Of these holders of military land, Samuel Eddins was a captain; Henry Baylis, a lieutenant ;
William Nelson, a colonel ; Carter Page, a captain; William Croghan, a major; Alexander
Balmain, a colonel; Francis Dade, a captain, and Richard C. Anderson, a colonel. Warner and
Addison Lewis were probably land speculators, for they owned thousands of acres of land in the
county, and it was the practice in the early days for these speculators to buy up land warrants
from many of the veterans of the Revolutionary War. Willis Wilson and Robert Pollard were
probably heirs or assignees and it is certain that Nancy Grimes was the heir of Capt. William
Grimes.
Not all of the surveys included in this table lie wholly within the town-
GREENE COUNTY, OHIO - 227
ship. Those lying partly within the township are Numbers 2235, 2234, 1044, 3,908, 1729, 3913,
1274 and 2383.
TOPOGRAPHY AND DRAINAGE.
Caesarscreek township as it stands at present is located in the south-central part of the county and
is bounded on the north by New Jasper and Xenia townships, on the east by Jefferson township,
on the south by Clinton county and on the west by Spring Valley township. The surface of the
township is somewhat rolling and is fairly well forested with hardwood trees that are native of
this section of the country. On the ridges are found many productive upland farms, comprised of
soil of rich clay, and here are raised consider-able quantities of corn, wheat and oats. Much of the
rolling land affords excellent pasture for hundreds of horses, cattle and sheep and during the year,
many swine are "fed out" for the market.
The central part of the township forms the divide between Painters creek and Caesars creek. The
former rises in the extreme southern part of Silvercreek township, flows across the northwest
corner of Jefferson township, enters Caesarscreek township at its northeast corner and then its
course describes a circular course down through the southern part of the township, which the
stream leaves near the southwestern corner. This stream has several tributaries, one of which is
Mursers run. This stream rises in the surveys numbered 2474 and 2526, flows southwest and
empties into Painters creek in the southwest corner of the township. Caesars creek forms a part of
the northwestern boundary of the township. It is from this stream that the township derives its
name. The creek in turn takes its name from the Negro servant of the officers who commanded
the expedition of Gen. George Rogers Clark against old Chillicothe on the Little Miami in 1794.
The expedition had progressed all the way from Kentucky without the knowledge of the Indians
until they reached the territory now comprising Greene county, but this negro, whose name was
Caesar, stole away from the command and brought the intelligence of their impending danger to
the Shawnees at old Chillicothe. It is possible that Caesar left the command while it was in the
whereabouts of the creek that bears his name.
THE FIRST SETTLER.
Possibly about 1800 David Painter, who had before that year become a member of a settlement
of Friends at Waynesville, in what later became Warren county, decided to move northward into
what was erected into Greene county in 1803. At the time when he reached his decision to
change his place of residence, there was only an old Indian trail which led from Waynesville to
Oldtown, but he loaded his few agricultural implements and household
228 - GREENE COUNTY, OHIO
goods into wagons, and accompanied by his family, moved slowly northward along this old trail.
When he reached the creek, which later was given its name in honor of this early settler in the
township, Painter decided to establish here his home. His family at that time consisted of three
sons, Jesse, Jacob and Thomas, and one daughter, all of whom contributed their whole-hearted
efforts to the building of the home in the forest and to the bringing of the soil under cultivation.
The land which David Painter settled now comprises the Harvey C. Faulkner farm.
At the time of the Painter family's settlement here, there were only three cabins between Painter's
cabin home and Waynesville, but soon afterward other settlers of the same creed of this sturdy
Quaker flocked into the town-ship, and a Friends society was organized. Painter himself was
instrumental in the organization of this society. The death of this old settler occurred about 1840
and since that year all of his children have followed him to the grave. The Painters were ideal
settlers, for they were a thrifty, steady and yet enterprising family. Moreover, their adherence to
the creed of the Friends was instrumental in their becoming valuable and moral citizens of the
new county and neighborhood. Even though the teaching of the Friends is against war, this first
settler of the township waxed warlike when it seemed that a wholesale butchery of whites
impended after Hull's surrender at Detroit. On that Sabbath morning when the news of the
disaster arrived in the settlement, David Painter, under the exigency of the moment, shouldered
his rifle and march off to join the volunteers who were hastening to Urbana to protect the Ohio
settlements from the Indians who were reported to be coming southward.
OTHER EARLY COMERS INTO THE TOWNSHIP.
Shortly after the Painter settlement was established, Caleb Lucas, a native of Virginia who had
settled temporarily in Warren county, moved northward into what is now Caesarscreek township
and located on the Phillip Powers farm. Caleb Lucas was born in the Old Dominion on October
2, 1776, and his death occurred on April 25, 1851. He was a soldier of the War of 1812. A
comparatively short time after he settled here in the township, he sold his land to Samuel Martin,
the so called Indian doctor. The farm was later sold to Edward Powers, from whom it reverted to
his son, Phillip Powers. Soon after Caleb Lucas settled in the township, his brother, John Lucas,
settled on the Jamestown pike, on the farm which later came into the possession of his grandson,
James Lucas. Since they were high-spirited Virginians, the two Lucas brothers were in frequent
altercations with their neighbors and such difficulties were generally settled in fisticuff
encounters in which the combatants went at it "hammer and tongs," as it
GREENE COUNTY, OHIO - 229
was described then. John Lucas was the younger of the two brothers, he having been born on July
29, 1793. His death occurred in 1871 after he had lived almost four score years.
Another settler who came to the township before 1803 was Frederick Price, a Virginian of
German descent, who settled on what later came to be known as the D. M. St. John farm. Price
remained there until 1830, in which year he sold his holding to Stephen Bones and then removed
to Indiana, where his death occurred in 1870.
SOME LATER COMERS.
In 1806 Elisha Bales, a native of Pennsylvania, brought his family, including his four sons,
Jonathan, John, Jacob and Elisha, Jr., into Greene county and settled in Caesarscreek township. A
part of the family located in the northern part of this township and some members settled in that
part of Caesarscreek township which was later included in New Jasper township. The elder Bales
spent the rest of his life in the township, improving his farm, and his death occurred in 1828.
In the same year came Robert Faulkner, a brother-in-law of David Painter and a native of
Virginia. He located with his family on a tract of land adjoining Painter's place and for many
years the Faulkner posterity continued to reside in the community.
In 1807, David Murphy, also a native of the Old Dominion, brought his family to this township
and located in the military survey which joined the possession of Caleb Lucas on the west. His
wife had fallen heir to this part of the military survey, her father having evidently been a veteran
of the Revolutionary War. The Murphys possibly became dissatisfied with their location here and
in 1850 the family moved to Indianapolis, Indiana.
THE EARLIEST ELECTION RECORD OF THE TOWNSHIP.
When the associate judges laid out the county into townships on May JO, 1803, they ordered that
the election for the township of Caesarscreek be held in the house of William J. Stewart in
Caesarsville. It is almost a certainty that the election was held sometime later in the year and at
the place indicated, but the whereabouts of the poll-book of that first election in the township is
not known. On October 9, in the following year, another election was held. and the poll-book of
this election is the earliest one found pertaining to Caesarscreek township. From this poll-book
one can determine the names of some of the earliest settlers of the township as it was then, but
the limited number of electors included indicates that the settlers either were careless in
exercising their right of suffrage or were too busy garnering their crops to take a part.
230 - GREENE COUNTY, OHIO
THE POLL-BOOK.
Tuesday, October 9th, A. D. 1804,
State of Ohio, Greene County, Township of Ceasars Creek. Poll Book of an Election held at the
House of Wm. I. Stewart for the purpose of Electing one member of Congress, one member of
the Assembly, also one Commissioner and one Senator.
The Electors' Names—Samuel Anderson, Frederick Bonner, James Bonner, Valentine Bone,
Jacob Bone, William A. Betty, John Billington, John Campbell, John Casey, Josiah Elam,
Edward Flood, Josiah Grover, John Hoop, George Isham, Samuel Lee, Caleb Lucas, Abraham
Lucas, Joseph Lucas, Joseph Lambert, Charles Moore, Isaiah McDonald, Dempsey McDonald,
Samuel Miller, William McFarland, John McClelland, Samuel G. Martin, John Martin, John.
Mendenhall, John Paul, David Price, William Price, Frederick Price, John Stafford, Gardner
Sutton, Gennire Sutton, Samuel Sutton, John Sterritt, Joseph Sterritt, Moses Trader and
Remembrance Williams.
Judges : Frederick Bonner and Isaiah McDonald.
Clerks : Charles Moore and Chappell H. Bonner.
The result of this election in the township was that Jeremiah Morrow received thirty-nine votes
for Congress; John Bigger, forty votes for the state Senate; John Sterritt received twenty-seven
votes for state senator and Joseph Tatman, twelve; James Snodgrass, forty votes for county
commissioner.
THE FIRST ENUMERATION.
The first enumeration sheet of the township antedates the above poll-book by a year and from it
one can obtain the names of many more of early pioneers of the township as it stood in 18433.
This enumeration of the free males in the township above the age of twenty-one years was begun
by the lister, Joseph Price, on August 3, 1803, and was finished on the tenth of the same month.
The additional names which thus can be added to the above list are the following: Isaac Bonner,
Samuel Bone, James Corey, William Conkleton, Joel Coleman, Stephen Hoggett, Josiah Hunt,
James Lawrey, John Montgomery, Leavitt McDonald, Stephen Mendenhall, William Mullen,
Martin Mendenhall, Edward Mercer, Joseph Price, David Price, Jr., Peter Price, David Painter,
Nathan Porter, James Porter, Henry Prill, Sr., Henry Prill, Jr., Isaiah Sutton, Jonah Sutton,
Amariah Sutton, Lewis Sutton, William I. Stewart, Noah Strong, Reuben Strong, William
Stanfield, Leonard Stump, Joseph Wilson, Sr., Joseph Wilson, Jr., Remembrance 'Will-iams.
As this list of names is scanned, the impression must not be gained that these early settlers were
all residents of Caesarscreek township as it is today. Reference to the discussion of the changes
of the boundaries of the township reveals that many of these settlers no doubt lived in the eastern
part of what is now Xenia township or in the present townships of Silvercreek, Jefferson or
Spring Valley.
GREENE COUNTY, OHIO - 231
IMPROVEMENT IN THE TOWNSHIP IN THE EARLY DAYS.
Under the steady strokes of the ax, the magnificent forests in Caesarscreek township gradually
gave way before these sturdy pioneers, and soon there were scattered over the whole extent of the
township log cabins and log barns which housed the settlers, their families and live stock. As
time passed tanneries sprang up here and there to provide leather for the old-fashioned
"fare-leathers" saddle and for the shoes used by the pioneer household. Since whisky was held to
be absolutely necessary for the early resident of the county in those day to neutralize the heat of
summer, the cold of winter, the ravages of ague, stomach trouble, for weddings, for influencing
bids at public sales, for influencing voters and for dispensing good cheer on all occasions, several
distilleries were erected in the township and did a flourishing business for many years. Then,
with the passing years, the prosperity of the settlers became more evident with the abandonment
of the old log cabin which sheltered them and their families in the early years of their residence
here, and they erected in, their places dwellings of brick or of timber which had known the buzz
of the saw-mill. A glance at the assessor's returns for the years 1830, 1833, 1840 and 1841,
reveals some of the improvements which were made in the township in those years.
In 1830 David Painter, the first settler in the township, razed his old log house and erected in its
stead a brick structure which was valued for taxation at one hundred dollars. In the same year
Joel Ellis built a brick addition, valued at one hundred and fifty dollars, to his house. Three years
later, it was found that Isaiah Oglesbee was finishing his new dwelling in survey No. 1831, but
the value of two hundred dollars which the assessor placed upon it brought a warm protest from
the owner, because he thought the estimate too high. In that same year, John Fudge, who was a
prominent figure in the politics and government of the county in his day, was the owner of a
tannery in survey No. 1383, valued at three hundred dollars. The assessor's returns for 1833
showed that Jesse Faulkner was busily engaged in adding two hundred and fifty dollars' worth of
improvements to his holding in survey No. 1274.. James Curl, the owner and operator of a
tanyard, the land for which he had leased from Jacob Painter, succeeded in having the value of
his enterprise reduced one hundred dollars.
In 1840-41 Joel Peterson was meeting the wants of his neighbors for liquid refreshment with his
distillery on survey No. 3708. This enterprise was of considerable importance as compared with
other like enterprises of the township, because it was valued at one thousand dollars. The clearing
away of the old, friendly log cabins, which gave place to the frame buildings, created the need for
a saw-mill and one such was owned by Elijah B.
232 - GREENE COUNTY, OHIO
Hartsook on a part of a tract of one hundred and ten acres in survey No. 2435. The motive power
for the plant was derived from an adjacent stream, the volume of which did not always admit of
running the mill more than six months of the year. William Whinnery, a tanner of the township,
fur-nished the residents of the township with leather. In that part of the township which was later
included in New Jasper township William Long and William Hardie had erected, respectively, a
brick and frame dwelling, the former of which was valued at four hundred dollars and the latter
at three hundred. Evidently distilleries at that more recent date furnished an acceptable market for
the corn grown in the township, for Bernard F. Rowe operated a steam distillery and
chopping-mill in connection on a one-acre lot which was a part of survey No. 1378.
THE VILLAGE OF PAINTERSVILLE.
The only village in Caesarscreek township as it is today is Paintersville, which is located in the
eastern central part of the township, about a mile from the township line, in military survey No.
2254. The town was laid out along the Jamestown pike, which forms the main street of the
village. About two hundred yards north of the northernmost lot of the village flows Painters
creek.
Before the village was laid out, the site was a part of the farm of one hundred and fifty acres
which belonged to Jesse Painter, a son of David Painter, the first settler of Caesarscreek
township. Before the town was laid out Jesse Painter and Jonathan Oglesbee owned country
stores on its site, where the residents of the surrounding country came to purchase their supplies.
A short time before 1840 Painter decided that the modest trading point could take upon itself the
dignity of a village of considerable importance and since he was the owner of the surrounding
land he secured the services of Moses Collier, the county surveyor, who platted the village in the
latter part of the summer of 1837. The work was finished on September 7, 1837, and on the 16th
of the same month the plat was received for record and recorded by J. H. McPherson, the county
recorder, as follows :
PLAT OF THE VILLAGE OF PAINTERSVILLE.
The Town of Paintersville, in Greene County, O., of which the above is a correct Plat, was laid
out and surveyed by the undersigned for Jesse Painter, the Proprietor, on part of a survey,
originally made for Nancy Grimes, No. 2354. Main Street and Ash Street are 6o feet wide,
Walnut Street is so feet wide, alley No. 2 1S 16 feet wide and all other alleys are 12 feet wide.
The bearing of Main Street is N. 5 E. and the lines of all the streets, lots and alleys (except the
South line) are parallel and right angles thereto.
Lots No. 1, 2, 24, 25, 30 & 31 are 6o feet front on Main Street and 80 feet back, containing 4,800
square feet. Lots No. 12, 13, 20, 27, 28 & 29 are 60 feet front on Main Street & 140 feet back,
containing 8,400 square feet. Lots No. 14 is 70 feet in front, containing
GREENE COUNTY, OHIO - 233
5,300 square feet ; No. 15 contains 5,100 square feet ; No. 16 contains 5,490 square feet; No. 17
contains 6,070 square feet ; No. 18 contains 6,540 square feet and all the other lots are 60 feet
front & 120 feet back, containing each 7,200 square feet. A stone was planted by my direction at
each intersection of the lines of Main and Ash Streets.
Given under my hand this 7th day of September, 1837.
MOSES COLLIER,
Surveyor of Greene County, Ohio.
FURTHER DESCRIPTION OF THE VILLAGE.
As was said before, Paintersville's main street is a part of the Jamestown pike, which extends a
short distance south of the village where it intersects with the county road and the New Hope
pike. Beginning at the north the first cross street is Ash, which extends westward until it
intersects the county road. The next cross street south is Walnut, which is a con-tinuation of the
Port William pike joining the county road a short distance from where Ash street does the same.
In all there are thirty-three lots indicated on the original plat. West of Main street and north of
Ash street are lots No. 19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 24, 25, 26 and 27. Between Ash and Walnut streets and
west of Main are lots No. 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12 and 13. South of Walnut are lots No.
14, 15, 16, 17 and 18. East of Main are lots No. 28, 29, 30, 31, 32 and 33. The date of the sale of
these lots is not on record ; however, it is known that the proprietor sold them at twenty and
twenty-five dollars each, according to location.
GROWTH AND BUSINESS 1NTERESTS OF THE VILLAGE.
When the village was platted in 1837, it had two stores, as was stated before, one belonging to
Jesse Painter, the proprietor of the village, and the other Jonathan Oglesbee. Soon after the laying
out of the town Joseph Oglesbee erected a frame building on the lot later owned by John Mason.
Cornelius King built the next building, a brick structure, which later be-came the property of
Lewis Thomas. There followed a number of log houses which in time gave place to frame and
brick structures. At present the village contains about twenty-five houses. The population of the
town in 1881 was about one hundred and fifty, in 1896, one hundred, and at present (1918) about
one hundred and fifty. Since the town is not located on a railroad, its progress has been retarded.
In the early eighties a nar-row-gauge railroad from Cincinnati to Columbus was projected
through the village, but the plan was never realized.
A comparison of the business interests of the village at different dates shows that the movement
of population to the urban centers, the rapid means of communication facilitated by the
automobile and telephone, and the proximity of larger adjacent towns has caused a lagging in the
estab-
234 - GREENE COUNTY, OHIO
lishment of business enterprises in the town. In fact the town has deter-iorated in this respect. In
1881 Paintersville had a saw-mill, owned by James and Thomas Babb; a carriage factory, by
Allen and Eli Powers; a blacksmith shop, by William King; a grocery store, by John B. Mason; a
harness shop, by Lewis Thomas and a physician, Dr. William Rowse. In 1896 the town had two
grocery stores, one harness shop, two blacksmith shops and one saw-mill.
WINCHESTER.
Few people now living in Greene county have ever heard of the town of Winchester in this
county. but a reference to the records in the office of the county recorder reveals the plat of a well
laid-out town by the name of Winchester. In fact there is no town in the county with a more
artistic and finely planned set of streets than this town, a town which never got beyond the
beautiful plat which its fond promoters had made of it.
Here is the official record on this town :
State of Ohio}ss
Greene County} ss
THOMAS BABB, proprietor.
Caesar Creek Township, Greeting :
I, Reuben Strong, one of the acting Justices of the Peace of this Township and county aforesaid,
do hereby certify that personally came Thomas Babb, a resident of Clinton County, and freely
acknowledged the site and title and the within Plat be a true form laid down for the use and
purpose of a town within Caesars Creek Township to be established as a Town by the name of
Winchester.
In testimony whereof I have hereunto set my hand and seal this 26th day of February, 1816.
REUBEN STRONG, J. P. (Seal)
This town was located on the west side of the present Wilmington-Xenia highway, just after the
road crosses Caesars creek. There is nothing in the record of the plat to indicate its location any
nearer than "Caesarscreek township." As far as is known there was no serious attempt to establish
a town on the site, and it is difficult to see at the present time why any one should have thought a
town would have made any growth there. The plat on record shows it to have been the best
laid-out town in the county. There were seventy-two in-lots and sixteen out-lots, the whole site
being surrounded by a street which might be called a boulevard.
AGRICULTURAL INTERESTS OF CAESARSCREEK TOWNSHIP.
The prosperity of Caesarscreek township depends entirely upon its agricultural operations. As
was said before, the township lacks the alluvial valleys of broad bottom lands of some of the
other townships of the county, but the fertile clay soil of its uplands yields bountiful crops of
corn, wheat, oats and rye. The general condition of the surface admits of the grazing of large
numbers of cattle and sheep. It is one of the best hog-raising dis-
State of Ohio
GREENE COUNTY, OHIO - 235
tricts of the county, there having been "fed out" over six thousand hogs in the township in 1917.
The dairy products of this section also are quite important sources of wealth.
It is interesting to compare the agricultural statistics of sixty-seven years ago with. those of the
present (1918). Returns of the census of 1850 com-pared with the detailed agricultural report of
the county for 1917, compiled from the returns of the township assessors show the following:
LIVE STOCK.
For its size the township grows a comparatively large amount of live stock, of which hogs
predominate. In the following table are included butter and wool: