100 - CINCINNATI—THE QUEEN CITY


from sight; they knew the old licks and the old trails. They practiced the lost arts of the woodsman ; they had eyes and ears of which their successors in these valleys do not know. They did not become white Indians for, it would seem, they did not mingle as closely with the red men as did the French ; but they became exceedingly proficient in the Indian's woodland wisdom. Browned by the sun and hardened by wind and rain and snow, they were a strong race of men ; they could paddle or walk the entire day with little fatigue. Yet their day's work was not such usually as made mere brute machines of them. . . . There were songs to be sung as the canoe glided speedily along beneath the shadows of those tremendous forest trees ; dangers intensified the joys, and, as everywhere else, added a flavor to living, a romantic tinge to what otherwise might have been commonplace."


As the fur trade passed away, these rivermen found other occupations which their knowledge of the river and its surroundings fitted them for. They became bargemen and flatboatmen. As the Indians disappeared and white settlers came, there came also hordes of desperate men, gamblers. horse thieves, and worse, into this valley.


Cassedy, in his History of Louisville, says : "The bargemen were a distinct class of people, whose fearlessness of character, recklessness of habits and laxity of morals rendered them a marked people. Their history will hereafter form the groundwork of many a heroic romance or epic poem. In the earlier stages of this sort of navigation, their trips were dangerous, not only on account of the Indians whose hunting grounds bounded their track on either side, but also because the shores of both rivers were infested with organized banditti, who sought every occasion to rob and murder the owners of these boats. Beside all this, the Spanish government had forbidden the navigation of the lower Mississippi by the Americans, and thus hedged in every way by danger, it became these boatmen to cultivate all the hardihood and wiliness of the pioneer, while it led them also into the possession of that recklessness and independent freedom of manner, which even after the causes that produced it had ceased, still clung to and formed an integral part of the character of the western bargeman. . . The crews were carefully chosen. A `Kentuck,' or Kentuckian, was considered the best man at a pole, and a `Canuck,' or French Canadian, at the oar or the `cordelles,' the rope used to haul a boat up stream. Their talk was of the dangers of the river ; of 'planters and sawyers,' meaning tree trunks imbedded more or less firmly in the river ; of 'riffles,' meaning ripples ; and of 'shoots,' or rapids (French chutes). It was as necessary to have violins on board as to have whiskey, and all the traditions in song or picture of 'the jolly boatman' date back to that by-gone day. Between the two sides of the river there was already a jealousy. Ohio was called 'the Yankee state,' and Flint tells us that it was a standing joke among the Ohio boatmen when asked their cargo to reply, Pi'Pitcoalndigo, wooden nutmegs, straw baskets, and Yankee notions.' The same authority describes this sort of questioning as being inexhaustible among the river people and asserts that from one descending boat came this series of answers, all of which proved to be truthful : 'Where are you from ?"Redstone.' `What is your lading?' Millstones."What's your captain's name ?"WhWhetstone.' 'Wherere you bound ?"To Limestone.' "


CINCINNATI--THE QUEEN CITY - 101


The first ocean going vessel that passed out of the Ohio was the St. Clair. She came down the Ohio to Cincinnati April 27, 1801, with a cargo for the West Indias. The banks of the river at this port were crowded with people anxious to gaze upon this wonder.


As early as 1801, a decade before the inventor of steamboats was considering placing these upon western waters, there was a call among citizens of Cincinnati for a meeting at Yeatman's tavern to discuss the practicability of driving boats up stream by the "power of steam—or elastic vapor."


But for several years yet the boats moved by poles, oars and sails continued to hold the river traffic undisputed. These boats were capable of conveying fifty to one hundred tons each. Five or six dollars a hundred was the freight charge to New Orleans from this place.


When the river was full, these boats made two trips annually to and from New Orleans.


Baum and Perry, and Riddle, Bechtle and company controlled most of the river traffic at this point. They conveyed up the Mississippi and the Ohio a greater part of the goods brought to Cincinnati, and they continued their business for several years after steamboats had been introduced on these waters.


Flatboats and small keelboats as well as packets were employed in the traffic with the upper Ohio. Canoes were also employed for journeys to Wheeling.


"The New Orleans" was the first steamboat to come to the port of Cincinnati. This was on the 27th of October, 1811. Liberty Hall, October 30, 1811, stated, "The steamboat, lately built at Pittsburgh, passed this town at 5 o'clock in the afternoon, in fine stile, going at the rate of about ten or twelve miles an hour." The editor, apparently, did not grasp the vast significance of the event and the revolutionary effect that event was to have on the commerce of this city, as \Veil as on all towns on the western waters.


When Theodore Roosevelt, as president, made a memorable trip down the Ohio and Mississippi, he recalled with justifiable pride that it was his uncle. Nicholas J. Roosevelt, who had built and commanded this first steamboat on western waters.


When Fulton and his associates in the New York company decided to build a steamboat for the western waters. William Robson, who had worked on the Clermont, Fulton's first steamboat on the Hudson, was sent to Pittsburgh to superintend its building. Robson came to Cincinnati in June, 1818, and was for years prominent in the coppersmith and brassmaking business in Cincinnati. This Cincinnati is related to the pioneer of steamboat making in the west.


Charles J. Latrobe, in his "First Steamboat Voyage on the Western Waters," said in regard to this first voyage of the "New Orleans :" "Circumstances gave me the opportunity of becoming acquainted with the particulars of the very first voyage of a steamer in the West; and their extraordinary character will be my apology to you for filling a page of this sheet with the following brief relation :


"The complete success attending the experiments in steam navigation made on the Hudson and the adjoining waters previous to the year 1809, turned the attention of the principal projectors to the idea of its application on the western rivers ;.and in the month of April 'of that year, Mr. Roosevelt, of New York, pursuant to an agreement with Chancellor Livingston and Mr. Fulton, visited


102 - CINCINNATI—THE QUEEN CITY


those rivers with the purpose of forming an opinion whether they admitted of steam navigation or not. At this time two boats, the North River and the Clermont, were running on the Hudson. Mr. Roosevelt surveyed the rivers from. Pittsburgh to New Orleans, and, as his report was favorable, it was decided to build a boat at the former town. This was done under his direction, and in the course of 1811 the first boat was launched on the waters of the Ohio. It was called "The New Orleans," and intended to ply between Natchez, in the state of Mississippi, and the city whose name it bore. In October it left Pittsburgh for its experimental voyage. On this occasion no freight or passengers were taken, the object being merely to bring the boat to her station. Mr. Roosevelt, his young wife and family, a Mr. Baker, the engineer, Andrew Jack, the pilot and six hands, with a few domestics, formed the whole burden. There were no woodyards at that time, and constant delays were unavoidable. When, as related, Mr. Roosevelt had gone down the river to reconnoiter, he had discovered two beds of coal, about one hundred and twenty miles below the rapids at Louisville, and now took tools to work them, intending to load the vessel with the coal and to employ it as fuel, instead of constantly detaining the boat while wood was procured from the banks.


"Late at night, on the fourth day after quitting Pittsburgh, they arrived in safety at Louisville, having been but seventy hours descending upwards of seven hundred miles. The novel appearance of the vessel, and the fearful rapidity with which it made its passage over the broad reaches of the river, excited a mixture of terror and surprise among many of the settlers on the banks, whom the rumor of such an invention had never reached ; and it is related that on the unexpected arrival of the boat before Louisville, in the course of a fine, still, moonlight night, the extraordinary sound which filled the air, as the pent-up steam was suffered to escape from the valve on rounding to, produced a general alarm, and the multitudes in the town rose from their beds to ascertain the cause. I have heard that the general impression among the good Kentuckians was that the comet had fallen into the Ohio; but this does not rest upon the same foundation as the other facts which I lay before you, and which I may at once say I had directly from the lips of the parties themselves. The small depth of water in the rapids prevented the boat from pursuing her voyage immediately, and during the consequent detention of three weeks in the upper part of the Ohio, several trips were successfully made between Louisville and Cincinnati. In fine, the waters rose, and in the course of the last week in November the voyage was resumed, the depth of water barely admitting their passage.


"When they arrived about five miles above the yellow Banks, they moored the boat opposite to the first vein of coal, which was on the Indiana side, and had been purchased in the interim of the State government. They found a large quantity already quarried to their hand and conveyed to the shore by depredators, who had not found means to carry it off ; and with this they commenced loading the boat. While thus engaged, our voyagers Were accosted in great alarm by the squatters of the neighborhood, who inquired if they had not heard strange noises on the river and in the woods in the course of the preceding day, and perceived the, shores shake, insisting that they had repeatedly felt the earth tremble.


CINCINNATI--THE QUEEN CITY- 101


"Hitherto nothing extraordinary had been perceived. The following .day they pursued their monotonous voyage in those vast solitudes. The weather was observed to be oppressively hot ; the air misty, still and dull ; and though the sun was visible. like a glowing ball of copper, his rays hardly shed more than a, mournful twilight on the surface of the water. Evening drew nigh, and with it some indication of what was passing around them became evident. And as they sat on the deck, they ever and anon heard a rushing sound and violent splash, and saw large portions of the shore tearing away from the land and falling into the river. 'It was,' as my informant said, an awful day.; so still that you could have heard a pin drop on the .deck. They spoke little, for everyone on board appeared thunderstruck.' The comet had disappeared about this timer which circumstance' was noticed with awe by the crew.


"The second day after their leaving the Yellow Banks, the sun rose over the forest the same ball of fire, and the air was thick, dull and oppressive as before.. The portentous signs of this terrible natural convulsion continued and increased. The pilot, alarmed and confused, affirmed that he was lost, as he found the channel everywhere altered ; and where he had hitherto known deep water, there lay numberless trees with their roots upwards. The trees were seen waving and nodding on the bank, without a wind ; but the adventurers had no choice but to continue their route. Towards evening they found themselves at a loss for a place of shelter. They had usually brought to under the shore, but everywhere they saw the high banks disappearing, overwhelming many a flatboat and raft, from which the owners had landed and made their escape. A large island in mid channel, which was selected by the pilot as the better alternative, was sought for in vain. having disappeared entirely. Thus, in doubt and terror, they proceeded hour after hour till dark, when they.. found a small island, and rounded to, mooring themselves to the foot of it. Here they lay, keeping watch on deck during the long autumnal night, listening to the sound of the waters which roared and gurgled horribly around them, and hearing from time to time the rushing earth slide from the shore, and the commotion as the falling mass of earth and trees was swallowed up by the river. The mother of the party, a delicate female, who had just been confined on board as they lay off Louisville, was frequently awakened from her restless slumbers by the jar given the furniture and loose articles in the cabin, as several times in the course of the night the shock of the passing earthquake was communicated from the island to the bows of the vessel. It was a long night, but morning dawned and showed them that they were near the mouth of the Ohio. The shores and the channel were now equally unrecognizable; everything seemed changed. About noon that day they reached the small town of New Madrid, on the right bank of the Mississippi. Here they found the inhabitants in the greatest distress and consternation; part of the population had fled in terror to the higher grounds ; others prayed to be taken on board, as the earth, was opening in: fissures on every side, and their houses hourly falling around them.


"Proceeding thence, they found the Mississippi, at all times a fearful stream, row unusually swollen, turbid and full of trees; and after many days of great danger, though they felt and perceived no more of the earthquakes, they reached their destination at Natchez, at the close of the first week in January, 1812, to


104 - CINCINNATI—THE QUEEN CITY


the great astonishment of all, the escape of the boat having been considered an impossibility. At that time you floated for three or four hundred miles on the rivers, without seeing a human habitation. Such was the voyage of the first steamer."


This steamer ran regularly between Natchez and New Orleans up to July 14, 1814, when it sank at Baton Rouge. In 1818, its engine and a new boiler were placed in a new boat also called the New Orleans.


The second steamboat on the Ohio was the Comet, also built at Pittsburgh, sometime previous to the summer of 1813. It was of one hundred and forty-five tons burden, and had a novel stern wheel.


The third steamer on these waters was the Vesuvius, which was constructed at Pittsburgh by Robert Fulton, and launched in November, 1813. The first effort made by a steamer to come up the Ohio past the falls at Louisville was made by this boat, but the attempt was a failure, as she grounded on a bar seven hundred miles above New Orleans. After remaining five months on this bar and then being floated off by rising water, this boat was employed on the lower Mississippi.


In 1814 the "Enterprise," forty-five tons, was built at Brownsville. The Aetna, of three hundred and forty tons, came next while the Despatch, the Buffalo, the James Monroe, the Washington, and others, came in due time.


The Enterprise was the first steamer to successfully make the trip up the Ohio and past the falls at Louisville. A local newspaper of that time announced the event : "The Steam Boat Enterprise.—This is the first steam boat that has ascended the Ohio. She arrived at Louisville on the first inst., sailed thence on the l0th, and came to this port on the evening of the 13th, having made her passage from New Orleans, a distance of one thousand, eight hundred miles, in twenty-eight running days (by the aid of her machinery alone, which acts on a single wheel placed in the stern), against the rapid currents of the Mississippi and the Ohio. This is one of the most important facts in the history of this country, and will serve as data of its future commercial greatness. A range of steamboats from Pittsburgh to New Orleans—connecting Pittsburgh and Cincinnati, Cincinnati and Louisville, Louisville and Smithland, at the mouth of the Cumberland, or some eligible place on the Mississippi, below the mouth of the Ohio, thence to Natchez, and from Natchez to New Orleans—will render the transportation of men and merchandise as easy, as cheap and expeditious on these waters as it is by means of sea vessels on the ocean, and certainly far safer. And we are happy to congratulate our readers on the prospect that is presented of such an establishment. Two steamboats, considerably larger than the Enterprise, and yet not too large for the purpose, are already built at Pittsburgh, and will no doubt commence running in the fall. Others will follow. The success of the Enterprise must give a spring to this business that will in a very few years carry it into complete and successful operation."


It is said that the first steamboat built in Cincinnati was the Eagle, of seventy tons. It was made in 1818 for the firm of James Berthoud & Son, of Shippingport, Kentucky, for the Louisville, later the Natchez, trade. About the same time there was built the Hecla, of seventy tons, for Honorie & Bar-



CINCINNATI—THE QUEEN CITY - 105


barox, of Louisville. The Henderson, eighty-five tons, was constructed for the Messrs. Bowers, to run between Henderson and Louisville. The "Cincinnati," one hundred and twenty tons, was partly owned by men in this city, and was the first steamboat in which Cincinnatians held any shares. This boat was built for Pennywitt & Burns of Cincinnati, and Paxson & Co., of New Albany ; it was to ply in the Louisville trade.


The first steamboat wholly owned in Cincinnati was the Experiment, of forty tons and built in 1818. Mr. Cist observes, "it seems that thirty-two boats had to be built before we could furnish capital and enterprise to own one."


In spite of the increasing numbers of the steamboats the old style of boats continued their business for a considerable period longer. Dr. Drake notes that in 1815, though two kinds of steamers were plying on the Ohio, navigation was conducted by flatboats, keelboats and barges only.


It still required a hundred days for the round trip to New Orleans.


Though Cincinnati had been made a port of entry in 1808, since shipbuilding had ceased on the Ohio, no vessel was cleared here until 1815.


The Cincinnati Gazette of July 15, 1815, announced : "Arrived on Thursday, the sixth instant, at this port, the elegant barge Cincinnati, Captain Jonathan Horton from New Orleans ; passage eighty-seven days. Cargo : sugars, molasses, rum, lignum vitae, Spanish hides. etc., to Jacob Baymiller."


The traveler Burnet states that in 1817 numerous arks, bearing emigrants on their way to the West were to be seen frequently near the landing.


At the same time Burnet noted seven Kentucky boats with coal, iron and dry goods from Pittsburgh. He saw four barges or keelboats, one of one hundred and fifty tons and two masts, which ran up and down the rivers between Pittsburgh and New Orleans. He noted four flats of scows laden with building stones and salt from the Kenhawa salt works.


He saw six arks with emigrants and their possessions these people on their way down the river commonly tarried here to lay in provisions.


But Cincinnati soon afterward awoke to the importance of the shipbuilding: industry, and between 1817 and 1819, about one-fourth of the vessels constructed on western waters were built here.


Niles Weekly Register, Jan. 4, 1823, said : "Steamboats on the Mississippi, etc. From the Louisiana Advertiser of the 25th November. The first steamboat employed in trade on the Mississippi, was called the New Orleans, of New Orleans. Built at Pittsburgh in 1812, and enrolled and licensed for the coast trade, at the port of New Orleans, in 1813, nine years ago, since which period, up to the present time, there has been eighty-one different boats enrolled at the port of New Orleans.


"Of this number, several have been built at New Orleans, but they have been principally built on the waters of the Ohio, being, in the aggregate, a tonnage exceeding 18,000 tons.


"This first boat was lost in 1814, and tip to the present time there have been 23 other boats lost, either being sunk or destroyed by fire, decayed or laid up, and out of use, forming in the aggregate, about 4,000 tons—and leaving a balance, say in round numbers, 14,000 tons of this description of vessels now


106 - CINCINNATI-THE QUEEN CITY


employed or which may be employed in trade on the Mississippi and its tributary waters, with the port to New Orleans.


"This 14,000 tons does not probably employ mbre than 1,000 hands, and can do more in a given time than 50,000 tons could have done in barges, keelboats, or any other kind of vessels employed ten years ago, with 20,000 hands." The rapid increase of steamboats head very soon the natural tendency of reducing freights, and although the owners suffered severely from this cause and the consequent diminution in the value of the vessels, yet the country at large has been greatly benefited by their introduction ; and it is to be hoped the number in existence can now be beneficially employed."


Niles Weekly Register, Balt., Jan. 18, 1823, states : "The Western Waters. - No less than seven steamboats are prepared, or preparing, to start from Pittsburgh early in the spring, to ply between that place and St. Louis, Nashville, New Orleans, etc., regularly. They are amply fitted for the transportation of passengers and merchandise or goods of all sorts, and will depart and arrive in succession, so as to afford the greatest possible facilities to transportation, whenever the river will admit of it. The land carriage to Pittsburgh is now very moderate."


From about 1817 the steamboat traffic began to come into its own. Navigation changed from the broadhorn to the steamer.


In 1818, the first steamboat, the Eagle, that was built here, as before stated, was put into commission. Immediately succeeding that date the business of steamer building went forward rapidly. There was in the building of steamers on the Ohio the great advantage of cheapness compared with those constructed in eastern cities. Cincinnati appears to have led in this industry. In 1824-1826, Cincinnati rivalled any other city in the world in this business. The black locust of this vicinity proved better for ship building than any wood available elsewhere.


It is astonishing to contemplate the growth of steamer building in this region. By 1826, two hundred and thirty-three steamboats had been launched. 1811 saw one built ; 1814 another; 1816 three; in 1817 there were seven built. In 1818, twenty-five steamboats were constructed on these waters.. In the intervening years until 1826, one hundred and seventy-six more steamers were built. Forty eight of the total were constructed at Cincinnati.


About 1826, the old styles of crafts had almost vanished from the river traffic. By that time the industry of steamboat making had risen to be among the chief businesses of Cincinnati.


The annual products, however, of this kind varied greatly from year to year. In 1856, thirty-three steamers were built ; in 1857, thirty-four ; 1858, fourteen; 1859, eleven ; 1860, twenty-eight ; 186r, eleven ; 1862, four ; 1863, forty-three ; 1864, sixty-two ; 1866, thirty-three ; 1867, eighteen ; 1868, eleven; 1869, eleven; 1870, fifty-two ; 1871, forty-four ; 1872, fifty-two ; 1873, forty-eight ; 1874, twenty-nine ; 1875, sixteen ; 1876, nineteen ; 1877, twenty-one ; 1878, thirty ; 1879, twenty-four.


In 1880, the report of the committee on river navigation said : "A good number of boats have been built here the past year-the number of all crafts being twenty. with tonnage six thousand, six hundred and eighty-three, against twenty-


CINCINNATI—THE QUEEN CITY - 107


four last year, and tonnage ten thousand, six hundred and forty-one. In the future we must not look for a greater number of boats, but expect a heavy increase in tonnage ; this is more applicable to stern wheel boats, which in former years were of small size and used mostly in making short trips. There are those that have attained the carrying capacity of three thousand tons. Now, however, boats, whether of a side or stern wheel, for short packet trade or for more distant ports, are of large size ; indeed it seems a question to what point the size of boats may reach. This change in building larger boats .for the Upper Ohio, with more speed, is only following the prediction of those who advocated the lengthening and widening of the Louisville and Portland canal and lessening the rates of its tolls."


In 1880, the report of the Chamber of Commerce stated : "The arrivals for the year aggregated three thousand, one hundred and sixty-three boats, compared with two thousand, seven hundred and twenty-five in the year immediately preceding, and the departures three thousand, one hundred and sixty-seven, in comparison with two thousand, seven hundred and thirty. The whole number of steamboats and barges which plied between Cincinnati and other ports in the past year was three hundred and twenty-two, with an aggregate tonnage of eighty-three thousand, five hundred and sixty-nine. In this connection it must be kept in mind that in the past year vessels have run with great regularity and frequency, and that, in consequence, an equal. number of vessels represents a larger business, because each vessel in the latter category is counted but once, no difference how frequent may have been the visitations. Again, it is true that the same number of arrivals and departures also represented an increased business, inasmuch as it comprised generally vessels which from the regularity of arrival and departure, and the general exemption of transient boats, had uniformly good cargoes. It is worthy of note that the number of arrivals and departures for each leading point has increased over the preceding year. Thus, the arrivals from New Orleans aggregated, in the past year, one hundred and three vessels, compared with eighty-five in the preceding year and the departures one hundred and sixteen in comparison with ninety seven. From Pittsburgh the arrivals were one hundred and eighty two, compared with one hundred and sixty-three, and the departure one hundred and seventy-seven, in comparison with one hundred and sixty-two. From St. Louis the arrivals aggregate ninety-three, compared with sixty-four, and the departures ninety-four, in comparison with seventy-five. From all other points the arrivals aggregated two thousand, seven hundred and eighty-five, compared with two thousand, four hundred and thirteen, and the departures two thousand, seven hundred and eighty, in comparison with two thousand, three hundred and ninety-six. A study of the figures through a series of years reveals the fact that the increase the past year was not solely over 1878-79, which was a year that was seriously interfered with by cold weather that diminished the number of arrivals and departures for the year, but exhibits a general increase extending through a series of years. Thus, the entire number of arrivals and departures exceeds any preceding year in a period of fourteen years, and has but three times been exceeded in the history of the city, which was in 1857-58, when the excess was very small, and in 1864-65 and in 1865-66, the years that closed and immediately succeeded the war, which was a time


108 - CINCINNATI—THE QUEEN CITY


that, for a period of normal conditions, would not be a fair measure." The whole number of steamers in the freight and passenger traffic between Cincinnati and other ports, and total tonnage, compared for ten years, between 1893 and 1902, was as follows : 1893, steamers 36, tonnage 22,569 ; 1894, 34 and 20,527; 1895, 30 and 18,587; 1896, 25 and 15,032; 1897, 27 and 15,881; 1898, 25 and 14,677; 1899, 29 and 16,311 ; 1900, 28 and 15,618 ; 1901, 29 and 15,130; 1902, 30 and 15,483.


The first ocean going vessel to load at Cincinnati for Europe was the Muskingum, in 1844. This boat was built at Marietta, and was of three hundred and fifty tons burden. In the autumn of 1844 she took on her cargo at Cincinnati and started for Liverpool. The Times of Liverpool, January 30, 1845, stated : "Arrival direct from Cincinnati.—We have received a file of Cincinnati papers brought by the first vessel that ever cleared out of that city for Europe. The building of a vessel of 350 tons, on a river seventeen hundred miles from the sea, is itself a very remarkable circumstance, both as a proof of the magnificence of the American rivers and the spirit of the American people. The navigating of such a vessel down the Ohio and the Mississippi, and then across the Atlantic, would, a few years ago, have been thought impossible. She brings a cargo of provisions ; and we trust that the success of this first adventure will be such as to encourage its frequent repetition. The name of the vessel is the Muskingum."


The Gazette of Cincinnati spoke editorially of this event : "If one had stood upon the eastern hill top which overhangs our city, in the early gray of the morning on Saturday, and looked out upon the river he might have thought a phantom ship was floating upon it. The quick puffing of the steamer was heard, and out beyond it seemingly a full rigged ship, its masts towering up and all spars set, was evidently looming on and making direct for the landing of the city. Early risers were startled. Even those who knew that enterprising men of Marietta were building a sea vessel were astonished when it unexpectedly hove in sight. But when it approached nearer and nearer, and bodied itself forth plainly to the naked vision, the cry went up, 'a ship, a ship,' with a thrill akin, at least, to that which men and women feel on the ocean shore, when welcoming back the long absent 'sea homes' of relative and friend."


Previous to 1850, John Swasey and Company of Cincinnati, built three ships of two to three hundred and fifty tons. One of these was the Louisa, a full-rigged brig. The others were barks, one named the John Swasey and the other the Salem. These were towed by steamers to New Orleans. At that place they set out for sea.


A ship of eight hundred and fifty tons, called the Minnesota, was constructed in Cincinnati at the same period by other builders for a New Orleans man.


About 1826, one hundred flatboats were annually brought down the Big Miami. There were thirty came down each year out of the Little Miami. These carried thirty-three thousand five hundred barrels of flour, worth about one hundred thousand dollars.


The time had been reduced by the steamboats between Cincinnati and New Orleans to twelve or fourteen days.


Heavy merchandise, groceries, queensware and so on, still came by way of New Orleans. Dry goods and lighter materials were brought from eastern cities


CINCINNATI—THE QUEEN CITY - 109




to Pittsburgh and Wheeling and came to Cincinnati by the river. Iron came from Pittsburgh and from the Licking and Sandy rivers. From the vicinity of Paint creek and Brush creek, in Ohio, came most of the castings. Pittsburgh furnished nails. Missouri supplied lead ; salt was brought from Conemaugh, Pennsylvania and the Kanawha, Virginia. Lumber came in rafts from the head waters of the Allegheny.


Cincinnati sent its exports chiefly to the West Indies and South America. Whiskey and pork went to the eastern cities. The Mississippi region bought a large part of the Miami products.


In 1832 the commerce of Cincinnati figured $4,000,000. In 1835 it exceeded $6,000,000.


In 1835 the steamer arrivals were two thousand, two hundred and thirty.


In that year there were imported ninety thousand barrels of flour and fifty-five thousand barrels of whiskey.


Five million, two hundred thousand &tars were in 1840 invested in foreign trade and commerce.


There were $12,877,000 in retail dry goods business, hardware, groceries and the like.


There was an investment of $133,000 in the lumber trade, which occupied twenty-three yards, with seventy-three employes. The lumber sales in 1840 were $342,500.


In 1841 there were eighty-eight steamboats owned in the Cincinnati region. The tonnage was eleven thousand, seven hundred and thirteen.


In 1850 trade and commerce had grown greatly. At that time a single house in Cincinnati was doing $1,200,000 of commercial business. More than half its shipments were sent to Great Britain.


In 1851 the city's commerce was rated at thirty-six millions.


Coal had now come to be a great import to this city. In 1851 there were seven millions, seven hundred and eighty-five thousand bushels used here. In 1859 there were sixty-eight coal yards here and there were fifteen million bushels used.


In 1858, the increase of coffee imports was eleven per cent ; sugar thirty per cent and molasses sixty per cent. Wool import increased one hundred and fifty-five per cent ; import of potatoes two hundred and sixty-nine per cent ; manufactured tobacco ninety-six per cent.


The exports of horses increased one hundred and forty-one per cent. Those of furniture eighty-nine per cent ; molasses sixty-one per cent.


The river traffic of Cincinnati in 1869 was one hundred and sixty-nine million, five hundred thousand dollars.


At that time Cincinnati manufacturers began to send crackers to China and candies to Greece.


A vast amount of provisions was sent to the Eastern cities. Still, the chief markets for exports were in the South.


The West and the Southwest received most of Cincinnati's manufactures.


In 1873 the local commerce of Cincinnati amounted to five hundred and forty millions.


110 - CINCINNATI—THE QUEEN CITY


The corning of the steamboat wrought in due time a change, in the personnel of the rivermen. The new mode of boat propulsion met, of course, bitter opposition from the old time men whose industry was threatened. Heretofore sheer muscular strength had, counted in river traffic, but steam introduced need of better intelligence as well as the learning of new. modes. Flatboat, barge and steamboat continued to do business side by side, but the old boatman found themselves outstripped and outclassed. The steamboat necessarily ran sharper division between the management and employes than ever before. Captains and other officers were separated as by a gulf from deck hands. The captains were usually of a fine type of men. The "hands" were generally much inferior to the old time, independent bargemen'!


One of the most notorious features of steamboat life for many years was gambling. Professional gamblers swarmed on the packets from Pittsburgh to New Orleans. Victims of the card sharpers were to be counted by thousands, and traditions of murders and all manner of crimes still linger in regard to those days.


A gambler has given this account of one of his experiences : "Coming up on the Sultana, one night, there- were about twenty-five of the toughest set of men as cabin passengers I believe I ever met. They were on their way to Napoleon, Arkansas, which at that time was a great town and known as the jumping-off place. In those days these Napoleon fellows were looked upon as cutthroats and robbers, and thought nothing of murdering a fellow simply to make them appear big men with their gang. I had for a partner a man named Canada Bill, as game a party as ever; strode the deck of a steamboat, and one of the shrewdest gamblers I ever encountered. As soon as supper was over this gang of Arkansas toughs got in the cabin and of course wanted to play cards. Bill had opened up business in the main hall, .and a great crowd had gathered about him.. I saw-that most of these devils had been drinking, and gave Bill the nod, which he of course understood. He only played a short while and left the ,game, pretending to be broke. Then we fixed it up that I should. do the playing and he would watch out for any trouble. Well, the result was I got about everything the twenty-five men had, including their watches, and beat some seven or eight other passengers. The men all took it apparently good natured at the time, but as the night wore on and they kept drinking from their private flasks I made a sneak to my room and changed my clothes. By the back stairs I skipped down into the kitchen and sent a man after my partner. I had blackened my face and looked like one of the negro rousters. I only had time to warn him when a terrible rumpus upstairs told me the jig was up, and with their whiskey to aid them they were searching for me, and if they caught me it would be good day for me. I paid. the cooks to keep mum, and Bill made himself scarce. They had their -guns out and were kicking in the stateroom doors hunting for me. Some of them came down on deck, and were walking back and forth by me, cursing and threatening vengeance. I heard one of them ask a roustabout if he had noticed a well dressed man down on the deck lately. He of course had not, as Bill had gone back up the kitchen stairs, and with these devils was raising Cain, looking for me, and my disguise had not been discovered under the darkness of the night. The boat was plowing her way along up the


CINCINNATI—THE QUEEN CITY - 111


coast. The stevedores were shouting to the darkies, hurrying them along with the freight for a landing soon to be reached. The boat's whistle blew, and soon she was heading in for the shore. A crowd of these fellows were waiting for me, -as they suspected I would try and get off. They were looking, mind you, for a well-dressed man: As soon As the boat landed., about ten of them, guns in hand, ran out over the stage to shore and closely scanned the face of every person that carne off. There was a stock of plows to be discharged from the boat's cargo, and noting the fact, I shouldered one and with it followed the long fine of 'coons' amid the curses of the mates, and fairly flew past these men who were hunting me. I kept on up the high bank and over the levee and when I threw my plow in the pile with the others made off for the cotton fields and laid flat on my back until the boat got again under way, and the burning pine the torches' on deck had been extinguished. It was a close call, I can assure you Bill met me at Vicksburg the next day and brought the boodle, which we divided. He said the crowd took lights and searched the boat's hold for me after we left the landing. Bill must have played his part well, as he told me afterward that they never suspicioned him. Yes, I could tell, many of my exploits. The river was for the greater portion of my gambling career my strongest hold. But it's all over now. Even should a man strike a big winning, there are always too many smart Alecks about, and you would have to whack up with so many that there would be little left for the winner."


The rivalry in speed and the racing of steamboats was another notorious feature of some years ago. The stories go that frequently the passengers incited the officers of the boats to race, paid for extra fuel and became wildly excited over the result. Stories go that sometimes; when 'other fuel failed, hams were cast into the furnace as a last resort to create more steam.


James Hall, in "Statistics of the West," 1836, quotes William C. Redfield, steam navigation agent, as saying: "The contests for speed, or practice of racing, between rival steamboats, has been the cause, and perhaps justly, of considerable alarm in the community. It is remarkable, however, that 'as far as the information of the writer extends, there has no accident occurred to any boiler which can be charged to a contest of this sort. The close and uniform. attention which is necessarily given to the action and state of the boilers Wand engines, in such contests, may have had a tendency to prevent disaster. But this hazard as well as the general danger of generating an' excess of steam, is greatly lessened by the known fact that in most ;steamboats the furnaces and boilers are not competent to furnish a greater supply of steam than can be used with safety, with an ordinary degree of attention on the part of the engineers.


"The magnitude and extent of the danger to which passengers in steamboats are exposed, though sufficiently appalling, is comparatively much less than in other modes of transit with which the public have been long familiar ; the accidents of which, if not so astounding, are almost of every day occurrence. It will be understood that I allude to the dangers of ordinary navigation, and land conveyance by animal power on wheel carriages."


The beginning of work to improve the Ohio river was in 1825. At that period the river in its whole length was obstructed by sand bars, snags, rocks and gravel. Much has since been done by the government to better the condi-


112 - CINCINNATI—THE QUEEN CITY


tions on the river and its tributaries. Lighthouses have also been placed. Ice harbors have been formed at a number of points as refuges for boats in time of peril from ice was


The amount of money invested in boats is about ten millions, while the expenditure for improvements in the river have not been more than three per cent of the value of the freight carried in one year.


The series of movable dams now in progress constitute the greatest effort ever made to make the Ohio navigable. The Davis dam, near Pittsburgh, was opened in 1885. The series of dams is to be in time extended to the mouth of the river.


The Fernbank dam near Cincinnati was opened in August, 1911.


The present condition of government work in the improvement of the West Virginia, Ohio and Kentucky tributaries of the Ohio river is detailed in the annual report sent to Washington July, 1911, by Major John C. Oakes of the United States engineer's office. The rivers are the Big Sandy, Muskingum, Kentucky and Guyandot, forming what is known as the Second Cincinnati district.


The Kentucky river, with its stretch of navigable waters reaching back into the state for 240 miles from its mouth at Carrollton, is now the biggest and most important of them all. Its freight traffic for the past year reached the aggregate of $1,921,581.28, and by the completion of Dam 13 the slack water of the river is at last brought to the coal fields, which were the great objective point all along.


The government improvements of the Kentucky are now at the beginning of the finish. The contract for the building of Dam 14, to be located at Heidelberg, has been let to Gahren, Dodge & Maltby, and is to be completed by December 31, 1913. It is the last of the locks and dams on the Kentucky. Contractors W. F. Garretson of Cincinnati, is to finish building the lock at Dam 13 by September 1, 1912. All the other locks are in regular operation. There are nineteen steamers plying on the river, and they carried 9,842 passengers in the year, while 2,003 rafts of logs were also floated down its waters to the Ohio.


Timber was the chief article of commerce on the Kentucky, the amount of this being nearly six million cubic feet, valued at $510,056.75. It was brought down the river distances of 155 miles. Great quantities of lumber and staves were also carried. Next import of the Kentucky products was tobacco, the value of it being $341,460. Iron and steel and oil also figure in the river's freight, and the coal brought down was $209,810. Whiskey is among the unimportant items of the traffic, the boats carrying but forty-two barrels of it during the whole year ; its value was $3,150.


The operating expense for the year was $130,860.04.


The Muskingum river, with its system of eleven locks and dams, cost $49,521.45 for operating expenses. The craft on this river include 16 steamers, 25 gasoline boats, 132 launches and others, all of them together carrying 35,153 passengers during the year. The total traffic is valued at $2,644,150. There were 63,250 tons and the hauls varied from four to fifty-five miles. Merchandise was the chief item, its value being $1,938,700. Great quantities of eggs were also in the freight, their value being represented by $138,000. Horses and mules, live stock and poultry are also in the showing.


CINCINNATI—THE QUEEN CITY - 113




All the regular construction work has been finished for this river and only repairs and maintenance are now called for. The expenditures for this were $49,52 I .49.


Navigation was much hindered on the Big Sandy in the past, there being 151 days in which it stood suspended owing to low water or dangerous currents. Ties were the chief article of traffic, there being $175,175 worth of them shipped down the river. Twenty boats ply on the main stream and its two forks, carrying manufactured iron, timber and other merchandise. The operating expenses for the year were $19,608.30.


Plans for the improvements during 1912 are not yet announced.


The completion of the Fernbank darn, officially Dam 37, is the big and significant particular in the annual report of the past year's work on Ohio river improvements sent to Washington by Major H. Jervey, now in charge of the Cincinnati division. The work on this darn was begun in May, 1905, so that it has been six years in building. Some of the hardest of the hard work here was that encountered in getting ready for operating the dam after all the rest had been done.


Mud, rubbish and debris enough to build a hill had to be removed from the foundations where it had collected. The chief trouble came in getting the lock gates to move. This kept engineers and workers busy for several months past, but all the usual means failed and it was not until the regular engines were aided by others with the tremendous force of 150 tons extra power that the gates were finally made to move as they should. The difficulty, Major Jervey stated, was due to the axles of the gate bearings getting corroded in the water in which they have been standing the past two and one-half years. At present the gates can be moved by their own engines without other help.


Work has begun on the newest of the important dams—dam No. 29. The location for the buildings includes 13.22 acres on the Kentucky side of the river. The Bates & Rogers Construction company have the contract.


The total appropriations made by the United States government to date for improving the Ohio river since 1827, when it was first begun, to date, amount only to $8,201,439.72. Considering the long period of eighty-four years and the importance of the Ohio as a trade artery it is small.


The great event of opening the Fernbank dam took place July 22, 1911. The Commercial Tribune of that date said : "The nine-foot stage of water for the Ohio river, talked of for years, today becomes a reality. Beginning at 5 o'clock this morning the new Fernbank dam will go into operation by the raising of its wall of wickets, now ready for their task of holding back the water of the river until all that part above Fernbank and reaching along the city's entire water front and for some distance beyond Coney Island, reaches a depth of nine feet.


"The stretch of slack water will extend for a' distance of twenty-six miles, from Fernbank to a point one-fourth of a mile from the head of Eight Mile dyke.


"When this pool is full to the depth required the river at the foot of Broadway will show a stage of 11.3 feet. At the head of the lower Four Mile bar there will be a raise of 6.3 feet above the present low water stage ; at Gander bar a raise of 3.8 feet ; at Five Mile bar 2.1 feet raise, and at the quarter mile above the head of Eight Mile the slack ends altogether.


Vol. II.-8.


114 - CINCINNATI—THE QUEEN CITY


"All day the filling up of the pool will be going on. It is proposed to make it very slow work, so that the temporary fall of water in the river below Fern-bank will not give trouble to the boats plying there. Some alarm had started yesterday already on this subject among boatmen, who were led to think that the fall in that part of the river would be enough to stop navigation entirely for' some time at least.


"Their fears about this were communicated to the managers of the darn and they were assured there would be no trouble, the intention being to have the raising of the wickets effected so gradually that the fall in the river below the dam would be very slight. It is likely the work will not be finished before Sunday morning, depending on circumstances.


"The river stage for this city yesterday was 5.7 feet at the foot of Broadway, and not till this is brought to 11.3 feet will the filling up be completed.


"Boats passing the dam will have to enter the lock on the Ohio shore after exchanging signals as follows :


"Signals—Boats approaching from either direction and desiring to pass through the lock will notify the lock-tender by four short whistles. The signals from the lock for boats or other craft to enter will be three short whistles ; the signal for leaving the lock will be one long whistle.


"Lights—When the dam is up signal lights will be displayed after dark as follows :


"At the head of the river wall of the lock three red lights in a vertical line.


"At the foot of the river wall of the lock two red lights in a vertical line."


On the next day the Commercial Tribune said : "All yesterday and last night the work of harnessing the Ohio went forward without hitch or halt at Fern-bank, and by noon today there will be seen the realization of the nine-foot river stage for the whole Cincinnati harbor and for miles of its approaches above and below the city.


"The operation was a slow one, because that was necessary. The- need to keep the river below the dam supplied with water sufficient for the boats plying there required that the raising of the wickets should be very gradual and that they should be brought into place one at a time. It was not till after midnight that the last one of them was raised, and then the wall of sheet steel was complete from the Kentucky to the Ohio shore, holding back the waters above.


"Crowds from the city and surrounding towns were on the scene all day. Hundreds of spectators crowded the tractions to the place, and as many more took in the sights from the excursion boats that made the trip down from the city. Launches without number kept coming and going with gay outing parties bent on being among those to claim having seen the big dam's opening day.


"Very fitly the distinction of being the first of the boats to pass through the lock fell to the pleasure craft Romona, in command of Albert Bettinger, the strenuous and devoted advocate and leader in the cause of the river's improvements.


"The Romona had made the passage of that section of the Ohio many times before, and a shade of sadness was added .to the feelings of those aboard by the


CINCINNATI—THE QUEEN CITY - 115


void in their ranks made by the death of George Guckenberger, president of the Atlas National bank, missing now for the first time in the party, to which he contributed life and pleasure.


"The Ramona had laid up the evening previous just below the dam, and before retiring for the night its crew held brief memorial services for Mr. Guckenberger. In the morning Captain Bettinger headed the boat for the lock, and in response to his signal its gate opened and the craft, with flags flying, made its way through to the upper course.. All the machinery of the lock worked to perfection. The Roniona was duly credited on the records as the first boat to pass. Those in the party with Mr„ Bettinger were George A. Dieterle, Louis J. Hauck, George F. Dieterle, Charles Albrecht, Charles Wiedemann and George and Herman Guckenberger.


"Half an hour later the steamer Douglas Hall, coming up the river to the city, arrived at the dam and signaled.


"It had been its captain's intention to be the first to make the passage through the lock, arid although the regular channel was still open and the way clear, the captain insisted on having second honors for the Douglas Hall, and the lock was operated a second time to let that boat through.


"The raising of the wickets was begun at 6 o'clock in the morning, starting at the Kentucky shore abutment. It went on at intervals. Each time a wicket was raised the water passage of the river between the Ohio and Kentucky shores was shortened by three feet, that being the width of the wickets, of which there are 225 in all.


"The need for letting enough water pass to the river below the dam obliged the men to go very slowly in extending the steel wicket wall. It was not until the afternoon that wickets adjacent to the Ohio shore began to be raised, and all day a central passage was left open for boats to pass up or down without having to go through the lock. The steamer Indiana of the Louisville and Cincinnati Packet company went through this passage on its way to the Falls city last evening, there being some doubt as to whether the water stage at the lock would be sufficient for a boat of the Indiana's draught.


"The Romona and the Douglas Hall were the only boats making the lock passage during the day. With the stage that will be effective today the lock will be able to accommodate all comers. It has a length of 600 feet and a width of 110 feet.


"The working of the upper gate of the lock was interrupted for a few hours in the afternoon by the breaking of a cross-head in the driving engine. This added some of the necessary delay in raising the wickets.


"Assistant Chief Engineer R. R. Jones of the United States engineer corps, was personally in charge of the arrangements for the starting of the dam. These were carried out with entire success at all points. Major Jervey of the engineer corps, in charge of the Ohio river, was among those present to witness the workings.


"When the filling up of the Cincinnati pool is completed today the river stage at the foot of Broadway will stand at 11.3 feet, and from that will gradually decline to 9 feet at a short distance above Coney Island, and the Eight Mile bar."


116 - CINCINNATI—THE QUEEN 'CITY


Cincinnati looks forward eagerly to the completion of the nine-foot stage to Cairo, and then to the opening of the Panama canal and to the vast increase of business these two events are bound to give to the Queen City.


In the autumn of 1911, Cincinnati expects to take part in the celebration of the hundredth anniversary of steam navigation on the Ohio.


The hull of the steamer New Orleans, a replica of the first steamboat that navigated the Monongahela, Ohio and Mississippi rivers, from Pittsburgh to New Orleans, was launched Thursday, August 30, 1911, at the Elizabeth Marine Ways company, Pittsburgh, in the presence of several members of the Historical society of western Pennsylvania, under whose auspices the vessel is being built. The boat will be finished by the middle of October and will take part in the river pageant, repeating the first voyage to the port of New Orleans.


The vessel will be christened October 31, when Mrs. Nicholas Longworth will break a bottle of champagne over the bow of the boat. Mrs. Longworth is a grand-niece of Nicholas J. Roosevelt, who built the original New Orleans. The boat is 138 feet long and 26% feet beam, eight-foot depth of hold and of about 400 tons burden and every way a duplicate of the original steamer.


CHAPTER X.


THE POSTOFFICE.


THE PRIMITIVE POSTOFFICE A VERY RUDIMENTARY AFFAIR-ABNER N. DUNN KEPT THE FIRST POSTOFFICE IN HIS LOG CABIN ON SECOND STREET-FIRST MAILS CARRIED BY A POST RIDER-POSTAGE ON LETTERS TWENTY-FIVE CENTS IN COIN-POSTMASTERS AND POSTOFFICE BUILDINGS.


The colonial postoffice, as well as that of the early days after the independence of the country, was a very rudimentary affair. Perhaps the earliest official notice of it is seen in the following paragraph from the records of the general courts of Massachusetts in 1639. "It is ordered that notice be given that Richard Fairbanks, his house in Boston, is the place appointed for all letters which are brought from beyond the seas, or are to be sent thither to be left with him ; and he is to take care that they are to be delivered or sent according to the directions ; and he is allowed for every letter a penny, and must answer all miscarriages through his own neglect in this kind."


That court in 1667 was petitioned to make better postal arrangements, the petitioners alleging the frequent "loss of letters whereby merchants, especially with their friends and employers in foreign parts are greatly damnified many times the letters are imputed ( ?) and thrown upon the exchange, so that those who will may take them up, no person without some satisfaction, being willing to trouble their houses therewith."


In Virginia the postal system was yet more primitive. The colonial law of 1657 required every planter to provide a messenger to convey the dispatches as they arrived to the next plantation, and so on, on pain of forfeiting a hogshead of tobacco in default. The Government of New York in 1672 established "a post to goe monthly from New York to Boston," advertising "those that bee disposed to send letters, to bring them to the secretary's office, where, in a lockt box, they shall be preserved till the messenger calls for them, all persons paying the post before the bagg be sealed up." Thirty .years later this monthly post had become a fortnightly one, as we see by the following paragraph in the Boston News-Letter. "By order of the postmaster general of North America. These are to give notice, That on Monday night, the 6th of December, the Western post between Boston and New York sets out once a fortnight, the three winter months of December, January and February, and to go alternately from Boston to Saybrook and Hartford, to exchange the mayle of letters with the New York Ryder ; the first turn for Saybrook to meet the New York Ryder on Saturday night the 11th currant ; and the second turn he sets out at Boston on Monday night the loth currant, to meet the New York Ryder at Hartford, on Saturday night the 25th currant, to


- 117 -


118 - CINCINNATI—THE QUEEN CITY


exchange mayles ; and all persons that sends letters from Boston to Connecticut from and after the 13th inst. are hereby notified first to pay the postage on the same." This office of postmaster-general for America had been created in 1602.


In the American colonies postal improvements may be dated from the administration of Franklin, who was virtually the last colonial postmaster-general, as well as unquestionably the best. In one shape or another he had forty years' experience of postal work, having been appointed postmaster at Philadelphia as early as October, 1737. When he became postmaster-general in 1753 he bestirred himself for the improvement of his department in that practical painstaking way with which he was wont to guide any plough he had once put his hand to, whatever the ground it had to work in. He visited all the chief post-offices throughout Pennsylvania, New Jersey, New York, and New England, looking at everything with his own eyes. His administration cannot be better summed up than we find it to be in a sentence or two which he wrote after his dismissal. Up to the date of his appointment, he says, "the American postoffice had never paid anything to that of Britain. We (himself and his assistant) were to have six hundred pounds ($2,916) a year between us, if we could make that sum out of the office. . . . In the first four years the office became above nine hundred pounds ($4,374) in debt to us. But it soon began to repay us ; and before I was displaced by a freak of the minister's, we had brought it to yield three times as much clear revenue to the crown as the postoffice of Ireland. Since that imprudent transaction they have received from it—not one penny."


Benjamin Franklin was removed by the home department of the government of Great Britain from his office of postmaster-general in America in 1774. On July 26th, 1775, the American Congress assumed direction of the postoffices, reappointing Franklin to his former post. Shortly afterwards, when Franklin was sent as ambassador to France, his son-in-law, Richard Bache, was made postmaster-general in November, 1775.


In 1789 the number of postoffices was seventy-five; in 1800, nine hundred and three; in 1825, five thousand, six hundred and seventy-seven ; in 1875, thirty-five thousand, seven hundred and thirty-four ; in 1909, sixty thousand, one hundred and forty-four.


In 1789 the gross revenues of the postal service were $30,000 ; in 1800, $280,000. In 1884, the receipts were $43,325,959; the expenditures were $47,224,560, and salaries of postmasters were $11,283,830. In 1909, the receipts were $203,562,383 ; expenditures $221,004,102 ; salaries of postmasters, $26,569,892.


At first, and for many years, the postage. rates varied with the distance the matter was carried. In 1792, the rates were from six cents for distances of thirty miles or less to twenty-five cents for distances of four hundred and fifty miles or more. One cent was the rate for a newspaper for one hundred miles or less ; one cent and a half for greater distances.


Post riders carried the mails in saddle bags. Long distances and bad roads caused prolonged intervals between mail days and often great delays beyond the appointed times. When the post rider did come the community turned out en masse. The mail carrier was also a dispenser of news by word of mouth and always had an excited and eager group of hearers hanging on his words as to events beyond their boundaries.


CINCINNATI—THE QUEEN CITY - 119


Nearly every post road was at some time the scene of a mail robbery, a capital crime then, and many points are still indicated by traditions where such robbers have been shot or hanged.


In September, 1789, Jonathan Dayton, of New Jersey, and a member of Congress, wrote John Cleves Symmes, "Do not send your packets by the mail, as the expense is heavy. The letter said to be forwarded by Major Willis was by him, or some other person, thrown into the postoffice, and I was obliged to pay six shillings and eight pence in specie for it."


It was not every one who cared to receive mail in those days if the postage had not been prepaid. Sometimes people declined to take out their letters, not knowing whether or not they were of interest or value enough to justify the payment of the postage.


The Centinel of the Northwestern Territory, of June 28th, 1794, announced : "We learn that there is a post established from Pittsburgh to this place and that Albert M. Dunn, Esq., is appointed deputy postmaster-general in this place." This naturally caused a stir in the frontier, village. The same paper announced a fortnight later that the post from Pittsburgh had come, and that the office would be in the home of Dunn.


The first postmaster was Abner M. Dunn. His cabin on the corner of Butler street and Columbia Road, now Second street, beyond Fort Washington and the Artificers' yard, was the first postoffice.


On account of dearth of news and the uncertainty of the mails, the printer Maxwell stated in November that his first page each week would be devoted to printing the laws of the Territory.


In March of 1795 the postmaster Dunn warned "those who have a right to calculate on receiving letters or papers at his office that in future they must come prepared with ready cash in hand or no letters or papers."


In 1795, M. T. Green of Marietta agreed to convey the mails between Cincinnati and Pittsburgh in a canoe equipped with paddles and poles. On down stream journeys, on which traveling was easier, Greene carried some freight and an occasional passenger. A line of rowboats was soon established between these points, with relays at different stations to carry the mail.


After certain postoffices were established further up in the Miami region the mails were carried on horseback by William Olim.


Abner Dunn, postmaster, died July 18, 1795. He was succeeded in office by William Maxwell, the editor and the founder of the first newspaper in the Northwest Territory. His appointment was followed by the announcement : "Gentlemen and others wishing to send letters by the post may leave them at the printing office where the postoffice is now kept."


In the Centinel of October 3, 1795, John G. McDowell announced that he had contracted to carry the mails between Cincinnati and Graham's Station; that he would arrive at Cincinnati on Monday at twelve o'clock noon and remain until the following morning, "which is giving a sufficient time for the inhabitants of Cincinnati to answer their letters."


April 2d, 1796, the postmaster gave notice to such as were indebted to the postoffice to pay at once and that such as were looking for newspapers in the mail should come and pay the postage.


120 - CINCINNATI—THE QUEEN CITY


As throwing some light upon the relations of the Miami region to Cincinnati in the matter of the mails in early days the following facts in regard to Warren county will prove of interest. There were no postoffices within the limits of Warren county for more than eight years after the settlements were commenced. Cincinnati was for several years the postoffice for the whole Miami valley. In the year 1800 letters were advertised as remaining in the postoffice at Cincinnati addressed to the following persons in Warren county : John Bigger, Fourth Range; Thomas Espy, Little Miami ; John Wallace, schoolmaster, Turtle Creek ; Moses Crane, Fourth Range ; others were addressed "Bailey's Station," "Below the Big Miami," "Duck Creek," "Big Prairie," &c.


Within two years after the, organization of the State government, four post-offices were established in Warren county ; at Waynesville, Deerfield, Franklin and Lebanon. Ten years elapsed before any others were established. In 1812, Montgomery, in Hamilton county, was made a postoffice, and it accommodated a portion of the people of Warren living in the southwestern part of the county. Thus the people to the northward were gradually but slowly relieved of the necessity of depending upon Cincinnati for their mails.


The first mails to postoffices in Warren county were carried by a postrider. The route was from Cincinnati to Lebanon, Xenia, Urbana, thence across to Piqua, down through Dayton, Franklin and Hamilton to Cincinnati, taking a week to make the trip. The people thought themselves fortunate in having a weekly mail for some years. The mail was carried by postriders until about the year 1825, when stage lines were started with the mails.


There are perhaps people still living who can remember when the postage on a letter, which must be written on a single sheet of paper, was twenty-five cents between' Cincinnati and New Orleans, while the freight on a barrel of flour between the same points was sometimes below that figure. Most men at that time would have regarded our present mail facilities an impossibility, and especially would the prediction that letters' would one day be carried from Maine to California for two cents have been regarded as a Utopian dream.


Daniel Mayo succeeded Maxwell as postmaster of Cincinnati in July, 1797. On his removal to Newport, Kentucky, he was no longer eligible to the Cincinnati position but he was soon appointed postmaster at his new home and continued to act in that capacity during the remainder of his life.


William Ruffin became postmaster January 1st, 1799. He removed the post-office to his home, a two-story frame house, on Columbia and Lawrence streets. Major Ruffin held this position until the end of 1814, when he resigned and went into business with his son-in-law Major Oliver.


In Ruffin's time of service, the postage of a letter was twenty-five cents in coin. Four weeks was not an unusual period for the mail to be enroute to or from the east. The amount of mail matter in the Cincinnati office was so small as to be cared for in the corner of one room, where Major Ruffin attended to it behind glass doors. He had no assistant. The mail from the east then came once a week from Maysville, Kentucky, in one pair of saddle bags.


On May 17, 1799, the Western. Spy and Hamilton Gazette announced : "Postoffice.—Notice is hereby given that a postoffice is established at Chelicotha. The persons, therefore, having business in that part of the country may have speedy


CINCINNATI—THE QUEEN CITY - 121


and safe conveyance by post for.letters, packets, &c." That mail was then taken on horseback, following an Indian trail.


The same paper stated March 12, 1800, that a post route had been opened between Louisville and Kaskaskia, also one between Nashville and Natchez. "This will open an easy channel of communication with those remote places, which has heretofore been extremely difficult, particularly from the Atlantic States."


The mail carrier from Louisville was compelled to carry food for himself and horse from Louisville to Cincinnati. His path lay all the way through woods, where he was exposed to perils from animals and Indians as well as to hunger.


The Daily Commercial, Cincinnati, December, 1874, gave some reminiscences of this period in an interview : "In 1808-09 Peter Williams had contracts for carrying the mails between Louisville and Cincinnati, Cincinnati and Lexington, Cincinnati and Chillicothe, and Cincinnati and Greenville in Darke county. All these contracts were performed with pack horses through the dense forests and along the 'blazed' tracks or paths which, in those days, were called roads. The trip from Cincinnati to Louisville was generally performed in about two weeks' time. The provender for the horses had frequently to be carried along, it being impossible to procure any on the way. So of the other routes to the different places named,—everywhere through the grand dense forests, filled with wild game of all kinds. Our informant recollects many rude incidents which occurred on many trips he, as a boy, made with his father, and afterwards by himself, as he became older, to Chillicothe, Greenville, Louisville, &c. Mr. Williams retained these mail contracts up to 1821, using pack horses during the whole time, and only releasing them on the advent of the stage coaches, owners of which could afford to carry the mails at about one half the price he was getting. In those early days the pack horse was the only way in which supplies of every kind could be transported any distance ; and Mr. Williams distinctly remembers that his father possessed the only wagon in the country around Cincinnati, and that, being of no use, was suffered to rot down in the barn."


Samuel Lewis was one of the youthful carriers of mail employed by Mr. Williams. His son said in an account of his life : "After working a short time upon the farm, he was employed in carrying the United States mail, for which Mr. Williams had a contract at that time. His route was at first from Cincinnati to Williamsburg, and afterward from the latter point to Chillicothe. This work often required seven days and two nights in the week, making the labor very severe. In addition to this, the creeks and small rivers along the route were to be forded, bridges at that period being out of the question. This was all clone on horseback. The routes covered most of the country east of Cincinnati to the Scioto river at Chillicothe, and southward of this to the Ohio river, including Maysville, Kentucky.


"Over some of these .streams, during high water, it was necessary to swim the horse ; while often the attempt was accompanied with much danger. At one time, being compelled to swim his horse, he had secured the mail bag, as he supposed, and commenced grossing the stream, swimming himself and leading the horse. When nearly over, the mail bag from some cause became unloosed and


122 - CINCINNATI—THE QUEEN CITY


floated off. His horse was first to be secured, and then the mail. Its recovery and the renewal of his journey would have been speedy, but he was struck by a floating log and severely injured. Making his way with extreme difficulty to the shore, he succeeded in mounting his horse and continuing his journey to the next town, which he reached completely drenched and exhausted, and where he remained for some days before he was able to renew his round. The accident unfitted him for his employment for the time, and when he returned to Cincinnati he was occupied with other labor."


Mr. Lewis afterward became a distinguished man, was largely influential in the founding of the two greatest high schools of the city, and was the first superintendent of public schools in this state.


January 1st, 1815, William Burke became postmaster. He was commonly called "Father Burke," was a Methodist itinerent preacher and had been presiding elder. Mr. Mansfield states that Burke was a southerner : "He seemed to have lost his voice and always spoke low and in guttural tones. He was always chewing tobacco and, being a postmaster, was always a democrat. He was a strong Methodist and seemed an amiable man." Burke separated himself from his denomination, procured a place of worship for his followers, and often preached there. He was inclined to politics, was at first a Jeffersonian and then a Jackson democrat. He held office until the whigs came into power. Burke had as his assistant for a long time Elam P. Langdon, who also maintained the Cincinnati Reading Room, where many newspapers and journals, American and foreign, could be consulted. The postoffice in 1819 was at 157 Main street.


April 13th, 1841, President Tyler appointed as postmaster W. H. H. Taylor, who removed the office to Main street above Columbia or Second street ; subsequently he chose a site on Main street, near Fourth.


The number of mails to and from Cincinnati in 1826 was twenty each week. A portion of these was carried on ten stage coaches, three on the Chillicothe route, three on the Lebanon, three on the Dayton and Columbus route, and one on that to Georgetown, Kentucky. Ten mails were conveyed by postriders.


In 1826 the income of the Cincinnati postoffice from postage was eight thousand, one hundred and odd dollars. There were delivered in that year three thousand, seven hundred and fifty free letters.


Early in 1827 another line of stage coaches was started by way of Xenia, Urbana, Maysville, and Bucyrus to Lower Sandusky. At Sandusky the mail was put on a boat, and by this change letters reached New York in ten days. A daily line was also run to Wheeling, reaching Baltimore in eight or nine days; this route was almost the same as that taken later by the National pike. Stages at this time also were run from Cincinnati to Lexington, eighty miles.


In 1828-29 the income of the Cincinnati postoffice was twelve thousand, one hundred and fifty dollars, an increase of fifty per cent in three years. Twenty-three mails came and went each week, eighteen by stages and five by horseback.


In 1829-30 the income was sixteen thousand, two hundred and fifty odd dollars. In 1833, it was twenty-six thousand, one hundred and odd dollars. In this latter year, sixty-four mails came and went each week. Of these, thirty-six were by stages, eleven on horseback, ten on steamboats, and seven part way by steamboat and partly by land.


CINCINNATI—THE QUEEN CITY - 123


In 1836 there were the eastern mail, the southern mail by steamboat, the northern mail by way of Hamilton, Chillicothe, West Union ; southern by way of Georgetown, Brookville, Cynthiana ; western by way of Lawrenceburg, Maysville, Newport, and Covington, Walnut Hills, Mount Healthy and Cumminsville. There was a twice-a-week mail to Guyandotte, Virginia.


For distances less than thirty miles the letter postage was six and a quarter cents. This increased to twenty-five cents for distances more than four hundred miles. This was for single sheet letters ; double sheet letters were charged double, and there was apportionate increase according to the number of sheets.


The postoffice was removed about 1836 to Third street between Vine and Walnut streets. In November, 1841, the office was removed to a new building on East Third street, between Sycamore and Main streets. This had been erected especially for the postoffice by R. L. L'Hommedieu ; the office occupied the first floor.


Dickens in his "American Notes," gives an entertaining account of his observations of the stage coaches. He says : "We rested one day at Cincinnati, and then resumed our journey to Sandusky. As it comprised two varieties of stage coach traveling, which, with those I have already glanced at, comprehend the main characteristics of this mode of transit in America, I will take the reader as our fellow passenger, and pledge myself to perform the distance with all possible dispatch.


"Our place of destination in the first instance is Columbus. It is distant• about a hundred and twenty miles from Cincinnati, but there is a macadamized road (rare blessing) the whole way, and the rate of traveling upon it is six miles an hour. We start at eight o'clock in the morning, in a great mailcoach, whose huge cheeks are so very ruddy and plethoric that it appears to be troubled with a tendency of blood to the head. Dropsical it certainly is, for it will hold a dozen passengers inside. But, wonderful to add, it is very clean and bright, being nearly new, and rattles through the streets of Cincinnati gaily.


"Our way lies through a beautiful country, richly cultivated, and luxuriant in its promise of an abundant harvest. Sometimes we pass a field where the strong, bristling stalks of Indian corn look like a crop of walking sticks, and sometimes an enclosure where the green wheat is springing up among a labyrinth of stumps ; the primitive worm fence is universal, and an ugly thing it is ; but the farms are neatly kept, and, save for these differences, one might be traveling just now in Kent.


"We often stop to water at a roadside inn, which is always dull and silent. The coachman dismounts and fills his bucket, and holds it to the horses' heads. There is scarcely ever any one to help him ; there are seldom any loungers standing around, and never any stable-company with jokes to crack. Sometimes, when we have changed our team, there is a difficulty in starting again, arising out of the prevalent mode of breaking a young horse ; which is to catch him, harness him against his will, and put him in a stage coach without further notice ; but we get on somehow or other, after a great many kicks and a violent struggle, and jog on as before again.


"Occasionally, when we stop to change, some two or three half-drunken loafers will come loitering out with their hands in their pockets, or will be seen


124 - CINCINNATI—THE QUEEN CITY


kicking their heels in rocking chairs, or sitting on a rail within the colonnade ; they have not often anything to say, though, either to us or to each other, but sit there idly staring at the coach and horses. The landlord of the inn is usually among them, and seems, of all the party, to be the least connected with the business of the house. Indeed, he is with reference to the tavern, what the driver is in relation to the coach and passengers ; whatever happens in his sphere of action, he is quite indifferent, and perfectly easy in his mind.


"There being no stage coach next day upon the road we wished to take, I hired an extra, at a reasonable charge, to carry us to Tiffin ; a small town from whence there is a railroad to Sandusky. This extra was an ordinary four-horse stage coach, such as I have described, changing horses and drivers, as the stage coach would, but was exclusively our own for the journey. To insure our having horses at the proper stations, and being incommoded by no stranger, the proprietors sent an agent on the box, who was to accompany us the whole way through ; and thus attended, and bearing with us, besides, a hamper full of savory cold meats, and fruit and wine, we started off again, in high spirits, at half past six next morning, very much delighted to be by ourselves and disposed to enjoy even the roughest journey.


"It was well for us that we were in this humor, for the road we went over that day was certainly enough to have shaken tempers that were not set at fair, down to some inches below stormy. At one time we were all flung in a heap in the bottom of the coach, and at another we were crushing our heads against the roof. Now, one side was down deep in the mire, and we were holding on to the other. Now the coach was lying on the tails of the two wheelers ; and now it was rearing up in the air in a frantic state, with all four horses standing on the top of an insurmountable eminence, looking coolly back at it, as though they would say, 'unharness us. It can't be done.' The drivers on these roads, who certainly got over the ground in a manner which is quite miraculous, so twist and turn the team about in forcing a passage, corkscrew fashion, through the bogs and swamps, that it was quite a common circumstance on looking out of the window to see the coachman with the ends of a pair of reins in his hands, apparently driving nothing, or playing at horses, and the leaders staring at one unexpectedly from the back of the coach, as if they had some idea of getting up behind. A great portion of the way was over what is called a corduroy road, which is made by throwing trunks of trees into a marsh and leaving them to settle there. The very slightest of the jolts with which the ponderous carriage fell from log to log was enough, it seemed, to have dislocated all the bones in the human body. It would be impossible to experience a similar set of sensations in any other circumstances unless, perhaps, in attempting to go up to the top of St. Paul's in an omnibus. Never, never once that day was the coach in any position, attitude or kind of motion to which we are accustomed in coaches. Never did it make the smallest approach to one's experience of the proceedings of any sort of vehicle that goes on wheels:


"Still it was a fine day, and the temperature was delicious, and though we had left summer behind us in the west, and were fast leaving spring, we were moving towards Niagara and home. We alighted in a pleasant woods towards the middle of the day, dined on a fallen tree, and leaving our best fragments with


CINCINNATI—THE QUEEN CITY - 125


a cottager and our worst with the pigs that swarm in this part of the country like grains of sand on the seashore, to the great comfort of our commissariat in Canada, we went forward gaily.


"As night came on, the track grew narrower and narrower, until at last it so lost itself among the trees, that the driver seemed to find his way by instinct. We had the comfort of knowing at least that there was no danger of his falling asleep, for every now and then a wheel would strike against an unseen stump with a jerk, that he was. fain to hold on pretty quick and pretty tight to keep himself upon the box. Nor was there any reason to dread the least danger from furious driving, inasmuch as over that broken ground the horses had enough to do to walk ; as to shying, there was no room for that ; and a herd of wild elephants could not have run away in such a wood ; with such a coach at their heels. So we stumbled along quite satisfied."


June 24, 1845, William H. Taylor was removed from the postmastership by President Polk, and George Crawford was appointed to the position. At this time the postoffice was taken to the corner of Walnut and Third streets.


Major William Oliver was appointed May 2, 1849, by President Zachary Taylor, and the postoffice was taken to the Art Union building, Sycamore and Fourth streets. As Major Oliver died in office, James C. Hall was appointed February 4, 1852, to serve out his term.


April 29, 1853, Dr. John L. Vattier became postmaster. He was removed by President Buchanan and James J. Faran was appointed June 4, 1855.


October 21, 1859, Dr. Vattier was again appointed and served until April, 1861.


In 1851 the government purchased ground at Fourth and Vine streets, paying fifty thousand dollars for the lots. In 1856 the government building on that site was completed and the postoffice was removed to it.


J. C. Baum took office April 15, 1861. He was succeeded May 12, 1864, by F. J. Mayer, and he by William H. H. Taylor, November 6, 1866.


Calvin W. Thomas became postmaster April 20, 1867, and Thomas H. Foulds, April 5, 1869. •


January 9, 1874, Gustave R. Wahle became postmaster and John P. Loge succeeded him January 25, 1878.


The position was given S. A. Whitfield January 31, 1882. The next to hold this office was John C. Riley, appointed August 6, 1886.


John Zumstein was appointed February 9, 1891, and Charles E. Brown March 30, 1895.


Captain Elias R. Monfort, who had been a brave soldier in the Civil war, and is a citizen of prominence and usefulness, became the postmaster of Cincinnati March 2, 1899, and still holds this office. He is highly esteemed by all citizens and under his long administration the postoffice has seen its greatest development until it is now one of the model offices of the world.


In March, 1874, the government sold its old building and the site at Fourth

and Vine streets to the Chamber of Commerce for one hundred thousand dollars


The government in 1873 purchased ground at Fifth street, between Main and Walnut streets for a new government building. This ground cost six hundred and ninety-six thousand, seven hundred and odd dollars. Eleven years were


126 - CINCINNATI—THE QUEEN CITY


occupied in the erection of the building, at a cost of four million, five hundred and fifty-three thousand, two hundred and eighty odd dollars.


In May, 1885, the postoffice was removed to the new Federal building, where it occupies the ground floor.


Free city delivery was established in July, 1863. The railway mail service came into use August, 1864. Special delivery service was established October 1, 1885. The International parcel post, January 1, 1888. Rural free delivery, October, 1896.


The first postage stamp was sold in New York, July 1, 1847. The first stamped envelope June, 1853. The first newspaper wrapper February, 1861. The first special request envelope, 1865. The first postal card May 1, 1873.


The first registered letter at the New York postoffice was handled July 1855. The first letter that was returned to the writer was in 1829.


The first money order was issued November I, 1864. The first international money order in 1867. The first permit matter was authorized April 28, 1904. The first post cards May 19, 1898. The first newspaper mail at pound rates was sent March 3, 1879.


UNITED STATES GOVERNMENT BUILDING.


This great structure, the finest, most imposing and colossal of all the public buildings in the city, is a magnificent contribution to the many architectural attractions of Cincinnati, and is justly a source of pride to its citizens. It includes the postoffice, custom house, internal revenue department, offices of the railway mail service, weather bureau, and federal courts of the United States, and occupies one-half of the square bounded by Fifth, Sixth, Walnut and Main streets, with the main front facing on Fifth street. The building is 364 feet front and 164 feet deep, four stories in height above ground, exclusive of the attics and roof stories. There is an underground basement fourteen feet high and a sub-basement ten feet, furnished with light and air from an area twelve feet wide, running entirely around the building. The exterior is designed in the Renaissance style of four superimposed orders. The principal facade. 354 feet long, is divided into center and corner pavilions, connected by receding bays, while the end facades have corner pavilions only, connected by receding bays. The pavilions are strongly marked by porticos, with full, detached columns, and the divisions rendered more effective by large dormers and prominent roof lines at the corners, while the center pavilion terminates in an attic of two stories and high towering roof 170 feet from the ground. The windows, liberal in size and simple in form, are kept entirely subordinate to the orders which form the decorative features of the facades. The lines are generally rigid and the openings square at head, except in the crowning story, where arched openings give a very pleasing termination. The orders are very originally treated in the first story. The pilasters and columns, placed on a high pedestal, are rusticated, and by an ingenious introduction of the triglyph into the capitals, the characteristics of the Doric order are given with a decidedly new effect. This rusticated order, with its reinforcement of piers, forms an appropriate and massive substructure on which the other and lighter orders rest. These upper orders are a modified


CINCINNATI—THE QUEEN CITY - 127


tonic in the second story and composite in the third and fourth, the whole at a height of ninety-five feet from the ground, surmounted by a modillion cornice of ornamental detail. The exterior walls are of granite, the basement and stylobate from the red granite quarries of Middlebrook, Mo., and the superstructhre from quarries at Fox Island, Maine. The interior construction is of a strictly fireproof character, as in other first-class government buildings. with partitions of brick, and floors of iron beams and brick arches. The entire first story of this magnificent building is devoted to the postoffice department, rooms for the postmaster, cashier, money order and registry offices, vaults, etc., being located at the ends of the building, while the central portion forms one vast business room, 132x225 feet, which in addition to the usual complement of side windows, has a large portion of its ceiling of glass, making a skylight 63x220 feet. The building was commenced in 1874 and completed in 1885, the total cost, including the site ($800,000), being nearly five million dollars.


In 1826 there were 20 weekly mails carried on ten stages and ten horseback routes. In 1833 there were 64 mails per week, received and sent on thirty-six stages, ten steamboats, eleven horseback routes, and seven on steamboat and land carriage. In 1884 there were 229 dispatches by railrods, four by steamboats and four by hack, a total of 237 daily. In 1909 there were 709 mails received and dispatched daily, 331 on railroads and 278 on traction lines. In 1884 there were 104 clerks and 87 carriers and in 1910, 391 clerks and 20 substitutes, 326 carriers and 50 substitutes.


The growth of the Cincinnati postoffice may be shown by the revenues collected from 1800 to 1909, as follows :



1800

1805

1810

1815

1820

1825

1830

1835

1840

1845

1850

1855

1860

1860

1865

1870

1875

1880

1885

1890

1895

1900

1909

$ 560.35

1,319.15

1,929.13

5,426.93

7,021.15

7,286.50

16,557.06

30,698.05

49,809.54

59,924.15

77,098.59

$89,734.97

120,326.58

229,602.17

294,871.89

414,603.00

520,676.27

665,041.14

809,605.87

1,065,403.34

1,291,088.56

1,947,211.02

2,298,581.71




RATES OF POSTAGE.


Established by Act of Congress March 3, 1825, and the amendatory Act of March

2, 1827. On a single letter composed of one piece of paper



 

Miles

Cents

For any distance not exceeding

Over 30 miles, and not exceeding

Over 80 miles, and not exceeding

Over 150 miles, and not exceeding

Over 400 miles

30

80

150

400

6

10

12 1/2

18 3/4

25





128 - CINCINNATI—THE QUEEN CITY


A letter composed of two pieces of paper is charged with double those rates; of three pieces, with triple ; and of four pieces, with quadruple. "One or more pieces of paper, mailed as a letter, and weighing one ounce, shall be charged with quadruple postage; and at the same rate, should the weight be greater."


NEWSPAPER POSTAGE.


For each newspaper carried not over 100 miles - 1

Over 100 miles - 1 1/2

But if carried to any office in the State in which it is

printed, whatever the distance may be - 1


In 1855 the rate of postage for 3,000 miles was 3 cents if prepaid, and 5 cents if not prepaid. For any distance over 3,000 miles double the amount was charged. By Act of March 3,. 1885, the rate of postage on letters was reduced from 3 cents for each half ounce, or fraction thereof, to 2 cents for each ounce, or fraction thereof.


IMPROVEMENTS.


As the business increased in volume, provision was made to take care of it. Within ten years the furniture and fixtures in the main office have undergone frequent changes and improvements to insure more accurate and rapid handling of mails. Carrier routes have been increased, improved schedules made, more frequent deliveries established in the business and manufacturing regions and new routes extended in the suburbs where the requirements of free delivery exist. Eleven rural free delivery carrier routes have been established over which mail is received and distributed from the outlying branch stations. Twenty-five years ago there were but two carriers stations, A and C, now there are twenty stations and thirty-two numbered sub-stations. Nearly all of these stations have been reestablished in new buildings with modern equipments. Since 1902, free delivery has been extended to the outlying towns and villages of Winton Place, St. Bernard, Elmwood Place, Bond Hill, Carthage, Hartwell, Lockland, Reading, Arlington Heights, Wyoming, Pleasant Ridge, Kennedy and Oakley. To meet the needs of the service, two mail cars were put in commission in 1907 making nine round trips a day, delivering mail to stations and bringing back mail to the main office. We now have a very efficient collection service with eighteen collectors bringing mail from nearly all the mail boxes in the city during the afternoon and evening, the last collection being made before midnight. There are also i0 day collectors at stations.


Among the improvements urgently pressed by this office, and which we hope will soon be established, is the pneumatic tube service between the postoffice and railway stations, with extensions to the larger free delivery stations which will insure a more rapid delivery of mail to the business and manufacturing districts.


The department has laid responsibilities upon the Cincinnati postoffice in addition to the regular postal service. This office has been made the depository


CINCINNATI—THE QUEEN CITY - 129




for postal funds from 1,977 offices which, during 1909, amounted to $3,570,925.01. It is also the depository for 500 money order offices and $3,604,078.04 was received during the year 1909. This is also the postal card sub-agency for nine states and the value of cards distributed last year amounted to $1,123,958.00. The Cincinnati office is the mail bag depository and dispatches sacks and pouches to offices in eight states and during the past year the following equipment was distributed, 544,000 No. 1 sacks, 29,100 No. 2 sacks, and 67,390 pouches. The postmaster has been. appointed the disbursing officer for the rural free delivery service in Ohio and the salaries paid for this service during 1909, amounted to $2,298,227.00.


The Cincinnati postoffice has kept pace with the commercial, industrial and social development of the northwest territory and today has a record in Washington second to none in the high standard and efficiency of its employes and the quick receipt, delivery, and dispatch of mail.


COMPARATIVE STATEMENT OF WORK CINCINNATI POSTOFFICE DURING CALENDAR YEARS ENDED DECEMBER 31, 1884-1909.


MAILING DIVISION.



 

1884

1909

Letters, postal cards and circulars dispatched

Newspaper mail received for distribution

Total number distributed

Pieces 3rd and 4th class permit matter

Second class matter mailed by publishers, lbs

Misdirected mail matter handled

41,599,680

19,694,500

61,294,180


3,255,67

470,426

150,408,520

59,814,000

210,222,520

10,582,034

13,000,191

912,113

CITY DELIVERY DIVISION.

Letters, postal cards and circulars distributed,

including drop letters, circulars, 2nd and 3rd class matter

Total number recd. and handled by Gen. Del. Section

Total number recd. and handled by Directory Section

Special delivery letters received



30,366;081


205,190.


185,996



129,471,510


874,866


793,029

165,504

REGISTRY DIVISION.

Letters and parcels reg. with fee prepaid Official letters and parcels registered free Registered letters and parcels recd. for deliv Desk deliveries of reg. letters and parcels Carrier deliveries of reg. letters and parcels Reg. letters and parcels handled in transit

35,336

2,289

114,761

56,540

45,232

137,549

263,591

42,817

334,758

101,479

216,988

562,816

Total of registry items designated

391,707

1,522,449


Vol. II-9.


130 - CINCINNATI—THE QUEEN CITY


CASHIER'S DIVISION.

Postal receipts  

Receipts from depositing postmasters 

Salaries paid rural carriers, Ohio

$ 610,268.60

$2,298,581.71

3,570,925.01

2,298,227.00

MONEY ORDER DIVISION

Domestic orders issued  

International orders issued  

Received from depositing postmasters 

Domestic orders paid  

International orders paid  

Postal Card Subagency

$ 495,349.16

82,201.27

1,950,720.58

2,415,586.33

45,116.02

$ 688,329.53

162,715.40

3,604,078.04

4,455,435.12

67,776.95

$1,123,958.00




ROSTER OF CINCINNATI POSTOFFICE.


Elias R. Monfort, postmaster ; William C. Johnson, assistant postmaster ; Clyde B. McGrew, superintendent of delivery ; William D. Baker, superintendent money order division ; Alfred A. Tucker, cashier ; John H. Meyer, Frank N. Beatty, assistant superintendents delivery division ; William H. Eggleston, assistant superintendent money order division ; Septimus G. Sullivan, superintendent of mails ; George Reiter, superintendent registry division ; Edward Weimer, superintendent postal card sub-agency ; Robert P. Kelly, Fred Raine, assistant superintendents mailing division ; John Mitchell, assistant superintendent registry division ;Albert E. Diederich, secretary to postmaster.


SUPERINTENDENTS OF POSTOFFICE STATIONS.


Station A :—William H. Davis.

Station B :—Henry Smith.

Station C :—William Feemster.

Station D :—Augustus E. Irwin. 

Station. E :—George F. Seilacker.

Station F :—Frank Birkemeyer.

Station G :—Edith S. Whiteman.

Station I :—John P. Brunst.

Station L :—john F. Graichen.

Station N :—.–Frank E. Brown.

Winton Place Station :—Carlton W. Paris.

Norwood Branch :—Eli B. Brown.

College Hill Branch :—Anna E. Deininger.

Madisonville Branch :—Albert E. Klein.

Elmwood Place Branch :—Alfaretta Gaskill.

Station O :—Elmer E. Chambers.

Station S :—James Muller.

Station V :—Harry Schoep fel.

Lockland Branch :—Clarence H. Ashar.

Pleasant Ridge Branch :—Oliver W. Wood.


CINCINNATI—THE QUEEN CITY - 131


A great step forward in the postoffice arrangements is just now being made by the introduction of the mail tube system. Orders reached Postmaster Monfort some time ago directing him to invite bids for the installation of the pneumatic mail tube system and its operation for a period of four years. He acted upon his instructions. The tubes are to be at least thirty inches in diameter, affording space for the running of a car six feet long and twenty-four inches inside diameter. There is to be a double line of tubes between the postoffice and the depot. It is believed the tube transmission will be a great improvement in the rapid handling of the city's mail and the saving of time in the matter of earlier deliveries. The appropriation made by congress in 1911 for the tubes in this and other cities is $509,009. Postmaster Monfort is much pleased with the prospect, the arrangement being that which he and the business bodies of the city have spent much time in working for. A preliminary condition to the four-year contract is that the tubes shall be operated as an experiment for the first six months without expense to the government, satisfactory service then entitling the tube company to the four-year contract. The compensation is limited to not more than $17,000 per mile a year.


CHAPTER XI.


BENCH AND BAR.


DESCRIPTION OF THE COUNTY'S FIVE COURTHOUSES-FIRST COURTS AND JUDGES--RIDING THE CIRCUIT-PIONEER LAWYERS OF GREAT ABILITY-JUDGE JACOB BURNET, BELLAMY STORER, CHARLES HAM MOND--NOTED CASES-SALMON P. CHASE-JUDGE GEORGE HOADLEY-ALFONSO TAFT-WILLIAM H. TAFT-STANLEY MATTHEWS-AARON F. PERRY-GEORGE E. PUGH-RUFUS KING-WILLIAM HAINES LYTLE-WILLIAM S. GROESBECK-GEORGE H. PENDLETON-JOSEPH B. FORAKER-JUDSON HARMON AND MANY OTHERS-THE COURTS-LAW LIBRARY-LAW SCHOOL OF CINCINNATI-BAR ASSOCIATION-THE BAR OF TODAY.


BY HIRAM D. PECK.


One difficulty connected with the writing of a history of the bar of Cincinnati, or any other place, arises out of the fact that it is an unorganized body. The bar is not a corporation and has no organic unity, nor has it officers or agents authorized to speak for it, but is simply a number of individuals engaged in the same occupation, each for himself, although all are governed by certain rules and regulations which bring them into close contact and give them. something of the appearance of an organized body. These facts necessarily render the history of the bar of any particular locality mainly a series of biographies, and the changes in the body, from time to time, consist only in the alteration of its personnel.


It may be well at the outset, to describe the places where the work of the bar has been mostly done, viz., the courthouses of Hamilton county, of which five have been constructed and used for that purpose, although two or three buildings erected for other purposes were temporarily occupied as courthouses when there was no other to be had.


The first building used for the administration of justice in Hamilton county, appears to have been erected about the same year that the county was organized, viz., in 1790, on the south side of Fifth street, at Or near the west side of Main. We have few accounts of that building, which was probably constructed of logs, as we are told that all of the buildings in Cincinnati at that date were of that material, but there is no doubt that there was such a building and that it was accompanied by a whipping post placed in front of it, to the terror of evil doers, and that there were frog ponds in the vicinity from which the noise of the frogs was so loud and continuous as at times to constitute an obstruction to the administration of justice.


This building was succeeded by another in the year 1802,—which was also noted as being the year in which Cincinnati was first granted a municipal charter, —erected on the same site, and is said to have been a substantial stone structure


- 133 -


134 - CINCINNATI—THE QUEEN CITY


with a wooden cupola, the top of which was some eighty feet from the ground, a matter of much pride to the inhabitants of the incipient city. This courthouse was occupied for the purpose for which it was constructed until some time during the war of 1812. While that struggle was in progress it was used as a barrack for soldiers, and a number of them were quartered in it. In the year 1814 it took fire and was completely destroyed. The fire was said to have been occasioned by the carelessness of some of the soldiers who were engaged in a game of cards in the building.


Soon after that, a public spirited citizen, Jesse Hunt, one of the ancestors of the Pendleton and other distinguished families of the city, donated a lot at the corner of Court and Main streets for the purposes of a courthouse and a jail, which were subsequently built on it. This courthouse, which was known to the last generation of lawyers as "the old courthouse," was a building of some architectural pretensions- large, square, brick structure with a tall steeple, standing in the middle of the lot and surrounded by turf, shrubs and trees. It was doubtless a pleasant object to look at and is said to have been much admired by the citizens of Cincinnati when it was first completed, in the year 1819, and thereafter. A single courtroom of large size, and finished with what was termed elegance by the people of those days, extended the whole length of the building and was almost thirty feet in width. There was ample room for the court, jury, lawyers and spectators. The latter were separated from the others by a bar across the center of the room, in the rear of which were seats for witnesses and others attending court who were not members of the bar, a mode of constructing and arranging courtrooms then and perhaps still in general use throughout the country, and perhaps as good as has ever been devised, for it prevents that inter: mingling of bar, courtofficers and spectators, which necessarily happens in some of our small, modern courtrooms, to the confusion of business, and the production of disorder. At a later date, when what is known as the "old Superior Court of Cincinnati" was organized, a courtroom was finished in the second story of that courthouse, in which the superior court, then consisting of a single judge, transacted its business. At the corners of the lot separate buildings were erected on Main street, one north and the other south of the courthouse, for the county officers, such as the auditor, county commissioners, clerk, surveyor, etc. In the year 1819, when the courthouse was first erected, it was considered "out of town" because so far up Main street and there were no buildings very near it, but the business which it created in that neighborhood, and the growth of the city, soon brought about the upbuilding of Main street, and it was not long until the courthouse was fairly "in town." This courthouse existed until July, 1849, when it was completely destroyed by fire which originated in a neighboring building and was communicated to the courthouse. It is said that at the time of its destruction, the people of the city were contemplating the erection of a new building, as the old one had been found to be inadequate because of the growth of the city which had been very great during the preceding twenty years, the population having doubled itself during the decade from 1830 to 1840, and the numbers of that year were again doubled when the year 1850 was reached. More courtrooms were necessary, so that when the fire was communicated to the "old


CINCINNATI—THE QUEEN CITY - 135


courthouse" very little was done to extinguish it, and the fire department and people stood about and saw it burn, intending to replace it with a new one. The principal records were saved and the erection of a new courthouse was commenced soon after and completed about the year 1851. In the interval" courts were held in a neighboring pork-house.


The fourth courthouse was a fine stone structure with a handsome row of Corinthian columns in front, of the same size as the present courthouse, the walls of which are the walls which enclosed its predecessor, except the front which was removed and the present front substituted, mainly for the sake of securing the use of the space occupied by the colonnade. Many persons do not regard the present building as an improvement in appearance upon its predecessor, but rather the reverse. The courthouse of 1851 stood and was occupied for the administration of justice until the 29th of March, 1884, on the night of which a great riot occurred in Cincinnati, growing out of the indignation of certain citizens over the irregularities of the trial of persons accused of an outrageous murder. The building was set fire to, and before the police and military, who were summoned, could come to its rescue, a large part of it was destroyed. As good fortune would have it, the recorder's office, containing most of the real estate records of the county, was very little injured and few of the records in it were destroyed, but the records of the clerk's office and the probate court were mainly destroyed, although the original wills on file in the probate court were all saved because they were stored in a fireproof vault, and it was only necessary to copy them to restore that portion of the records. A special act of the general assembly was passed under which the records of many of the litigated cases involving the titles to real estate were restored by proceedings had in court for that purpose.


In the interval between the burning of the courthouse and the construction of another, court was held in the Albany building, situated on the east side of Vine street between Third and Fourth streets, and now occupied by the Bell Telephone company.


The erection of a new building was promptly commenced under a commission authorized by an act of the general assembly, and the present courthouse of Cincinnati was speedily constructed and first occupied in the year 1886. It is a substantial structure and pains were taken to make it as nearly fireproof as possible, for its three predecessors were destroyed by fire and the people of Cincinnati are not willing to lose another such building in that way.


TERRITORIAL ERA.


* * * *


In the period between the first settlement at Cincinnati, in 1788-1789, and the formation of the state of Ohio in 1802-3, affairs in all departments of life were in a very crude condition. It was the earliest era of the pioneers, and during the first ten years of that period, the little settlements along the Ohio were continually harassed by Indian raids and depredations. Naturally the growth of the settlement under such circumstances was slow, and the population of Cincinnati in the year 1800 is said to have been only seven hundred and fifty. The bar, of course, was in much the same condition as other institutions of the infant settlement. At the beginning, in 1788, there was no organized government nor any courts, and the few settlers were exposed to the depredations of rude and



136 - CINCINNATI—THE QUEEN CITY


dishonest men without any means of legal redress. Judge Burnet, in his notes on the Northwest territory, makes the following statement, showing how the difficulty was dealt with. "The people assembled to consult and devise a plan for their common safety. They chose a chairman and a secretary and proceeded to business. The meeting resulted in the adoption of a code of bylaws for the government of the settlement, for which they prescribed a punishment to be inflicted for various offenses, organized a court, established trial by jury, appointed William McMillan, judge, and John Ludlow, sheriff, and to these regulations they all agreed and each gave. a solemn pledge to aid in carrying them into effect." It was not long before an offender was arrested for robbing a truck patch. He was arrested by the sheriff, tried and convicted by a jury, and sentenced to receive twenty-nine lashes, which were promptly inflicted. But it appears that the officer in command of the garrison at Fort Washington did not look with favorable eyes upon these volunteer proceedings, and a conflict arose between the citizens and the military, in the course of which the judge received serious injuries. This state of affairs was soon terminated by the establishment of a general court of quarter sessions, and a county court of common pleas, by virtue of a law for that purpose published at Marietta upon the 23rd day of August, 1788. William McMillan was appointed presiding judge of these courts in the county of Hamilton."


The promptness and precision with which these pioneer citizens organized their little government and carried on their judicial proceedings, is another indication, in addition to those often pointed out, as to how deeply the genius of law and order is implanted in the Anglo-Saxon race. Within less than twelve months after the first settlement was made, in what up to that time had been an unbroken wilderness, there were orderly judicial proceedings voluntarily instituted by the people, and the old institution, always dear to English speaking people, of trial by jury, promptly makes its appearance. From the time of the regular establishment of the courts under the act, judicial proceedings were regularly had in the county, and there were judges and members of the bar whose duty it was to attend to such matters. What is now the State of Ohio, at that time constituted a part of the territory "northwest of the river Ohio," as denominated in the laws of congress, which consisted of what is now four or five states of the Union, including Ohio, Indiana, Illinois and Michigan, all of which were governed by the famous ordinance of congress passed in the year 1789. Under the provisions of the ordinance, there was a general court for the territory, consisting of three judges appointed by the president. It was the highest court of the territory, invested with original and appellate jurisdiction in all civil and criminal cases, but without chancery powers. It had the power to revise and reverse the decisions of other tribunals in the territory. It was held in Cincinnati in March of each year, at Marietta in October, and at Detroit and the western counties at such time in each year as the judges saw proper to designate. These places were separated by tracts of uninhabited wilderness, one hundred and fifty to two hundred miles in extent, without roads, bridges or ferries, yet it is stated that from the year 1796 to the formation of the state government in 1803, the judges of the court never missed a term at either place, though they were compelled to travel those long distances on horseback through


CINCINNATI—THE QUEEN CITY - 137




the wilderness, carrying with them such things as were necessary totheir support en route, and frequently passing through Indian villages and meeting wandering parties of Indians. One of their greatest difficulties in traveling was the crossing of streams at which there was neither a bridge nor a ford, so that, as Judge Burnet puts it, travelers had to rely upon their horses as the only substitutes for these conveniences. That fact made it common, when purchasing a horse, to ask whether he was a good swimmer, which was considered one of the most valuable qualities of the saddle horse. As late as 1801, Judge Burnet, upon his return from Marietta, found it necessary to swim various streams, among them the Whiteoak and the east fork of the Little Miami near Williamsburg, and again the same stream near where the town of Batavia now stands, and afterwards at Turpin's Bottom. Many similar stories of adventure are told in connection with the travels of these early judges and lawyers. The hardships which they voluntarily underwent, exhibit a devotion to duty for which it would be hard to find a parllel among modern judiciary.


Through the mist which obscures the view of those early times, the outlines of two or three prominent figures are visible. The earliest of these is William McMillan, by nature and training apparently well qualified to take the lead, in a pioneer community. He was born in Virginia, was graduated from William and Mary College, and had been admitted to the bar. He was a man of clear perceptions and strong reasoning powers, and his professional position was always among the leaders. To these qualities may be added those of determination, fearlessness and persistence, which were requisite in the somewhat turbulent community just coming into existence. He was one of the Denman party who stepped ashore at Yeatman's Cove, near the foot of Sycamore street, on that December day in 1788, which is usually regarded as the natal day of Cincinnati, and he immediately became the leader of the little colony in matters pertaining to law and government. As mentioned above, he was chosen by the people as their first judge and acted as such until a regular government was organized in the territory, and he was then appointed to the same position by lawful authority. Judge Burnet says of him : "He posssessed an intellect of a high order and had acquired a fund of information, general as well as professional, which qualified him for great usefulness in the early legislature of the territory." The late William M. Corry, a nephew of William McMillan. a gentleman himself well qualified to judge, and who did not bestow eulogy indiscriminately, in a public address' says of him : "During his professional career there was no higher man at the western bar than William McMillan. Its accomplished ranks would have done honor to older countries, but it did not contain his superior. Some of our distinguished lawyers of that day were admirable public speakers. He was not. Some of them were able in the comprehension of the law, and some were skillful to a proverb in their management. Of these he ranked among the first. His opinions had all the respectability of learning, precision and strength. They commanded acquiescence and they challenged opposition, when to obtain assent was difficult and to provoke hostility was dangerous." William McMillan, subsequently, in the year 1799, became the leader of the first delegation from Hamilton county to the territorial legislature, and still later was a representative in congress, the duties of which positions he performed with


138 - CINCINNATI—THE QUEEN CITY


great ability and success. He became a large land holder in and about Cincinnati, and is said to have laid out the prominent street in the suburbs which bears his name.


The next, and a still more important figure to make its appearance in that era, is a slender, erect, dark-eyed, military figure, which appeared as commandant at Fort Washington after the conclusion of General Wayne's campaign in the northwest. It was then that Captain William Henry Harrison was put in command of the force at Fort Washington, where he remained for some time, and from that time forward played a great part in the history of Cincinnati, the Northwest Territory and the State of Ohio. A few years afterward he became secretary of the Northwest Territory. He was a member of the General Assembly, a representative in 'congress, a member of the senate of the United States from Ohio, commanding general of the troops of the Northwest Territory, and finally conqueror of the Indians, and had the honor and glory of forever putting an end to the Indian raids and disturbances which had been going on in the territory for nearly a generation. Strangely enough, after these great public services, he served a number of years as clerk of the court of common pleas of Hamilton county. The explanation of that fact is to be found in the circumstance that he had fallen into financial trouble and it was necessary that he should be in a position to better his circumstances and maintain his family, with which he was residing at North Bend, the old home of John Cleves Symmes, the original purchaser of the lands between the two Miamis. General Harrison had married Judge Symmes' daughter, and brought up his family at North Bend. A number of his friends, becoming aware of . his straightened circumstances, secured his consent to accept the position of clerk of the court of common pleas, then the most lucrative office in the county, and the judges of the court, who then had power to do so, were prevailed upon to appoint him. His subsequent election as president of the United States and early death thereafter, are matters of national history.


Another figure which made itself apparent in Cincinnati at a very early date was that of Jacob Burnet, then a very young man. He was the son of Dr. William Burnet, a surgeon general of the United States army during the Revolutionary war, residing in Newark, New Jersey. The exact date of Jacob Burnet's appearance in this vicinity does not appear, but in the introduction to his notes on the Northwestern Territory, he speaks of himself as having been subject to an attack of malarial, fever and lying ill at Yeatman's Tavern, then the principal inn, in the year 1796. He was a graduate of Princeton College, a man of great energy and ability, and very soon made himself felt in the new settlement. He was a member of the first legislative council of the territory and took a large part in its deliberations. He soon became prominent at the bar and was very active in the practice, riding the circuit with the court for great distances through the forest and under circumstances of peculiar hardship. He subsequently occupied vaxrious public offices, in all of which he rendered distinguished service, one of them being that of a judge of the supreme court of Ohio. A number of his opinions may be found in the earliest volumes of Ohio reports. He was also a member of the United States Senate from Ohio, and becoming a man of wealth, he for a long time occupied a very prominent position. During the first half


CINCINNATI—THE QUEEN CITY - 139


century of the existence of the city, he was generally looked upon as the first citizen. His spacious mansion at the corner of Seventh and Elm streets was a center of hospitality, where distinguished visitors coming to the city were entertained, among others, Lafayette, President John Quincy Adams, Daniel Webster, Henry Clay and President William Henry Harrison dined at his board. It is notable that he refused to entertain Aaron Burr when that celebrity was in Cincinnati, because of the part that Burr had taken in the duel with Hamilton, saying that he regarded Burr as a murderer.


Illustrative of the difficulties of the practice of law in the Northwestern Territory at that early date, is an account given by Judge Burnet of a trip made by himself, Mr. St. Clair and a Mr. Morrison, from Cincinnati to Vincennes, on professional business.


"They purchased a small Kentucky boat, sometimes called an ark, in which they embarked with their horses, provisions, etc. In the afternoon of the fourth day they arrived at the Falls of the Ohio (Louisville), where they left their boat, mounted their horses and proceeded on their journey. About nine o'clock in the evening they discovered, at a little distance from the path they were traveling, a camp of four or five Indians, which they approached. After having shaken hands with them, they procured a brand of fire, and proceeded some distance further on their way, and then halted for the night. Having brushed away the snow from the spot they had selected for their camp and collected a good supply of wood for the night, they kindled a fire, took some refreshment, wrapped themselves in their blankets, and laid down to sleep.


"The next night they encamped in a rich valley, where they found an abundance of fallen timber, which enabled them to keep up a large fire through the night, before which they slept very comfortably till morning. During the night, a couple of panthers, attracted by the light of the fire, approached sufficiently near the camp to serenade them with their unwelcome music—but kept at a respectful distance. The next day, they encountered a severe snow-storm, during which they surprised eight or ten buffalo, sheltering themselves from the storm, behind the top of a beech tree, full of dead leaves, which had fallen by the side of the "trace," and hid the travelers from their view. The tree and the noise of the wind among its leaves, prey ented them from discovering the party, till they had approached within two rods of the place where they stood. They then took to their heels, and were soon out of sight. One of the company drew a pistol and fired, but without any visible effect.


That evening they reached White river, where they found an old cabin deserted by its builder, in which a large wild cat had taken shelter, and seemed disposed, at first, to vindicate his right of possession. He was, however, soon ejected, and the travelers entered and occupied the premises without molestation, during the night, and without attempting to do personal violence or injury to the tenant they had dispossessed. The next morning they arrived at Post Vincennes, where they tarried about a week. In the meantime Mr. Morrison proceeded westward. As soon as Messrs. S. and B. had closed their business, they set out for home, having abandoned the idea of engaging in the practice of law in that county, from a conviction that the profits of the business would not he an ade-


140 - CINCINNATI—THE QUEEN CITY


quate compensation for the fatigue and loss of time to which it would subject them."


In his later years Judge Burnet was persuaded to publish a volume of reminiscenes, which he did under the title of "Notes on the early settlement of the Northwestern Territory." It is not too much to say that the volume is invaluable, for without it the early history of Ohio would lack many an interesting and illustrative fact which it contains. It was published at Cincinnati by Derby, Bradley & Company in 1847. It will always remain a principal source of information for those who wish to delve into the history of that era. He is thus described by one who knew him in his old age: "Until his death in 1853, Judge Burnet was one of the most notable figures on the streets of Cincinnati. Tall and dignified in appearance, he retained the style and Manners of the olden time. He wore the old-fashioned queue, and in public assemblies his grave, stately deportment inspired, if not awe, at least respect. In his opinions and judgments he was decided. He did not believe in anything half way, nor did he hesitate to state his views when occasion required, and they were so stated as to be completely understood."


The most important event in the first decade after the settlement at Cincinnati was the campaign of General Wayne against the Indians of the northwest, in the years 1793-1795 ; ending with the total defeat of the Indians and the peace at Greenville, which for some years afterwards put an end to Indian wars throughout the northwest. The treaty of Greenville made a great impression throughout the country generally, and emigrants began to flock into the new territory in great numbers. It was said, in the rather grandiloquent language of the time, "to have opened the glorious gates of the Ohio to civilization." The population of the territory increased so rapidly that by the year 1802 it was deemed to be sufficient to authorize the creation of a new state, and steps were taken to that end. Bills were introduced into the territorial legislature looking to the division of the territory so that the eastern part of it would be bounded on the west by the Scioto river up to the Indian boundary, thence by a line to the western corner of the Connecticut Reserve, and with it to the Lake ; the middle state of the territory to extend along the Ohio from the Scioto river to the falls of the Ohio, and its western boundary to be a line from there to the Chicago river ; the western state to occupy the country between that line and the Mississippi. The bill was promptly passed by the legislature, but was soon found to be very unpopular. Many reasonable objections were made to it, and Congress rejected the scheme. By a large majority, an act of Congress was passed upon April 3o, 30,2, authorizing a convention of delegates to be elected in September by the votes of that part of the Northwestern Territory bounded on the east by Pennsylvania, south by the Ohio river, west by a line drawn from the mouth of the Great iMiaMiami north to an east and west line passing through the southern extremity of Lake Michigan, and by this line and the Canada line through Lake Erie to the west line of Pennsylvania. This last boundary, the northern one of the state, was afterwards corrected so as to fix the line between Ohio and-Michigan as it now is. Although there was a good deal of opposition, an election was held and delegates to the convention chosen. When the convention assembled, by a vote of thirty-four to one, it was determined to form a constitution and a state government. It was further ordained that an election for governor and members of the legislature, sheriffs and coroners, under the constitution, should


CINCINNATI `THE QUEEN CITY - 141


be held January 11, 1803, and that the legislature should commence its first session on the first of March at Chillicothe, as the capitol. On the 19th day of February, 1803, an act of Congress was passed reciting that a constitution and state government had been formed by the people, pursuant to the Enabling Act passed by Congress, that they had given it the name of the "State of Ohio," and that it was ordained that it be established as a judicial district of the United States ; that a district court be organized and hold its term on the first Monday in June at Chillicothe, and that the laws of the United States should be of the same force and effect in the said state as elsewhere in the United States. This was the first act passed by Congress recognizing the existence of the state of Ohio, and yet there was no state government in existence until after elections were held upon January 11th, and the general assembly met at Chillicothe on the first of March, when Edward Tiffin was declared elected governor. There has been a good deal of dispute as to the date when Ohio was admitted to the Union, but the better view appears to be that the true date was March 1, 1803, at the time of the original organization of the state government, for up to that time there certainly was no state government in existence, but a territorial organization, and that date was recognized by the executive officers of the government of the United States by fixing March 1, 1803, as the date up to which the salaries of the territorial officers should be allowed and paid. It is a curious fact that the organization of Cincinnati into a municipality occurred slightly before the admission of Ohio as a state, the Territorial Legislature having passed an act for that purpose in the year 18o2, and that the county of Hamilton was created before either, as it was organized by an order of Governor St. Clair in the year 1790.


The growth of the city proceeded steadily after the admission of the state of Ohio into the Union, although it was more or less interrupted by some exciting events, the first of which was the Aaron Burr expedition, which passed down the Ohio in the year 1806. The leader of it, Burr, stopped at Cincinnati and was received with a good deal of hurrah. His schemes were misunderstood and magnified until they had come to be something tremendous in the eyes of the people. When the real proportions of the enterprise became known, it was regarded as ludicrous and was made the subject of a good many jokes. The governor of Mississippi arrested Burr in January, 1807, and reported to the president, Mr. Jefferson, as follows : "This mighty alarm, with all its exaggerations, has eventuated in nine boats and one hundred men ; and the majority of these are boys and young men just from school." Burr's acquittal of the charge of treason after a long trial, is a matter of history. John Smith of Cincinnati, a member of the United States senate from Ohio, was expelled on the charge of being an accomplice of Burr. The prosecutor of the charge against him was John Quincy Adams.


Next in time after the Burr conspiracy, but much greater in proportion, was the War of 1812, between the United States and Great Britain, which was a matter of prime importance to the people of Ohio, because a large part of the actual fighting occurred in or near the boundaries of the state. Cooperating with the British, Tecumseh undertook to revive and extend the great Indian confederation, with the object of driving the whites out of Ohio and the neighboring territory and extending the Canadian boundary to the Ohio river. Na-


142 - CINCINNATI—THE QUEEN CITY


turally these were very alarming propositions to the people of Ohio, and they rose against them with great courage and determination. At first the fighting seemed to favor the British and the Indians, but later William Henry Harrison, having been put into supreme command, gathered together his forces including a large body of volunteers from Kentucky under the lead of Governor Shelby, and made his famous campaign through the northwest, ending with the decisive battle of the Thames and the death of Tecumseh. About the same time, Commodore Perry achieved his great victory over the British fleet on Lake Erie near Put-inBay and within the boundaries of the state of Ohio: These events, together with the Jackson victory at New Orleans, wound up the war in a blaze of glory, although so far as the original controversy with England was concerned, very little was gained by it, yet the people of Ohio were the gainers by the final and complete determination of all their troubles from the Indians, and the possession of the northwestern forts and territory by the whites.


During all this period a considerable stream of emigration had been pouring into Ohio, and cities and towns were rapidly increasing in population and others were springing up. The bar of Cincinnati naturally grew and increased with the growth of the state and city, and became a body for which the people had great respect, and, judged by its personnel and its achievement, it was entitled to it. When the courthouse which was destroyed by fire, as above stated, in 1814, was rebuilt at the corner of Main and Court streets and finished in the year 1819, the bar of Hamilton county consisted of twenty-seven members, and there were among them an unusually large percentage of men of much more than ordinary standing and prominence. The names of Jacob Burnet, William Henry Harrison, William Corry, Nathaniel Wright, Nicholas Longworth and Nathaniel G. Pendleton were known far beyond the boundaries of Ohio. There were others perhaps entitled to rank with these, whose names might be mentioned, but it is not the purpose of this article to exhibit a catalogue of members of the bar, but only to mention such as became very prominent or made a deep impression upon the legal or judicial history of the state. In addition to those above mentioned, there were two young men who made their advent in Cincinnati about that time who afterwards became famous by reason of their professional and personal qualities and their conduct on great occasions. They were Charles Hammond and Bellamy Storer.


It has been said of Ohio, that after its admission to the Union, "the next thirty years of life in the state may be summarized as a long struggle of the pioneers with the forest and bad roads." They were literally "getting out of the woods." The times were very hard. There was little private capital and no public accumulations out of which roads or other public improvements could be constructed. The houses were mainly constructed of logs, and even public buildings were of that material. The state house at Chillicothe, where the first constitution of Ohio was drawn up and adopted, is said to have been built of hewn logs, two stories in height, and was thirty-six feet by twenty-four feet in size. "The millions who are dwelling in peace and plenty in the broad farms and busy towns of Ohio today, can get no realizing sense by mere words, of the hardships by which their prosperity was earned. The toilsome journey, the steep mountain ways, the camping out where there were no inns, and hardly a road to guide them, were as


CINCINNATI—THE QUEEN CITY - 143


nothing to the dreariness which, at the journey's end, confronted the emigrant, his wife and children. The unbroken forest was all that welcomed them. The awful stillness of the night had no refrain but the howl of the wolf and the wail of the whip-poor-will. The nearest neighbor often was miles away." These conditions were gradually ameliorated, but the progress was necessarily slow. Roads were opened, farms cultivated, and houses constructed.


One of the great difficulties with which these early people had to contend, was the want of money, of which there was very little. Business was chiefly conducted by barter. An illustration of the want of money, is the fact that Mexican dollars, of which a number came up from the southwest, were cut into quarters and in that way circulated as small change. Institutions called banks sprang up in the towns and were incorporated under acts of the legislature. Nearly all of these were authorized to issue paper money, consisting of the written promises of the bank to pay a specified number of dollars upon demand. As the security for the payment was often small and the conduct of the business was anything but conservative, a great deal of trouble and litigation necessarily grew out of these conditions. If the early history of Ohio on the subject of "wild cat" banking could be fully written, it would furnish a very instructive financial lesson. Gradually, however, there grew up a few strong and solvent concerns, but these were surrounded by a multitude of petty institutions of a very different sort. In the year 1817, the government of the United States established two branches of the United States Bank in Ohio, one located at Chillicothe with a capital of $500,000.00, and the other at Cincinnati with a capital of $1,500,000.00. This immediately created great excitement throughout the state. All those interested in local banking were intensely hostile to the federal institutions, and many others, for various reasons, economic and political, were violently opposed to them. The same objections to the United States Bank which prevailed in other parts of the country, were strongly urged in Ohio and very much aggravated by local conditions. It was publicly stated, and doubtless believed by many prominent persons, that "the object of the United States Bank was to destroy the country banks, drain the country of specie, oppress the public and endanger the liberties of the people."


The local banks had been issuing paper currency without limit, and no sort of control had been exercised over them. The natural result was that they soon became unable to redeem their currency and there was a general suspension of specie payment. Congress passed an act requiring the resumption of specie payments in 1817, which they were totally unable to do, and the act was claimed to be a great hardship, for which, in the minds of the people, the United States Bank was largely responsible.


"When the legislature assembled in 1819, acting under the leadership of such men as William Henry Harrison and Charles Hammond, an act was passed entitled : "An act to levy and collect a tax from all banks, and individuals, and companies, and associations of individuals, that may transact banking business in this state without being allowed to do so by the laws thereof." The act recited that the Bank of the United States pursued its operations contrary to the laws of the state, and provided that if after the first day of the following September, the said bank or any other should continue to transact business in the state, it


144 - CINCINNATI—THE QUEEN CITY


should be liable to an annual tax of fifty thousand dollars upon each office of discount and deposit, and further provided for the summary collection of the same by the state auditor, by demand and levy, with authority to go into every room, vault, etc., and to open every chest, etc., in search of what might satisfy the claim. The bank declined to pay the tax or to leave the state, and thereupon, Ralph Osborn, auditor of state, in the following September issued his warrant and levied upon the branch bank at Chillicothe for the sum of one hundred thousand dollars, the payment of which being refused, the agents of the auditor took it by force from the vaults of the bank and carried it up to the capital at Columbus and delivered it to the state treasurer. These high-handed proceedings led to a great litigation. The bank filed a bill in the United States Circuit Court of Ohio to enjoin the proceedings of the auditor and recover its money. The case was heard in the circuit court, which rendered judgment for the bank and directed the restoration of the one hundred thousand dollars. The case was then carried to the supreme court of the United States, where it was argued before Chief justice Marshall and a full bench by a great array of counsel. At the head of these, on the part of the state of Ohio, was Charles Hammond, who was associated with and assisted by Nathaniel Wright. The bank was represented by Henry Clay, Daniel Webster, Mr. Sergeant of Pennsylvania, and others. The argument of Mr. Hammond was subtle and powerful to a degree. In deference to its force the great chief justice, in deciding the case, reviewed and restated the grounds of the decision of the court in the famous preceding case of McCulloch vs. Maryland. The principal point was whether the United States Bank was subject to taxation by state authorities. Mr. Hammond, in arguing the affirmative of that question, said it depended upon the nature and character of the institution. "If it stands upon the same foundation with the mint and postoffice, if its business character justly be assimilated to the process and proceedings of the federal courts, we admit without hesitation that it is entitled to the exemption it claims. The state cannot tax the official establishments and operations of the national government. Banking is in its nature a private trade, and is a business in which individuals may at all times engage, unless the municipal law forbids it. Wherever this is not the case, it is competent for individuals to contract together and create capital to be employed in lending money and buying and selling coins, . . . promissory notes and bills of exchange. No law is necessary to authorize a contract between individuals for concentrating capital to be thus employed, nor does the business itself depend upon any special laws for its creation or existence. He further argues that the incorporation of such a body engaged in the banking business does not change its condition, "but only enables it to manage its own affairs and hold property without the perplexing intricacies—the hazardous and endless necessity of perpetual conveyances for the purposes of transmitting it from hand to hand. It is chiefly for the purpose of clothing bodies of men in these qualities and capacities that Forporations were invented and are in use." From these premises he argued that such an institution was necessarily subject to taxation by the state, as any other business conducted by individuals would be. Mr. Hammond further contended that the real defendant of the action was the state of Ohio and not the auditor, against whom the bill


CINCINNATI—THE QUEEN CITY - 145


was filed, and that under the provisions of the eleventh amendment to the constitution, no such action could be maintained against the state.


Chief justice Marshall, in deciding the case, recognized the force of Hammond's argument, but pointed out that while the mere business of banking is in its own nature a private business and may be carried on by individuals or companies having ho political connection with the government, the United States Bank was not such an individual or company ; that it was not created for its own sake or for private purposes, but for the purpose of carrying into effect the powers vested in the government of the United States, and that while it might carry on the business of private banking in connection with its operations as an agent of the government, the two were inseparably connected, and the private banking might be and was a valuable adjunct and assistance in carrying out the operations which were deemed by the government as useful and necessary for the whole people, and that therefore the two parts of its business, private and public, could not be separated, and for that reason it was all necessarily exempt from taxation.


The statement of the foregoing case has been included for the purpose of showing that while the litigation in pioneer times mainly involved small matters and local questions, yet there were occasions when great questions arose, and such occasions always found lawyers quite competent to deal with them,


Charles Hammond was in many respects a remarkable man. During nearly all the time of his practice of the law, he was also connected with a newspaper. The Liberty Hall and Cincinnati Gazette of which he soon became chief editorial writer, and for which he later abandoned his practice at the bar and became famous as a political leader and writer, though he always declined public office. Among other positions which he declined to accept, was that of a justice of the Supreme court of the United States, which was at one time tendered him by President J. Q. Adams. He was famous as a leader of the Whig party, and still later as an anti-slavery writer. We have seen that in the beginning of his career he had distinguished himself as an advocate of the extreme view of state rights, a position which he took in common with Harrison and others, who afterwards became famous as leaders of the Whig party, which was not distinguished as an instrumentality for the promotion of state's rights. Their action in connection with the bank case goes to show to what extremes people may be carried in times of great popular excitement. The intense feeling against the "United States Bank at that time made them leaders in what was essentially an act of attempted nullification. At the time of his death, there was probably no more famous editor in the western states than Charles Hammond. As showing his versatility of talent it may also be stated that he has left behind him some very readable verses, sufficient to give countenance to the claim that he was a poet.


In addition to the other duties performed by him, Mr. Hammond acted as reporter for the Supreme court of Ohio. The first eight volumes of the reports of that court were compiled by him.


From the time of the construction of the courthouse in 1819, and for may years thereafter, the growth of the city and county were very rapid, the population and wealth of both constantly increasing. The bar grew in proportion. The membership increased to thirty-nine in 1825, and in 1831 was fifty-seven. Among the distinguished names added to the list during that period are those of Salmon


Vol. II-10


146 - CINCINNATI—THE QUEEN CITY


P. Chase, Vachel Worthington and Timothy Walker, all of whom continued to practice in Cincinnati for many years afterwards, and greatly distinguished themselves.


Mr. Chase was a man of large and commanding proportions, cool, careful and deliberate in speech and action, of untiring industry and very great ambition. He was the first compiler of the general laws of Ohio, and "Chase's statutes" still continue to be the standard and only compilation of that sort for the period covered by them, namely from the foundation of the state government down to about the year 1840. Mr. Chase took an active part in politics, at first in connection with the democratic party, and was elected governor of Ohio and afterwards to the United States senate. He was one of the earliest of the prominent men of the country to take a decided position antagonistic to slavery, and became known throughout the country as a strong anti-slavery leader.


He was always the friend and defender of the negro fugitives from slavery who found their way to Cincinnati. On the occasion of the removal of Mr. Chase's remains from Washington and their interment in Spring Grove cemetery, the late Governor Hoadly delivered an address in which lie says of Mr. Chase : "His legal services were freely bestowed in the protection of every fugitive slave and the defense of his friends. He was a walking arsenal of the law of liberty. What he could not do with the writ of habeas corpus, no man might accomplish. His weapons were ever ready for instant service. They required no burnishing, no loading, and with or without preparation they were always at hand for use. This office he never refused ; this duty he never neglected."


When the republican party was founded, he cast in his fortune with it, and so continued until after the Civil war, when he returned to the Democratic party. At the republican national convention in 1860, he was strongly supported for the nomination for the presidency and received the votes of a majority of the Ohio delegation, but was defeated by Abraham Lincoln, who showed his magnanimity and judgment of men by appointing Mr. Chase as secretary of the treasury in his cabinet, an office for which Chase was peculiarly fitted by reason of his long experience with the banking laws of Ohio and the difficulties which had been encountered in the state in establishing a satisfactory system of banking, but which was finally accomplished. He greatly distinguished himself as secretary of the treasury by providing the necessary funds for the conduct of the Civil war, an enormous undertaking, and the foundation of the system of national banks, the original act for which was drawn by him and still exists, with very little change, and under which all such banks are organized and now operate. Later, in the year 1864, he was appointed by President Lincoln, chief justice of the supreme court of the United States, which position he held until the time of his death, and the duties of which he discharged with great ability and success, but it is well known that he was never quite satisfied with the position and was always ambitious to become president. He received support in the democratic convention of 1868, and although the vote he received was very small, the circumstances were such that it was believed that a large portion of the convention was ready to go to his support in case of a favorable opportunity, which never came. Horatio Seymour of New York received the nomination, and was subsequently defeated by General Grant.


CINCINNATI—THE QUEEN CITY - 147


One of the cases decided by Mr. Chase as Chief Justice, was that of Hepburn vs. Griswold, in which it was held by him, with the concurrence of a majority of the court, that the legal tender feature of the law authorizing the issue of "green back" currency, was unconstitutional and invalid as to preexisting indebtedness. Mr. Chase was charged with inconsistency in so deciding, because that currency had been issued while he held the office of secretary of the treasury and, it was claimed, upon his initiative. The answer of his friends to this charge was that the issue of that currency was during the Civil war and while the government was grasping at any and all means to raise money for the prosecution of the war, and that if Mr. Chase had assented to its original issue, it was due to the stress of the times and circumstances, and that his decision in the supreme court represented his real opinions on the subject. The judgment in Hepburn vs. Griswold was afterwards reversed by the supreme court and the legal tender clause held to be valid in all respects, a proposition which has not by any means received the unanimous assent of the bar of the country, and which has been quite as sharply criticised as was Chase's original decision.


Another New England man of somewhat the same type, who made his appearance at the Cincinnati bar about the same time as Mr. Chase, was Timothy Walker. He devoted himself and almost his entire life to the practice of the law, not taking any great part in public affairs and holding but a single office for a short time, that of presiding judge of the Court of Common Pleas. He accumulated a large practice, and had the profound respect of the whole bar and the people of the city generally as a man of the highest character and finest attainments. In the year 1833, in conjunction with some others, he laid the foundation of the Cincinnati Law School, and for a number of years was the sole instructor in it. It was the first institution of its kind in any state west of the Alleghanies, and is now the oldest law school in the country except the Harvard. A little further along we shall have something more to say about this institution. Judge Walker continued on, devoted to the law and its practice, to the last. Among other things, he published a volume entitled "Walker's Introduction to American Law," which had a great circulation and has always been regarded as one of the best elementary works in existence stating the general principles of the law for the benefit of beginners.


Vachel Worthington, born in Kentucky in 1802 and graduated from the Transylvania University in 1822, settled in Cincinnati and began the practice of the law in 1824, and continued in the practice, with some minor interruptions, from that time until his death in 1877. He was in many ways a remarkable man. Clear, profound, incisive and of untiring industry, he was a model lawyer, and few, if any better, have ever practiced in Cincinnati. He was not an eloquent or an especially forcible speaker, but he greatly excelled in clear statement. He could state the facts in a complicated case in chancery so clearly and simply as to cause them to be understood by the least trained intellect. He was famous for the care and skill with which he prepared complicated legal documents. He wrote a round, smooth, clerkly hand, so that all his conveyances presented a pleasant appearance to the eye, for, according to the old practice, he nearly always wrote them with his own hand, and is said to have disdained the use of a printed form, as he could without form of any kind


148 - CINCINNATI—THE QUEEN CITY


write out on blank paper the most complicated instrument without blot or erasure. In court his cases were always thoroughly prepared, both as to law and fact. On one occasion he was presenting a somewhat complicated transaction to a judge of the court of common pleas, who was also a professor in the law school, and while Mr. Worthington was speaking, many of the students of the school were standing about the room listening to him and when he had concluded, the judge, for the moment forgetting his surroundings and apparently thinking he was in the law school, said, enthusiastically : "There, young gentlemen, that's the way to present a case to a court,"—and Worthington was as nearly a model in such matters as could be found. He took very little part in politics, but confined himself to the practice of his profession. His name appears in the printed reports of the supreme court of Ohio as early as 1827, and for the last time in 1875. He was attorney for the United States Bank and for the Ohio Life Insurance & Trust Company during their existence in Cincinnati. Some of the most famous lawyers of the bar of that city were trained in his office under his instruction, among them William S. Groesbeck, Stanley Matthews and Samuel S. Cox. Late in life he accepted a position for a term in the state senate, and there, as elsewhere, greatly distinguished himself by the industry and thoroughness with which he attended to his duties. He was the author of an act relating to the City of Cincinnati, which established what has since become a part of the policy of every political sub-division of the state, namely, the act requiring that before the city enter into any contract involving the expenditure of money, the money necessary to pay the contract price shall be in the city treasury and set apart for that purpose. It has been called "the pay as you go" plan, and obviously has a great tendency to prevent cities and villages from accumulating indebtedness. This law was originally known as the "Worthington Law." During the larger part of his life, Mr. Worthington practiced alone, but at one time he had for a partner one of his former students, Stanley Matthews.


The twenty years preceding the Civil war was a period of great growth and expansion in Cincinnati and the State of Ohio generally. The bar was a partaker of the general prosperity and increased in numbers and capacity as never before. The adoption of the new constitution in 1851, followed immediately by the passage of the Code of Civil Procedure and the first general codes of law relating to municipal and other corporations, opened a new era in the legal history of the state, and in Cincinnati the importance of these changes was greatly enhanced by the creation of the superior court and the election of the three famous 'judges who first occupied its bench. When that event occurred, and those judges first took their seats in general term, a body of counsellors and advocates appeared before them quite worthy of such a court. The list is too long to insert here, but it is sufficient to say that, taken as a whole, it constituted a body of lawyers not inferior to any then or since assembled at any local bar in our country.


In the front rank of those who were probably present at the opening of the new court in 1854 stood George Hoadly. Hit. term of office as judge of the old superior court, which had been created some twenty years before and consisted of a single judge, ended with the advent of the new regime, and although he was


CINCINNATI—THE QUEEN CITY - 149


the last official of the old, we may be sure that he heartily welcomed the new court. He was a young man not yet twenty-eight, although he had already served two or three years on the bench, of medium height, spare but not slender, and was notable for his intellectual countenance in which blazed two luminous eyes beneath a large dome-like forehead. His appearance plainly indicated his, character, at once energetic and reflective. Of New England origin, he had among his ancestors famous theologians and instructors. In early life his father had removed to Cleveland, and he received his education there at the Western Reserve, now Adelbert College, and afterwards at the Harvard Law School. Coming to Cincinnati, he entered the office of Salmon P. Chase, from which he was admitted to the bar in 1847. After the expiration of his term as judge of the former superior court, he remained at the bar for some five years, two of which he served in the office of the city solicitor. In 1859 he was elected a judge of the superior court, where he served out a full term with honor to himself and satisfaction to the bar and the public. Not many of his opinions have been reported, probably because there was no systematic reporting of the opinions of the superior court at that time. A few of them are to be found in the second volume of Disney's Reports and the legal periodicals of the day. They are marked by clearness, vigor and accuracy of judgment, and where occasion called for it, by a wide research of the authorities, and it is a matter of regret that more of them were not published. At the expiration of his term on the bench, Judge Hoadly resumed the practice of the law at the head of the firm of Hoadly, Jackson & Johnson, in connection with which he continued in active practice for nearly twenty years, during which time his practice, always large, was steadily growing and his reputation expanding. Not many, even of the best lawyers, have anything more than a local reputation. Any one may test this assertion by stopping to think how few of the lawyers of cities outside of his own state are known to him, and if he will exclude those who have become known to him by reason of prominence in politics, it is quite certain that he will find the number to be very small. judge Hoadly was an exception to the rule. He had a national reputation as a lawyer before he acquired a similar distinction in politics, and he deserved it. Our country has had few better all-around lawyers. At once profound and rapid, a great and continuous student of the law, amazingly industrious and broad-minded, with a ready wit and great facility of expression, he had a breezy quality of manner which compelled attention and pleased the hearer. He was famous for his quickness to take advantage of an opportunity or to avoid an attack. It was said of him that if he got a fall in the trial of a cause, he always managed to alight on his feet. He was equally at home before a jury or a court in banc. He was a wise and sympathetic counsellor, and his opinion and assistance out of court were in constant demand by those in control of the largest interests of the city, and in later years they came to him from distant states. He was always a welcome advocate to the supreme court, because he had a clear and forcible way of proceeding at once to the point of a case and stating his views so that they could not be mistaken or forgotten.

He had the confidence of all courts before which he appeared, because his sincerity in the presentation of a cause was as obvious as his ability. His fairness and generosity to opponents was one of the causes of his universal popularity