MISCELLANEOUS CONSIDERATIONS.
It will be noted that no buckwheat or flax seed is now reported as being produced in the
township. There probably was a considerable quantity of tobacco grown in the township in 1849,
but there was no return for it in the census report; the same is true of sweet potatoes in 1917.
Evidently kr this latter year this district was not the bee country that it was sixty-seven years ago,
but the fact that forty-one hives succeeded in producing only fifty-six pounds of honey in 1916
shows that the return was not complete or the residents of the township take little interest in
furthering the honey production.
The fact that there were several items in the one report which do not correspond with that in the
other makes it necessary to deal with them miscellaneously. In 1850 there were 18,250 acres of
improved land in the township and 13,588 acres that were unimproved. Bearing in mind the fact
that the township was twice as large then as it is now, there were, in 1917, 16,543 acres owned,
of which 12,648 acres were cultivated; 1,101 acres in pasture; 2,317, in timber; 106, in orchard,
and 317, waste land. The esti-
(17)
258 - GREENE COUNTY, OHIO
mated value of all the farming implements in .the township in 1850 was $32,153, but this amount
will not compare with what is invested in the same at the present. In that same year the animals
slaughtered were valued at $18,645.
In 1917 the farmers of the township reported eight silos and 217 tons of ensilage. In 1916 there
were forty-nine acres sowed in alfalfa, and during the same season seven hundred and twelve
acres of clover sod were turned under. At the same time 497,280 pounds of commercial fertilizer
was used. The day when the farmer made his own cheese has passed, but large quantities of other
dairy products were sold in 1917; for example, milk, 45,840 gallons; cream, 31,916, thus
showing the use of the cream separator. The hen contributed her share to the general prosperity of
the township by laying 41,160 dozens of eggs. Orchards produced 3,740 bushels of apples. There
were nine rent-ers in the township who worked for wages and eleven farms were rented to
tenants. No resident of the township was reported as having moved from the farm to the city
during the year.
THE VILLAGE OF BELLBROOK.
Bellbrook is a historic little village tucked down in the grand old hills of Sugarcreek township. It
is located at the intersections of sections and 2, township 2, range 6, and sections 31 and 32,
township 3, range 5, on Little Sugar creek, about one mile west of the Little Miami river. From it,
roads lead to Dayton, Xenia, Waynesville and Spring Valley. Its population at present (1918) is
about two hundred and fifty and is apparently diminishing, according to successive census
returns.
The first settler of the locality which was later incorporated into the town was Joseph C. Vance,
who entered the land extending along the east side of Main street, which was then a mere path
called the Pinkney road. At the time of his settlement here in the spring of 1797, he erected the
log cabin on the site which later became the southeast corner of Main and Walnut streets.
Following Vance came James Snoden, who later became an associate judge of the county and
who in 1799. entered land on which the western part of the village later was laid out. James
Clancey, another of the early settlers on the site of Bellbrook, was here prior to 1803, for his
name appears on the first poll-book of the first election in the township in June, 1803. When
Joseph C. Vance was appointed director of the new county seat of the county he disposed of all
his possessions in Sugarcreek township, including his cabin, and moved to Xenia. At the meeting
of the associate judges on May T0, 1803, when the county was laid out into townships, the court
ordered that the first election on the following June in Sugarcreek township should be held in the
house of James Clancey, hence Clancey was the possible
GREENE COUNTY, OHIO - 259
owner of the Vance cabin at that time. It seems to be an undisputed fact that it was this cabin
wherein this first election was held. It was in the same house in 1803 that the Rev. Robert
Armstrong preached to the little flock of Associate Reform Presbyterians (Seceders), and it was
also here that the township organization was brought about in the same year.
Finding that this cabin was thus becoming the center of the activities of the township, James
Clancey decided to open up a tavern. 'Accordingly he erected a more pretentious hewed-log
building to the front of the little cabin and raised his tavern sign after complying with the law and
receiving his license from the court of common pleas of the county. Apparently he began
business in 1816 after the platting of the village of Bellbrook, for his petition to the court for
permission was submitted in that year and a careful search through the records fails to reveal any
prior application. This application is as follows:
To the Honorable Judges of the Court of Common Pleas of Greene county :
The Petition of the undersigned freeholders of Sugar Creek Township Humbly repre-sent to your
honors that we conceive a publick house of entertainment in said Township would conduce to the
publick convenience ; we therefore recommend James Clancey, one of our citizens, as a man of
good character and every way Calculated to keep a publick house. We therefore pray your honors
would grant him a licence for that purpose and your petitioners as in duty bound will ever pray—
John Hutchinson, Andrew Bird, Joseph Gillespie, James Gillespie, David Lamme, James
McBride, John Clark, John B. Tode, John Blessing, Josiah Lamme, William Standley, Alexander
Armstrong.
January 22nd, 1816.
Clancey's tavern thus became the rendezvous for all the surrounding country. In 1820 Clancey
sold out his business and moved to Flat Rock, Indiana, where he lived the rest of his days.
LAYING OUT BELLBROOK.
In 1814 a couple of energetic men, Henry Opdyke and Stephen Bell, became residents of
Sugarcreek township, buying the land which comprises the western part of Bellbrook from James
Snoden in the following year, 1815, when the old judge left the county. These two men with
James Clancey, who was the proprietor of the land on the east side of the Pinkney road which
later became Main street, conceived the idea of laying out a town on this site. Accordingly they
set to work. It is not known who did the sur-veying, for that fact is not recorded on the original
plat of the village in Vol 3, p. 471, of the deed record in the office of the recorder at the court
house in Xenia. But by February 9, 1816, they had their work finished and submitted the plat to
James McBride, the justice of the peace for Sugar-creek township, for certification, and he made
the following entry on the plat :
260 - GREENE COUNTY, OHIO
The State of Ohio,
Greene County.
I, James McBride, a Justice of the Peaece in said County, do certify, that before me personally
came James Clancey, Stephen Bell and Henry Opdike, and each acknowledged the within plant
of the Town of Bellbrook to be laid out for that purpose. Given under my hand and seal the gth
day of February, 1816.
JAMES McBRIDE, Justice of the Peace.
On the following day, February 10, the plat and certificate were duly recorded by Josiah Grover,
the recorder of Greene county.
THE NAMING OF BELLBROOK.
Tradition has it that there was considerable difficulty in choosing a name for the new village and
among the names suggested were "Opdykeville" and "Clanceyville," but finally Henry Opdyke
hit upon the happy suggestion of "Bellbrook," which met with instant approval. The first part
of the name is derived from the name of one of the proprietors, Stephen Bell, and the latter part
no doubt come from the fact that Little Sugar creek curves around the southwestern corner of the
village.
THE ORIGINAL LIMITS OF THE VILLAGE.
Originally, the town was laid out north and south along the Pinkney or Alpha road. This became
Main street and it was made sixty-six feet wide. Beginning on the north the first cross street east
and west was Walnut which has the same width as Main. Farther south, Franklin street, which is
also sixty-six feet wide, crosses Main street in the center of the village. This street is a part of the
Xenia road. There are two side streets each thirty-three feet in width, extending north and south
parallel with Main, the one on the east being known as East street and the one on the west, West
street. They are both thirty-three feet wide. Extending along the southern edge of the village is
another, South street, but where it intersects Main street its course is changed from east to west to
northwesterly. This street is also sixty-six feet wide. On the original plat there is no street
extending along the north edge of the village, but when the Hopkins addition was made in 1849
High street was established and it extends westward from Main street. At some later date Maple
street, which is thirty-three feet wide and which extends east and west from one side of the
village to the other, was established between Franklin and South streets by widening an alley.
This street was first called Hooppole street, then Battle street and finally Maple street.
SALE OF LOTS.
By the original plat of the village eighty-four lots were laid out, twenty of which were north of
Walnut street, twenty-four between Walnut and Franklin streets and forty between Franklin and
South streets. Lot No.
GREENE COUNTY, OHIO - 261
is at the southwest corner of Franklin and Main streets. Each lot had a frontage of four rods and
was ten rods deep. When all was ready for the sale of lots, the following announcement appeared
in the Ohio Vehicle, a newspaper then being published at Xenia:
NOTICE.
The subscribers having laid out the Town of Bellbrook in the County of Greene, Sugar Creek
Township, on the great road that leads by James Clancy's tavern, leading from Lebanon to
Urbana, and -where the road crosses leading from Franklin to Wilmington. The lots in said town
will be sold to the highest bidder on Saturday, the 7th day of October, ensuing. The terms of the
sale will be made known on the day of the sale. The situation of the town is healthy and
convenient to springs which can be easily conveyed through the town. Saw and grist mills within
a mile. Adjoining town lands is a stream of water on which all kinds of machinery may be
erected.
STEPHEN BELL HENRY OPDYKE. JAMES CLANCEY.
September 19, 1815.
When the day of the sale arrived, the buyers of lots found Aaron Nutt, a pioneer auctioneer from
Centerville, Montgomery county, present to cry the sale. From the nature of the jokes ascribed to
him and the amount of liquid refreshment which was generally dispensed on such occasions, the
live-liness of the day can readily be imagined. The first lot sold was No. 1, whose location has
already been described, and then the remaining were sold in order.
At the time the only house in the village was the Clancey tavern, but soon after the sale James
Webb, the village blacksmith, built his house near the, corner of Main and Franklin streets on
Main. Other dwellings were soon erected, among which were those of David Black, Daniel
Lewis, Joseph Gillespie and Aaron Flowers. The latter had some difficulty in raising his house,
for he did not have the heartiest co-operation of his neighbors in his undertaking. After the frame
had been put up, it was carried off one night by his spiteful neighbors to the creek and there
broken to pieces. Others who became early residents of the village were John Bell and Moses
Mills.
ADDITIONS TO BELLBROOK.
As the years passed the steady growth of the town seemed to warrant the laying out of additions.
The first of these was made in the latter part of 1830 and was recorded on December 25 of that
year. This addition was laid out on both sides of Franklin street, just west of West street and the
lots numbered from 85 to 99, hence practically an extension of the original plat of the town. It is
not known who laid out. this addition, probably the original proprietors of the village.
The second addition to the town was made by John McClure in 1841.
262 - GREENE COUNTY, OHIO
It comprised sixteen lots, south of the addition of 183o, west of West street and north of South
street. Moses Collier, the county surveyor at that time, was employed by McClure to do the
platting, which was finished on June 12, 1841. On August 14, following, the plat was certified by
Edward Bennett, justice of the peace, and on the same day it was recorded at the court house in
Xenia.
The third addition was made by A. B. Hopkins. It comprised eight lots lying in a part of section
2, township 2, range 6, located at the northwest corner of the village and its establishment caused
the making of High street. which extends from Main westward across West street. The addition
was platted on May 24, 1849, by Samuel T. Owens, the surveyor of Greene county.
BELLBROOK BEFORE 1832.
As noted before, James Webb, the blacksmith, was the first man to erect a new house on the
village site and here he opened up his shop for business. If one of his neighbors wanted a horse
shod, a shovel mended or a chain or plow share made, he had to bring the iron along with him,
because the smith could not afford to keep sufficient material in stock. A little later his shop was
used by Silas Hale, who worked there at cabinet-making. Will-iam Holmes also carried on
blacksmithing in a shop which stood a little to the rear of the Mills house.
During this time there were several other business interests in the village. Robert Silvers kept a
tavern in the house which Aaron Flowers had so much difficulty in building. John Sowards made
hats in a shop which stood on the site of the show room which belonged to the Bumgardner
carriage shop. This place of business for some unaccountable reason was called the "Old
Penitentiary." The first meeting house, which belonged to the Methodist Episcopal church
society, stood on lots and 2.
THE INCORPORATION OF THE VILLAGE.
Sixteen years after the plat of the town was certified, the population of the village had grown to
such an extent, that it was deemed advisable to have it incorporated. For this purpose Dr.
William Frazier, acting on the suggestion of Dr. William Bell and Robert E. Patterson, framed a
petition to the Legislature which was signed by many of the citizens of the village. It was
favorably acted upon and on February 13, 1832, the village of Bellbrook was duly incorporated.
The first officers of the town were : William Bigger, mayor ; Abner G. Luce, treasurer, and Silas
Hale, marshal. The present officers of the corporation, who took their seats on January 1, 1918,
are as follows : J. H. Lansinger, mayor ; W. W. Tate, clerk; H. M. Turner, treasurer ; R. H.
Hopkins, marshal ; A. R. Howland, assessor ; J. L. Myers,
GREENE COUNTY, OHIO - 263
A. R. Howland, Jobe Anthony and D. H. Hopkins, members of the village board of education.
In the early years of its incorporation, Bellbrook did not need much funds with which to carry on
its municipal activities, for on March 9, 1835, there remained "in the treasury of the corporation a
balance of $2.98;" and on February 3, 1836, the coffers of the municipality were replenished by
Marshal Hale, who turned over to the treasurer $26.35, the tax for the year 1835.
FIRE PROTECTION.
In order to occupy its position as a fully fledged municipality, fire apparatus was necessary, and
the bustling city council on August 1, 1836, "ordered that John R. Dinwiddie be allowed
$23.1272 for fire hooks, ropes and ladders." The paraphernalia was then stored in the south end
of the old log meeting house which belonged to the Methodist Protestant church society. What
became of it is not recorded.
The first fire of any size destroyed what was known as the Academy which stood near the
Old-School Presbyterian church in 1852. This abandoned seat of learning belonged at that time to
Harrison Vaughan. In 1855 the large two-story building which stood on the first alley north of
Franklin street, off of Main, and in which Ephraim Bumgardner had his carriage shop, was
burned. The fire spread to the neighboring livery stable belonging to Samuel Elcock's hotel. The
old Magnetic Hotel burned in 1893 and the bath house shared the same fate in 1913. The
Bellbrook Inn, the competitor of the old Magnetic Hotel, burned in 1900.
THE MAGNETIC SPRINGS.
In 1882 Andrew Byrd, who had bought the old United Presbyterian church at the corner of Main
and Walnut streets, began the repair of that building with the intention of making it into a
dwelling house. He started to dig a well in the basement of the house but at a depth of only, a few
feet encountered so strong a vein of water that digging was stopped. When all was ready for the
plastering of the house, Robert Butler was employed to do the work and the water with which he
mixed the mortar was obtained from the shallow well. To the amazement of Butler, the trowel
which he used became magnetized so that it would pick up lath nails and after some
experimentation it was found that any piece of steel allowed to remain in the water from this well
for a short time would become magnetized.
Immediately the probable medicinal properties of this water occurred to Byrd and a sample of it
was taken to a chemist for analysis. This analysis was quite formidable in the matter of the names
applied to the various components, and these names appeared especially so when they were
emblazoned
264 - GREENE COUNTY, OHIO
upon large advertising posters by the promoter and a local artist. Soon the finding of this
"fountain of youth" became noised about in the village and many of the citizens began to take the
healing waters for all sorts of ailments. Testimonials were gathered from those. thus benefited
and these recommendations were sent to the newspapers and were printed all over the country.
The free advertising which thus heralded the finding of the "fountain of youth" brought a
continuous stream of vistors to Bellbrook, each bringing some kind of vessel in which to carry
away a portion of the healing waters. On one Sunday during the first paroxysm of excitement
occasioned by the discovery of the "Magnetic Springs," as the well had been named, the streets of
the village were completely filled with equipages of all descriptions, and the crowd for that one
day alone was estimated at five thousand.
Byrd abandoned his intention of using the old church as a dwelling house and turned the building
into a "sanitorium" to which the suffering members of the human race could come for treatment
for all manner of diseases. Byrd sought to increase the flow of water by digging the well deeper
and wider, but he was not so fortunate as to tap another vein of the precious water. The result was
that the increased flow only diluted the strength of the water from the healing source. When it
seemed that the financial suc-cess of the undertaking was on the decline, Byrd sold the old
church and bath house which he had constructed nearby to the Ohmer brothers of Dayton, who
turned the sanitorium into a hotel under the supervision of George McIlwain. A long addition
was made to the old church on the left and the business continued to thrive. Later the owners of
the hotel sold their interests to Arthur Duffy, who owned the establishment until it burned in
1893. Duffy then built a bath house on the site of the old hotel and a dancing pavilion on the hill
above. When the enterprise lost its commercial value, Duffy sold bath house, pavilion and well to
Michael McMullen, a wealthy member of the city council of Cincinnati, in 1909. McMullen
fitted up the pavilion and grounds for a summer home. It was surrounded with well-kept lawns
and the beautiful natural scenery of "Mullen Camp," as the place was called, made it one of the
prettiest places in the county. But the bath house shared the same fate as the old hotel on October
21, 1913, when it, too, burned to the ground.
Of course Bellbrook had visions of growth. The Bellbrook Magnet in 1884 said :
"Notwithstanding the extreme cold weather, the demand for magnetic water is still on the
increase and the prospects for a boom in the spring is a fixed fact. Now is the time to buy lots."
Some lively members of the community decided that Byrd did not have a monopoly on all the
magnetic water in the township and they organized
265 - GREENE COUNTY, OHIO
a company, sold stock and built the Bellbrook Inn on the other corner of Main and Walnut
streets, near what was claimed was another spring just as good as the original. As time passed
this enterprise ceased to be a paying one and several members of the Bellbrook community have
souvenirs of the discovery of the magnetic spring in the form of certificates of stock in the
Bellbrook Inn. Finally, after withstanding the vicissitudes of fortune for many years, the Intl
shared the fate of its old competitor, the Magnetic Hotel, for it burned sometime in 1900.
FIVE HUNDRED INDIANS IN BELLBROOK.
After Lewis Cass and Duncan McArthur had bought the lands belonging to the Indians north of
the Greenville treaty line by the treaty of St. Marys in 1818, certain tracts were reserved for the
remnants of the Wyandotte, Delaware and Seneca tribes. But these reservations were
subsequently ceded to the United States. The last of these aborigines of Ohio to leave were the
Wyandottes, who turned over their lands to the government in 1842.
During the July of the next year, these Indians, numbering at least five hundred, were removed to
Kansas. After they were all collected, they started for Cincinnati, and as the weather was
pleasant, they made the journey overland. During that month their long wagon train passed
through Bell-brook and they pitched their wigwams between the village and Little Sugar creek,
where they prepared to spend the night, and during their brief stay were visited by many of the
villagers. The Indians did not remain long, for by seven o'clock the next morning their great
caravan had already started on its way toward Cincinnati. From there the redskins boarded a river
boat which took them to Kansas, where they were met by their kinsmen who had preceded them.
THE ONLY CASE OF HOMICIDE.
The only homicide ever committed in the village or township occurred on February 20, 1858,
when Andrew Kirby stabbed John Stanton with a butcher knife. The scene of the tragedy was a
house in the southeast part of the village, on East street, belonging to Mrs. Cusic. Kirby
immediately ran to the house of Silas Hale, who was then justice of the peace, to surrender
himself. Stanton lived only a short time. At the trial Kirby was defended by Hon. Thomas
Corwin, but was sentenced to a life term in the Ohio penitentiary.
THE PORK 1NDUSTRY AT BELLBROOK.
In the early days of the Miami country, pork-packing was an important industry in all the small
towns of the valley. In those days the farmers drove their hogs to the slaughter houses at or near
the village, the carcasses were
266 - GREENE COUNTY, OHIO
then cut up, and the finished product was hauled to Cincinnati by wagon. In later years, after the
advent of the railroad, the meat was taken to the nearest station and sent by to that city. In those
days Bellbrook was an important local center in the pork business and and thousands of hogs
were slaughtered here and sent down to Cincinnati.
This industry began in Bellbrook on a more or less extensive scale as early as 1835, when B. F.
Allen erected a large brick pork house in the village. This building was used for this purpose
until Allen retired from the business. As the years passed the business prospered and thousands
of hogs were killed for the market in Bellbrook. The four men who were well-known cutters
were Joshua Brelsford, Charles Wright, George Sebring and Eber Turner. Sharp Weller barreled
the sidemeat. David Snoden had charge of the bulking of the meat in the cellar, where it was
cured with lake salt. The kettles for rendering the lard were located on the east part of the
building and David Raper generally had charge of this work. The cooperage came from Dayton
and Centerville, the barrels and kegs being brought by teams from these two towns. The
cracklings were sold to the soap factories at Dayton. After the meat was cured, it was hauled to
Spring Valley to be shipped by rail to the markets. After the packing season was over, there being
no refrigeration facilities in those days, the pork house was cleaned and whitewashed on the
inside. It then became, on account of its size, the social center of the community, being used for
singing-schools and the like. These singing-schools were taught by Newton Carman, Thomas
Harrison, H. Vaughan and others, at two dollars a term.
In 1839 a slaughter house was erected at the junction of the two Sugar creeks, south of
Bellbrook. This was a rough, substantial, low, one-story building, built of hewed logs, and was
used for about three seasons or until a flood swept the entire establishment away into the Little
Miami and the site was abandoned for slaughter-house purposes. Alexander Hopkins was the
manager of the establishment. A second slaughter house was built on Alexander Hopkins' farm
on North Main street, near the top of the hill, so that access could be had to the large spring there.
This structure of heavy frame was erected about 1843 and in it thousands of hogs were
slaughtered. The third, or Western slaughter house, which was erected about 1844, was a
substantial frame building, located on the Dayton pike, just west of town near a large spring. This
plant could turn out daily from two hundred and twenty-five to two hundred and fifty hogs.
Alex-ander Hopkins also was superintendent of this slaughter house, William Law was "sticker,"
and Charles M. Rose11 had charge of the scalding. The cleaners were Tom Duffy, George
Snowden, John Sebring, John Belt, Pat Kirby and others. Some lard rendering was also carried
on at the slaughter house and Henry Harmon had charge of this part of the work.
267 - GREENE COUNTY, OHIO
THE BUMGARDNER CARRIAGE WORKS.
Ephraim Bumgardner established a carriage-manufacturing plant in Bellbrook some time after
1840 and his enterprise was flourishing in the '50s. He had a large two-story building on Franklin
street where he carried on his work. In the late '60s and the early '70s the carriage factory, then
located on lots 49 and 50 on Main street, had reached considerable proportions, it then consisting
of blacksmith, wood-working, paint and trimming shops, and it was. said at that time the product
of its concern surpassed that of any other place in southern Ohio. It was the custom in those days
for the employees of the carriage shop to board at Bumgardner's house and among those who
thus sat at their employer's table in the late '60s were Horatio Kemp, Albert Blease, Alva Smith,
Albert Kemp, Harry Butler, Lewis Raper, Thomas Gibbons, William Luce, "Bud" Truman,
William Davis, Theodore Schaffer, Samuel Raper, Samuel Willoughby, William Willoughby,
William Thorne, John Cathers, William Cathers, Patrick Gibbons, Lewis Dingler, James
Maloney, Charles Cunningham, Charles Mills, Amos Harnish, Baty Weller and John Weise. This
enterprise ceased some thirty or forty years ago.
A PIONEER UNDERTAKER.
In the early days before the coming of the undertaker to this section people would prepare, with
the help of their friends and neighbors, the bodies of their loved ones for burial. The first
undertaker in Sugarcreek township and one of the first in Greene county was John M. Stake, who
was actively engaged in this business in Bellbrook for sixty years at least and was in 1897 the
oldest living member of his profession in the county if not in the state.
John M. Stake was a native of Maryland, where he Was born on October 20, 0308. When he was
eighteen years of age he began learning the trade of cabinet-maker, and in 1834 began plying his
trade and undertaking at Boonesborough in that state. He had married in the meantime and in
1838 he removed to Bellbrook where he bought out the business of Andrew Byrd, who was
engaged in cabinet-making here at that time. Stake's place of business stood at the corner of West
and Franklin streets, where he manufactured coffins and furniture for many years. He was one of
the first men in the county to have a hearse and the first person buried from this hearse in the
township was the father of Michael Swigert, Sr., whom Stake interred in the old Beavercreek
church yard. Before the day of the hearse, the coffin was called for at the shop, the corpse put in
it at the residence, and then hauled to the cemetery in a common wagon. Stake made some of the
early interments in the pioneer cemetery at Bellbrook, and
268 - GREENE COUNTY, OHIO
in 1852 he buried the first person, Mrs. Rachel Hopkins, in the new Bellbrook cemetery. He also.
buried the first person in the Catholic graveyard at Dayton. Formerly there was a graveyard
located on a mound near the Tresslar mills, but it has long since been abandoned. Stake made the
first interment in this cemetery and the corpse was taken across the Little Miami in a canoe, as
the river was too high to be forded and there were no bridges. The first horse Stake used when he
came to the village cost him five dollars, and, although it was somewhat lame, it was a
serviceable animal as a hearse horse for many years. During the many years that he was in
business, Stake buried between five thousand and six thousand bodies.
THE INVENTION OF THE FIRST REAPER.
It is said that Bellbrook is the place where the first machine for cutting wheat was invented. In
his little work shop in an obscure part of the village the inventor, Jesse Sanders, a mechanic, had
worked on the problem of perfecting a machine which would eliminate the cradle. He worked on
the reaper at his spare time from 1840 until 1845, and finally it was completed. During- this time
he had taken into his confidence Ephraim Sparks and Captain Fryant, who gave him some
valuable suggestions on the mechanism of the machine. On the day appointed for the testing of
the reaper a large crowd of the villagers and neighboring farmers congregated at the farm of
Jacob Haines to see the reaper tried out; but, as the story goes, a stranger was also in their midst
and he examined the reaper carefully and made many inquiries concerning its construction. The
bystanders thought little of the man's actions at the time, for they were intensely interested in the
little machine which had acquitted itself so well at its first test. It is said that when the
McCormick Company of Chicago put a reaper of exactly the same pattern on the market in the
following year, a suspicion was created in the minds of the neighbors of Sanders that the affable
stranger seen on that day was none other than one of the agents of that company and had
appro-priated Sanders' invention. Sanders never realized anything for his labors and died a poor
man after giving to the world one of the greatest inventions of the age.
TAVERNS, HOTELS AND TRANSPORTATION.
The first tavern was the old Clancey House which has already been described. Another was
called the Mansion House. This latter had a very high sign post in front with the name
emblazoned on it in large characters. A part of this old tavern is now used for a dwelling, the last
house on South Main street on the west side. On the northwest corner of Main and Franklin
streets was the Eagle Exchange with its sign post. The Green Bay Tree, a brick building on the
west side of North Main street and which is still
GREENE COUNTY, OHIO - 269
standing, was also a well-known center in the earlier days. One of the most interesting of these
taverns was the Eagle Exchange which still stands on the corner before mentioned. Alongside its
great chimney is the old tavern bell in its little belfry, where it has hung for almost three-quarters
of a century.
In the early '40s a stage line was run from Dayton to the Little Miami railroad at Spring Valley,
and Bellbrook, which is four miles distant from the latter place, was a station on the stage line.
The coach drawn by six prancing horses of the best blood, each in a fine set of harness and with a
full set of bells, would rumble in from the west from Dayton along Frank-lin street and stop, at
the Eagle Exchange. When the stage was all ready to resume its journey toward Spring Valley,
the driver would wind his bugle and the passengers would clamber up into their seats, and with a
parting blare of the horn, the stage would start away. Oftimes the bugler would continue his calls
until they would die away in beautiful echoes among the surrounding hills.
During the latter part of the past century several railroads were projected through Bellbrook and
Sugarcreek township, and at one time two surveying parties crossed their chains in the southwest
part of the village. All of these activities were considered a good omen, but still Bellbrook and
the entire township has no steam railroad. In the '70s many of the citizens of the town had visions
of the place becoming a bustling manufacturing center, if it could only be favored by having a
railroad pass through it. The town, however, was forced to wait the advent of the electric cars.
The Dayton & Xenia Traction Company projected a line through the village to Spring Valley
from Dayton during the latter '90s and on March 5, 1900, the first car passed through the town.
The Cars began to run regularly on Monday, April 23, following, and on that day general
business in the village was laid aside to greet this beginning of a new era for Bellbrook. The first
car arrived at half past seven in the morning, and those of the citizens of the village to board this
first car were Harry Weaver, Frank Newland, J. H. Racer, Charles Mills, Doctor Hook, Frank
Pennewit, Patrick Gibbons, Mrs. John Marmon, Miss Caroline Harmon and Miss Emma Racer.
Thomas Degnan was the conductor and E. W. French the motorman. During this first day eight
cars arrived.
GROWTH AND DECLINE OF BELLBROOK.
The growth of Bellbrook was about normal and reached its zenith in 1850, when the population
of the village was five hundred and two. The "two" were colored, and one of them was Lucretia
Johnson, more familiarly known as "Aunt Cressie," who was held in high esteem by her white
neigh-
270 - GREENE COUNTY, OHIO
bors. The population in 1870 was 369; in 1880, 425; in 1890, 350; in 1900, 352, and in 1910, it
was 238. lt is thus apparent that Bellbrook is having the same experience as hundreds of the
smaller towns in the United States, where there is a concentration of population in the larger
cities.
BUSINESS INTERESTS AT BELLBROOK.
About 1812, three years before the village was laid out, James Gowdy, the. first merchant at
Xenia, decided to extend his business by establishing a store in the settlement which later became
known as Bellbrook. He opened a store in a little log cabin which. stood at about the northeast
corner of Lot No. 50, but soon found that the business would not pay and he left the place for a
more promising field. The first blacksmith to locate in the village was James Webb, who came in
1815. Silas Hale was the cabinet-maker. John C. Hale, Sr., was the tanner. John Sowards
furnished hats for the masculine members of the community. In 1840 the following men had
stores : Benjamin Allen, Silas Hale and the firms of Harris & Allen and Harris & Larew.
In the early '70s the business interests of the village were in the hands of the following:
Alexander Patterson and Harry Richards, shoe shops; Samuel Lamb, Samuel Dinwiddie and
Jesse Watson, wagon shops; Samuel Lamb and Charles Killian, cooper shops; Brazil Pancoast,
Jacob Boroff and Charles Miller, blacksmiths; Ross Tampsett, pump shop; John M. Stake,
cabinet-maker and undertaker; Joseph Black, drug store; Thomas Austin, grocer; William
Hopkins, dry goods; Campbell's grocery; Silas Hale, general store; Mrs. Farley, grocer; Ed.
Kline, tin store; Ephraim Bumgardner, carriage factory and livery stable.
The business interests of Bellbrook in 1918 are in the hands of the following : Automobile
dealer, J. Z. Myers; blacksmiths, Charles F. Mills and Eugene Pennewit; cabinet-maker, John
Stake; carpenter, J. T. Finley; coal, W. H. Hodges; furniture, John Stake; garage, Hess Brothers;
groceries, C. F. Schwarts, J. S. Turner & Son, O. R. Peterson & Company, W. H. Hodges; livery,
James Crowl; physician, Dr. G. C. Hook; postmaster, H. M. Turner; restaurant, W. W. Tate ;
saw-mill, John Weaver; undertaker, James Crowl.
CHAPTER XIV.
XENIA TOWNSHIP.
The four original townships of the county erected by the first meeting of the associate judges on
May 10, 1803, could not long retain their original extent, and the first township organized after
the government of the county had been established was Xenia township, August 20, 1805.
The erection of Xenia township was not brought about by the associate judges, but by the county
commissioners, to whom the court of common pleas had turned over the county business in the
spring of 1804.. It was at a meeting of the board of county commissioners held, on the date
mentioned above that the following order was issued :
On the Petition of James Collier, John Sterritt, James McCoy and others, it was considered by the
Board of Commissioners that there shall be one Township composed out of part Ceasars Creek
and Beaver Creek Townships in the following manner :
All the part of Beaver Creek Township, East of the little Miami and above the Mouth of Massies
Creek ; thence with Beaver Creek Township to the North East corner of Sugar Creek Township ;
thence with the Sugar Creek Township line to the mouth of Andersons fork ; thence up the main
fork of Ceasars Creek with the meanderings thereof to the East line of the County ; thence North
with said line to the North East corner ; thence West to the Miami ; thence down the River to the
beginning; which shall be called and known by the Name of Xenia Township, and the first
election shall be held at the house of William A. Beatty in Xenia.
JOHN PAUL, Cl'k.
ORIGINAL BOUNDARIES OF THE TOWNSHIP.
From the above order of the commissioners the extent of Xenia township can be described with a
fair amount of clearness. Evidently the place of beginning was the mouth of Massies creek and
then the line of the township extended due southward to the mouth of Andersons fork, a tributary
of Caesars creek. The line from that point followed Caesars creek, presumably up the north
branch, to a point in the northeast corner of what is now New Jasper township, which is about
eight miles north of the south county line and seven miles west of the east line of the county. The
locus of this point is not exactly determined by the order of the commissioners, but it was
established before Silvercreek township was cut off from Caesarscreek township in 1811. From
this point the line of Xenia township extended due eastward to the east boundary of the county.
From thence the eastern boundary of the township ran northward to the northeast corner of the
county, whose
272 - GREENE COUNTY, OHIO
boundary had only a few months previously been established along the line of the southern
boundary of the ninth range of townships by the erection of Champaign county. From this point
the line of the township extended westward, coincident with the northern line of the county, to
the Little Miami river, down which the line extended to the point of beginning, the mouth of
Massies creek.
Xenia township at the time of its erection was bounded on the west by Beavercreek and
Sugarcreek townships; on the north mostly by Beavercreek township and a short distance on the
eastern end of the northern boundary by Champaign county (Clark county not being organized
then) ; the east and a part of the south by Caesarscreek township. Some of the townships of the
county have been erected wholly or partly out of territory which formerly was embraced within
the boundaries of Xenia township, such as the greater part of what is now Xenia township,
Cedarville township, Ross township, Miami township, New Jasper township, Vance township.
CHANGES IN THE BOUNDARIES OF THE TOWNSHIP.
Not long did Xenia township retain its unbroken extent to the eastern boundary of the county. On
June 8, 1808, the commissioners erected Miami township which was set off partly from Xenia
township and -partly from Bath township. The southern boundary of the new township was
deter-mined by the north boundary line of section 5, township 3, range 7, and its line extended
eastward to the county line. Thus Xenia township lost all of its territory east of the Little Miami
and north of the present southern boundary line of Miami township.
At the same meeting of the board of commissioners on June 8, 1808, Xenia township had an
acquisition of territory west of the Little Miami, from Beavercreek township. It was then
"ordered that the following tract or part of Beaver Creek Township, East of the line hereafter
mentioned, be struck off and attached to Xenia Township; viz., Beginning at the North East
corner of Section No. 5, Township 3 & Range 7, thence south to the Little Miami." This tract
now forms in part the northwest part of the township at present. The township was again shorn of
considerable territory on the east by the erection of Ross township on March 4, 1811. The
western boundary of the new township began at the northwest corner of Silvercreek township,
where the line of Xenia township left the course of Caesars creek and extended east to the county
line. From that point the west line of the new township proceeded northward to the Miami
township line.
The loss of the territory comprising Ross township was partly com-pensated for by a gain of
territory at the expense of Beavercreek township
GREENE COUNTY, OHIO - 273
in 1816. It was then "Ordered by the board of Commissioners that so much of Beaver Creek
Township as lies below the mouth of Massies Creek and running down the meanderings of the
Little Miami so far that a due South line to the line of Sugar Creek Township will include the
dwelling house of Jonathan Paul & Jacob Hisewonger, be and the same is hereby attached to
Xenia Tp. It is therefore ordered that Moses Collier survey said line and make report thereof the
4th day of July, next, and that Robert Gowdy agreed to pay all expenses of survey &c." On
December 2, 1816, the board of commissioners acted favorably upon a petition for the addition
of a part of Sugarcreek township to Xenia township. The following appears on the record book of
the commissioners for that date: "On the petition of Frederick Bonner & others, praying for
(illegible) of Sugar Creek Township as may be East of a line commencing on the (illegible) line
of Sugar Creek Township, at the corner of Beaver & Xenia Townships, and to run South until it
crosses Glady Run; thence to run a South East course so as to intersect Xenia Township line
about the South West corner on Caesars Creek, to be attached to Xenia Township." Thus with a
few minor later changes, the western boundary of Xenia township was determined by 1817.
The eastern boundary of the township was not determined until after the erection of Cedarville
and New Jasper townships, respectively, in 1850 and 1853. Before the erection of these two
townships, the southeastern boundary of Xenia township was Caesars creek and the eastern line
of the township was the western line of the present township. of Jefferson produced until it
intersected the southern border of Miami township. The erection of Cedarville township
restricted the township of Xenia within its present northeastern borders and the part of New
Jasper township north of, Caesars creek was stricken off from Xenia township. Thus Xenia
township was in general confined. to its present borders by 1853.
THE PRESENT BORDERS OF THE TOWNSHIP.
The present irregular shape of Xenia township has not resulted from the caprice of the surveyors
who have platted it or its residents, but seems to have arisen from the formation. of the townships
which have been stricken in part from its territory. The fact that certain petitioners wished to
become residents of the new townships formed caused them to have the surveyor to include their
farms within the newly erected political units of the county. The fact that their farms lay in that
part of the county where the military surveys obtained, made the resulting line of the new
townships irregular. It follows then that the western line of Xenia township is fairly regular, but
the one on the east make the township look like a patch
(18 )
274 - GREENE COUNTY, OHIO
in a crazy quilt. Beginning at the northwest corner of the township, the line runs east one-half
mile, thence north one-half mile, thence east about one and one-half miles, thence south one
mile, thence east to the river, thence abruptly southward after crossing the river a short distance
about one-half mile. The line then runs southeast about three miles; thence south about a mile;
thence east in an irregular course; thence in a line bearing somewhat west of south to a point not
quite. a mile south of the Baltimore & Ohio railroad ; thence southwest one mile, southeast
one-fourth of a mile, southwest one-fourth of a mile, southeast one-half a mile, southwest a half
mile and southeast one mile to Caesars creek. From this point the line follows the meanderings of
the creek for about three miles to the Peterson farm ; thence north three-fourths of a mile ; thence
a little north of west three miles; thence one-fourth mile northwest to the Columbus pike, which
it follows a quarter of a mile northeast; thence northwest one mile; thence a little west of north
about a mile and a half ; thence north three miles to the Little Miami which it follows a mile
northeast ; thence north one mile, west one-half mile, north one mile, west one-half mile and
north a mile and a half to the place of beginning. This gives one a conception of the broken
boundary line of Xenia township.
Xenia township is touched by eight townships. It is bordered on the northwest by Bath ; on the
north by Miami; on the northeast by Cedarville; on the east by Cedarville and New Jasper ; on
the southeast by Caesarscreek; on the south and southwest by Spring Valley ; by Beavercreek on
the west, arid the corner of Sugarcreek township touches Xenia township on the south-west.
TOPOGRAPHY AND DRAINAGE.
In general the level, prairie-like areas of the township lie to the west and northwest of the city of
Xenia and the more hilly and rolling sections are in the eastern and southeastern parts of the
township. The parts of the township which are rough are found to the southeast along Caesars
creek and where Massies creek cuts the northeast part of the township in the vicinity of
Wilberforce. The average elevation of the township is approx-imately nine hundred and fifty feet.
The lowest elevation is where the valley of the Little Miami leaves Xenia township and enters
Beavercreek township, this point being here about eight hundred and four feet above sea level.
The highest point in the township is ten hundred and eighty-eight, feet above sea level, which
point is located about two and one-half miles southeast of Xenia on the Wilmington pike. Even
though the valley of the Little Miami is wide and very productive, it is flanked by higher land
which stretches away eastward in a broad plateau some one hundred feet higher than the level of
the valley. A very large part of the soil of the township admits of
|