliminary victories, of which announcement was made in the State Journal of May 26, as follows : The intelligence received last evening by the western mail of a conflict between General Taylor's forces and those of the Mexican General was issued from this office in an extra a little after ten o'clock. From 10:30 until between twelve and one o'clock our press was in motion issuing extras. We circulated near a thousand copies, and still hundreds left with out obtaining a copy. Our citizens who had generally retired were aroused from their slumbers by the ringing of bells, the firing of cannon, and shouts and singing prolonged far into the morning. Bonfires were kindled at various points, and all felt proud of our gallant little army which has borne itself so gallantly and threatens to end the war before aid is received. On May 27, a general rendezvous for the Ohio volunteers was established near Cincinnati, and called Camp Washington. General John L. Wool, of the regular army, was appointed to muster and organize the troops at that point. The two Columbus companies, Guards and Cadets, were nearly full by May 30, and the third company, Grays, was organized and ready if needed. The German Artillery had been ready since the issue of the call, and many of the men were willing to serve as infantry if not accepted for their favorite arm. In all the considerable towns of the State volunteers were making hasty preparations for marching orders, Aside from patriotic considerations the opportunity for making a voyage down the Mississippi, for visiting the Sunny South, and above all for marching to the “Halls of the Montezumas " under such a leader as 'Taylor, had a fascination for the adventurous which it was not easy to resist. The triumphant beginning of the war was auspicious of a speedy end. No Bull Run defeat obscured the prospect. The worst dangers to be feared by the northern recruit were those arising from changes of climate and mode of life. Disease was likely to slay more than the sword, and did, in fact, claim the largest share of the victims of the war. 2 * 18 - HISTORY OF THE CITY OF COLUMBUS. On June 8, announcement was made from the State Adjutant-General's office that more volunteer companies had been organized than would be necessary to fill the requisition of the War Department. Over a thousand men were at that time under drill at Camp Washington, and several companies had arrived at Columbus where they awaited orders to move on by canal or stage to Cincinnati. Arms and accouterments, it was stated, would be furnished to the Ohio troops from the Baton Rouge arsenal. Forty cartridges and two flints were to be supplied with each musket. On June 9, the following companies were ena route or under orders to march to Camp Washington : The Columbus companies, under Captains Walcutt and Latham; Captain George W. Morgan's Company, of' Mount Vernon ; a Zanesville company ; Captain Meredith's, of Coshocton ; Captain Stadden's, of Newark ; Captain Irvin's, of Lancaster; a Wooster company; Captain Allen's, of Massillon ; Captain Brunner's, of Circleville ; Captain Reynolds's, of Chillicothe ; Captain Patterson's, of St. Clairville ; Captain McLean's, of Athens; a Highland County company, and four Northern Ohio companies under Captain McLaughlin. In orders from the Adjutant-General's office it was stated that no other companies than those whose geographical position was east of a north-and-south line though Columbus would be accepted, excepting those already at Cincinnati. As to the companies west of the line mentioned, the Governor hoped that they would preserve their organization and discipline and await orders. Notwithstanding these orders, a Seneca County company marched into Columbus on the evening of June 10, with drums beating and flag flying. This company came entirely unheralded and was followed by a long train of wagons. As all the troops necessary to fill the requisition had already been accepted, the Governor and his staff were dismayed by this unexpected arrival, but finally arranged for the subsistence of the men until the disposition to be made of them could be considered. At this time a plan was seriously entertained for transferring the surplus Ohio volunteers to the states which had not yet filled their requisitions. For a time the organization of a regiment at Columbus was intended, but delay in the arrival of some of the companies expected to take part in the organization induced the Governor to order those already at the capital to proceed at once to Cincinnati. Accordingly the Columbus companies left by canal, June 9, for Camp Washington. The State authorities had found much difficulty in providing food and camp equipage for the troops sojourning at the capital, and were doubtless much relieved when these companies were transferred to the general rendezvous. On June 15 Governor Bartley and staff arrived at Camp Washington, where twentyeight hundred volunteers were then assembled. Two Portsmouth companies were denied admittance to the camp for the reason that it was already full, and a Cincinnati company, the Jefferson Grays, was also turned away. Three German companies were declined on the ground that they could not 11 speak and understand the English language." The discharged companies were furnished transportation home, and advised to preserve their organization, but accepted both the favor and the advice with very ill grace. SECOND WAR EPISODE -19 On June 22 three regiments were organized at Camp Washington, the field officers being chosen by the men, as follows: First Regiment. — Colonel, A. M. Mitchell, Cincinnati; Lieutenant-Colonel, John B. Weller, Butler County; Major, Thomas L. Hamer, Brown County. Second Regiment. -- Colonel, George W. Morgan, .Knox; Lieutenant-Colonel, William Irvin, Lancaster; Major, William Wall, Athens; Surgeon, William Trevitt, M. D., Columbus. Third Regiment. —Colonel, S. R. Curtis, Wooster; Lieutenant-Colonel, McCook, Steubenville; Major, J. S. Love, Morgan County. Of the colonels, Mitchell and Curtis were graduates of the West Point Academy; Colonel Morgan had also attended that institution for a time. Each regiment contained ten companies with a requisite muster roll of not less than sixty-four nor more than eighty privates each. The Columbus companies under Captains Walcutt and Latham were assigned to the Second Regiment. The First Regiment quitted Cincinnati for the seat of war July 2; the Second, about a week later Both regiments were transported to New Orleans "on steamboats provided for the occasion, on contract." During the ensuing November the Second was encamped at Camargo, Mexico. While the regiment was crossing the Rio Grande, Lieutenant John Arnold fell overboard from the steamer and was drowned. On December 4, 1846, Captain W. F. Sanderson, of Columbus, arrived at New Orleans by steamer Amaranth with Company B, United States Mounted Riflemen. This company had been largely recruited at the capital of Ohio, and was originally intended for service in Oregon. Its leader, Captain Sanderson, had been the commander of the Columbus Guards during most of the career of that noted company, and in 1841 had been appointed a brigadier-general in the Ohio Militia. Ile was an accomplished and very popular officer, with a natural taste for military life. During the winter of 1846-7 First-Lieutenant F. S. Munford, of the First United States Infantry, established a recruiting rendezvous at Columbus, under orders from the War Department. His advertisement contained these seductive phrases : A bounty of twelve dollars will be given, half down and half on joining the regiment to which the recruit may be attached ; also 100 acres of land given when be may be discharged. Board, clothing and medical attendance supplied by the United States. Pay from seven to seventeen dollars per month. Some items of personal mention which assist in fixing the historical sequence of events incident to the war may here be pertinent. On May 14, 1.846, Hon. Allen G. Thurman, then a member of Congress from Ohio, addressed the House of Representatives in support of the Mexican War appropriation bill. Mr. Thurman's speech was in the nature of a reply to attacks upon the general war policy made by Messrs. Giddings, Tilden [D. R.] and Delano. Hon. Thomas Corwin's famous speech condemning the war was delivered in the National Senate, February 11, 1847. A correspondent of the St. Louis Republican, writing on February 28, 1847, concerning the battle of Buena Vista thus referred to Lieutenant Irvin McDowell, 20 - HISTORY OF THE CITY OF COLUMBUS. of Columbus: "Lieutenant McDowell, aid of General Wool, deserves public notice for his untiring activity and unflinching courage in the most exposed points of the field, all day." The young officer thus spoken of afterwards became a leader of armies in the Civil War of 1861. Captain George E. Walcott, who had resigned on account of infirmity of health, returned to Columbus in the summer of 1846. On December 31 of that year the death of General Thomas L. Harper was announced in the Ohio Statesman. He had gone to the field as Major of the First Regiment, and on July 1, 1.846, had been commissioned as a brigadier-general. He was a popular and prominent member of Congress, and, as General Grant has since testified, a very able man. His death, which took place before Monterey after a brief illness, was deeply and universally regretted. On April 9, 1847, the War Department made requisition upon Ohio for ten additional infantry companies and one company of mounted riflemen. This started recruiting again, and during the ensuing five or six weeks two new companies were organized in Columbus. One of these, commanded by Captain Mitchell C. Lilley, was locally known as the Franklin Guards ; the other was a German company under Captain Otto Zirckel. Rosters of those companies, copied from original muster rolls, mostly much dilapidated, now in the Adjutant-General's office, are appended hereto. The departure of Captain Zirckel's command is thus referred to in the Ohio State Journal of May 27, 1847: For several days past troops have been passing from this place to Camp Washington as fast as they could be pressed into the public conveyances. On Tuesday afternoon the German company took its departure from this place. The leave taking extended nearly through the whole twenty four hours preceding their departure. This time was devoted by them to business arrangements, parting salutations, dancing and amusements. The parting scene extended from the rendezvous in the southern part of the city to half a mile west of Franklinton, and lasted from some time in the afternoon until twilight, when the volunteers took their seats in a number of coaches and moved off amid shouts and cheers. Scores of wives, sisters and sweethearts accompanied them to that extent on their way to Mexico. They were escorted out of town by Captain Lilley's Company, the Franklin Guards, who will follow them in a few days. The Licking Rangers, one hundred and twenty strong, Captain John It. Duncan, passed through Columbus about this time on their way to the seat of war. They were 11 escorted out of the city " by the Franklin Guards, Captain Lilley. As a parting testimonial Captain Lilley's friends made arrangements to present him with a fine sword, but he preferred to have them wait and see, when he returned, whether he deserved one. The Ohio Statesman of June 2, 1847, thus refers to the departure of his command This fine company of volunteers [Franklin Guards] under Captain M. C. Lilley, left this city for Cincinnati on last Monday evening [May 31] at six o'clock r. Al. They formed in front of General Gale's Hotel, and proceeded to the American Hotel, according to arrangements, where Second Lieutenant Robert Thompson was presented with a beautiful sword by T. J. Mathews on behalf of the young men and associates of Lieutenant Thompson. .. . After the presentation, Lieutenant Groom returned thanks to the citizens for the kindness SECOND WAR EPISODE - 21 shown them during the time of their recruiting, which was responded to with loud cheers. They then marched down to the bridge where they mounted the coaches prepared for them by the Ohio Stage Company, and were off amid the cheers of the people and the roar of artillery.. . . They were in full uniform of blue coats trimmed with buff and blue pants manufactured by William Burdell of this city, and looked remarkably neat and comfortable. They also had a grey fatigue suit, which is all right. Our gallant soldiers should be clothed, and so far as our companies are concerned this has been done. By this time many of the volunteers who had enlisted under the first call had completed a year's service, and were on their way to their homes. The Columbus companies of the Second Regiment were expected to arrive early in July, and arrangements were made to give theni a reception. General B. Gale was appointed Marshal of the Day, and Samuel Medary was requested to deliver an address. The day appointed for the reception was July 5, by which date a considerable number of the volunteers had arrived, in squads, by the western stages. A procession was formed, which moved down High Street to General Gale's Hotel, where open order was formed and the returning soldiers were saluted as they passed between the ranks. They were then welcomed by Mr. Medary. The organization of a new regiment to be known as the Fifth Ohio, to serve for the war, was undertaken a few days later by Colonel. William Irvin, of Lancaster, and an office for recruiting and reorganizing the Cadets for that regiment was opened at Columbus by Captain William H. Latham. Referring to this fact the State Journal of July 10 said : 11 Those who hunger and thirst for glory have now an opportunity to try their hand." Recruits were obtained rapidly and the new regiment was organized with William Irvin as Colonel, William H. Latham as Lieutenant-Colonel, and Captain Link, of Circleville, as Major. Lieutenant James Maryland was elected Captain of the Columbus Cadets vice Latham, promoted. On July 17, 1847, a report reached the city that General Scott had occupied the City of Mexico. This proved to be a canard. The actual conquest of the Mexican capital took place September 14, on which date the arrival of Scott's army before the city was first authentically announced in Columbus by telegraph. Particulars of the battles of Churubusco and Contreras were telegraphed on the same (late from Pittsburgh. An armistice followed Scott's victories, and on February 2, 1848, a final treaty of peace was concluded. In November, 1847, a public meeting was held for the purpose of starting a subscription for the purchase of a sword to be presented to Colonel George W. Morgan, of the Second Regiment. Byram Leonard was chairman of the meeting and D. A. Robertson secretary. The committeemen to solicit subscriptions were Samuel Medary, William Kelsey, Isaac Davis, E. Gale and Jacob Reinhard. Returning from Mexico, Colonel Morgan arrived in Columbus December 7, 1847, and on the tenth of that month was given a complimentary dinner at the American House. The invitation to Colonel Morgan bore the signatures of forty prominent citizens and members of the General Assembly. R. P. Spalding and J F. Williams were appointed to escort the guest of the evening to the table. Numerous toasts were proposed and responded to. The sword ordered for Colonel Morgan arrived and was displayed at the jewelry store of Mr. Savage, in February. 22 - HISTORY OF THE CITY OF COLUMBUS. It was described as “richly and brilliantly laid with gold," and was said to have cost five hundred dollars. The final return of the Ohio Volunteers from Mexico took place during the mid-summer of 1848. Coming up the Mississippi and Ohio rivers by steamers, they were welcomed at Cincinnati by the ringing, of bells, firing of cannon and other demonstrations of greeting. They were also formally escorted through the streets when that ceremony was practicable, but unfortunately it was in some instances not practicable. Speaking of the arrival of four companies of the Second Regiment in July, 1848, the Cincinnati Gazette said The firemen again turned out nobly, with their engines, &c., tastefully decorated, . . but there was no parade, no procession ; the wretched condition of the soldiers —many of them being destitute of shoes and [having] scarcely clothing enough to cover their nakedness [made them] refuse to leave the boat and march through the streets. In a later issue the Gazette stated that many of the returning soldiers when they arrived at the Cincinnati landing were destitute of hats, coats, shirts, shoes and even pantaloons, and that they had been fed during their voyage on 11 wormy bread and tainted meat." As their pay was reserved for final discharge, they were totally destitute of money. Most of the men belonging to the Columbus companies returned to the city, in detachments, during the month of July. On the twenty-seventh of that month a formal reception was given to them under the auspices of the Democratic Central Hickory Club. The returned volunteers, numbering about two hundred in all, were organized for the occasion into three companies, all under Lieutenant-Colonel William H. Latham, of the Fifth Regiment. They were bronzed and hirsute, sometimes wore articles of dress peculiar to the climate or customs of Mexico, and bore many curious mementoes of their campaigns. The President of the Day was Jacob Hare, and the orator Samuel Medary. Colonel Latham was assisted in the command by Captains M. C. Lilley and George E. Walcutt, and by his Lieutenants Hermann Jaeger, R. H. Thompson and Francis Royer. A procession comprising the volunteers, the escorting body and citizens was formed in front of General Gale's Union Hotel and moved by State, Third and Broad Street to High, from whence it proceeded down High Street to Jaeger's Orchard in the southern part of the city. The march is thus described by the Ohio Statesman: As the procession passed the Statehouse they [the volunteers] were met by a band of some sixty or seventy [actually fiftyfour] young girls dressed in white, supporting a vast wreath of oak and evergreen with which they encircled the volunteers, and thus marched with them to the place of reception. The large gateway of the orchard was formed into a triumphal arch; rare flowers were mingled with the evergreen and the oak, the whole surmounted and decorated with flags. On the left of the arch, and forming a part of it, was the American shield, on the right the American Eagle, and in the centre the words: Ehret die Braven--"Honor the brave." This arch was the work of our German friends. . . . The procession of young ladies which surrounded the volunteers and led them captive was the work of the German fair, and as the vast procession passed down High Street the beauty and appropriateness of the compliment made them the observed of all observers. As the procession reached the orchard, the German volunteers were received by two young ladies in the language of their "Faderland." SECOND WAR EPISODE - 23 The two little maidens here spoken of were Misses Silbernagel and Wendell. They were dressed in white, and welcomed the German volunteers in a poetical address in the German language, repeating the verses alternately. A bevy of young ladies strewed flowers in the path of the volunteers as they moved into the grove. Samuel Medary delivered an address of general welcome, to which Colonel W. A. Latham responded. In the evening the costly sword which had been purchased by citizens and friends for Colonel George W. Morgan was presented to him at the Democratic Hall, where a banquet was held. The presentation address was delivered by D. A. Robertson. Thus ended the second war episode of which the history has been blended with that of the capital of Ohio. NOTES. 1. Of these, eighteen were killed and thirtynine wounded. CAPTAIN WILLIAM A. LATHAM'S COMPANY COLUMBUS CADETS), SECOND REGIMENT OHIO VOLUNTEER INFANTRY. Mustered in July 1, 1846; mustered out July 1, 1847. 1 |
William A. Latham, captain. James Markland, first lieutenant. John Arnold, second lieutenant. John A. Harvey, first sergeant. W. H. Sanford, second sergeant. William Cloud, third sergeant. Victor Trevitt, fourth sergeant. Charles Johnson, first corporal. Lewis Hadley, second corporal. H. W. Johnes, third corporal. John Righter, fourth corporal. George Atwater, private. George Altin, private. James Bennet, private. Robert Benns, private. Moses Bedell, private. Joseph Bidwell, private. I. R. Brake, private Jacob Brown, private. A. Clarke, private. F. Coffman, private. Thomas Davies, private. Louis Evans, private. Elias Fink, private. J. S. Foley, private. William Forrester, private. William Greenly, private. |
John Leonard, private. B. F. Lincoln, private. Robert Lucas, private. Augustus Marcy, private. John W. Marcy, private. Abed Moore, private. Franklin Moyer, private. Samuel Mutchler, private. T. Nadenbousch, private. Samuel Pierce, private. Samuel Reaver, private. Joseph Righter, private. Samuel Sabines, private. D. K. Seltz, private. Frederick Schilling, private. John Scott, private. Samuel J. Scott, private. Ralph J. Scott, private. Scribner, private. M. Simcox, private. R. J. Shannon, private. James Sheperd, private. Seth Shoemaker, private. James Thomas, private. Samuel Taylor, private. Daniel Townsend, private. Henry Tuttle, private. |
24 - HISTORY OF THE CITY OF COLUMBUS, |
|
William Greenwood, private. S. Handsucker, private. Samuel Hartsoc, private. W. Harbaugh, private, Nicholas Harrington, private. John Knoderer, private. Christian Karst, private. George Krome, private. |
John Weaver, private. S. S. Weaver, private. Harvey Wheeler, private. Thomas Whiteford, private. Joel Williams, private. John H. Williams, private. Charles Yerk, private. Stephen Young, private. |
'This company was originally mustered in by General Stockton, at Columbus, all its officers and men being from that city. Seventeen men whose names are not above given deserted from the company. The above list has been copied from a muster roll in the office of the Adjutant-General of Ohio. CAPTAIN J. T. MICKUM'S COMPANY (MONTGOMERY GUARDS), SECOND REGIMENT OHIO VOLUNTEER INFANTRY. Mustered in July 1, 1846; mustered out July 1, 1847. 1 |
|
J. T. Mickum, captain. W. I. Medary, first lieutenant. J. Neereamer, second lieutenant. E. R. Hile, first sergeant. J. W. Cowan, second sergeant. H. G. Hood, third sergeant. M. A. Boling, fourth sergeant. John Heston, first corporal. W. Parkerson, second corporal. John W. Ford, third corporal. Jacob Oyler, fourth corporal. J. B. Ingalls, musician. Alexander Butler, musician. Daniel Acre, private. R. O. Allison, private. William Borgstrep, private. Orange Barnhart, private. Henry Baughman, private. Harry Bowman, private. A. H. Barnes, private. J. R. Bowman, private. James A. Boggs, private. Adam Bidwell, private. John W. Copeland, private. Peter G. Catlin, private. Thomas Cook, private. Samuel Cain, private. Joseph Cower, private. John Donalson, private. Daniel Deatz, private. John Edgar, private. C. Fenstoneak, private. |
C. Harbaugh, private. G. S. Hoover, private. Jacob Houtz, private. John Hanover, private. I. B. Hedges, private. A. I. Hinman, private. E. A. Hill, private. Harry Johnson, private. A. S. Jones, private. George Kroup, private. John Lash, private. John Moore, private. James McKelvey, private. Jacob Mosier, private. N. K. Miner, private. S. C. Mickum, private. C. Nagfster, private. J. Nagfster, private. J. W. Oyler, private. J. R. Osgood, private. H. Ogden, private. -- Peckham, private. James Pinney, private. J. Parret, private. D. C. Bowhan, private. S. Sparks, private. James Spurgeon, private. Daniel Shetler, private. Lemuel Swesey, private. D. H. Shaw, private. John Settson, private. William Shaw, private, |
SECOND WAR EPISODE - 25 |
|
B. L. Friar, private. William Fisk, private. John Fay, private. N. Gilkison, private. James Gale, private. Jacob Gale, private. Norton Hessel, private. E. B. Harris, private. Samuel Herrman. private. |
George Skidmore, private. John Wilkes, private. John Wetherhall, private. David Wilson, private. Wm. Wetherington, private. John C. Walton, private. Seneca Weathing, private. William Weeth, private |
1 This company was originally commanded by Captain George E. Walcutt, who resigned by reason of impaired health. Its officers and men were, with one exception, all from Columbus. Two men whose names are not above given are borne on the roll as deserters. The above list has been copied by permission from a musterroll in the office of the Adjutant-General of Ohio. CAPTAIN OTTO ZIRCKEL'S COMPANY, FOURTH REGIMENT, OHIO VOLUNTEER INFANTRY. Mustered in May 27, 1847; mustered out July 18, 1848. |
Otto Zirckel Eduard Proessler Frederic Schmidt Hermann Jaeger George Cullman John Kern John Rickenbacher Frederick Pruff G. A. Fuchs Charles Stephany Andrew Reinhard Peter Freudenberger Mathias Ruff Wilmer Simons Henry Snyder Henry Bieber Christian Brueck Jacob Breith John Battefeld Andrew Baumeister John Bergwitz William Dadt Paulus Dussel Frederic Becker John A. Eitel Pearce Freese William Fassig Henry Goebel Jacob F. Glauner Sebastian Gramlich Frederick Harris |
Captain First Lieutenant Second Lieutenant Second Lieutenant First Lieutenant First Sergeant Second Sergeant Third Sergeant Fourth Sergeant First Corporal Second Corporal Third Corporal Fourth Corporal Musician Musician Private Private Private Private Private Private Private Private Private Private Private Private Private Private Private Private |
Columbus Columbus Columbus Columbus Columbus Columbus Columbus Lancaster Columbus Columbus Columbus Columbus Lancaster Bloomfield Lancaster Paulding County Columbus Newport. Columbus Columbus Delaware Columbus. Columbus Columbus Columbus Lancaster Columbus Columbus Lancaster Columbus Columbus. |
26 - HISTORY OF THE CITY OF COLUMBUS |
||
John Hauffman Jacob Heller Jacob Hittler Christian Kastner George Kohlepp Henry Kruse Gottlieb Link Henry Longhenry Peter Marx Joseph Meyer August Maertens George Nitbard Ulrich Prell John Pranft Adolph Proetger George Schmidt George Schaeffer George Fleinman John Schrott Henry Schreiner George Schatzman John Scheryer Jacob Schoenlaub Valentin Scheuerman Jacob Schmerz George Schott Anton Speck John Tobler Paulus Trott John G. Trapp John Trapp John Voeth L. Weenesdoerfer Henry Witzel Christian Woehrly John Watter John Wider |
Private Private Private Private Private Private Private Private Private Private Private Private Private Private Private Private Private Private Private Private Private Private Private Private Private Private Private Private Private Private Private Private Private Private Private Private Private |
Columbus Lancaster Columbus Cincinnati Columbus. Mouth of Rio Grande. Columbus. Columbus Columbus Columbus Lancaster Marion. Columbus Columbus Columbus Columbus Columbus Columbus Columbus Columbus Cincinnati Columbus Marion. Columbus Columbus Chillicothe Columbus Cincinnati Columbus Columbus Columbus Columbus Columbus Columbus Columbus Columbus Columbus. |
DIED |
||
Henry Steinmetz Jacob Schenkel Jacob Noto Peter Oestrenger Gustav Hahn George Cullman |
Private Private Private Private Private First Lieutenant |
Columbus Columbus Columbus Columbus Columbus Columbus. |
DISCHARGED |
||
Edward Lilly John M. Hansel Adam Rickenbacher Charles Hantzsche |
First Sergeant Private Private Private |
Columbus Columbus Columbus Cincinnati. |
SECOND WAR EPISODE - 27 |
||
Bernhard Steint William Kuehner Napoleon Meyer Anton Voeth |
Private Private Private Private |
Columbus Columbus Columbus Columbus. |
TRANSFERRED. |
||
Benedict Diesterweig Jacob Schneider William Schneider |
Private Private First Sergeant |
Cincinnati Columbus Columbus |
Sixteen privates of this company, part of whose names are illegible on the original roll, deserted. Their names are not embraced in the above list. CAPTAIN M. C. LILLEY'S COMPANY, FRANKLIN GUARDS, FOURTH REGIMENT OHIO VOLUNTEER INFANTRY. Mustered in June 2, 1847; mustered out July 18, 1848. Copied from an original muster out roll in the possession of Captain Lilley. |
||
Mitchell C Lilley John C. Gloom Robert H. Thompson Abel Moore John Adams A. B. Parmenter Jacob Taylor John T. Collins David W. Henderson Charles P. Cavis Joseph G. McCormick Oliver N. Durant Charles E. Bynner Francis G. Bowers Andrew J. Baker Abram Bechtel Joshua Brothers J. M. C. Bogan William Burdit Daniel Bill Norman H. Bucklee W. W. Clevinger Andrew Clark Charles Carpenter James Cowdell Peter Deffenbaugh Ira H. Dayton John H. Dugan George W. Everson John W. Fletcher Noah Green |
Captain First Lieutenant Second Lieutenant Second Lieutenant First Sergeant Second Sergeant Third Sergeant Fourth Sergeant First Corporal Second Corporal Third Corporal Fourth Corporal Private Private Private Private Private Private Private Private Private Private Private Private Private Private Private Private Private Private Private |
Columbus Columbus Columbus Delaware Columbus Marysville Columbus Marion. Marysville Marysville Columbus Columbus Cincinnati Marion. Cincinnati Columbus Marysville Bellpoint. New Philadelphia. Columbus Columbus Watkins. Delaware Columbus Delaware Columbus Columbus Columbus Columbus Columbus Columbus |
28 - HISTORY OF THE CITY OF COLUMBUS. |
||
John Graham George W. Graham James B. Graham William Graham Samuel E. Bodwin Robert Geffs John Hughes Joseph G. Hawkins William Hopkins Alexander Houston Samuel Hill James P. Johnson Edward L. Johnson James Johnson William R. Johnson Abram Mathias William H. Morris Francis Miles Thomas McGraw Lewis Morrison German S. Merrick Farron Olmsted Thomas W. Pease John Price John Parker David Reed Alvan Rose Levi Richeldarfer. Hiram D. Robie Lemuel Rodarnel Frederick Smith Fletcher Shout Jacob Stickley Thomas Simmons Nelson Simmons John L. Smith James B. Tupper Ornon Tubbs Robert Thompson Owen Turney John White James F. Williams |
Private Private Private Private Private Private Private Private Private Private Private Private Private Private Private Private Private Private Private Private Private Private Private Private Private Private Private Private Private Private Private Private Private Private Private Private Private Private Private Private Private Private |
Columbus Marysville Columbus Columbus Columbus Columbus Columbus Columbus Columbus Cincinnati Cincinnati Marysville Columbus Marysville Columbus Columbus Columbus Columbus Columbus Marysville Delaware Columbus Marysville Marysville Columbus Marysville Delaware Columbus Jefferson Columbus. Marysville. Marysville. Johnstown. Rareysport. Rareysport Columbus Columbus Columbus Columbus Columbus Columbus. Westchester. |
DIED |
||
Thomas Coulter Richard George—1st Robert Giles Joseph H. Groom John Harrington James T. Johnson Alexander G. Oliver William R. Simmons Horace Train |
Private Private Private Sergeant Private Private Private Private Private |
Columbus Columbus Delaware Columbus Newark Columbus Marysville Columbus Mount Vernon. |
SECOND WAR EPISODE - 29 |
||
DISCHARGED |
||
George W. Clutter Hiram Deptin Alfred Foreman Elisha M. Glick Samuel Groover Richard George-2d John Harrison Daniel Rodarnel Lorenzo Simms Hiram Trout Joseph Thomas Elias Walters |
Private Private Private Private Private Private Private Private Private Private Private Private |
Columbus Delaware Columbus. Marysville. Columbus. Centerville. Marysville Columbus Columbus Delaware Columbus Columbus. |