(RETURN TO THE MAHONING COUNTY INDEX)




200 - YOUNGSTOWN AND THE MAHONING VALLEY


township, but data regarding them are not now available, Mr. R. M. Kirk, great-grandson, not having been born in their life-time. Of his grandmother, Catherine (Ewing) Kirkpatrick, however, he is able to recall very much. Robert Kirkpatrick and his wife and family lived in Jackson Township for many years, during which he did much clearing of land. He built a substantial house of brick in about 1820 or 1821. Their son Isaac, who always used the full name Kirkpatrick, of the family, moved in early manhood to the farm where Rosemont Station now stands. He met Eliza McAnlis, in Eden Valley, Pennsylvania, and she became his wife. She had spent her girlhood in that place. She had been born in Ireland, and was only six years old when her parents came to America with her, the voyage taking six weeks. Soon after he had married Eliza McAnlis, Isaac Kirkpatrick and his brother Martin settled on the 400 acres purchased by their grandfather Kirk at a cost of $1.75 per acre. The brothers each cleared his own tract, Isaac's being situated about five miles from the old Kirkpatrick homestead; and in time each brother had a good agricultural holding. Martin's farm is still in possession of his son Gibson, and Isaac willed his farm to his children. He had brought it into a good state of cultivation; indeed, it was considered to be one of the best farms in the district, and eventually it became the site of Rosemont Railway Station. But Isaac resolved to move into Kansas when that state was opened. He went into Kansas, bought land there, but he only held it for a few years. Isaac Kirkpatrick was well-known among agriculturists in Mahoning County. Politically he was a republican, and by religious conviction was a member of the Reformed Presbyterian, or Covenanters, Church. He came into some prominence as a breeder of Shorthorn cattle, South Down sheep, and Chester White hogs, and had much success as an exhibitor at agricultural fairs.


Isaac Kirkpatrick had an interesting part in the development and perfecting of the Buckeye mower and reaper. Mr. R. M. Kirk, of Canfield, son of Isaac Kirkpatrick, testifies that the first mowing machine he saw was in 1858, when he saw his father testing one at the request of its inventor, Colonel E. Ball. The machine ultimately was worn out in experiments on the Kirkpatrick farm, and those experiments resulted in the perfected Buckeye machine ultimately placed on the market. Isaac Kirkpatrick appears to have been of experimental inclination, and probably of innate mechanical aptitude. He had on his farm the first threshing machine marketed, and a chaff piler, merely a cylinder, the power coming to cylinder from belt motivated by horse power. This was later replaced by the tumbling rod. Isaac and Eliza (McAnlis) Kirkpatrick were the parents of six children, five of whom were sons. The children, in their order- of birth, were Robert A., who was a veteran of the Civil war. He died in St. Paul, Minnesota, at the age of seventy-six years. He was for many years a wholesale hardware merchant in that city. James M., also a veteran of the civil war, died in California, to which state he retired after having been for many years in business as a merchant in Wheeling, West Virginia, and at New Castle, Pennsylvania. Susan, who now lives in Canfield, is the widow of William Kernohan. who during his life-time was a farmer and merchant at Canfield. Renwick Martin is mentioned below. William John, who is a commercial salesman, resides in Kansas City, Missouri;. Saul S. died in Chicago.


Renwick Martin Kirk(patrick), fourth child of Isaac and Eliza (McAnlis) Kirkpatrick, was born in Ellsworth Township, Mahoning County, Ohio, July 8, 1846. He spent-his boyhood on the parental farm, attending the academy at Ellsworth in Jackson Township. His boyhood days probably were more or less filled by the responsibility of minor tasks upon the home farm, and, as was customary in his early days among the sons of farmers, he spent most of the long summer vacations in harvesting occupations on his father's farm. Long before his years of schooling had passed he had become familiar with most of the operations of agricultural pursuits. And by the time he had closed his schooling he may probably also be said to have completed his apprenticeship in farming. It was quite natural therefore that he should take to agriculture as a life occupation. He married when he was twenty- three years old, and his father bought him a farm of eighty acres, situated about a half mile distant from the Village of Rosemont. This he eventually sold to advantage, purchasing about that time another and larger farm of one hundred and seventy-five acres at Ellsworth Station. There he lived, steadily farming for about forty years, and the property still belongs to him, his eldest son having taken over the responsibility of its management since the father moved into Canfield to retire from strenuous labors. Renwick Martin Kirk, who has adhered to the shorter name Kirk, an Americanization of his patronymic, Kirkpatrick, succeeded well by his long period of consistent and enterprising farming. Ellsworth Station started on his farm, and it also is the postoffice for the township, Mr. Kirk being instrumental in establishing the Ellsworth Station post- office. All mail has since been distributed from there. The farm is a well improved one with good buildings, and the house that was erected in the early seventies is still standing and in good preservation. Mr. R. M. Kirk remained on the farm until about 1906, since which year it has been operated by his eldest son, Robert C.


Throughout his life Mr. Kirk has taken close interest in the affairs of his township. For several years he was township trustee, and, had he wished, he might have been elected to other township offices. He is generally well-regarded, is known to have been a good farmer, was a reliable, responsible and well-disposed neighbor, and was of estimable private life. Ever since the establishment of the republican party he has followed that cause, and in his district has at times exercised appreciable influence for the candidates of that party. He is a good Christian and churchman, both he and his wife being members of the Presbyterian Church. His wife, whom he married in 1869, was Mary C. Gault, who


YOUNGSTOWN AND THE MAHONING VALLEY - 201


was of his own own age, and was born in North Jackson Township, daughter of Andrew and May (Ewing) Gault, her genealogy coming into that of the Ewing family, her mother having been a cousin of the Ewings, and also of his own father. And to Mr. and Mrs. R. M. Kirk have been born the following named children: Robert Carey, who is in charge of the parental farm at Ellsworth Station; Jessie V., widow of Charles Fitch, and she and her two children, Josephine and Richard, live with her parents in Canfield; Frank McAnlis, a coal operator in Cleveland, Ohio, married Lucille Malcolm, but there has been no issue; Jean, who married Edward Dickson, of Homestead, Pennsylvania; and R, C., who married Helen Hall, of Youngstown, and they have four sons, Robert Hall, Martin Henry, Malcolm and Charles.




GERALD F. HAMMOND, of the law firm of Moore, Barnum & Hammond, has been a member of the Mahoning County bar since 1908, and in that time has distinguished himself for his industry, and has demonstrated his ability along the special line of building law. He is attorney for nearly all the lumber companies and building supply dealers in the Mahoning Valley.


His parents, Martin and Edna (Rowe) Hammond, were farmers in Ashtabula County, and his father was an old soldier, a veteran of Company K of the 29th Ohio Infantry. Gerald F. Hammond was born on his father's farm April 13, 1881, grew up there, attended district schools, the county high school, and for four years was a student at Oberlin College. He took his law course in the University of Michigan, where he was graduated in 1908 and soon afterward began the practice of law at Youngstown. He is a member of the Mahoning County and State Bar associations, the Kiwanis Club, the Youngstown Club, the Chamber of Commerce, and is a republican, and is affiliated with the Masonic fraternity.


In 1911 he married Miss Hazel McCreary, daughter of Enoch and Mary McCreary, of New Castle, Pennsylvania. They have two children, Rae Esther and Robert Martin. Mr. and Mrs. Hammond are members of the First Christian Church.


DANIEL CAMPBELL M. D. For nearly forty years the talents of Dr. D. Campbell have covered a wide field of professional service in and around Canfield, and at the same time he has expressed his energy and public spirit in behalf of many causes connected with the general welfare and the commercial life of his town. Doctor Campbell is president of the Farmers National Bank of Canfield and is a recognized leader in community affairs.


The Campbell family has been identified with the Mahoning Valley for over half a century. Doctor Campbell was born near West Point, Ohio, April 1851. His parents were Peter and Mary (Rennie) Campbell, natives of Scotland, his father being a highlander and his mother a lowlander. Peter Campbell was a tailor by trade. In 1837 he and his wife came to America by sailing vessel, traveled westward by canal and lake to Cleveland and thence by wagon to Columbiana County. He went to Columbiana County influenced by the presence of a brother who had already become identified with a Scotch settlement in Madison Township. In 1864 Peter Campbell came to Youngstown and bought a farm near the city, now known as the Campbell Allotment, opposite Haselton. The farm at that time was two miles east of Youngstown, but is now in the city limits. The old homestead is now occupied by Peter Campbell's grandson, Bruce Campbell, a nephew of Doctor Campbell. Peter Campbell died at the age of eighty-one and his wife at seventy-six. He was a faithful adherent of the Presbyterian Church but never took any interest in politics. Of his twelve children eleven reached mature years. The three sons were William, father of P. S. and Bruce Campbell; Daniel; and James, whose death at the age age of twenty-eight cut short a promising career as a scholar and lawyer. He was a graduate of the Rayen High School, attended Western Reserve University and Williams College, and was studying law under Col. Thomas Sanderson when he died unmarried. Four of the daughters are still living: Mary, widow of Robert McLauchlan, a former coal operator at Cleveland; Sarah, who lived at Cleveland, widow of William Poultney, a former furnace manager at Haselton; Louise, now living retired at Cleveland, where for a number of years she was a teacher in the public schools; and Martha, wife of M. W. Zedeker, a well known resident of Poland. The other daughters were: Janet, who married David Elton and both died at Cleveland; Margaret, who married Ed Finley, and both died in Florida, their son William Finley being a resident of Poland; Elizabeth, who died when past fifty, the wife of Hamilton Harris, a resident of Youngstown; Helen (deceased), who was the wife of T. H. Shingledecker, who lives at Struthers.


Dr. Daniel Campbell was thirteen years of age when his parents located on the old farm near Youngstown. He grew up there, graduated from the Rayen High School, and received his degree in medicine from the Western Reserve Medical College at Cleveland in 1881. He immediately began practice, and for nearly thirty-nine years has had his home in Canfield. Only two other physicians in Mahoning County when he began practice still remain, Doctor Peck and Doctor Schiller, both of Youngstown. Doctor Campbell has given his time and talents to a general practice, and especially in the earlier years performed his full share of the arduous labors of a country doctor, riding and driving over all sorts of roads and in all kinds of weather. He has been active in the medical societies, served four years on the pension board during Cleveland's second administration, and has filled a similar place under President Wilson.


Doctor Campbell is the only survivor of the original board of the Farmers National Bank of Canfreld, and has been a director continuously ever since. He has filled the office of president for the past three or four years and has always been a member of its financial committee. He has held all the local offices in the village, including that of


202 - YOUNGSTOWN AND THE MAHONING VALLEY


mayor, has been president of the school board and was secretary and president of the board of the old Northeastern Normal School at Canfield. Politically his affiliations have always been with the democratic party. Doctor Campbell is also a prominent layman of the Presbyterian Church, has been an elder at Canfield for thirty years, and has served as a delegate to the General Assemblies at Minneapolis and Buffalo. He was instrumental in the establishment of the local lodge of Masons at Canfield, in which he has held all the chairs, and is a member of the Royal Arch Chapter and Knights Templar Commandery at Youngstown. For twenty-four years Doctor Campbell was superintendent of the Presbyterian Sunday School.


In March, 1882, he married Lucy Edwards, whose father, Pierpont Edwards, was for many years a merchant and tanner at Canfield, where she was reared. Her death occurred in June, 1886. She was survived by two children: Carl H., a practicing physician at Canfield; and Winnifred C., a graduate of the Woman's College of the Western Reserve University with the degree A. B. She was a nurse who served as night superintendent of Base Hospital No. 31, spending one year in France, and until April, 1919, was in the Welfare Department of the Youngstown Sheet and Tube Company. At that time she went into Red Cross work, remaining until August, 1920. May 6, 1890, Doctor Campbell married Martha Patch, of Stevens Point, Wisconsin. She was born at Orland, Indiana, a daughter of Rev. Jacob Patch, a Presbyterian minister who came west from Groton, Massachusetts. Her mother, Jane Bush, was a native of Hanover, New Hampshire. Her father died at the age of ninety-five and her mother at ninety-four. Mrs. Campbell is a graduate of the Western Female Seminary at Oxford, Ohio, also attended college at Mount Holyoke, Massachusetts, and for some time before her marriage was a teacher in the Poynette Academy in Wisconsin. Doctor and Mrs. Campbell reared in their home Alice Haswell from the age of six years, and she still regards this as her own home.


Dr. Carl H. Campbell was born, April 20, 1883, at Canfield. He is a graduate of the Northeastern Normal College of Canfield. He is also a graduate of Wooster University, of Wooster, Ohio, where he received the degree A. B. His medical education was obtained in the Western Reserve Medical College at Cleveland, Ohio, where he received the degree M. D. in 1909, since which time he has been practicing in Canfield, On August 29, 1917, he married Isabel Armstrong, of Cleveland, a daughter of Mr. and Mrs. Samuel Armstrong, of Cleveland. They have two sons, Donald. A. and James E.


LYMAN BETZ FREDERICK is one of the esteemed residents of Boardman Township, now living on his farm and has devoted many years to agricultural pursuits. He was born at Lisbon, Columbiana County, Ohio, on December 25, 1847, a son of Zebulon, grandson of Samuel and great-grandson of Thomas Frederick. Thomas Frederick and his brother were captured by

the Indians, and remained in captivity several years. He finally escaped and made his way back to his mother, who identified him by a scar on his neck. His brother was never heard from. Zebulon Frederick became a farmer. When his son Lyman B. Frederick was two years old he came to Mahoning County and located in Green Township, where he spent the remainder of his useful life, dying at the age of seventy-six years.


Lyman Betz Frederick was reared in Green Township and attended the Poland Seminary, where he had as classmates L. R. Jackson and Brown Williams, both of whom later became noted attorneys. Following the completion of his studies Mr. Frederick taught school for eight terms in Green and Beaver townships, and many of his old pupils are numbered among the worthwhile men and women of this and other sections.


Lyman Betz Frederick was married to Laura Kirk, whose father, William Kirk, owned the present farm of Mr. Frederick. Mrs. Frederick was born at New Albany, Ohio. Mr. Kirk died at the age of seventy-six years. In 1887 Lyman B. Frederick took charge of the Kirk farm, and has lived on it for thirty-three years, and has owned it for some years. Recently he sold a portion of the farm to the High Tension Electric Road, but retains the remainder. Mr. Frederick has erected a silo, added to the stable and made other improvements. He and his son R. E. are engaged in dairying, their cattle being thoroughbred Jersey stock, which has been exhibited at county fairs. In politics he is a republican, and for fourteen years served as township clerk and until recently was road superintendent. Being a firm believer in good roads, he is taking an active part in the movement calculated to stimulate interest in further improvements of the roads in the county. The Poland Presbyterian Church holds his membership. Mr. and Mrs. Frederick became the parents of the following children: William K., who lives at Wheeling, West Virginia, is connected with. the Scranton Correspondence School; Charles L., who lives at Portsmouth, Ohio; Blanche A., who married Edgar McCullough, of Poland, Ohio ; Roy Edwin, who is mentioned below; and James Allen, who lives on a farm adjoining that of his father.


ROY EDWIN FREDERICK proprietor of the Walnut Springs Herd of Jersey cattle in Boardman Township, was born in Green Township on April 23, 1883. After acquiring a practical experience in dairy work under his father's instruction Mr. Frederick worked in the dairy department of the Ohio State University as supervising official of tests for the State Agricultural College. in 1906 he started his herd of Jersey cattle and now has twenty-eight head. Mr. Frederick has exhibited his cattle at county fairs and won a full share of honors with them. He bred and raised cows that held the state championship for several years, and also raised two Gold Medal cows, and his product is sought by breeders who pay fancy prices. Mr. Frederick is active in the Farm Bureau, which he helped to organize, and his ability and experience as a stockman are so generally recognized


YOUNGSTOWN AND THE MAHONING VALLEY - 203


that he is usually called upon to act as judge of stock at both the county and state fairs.

Roy Edwin Frederick was married to Florence Hughes, and they have three children, namely: Lyman Henry, Robert Hugh and Harry Hughes. Both Mr. Frederick and his father are held in the highest esteem in Mahoning County, and are recognized as men who have contributed much toward the advancement of agricultural interests in this region, and the development of a local pride in the quality of the stock bred and handled. The name of the farm is recognized as a guarantee of superiority, and that of their family as synonymous with good citizenship and upright living. It is such men as those hearing the name of Frederick who have made Ohio the great commonwealth it is today, and the efforts of the present generation are still directed toward a maintenance of this desirable prestige.




ALVIN W. CRAVER. Only those who come into personal contact with Alvin W. Craver, one of the able and successful lawyers of this section of the Buckeye state, can understand how thoroughly nature and training, habits of thought and action have enabled him to accomplish his life work and made him a fit representative of the profession to which he belongs. He is a fine type of the sturdy, conscientious, progressive American of today—a man who united a high order of ability with courage, patriotism, clean morality and sound common sense, doing thoroughly and well the work that he finds to do and asking praise of no man for the performance of what he conceives to be his simple duty. Alvin W. Craver is a native son of the county now honored by his citizenship, having been born at North Jackson on September 22, 1872. William Craver, his father, who was a native of Pennsylvania, came to Ohio many years ago, first locating in Trumbull County, but later removing to Mahoning County, where he spent the remainder of his days, his death occurring in 1901. He became one of the leading farmers of his community and enjoyed the respect and esteem of all who knew him. He married Mary Wanamaker, a daughter of Nathan Wanamaker, of North Jackson.


Alvin W. Craver was reared on his father's farm, where he assisted in the labors of agriculture and attended the neighboring schools. Subsequently he became a student in the Ohio Normal University at Ada, and during the following eight years he alternately attended the university and taught school. In 1897 he graduated from the law department of the university, was admitted to the bar, and immediately afterward he came to Youngstown and entered upon the practice of his profession. His abilities were quickly recognized and he rendered efficient service as assistant to the prosecuting attorney from 1900 to 1903. In 1907 he was elected mayor of Youngstown, and in 1909 was elected to succeed himself. In 1912 he resumed the practice of law, in which he was busily engaged until 1918, when he was again elected to the mayoralty, in which he served until January 1, 1920. He is a member of the law firm of Craver, Diser, Huey and Starrs, which has always commanded its full share of the legal business in the local courts.


The several administrations of Mayor Craver have reflected credit on his ability and sound judgment, and many needed reforms and improvements have been inaugurated and completed. It was during Mayor Craver's second administration that the land was purchased and bonds authorized and the Milton Dam located, and land was purchased for the construction of the present mammoth reservoir, giving to Youngstown an auxiliary to its water supply, which will be adequate in supplying its demands for the next fifty years. It may be truthfully said that he was the father of this much needed improvement. Among other improvements may be mentioned the widening of West Federal Street; the beginning of construction of the Mill Creek Park District sewer, involving an expenditure of over $500,000; a complete reorganization of the city water department, through which it was brought from a non-paying basis to a self-sustaining basis and at the same time providing the best water that has ever been supplied to Youngstown, the improvement including the best purification plant, with the best management, of any city in Ohio; the grade- crossing question has also been revived, it having lagged because of the exigencies of the recent war, and which will eventually involve the expenditure of several millions of dollars; through the city health department, the free treatment of venereal disease was inaugurated. In many ways Mr. Craver has shown a desire to promote in every way possible the welfare of the whole people, and his several administrations will go into local history as among the very best the city has ever had.


On June 26, 1901, Mr. Craver was united in marriage with Jeanette Noble, a daughter of Albie V. Noble, of St. Marys, Auglaize County, Ohio. Fraternally Mr. Craver is a member of the Free and Accepted Masons, the Independent Order of Odd, Fellows, the Knights of Pythias and the Benevolent and Protective Order of Elks. His social relations are with the Youngstown Club and the Youngstown Country Club. Genial and companionable to a marked degree, Mr. Craver is also a great lover of outdoor sports and of fine horses. Equally noted as a citizen whose useful career has conferred credit on the city and whose marked abilities and sterling qualities have won for him more than local repute, he holds distinctive precedence as one of the most enterprising and progressive men of his community. Strong mental powers, invincible courage and a determined purpose that hesitates at no opposition have so entered into his composition as to render him a dominant factor in public affairs and a leader of men. As a lawyer Mr. Craver enjoys a reputation as a sound and safe counselor and a successful practitioner. Possessing all the requisite qualities of the able lawyer, he stands without dispute among the eminent practitioners of the Youngstown bar. He possesses a gracious personality, being easily approached, and his circle of friends is coextensive with the circle of his acquaintances.


S. A. COLER, who carries on a general merchandising business at Woodworth Crossroads in Boardman Township, is one of the substantial men and old residents of Mahoning County. He was born in


204 - YOUNGSTOWN AND THE MAHONING VALLEY


Beaver Township, three miles south of his present home, near Lima, Ohio, on April 5, 1855, a son of John and Catherine (Swartz) Coler. John Coler was born on the same farm as his son, his birth taking place in 1825, his father, also John, having settled on this homestead when he migrated here from Pennsylvania, becoming a neighbor of the Fasnachts and the Hahns.



John Coler, the younger, spent his life on that farm, and in addition to conducting it, operated a saw-mill in partnership with his brother George. Another brother, Solomon, after serving for three years in the war between the states, settled down rn Beaver Township and was there engaged in farming the rest of his life. John Coler died in March, 1902, his wife having passed away two years before him. They were active in the work of the Mount Olive German Reformed Church at North Lima, and are buried in the cemetery connected with it. John Coler was a very active man, and in connection with his sawmilling, cleared out a good deal of timber in the county.


S. A. Coler remained at home until his marriage, and then took possession of a small part of his father's farm and a portion of his grandfather's farm that he owned. After nine years on it he moved to thirty-five acres of land in Beaver Township, and remained on it from 1887 until 1895, when he bought his present place on the township line between Boardman and Beaver townships. It is on the main road to North Lima Springs. His store was started over fifty years ago by Samuel Steel, who conducted it for years, but sold it when he moved to Youngstown, which he later served as mayor, and the property changed hands several times before Mr. Coler bought it from Amos Warner. At that time there were three small stores at Woodworth, but now Mr. Coler has the only one. He has a large trade and pleases his customers by his rigid adherence to the plan of selling at a small margin and turning his stock over rapidly. In 1903 he bought a farm of ninety-five acres, of which he still owns eighty acres. This is now conducted by his son, who is a successful farmer. A new set of buildings has been erected and the farm is kept strictly up to date. One of the features of the place is a fine sugar grove of 500 trees and in the grove is a well- equipped sugarhouse, and the entire plant is kept in excellent condition. The annual yield of sap is large and well handled. A postoffice was established at this point more than srxty years ago, and named "Steam Town" on account of the location here of the first steam mills. It was abandoned for several years, and then Lawrence D. Woodworth secured a new postoffice about thirty years ago, and it was named in his honor. S. A. Coler served as postmaster for some fifteen years, and then the office was discontinued and the rural free delivery service was installed.


During the war between the states S. A. Coler, then an impressionable lad, used to read the newspapers out loud to his father, and became so impressed by statements in these journals laying the blame of the conflict upon the democratic party, that he became a strong republican, in spite of the fact that his father was a democrat, and when he reached his majority, cast his first vote for the republican ticket. From then on he has continued a stanch supporter of that party, and strange to say, from then until his death his father, influenced by his son, voted the same ticket. Fraternally Mr. Coler is a member of the Knights of Pythias and was a charter member of Manitou Lodge of North Lima. He has been three times representative to the state convention of the Knights of Pythias.


S. A. Coler was married when he was twenty years old to Celesta Catherine Lower, born in Pennsylvania, but reared in Beaver Township. They became the parents of two sons, namely: Henry E., who owns and operates a grocery and market at West Lake Crossing, married Mary E. Mentzer, and they have one daughter, Sethy; and Park D., who is operating his father's farm, married Blanche Chubb, and they have three children, Evelyn, Erna C. and S. A., Jr. It would be difficult to find any family more generally esteemed than that bearing the name of Coler.


WILLIAM W. BROWNLEE. Six miles east of the City of Youngstown, in Coitsville Township, is situated the fine homestead farm of William Wellington Brownlee, and an additional interest attaches to his ownership of the property by reason of the fact that the farm figures as the place of his birth. In a substantial house that is still standing on this old homestead he was born on the 2d of April, 1854, and the name which he bears has been long and worthily identified with the history of Mahoning County. He is a son of John S. and Jeanette (Patterson) Brownlee, both of whom were born in a village not far distant from the City of Glasgow, Scotland, where they were reared to maturity and where their marriage was solemnized. Within a comparatively short time after their marriage they came to America, the voyage having been made on a sailing vessel of the type common to that day, and eleven weeks having been passed on the ocean ere they disembarked in the land of their adoption. They passed the first winter at Chambersburg, Pennsylvania, and in the following spring they came to Mahoning County, Ohio, and established their home near Struthers, as pioneer settlers in this part of the county. During the winter of the first year here Mr. Brownlee was engaged in digging iron ore from the pioneer ore bank at Struthers, and in the following spring he purchased ioo acres of heavily timbered land and instituted the development of a farm. The original habitation was a log house, and this primitive dwelling is still in a good state of preservation, though not occupied. Their son William W., of this review, was born in a frame building erected in place of the log house. The house is commodious, attractive in its simple and honest design and construction, and constitutes a worthy landmark of the early. days in Coitsvilre Township. In due time John S. Brownlee reclaimed his land to cultivation, and he purchased sixty acres of additional land one-half mile distant from the home place. For this latter property he paid $7.00 an acre, and the difference in valuations at that time and the present is shown in the fact that he at one time considered the purchase of land on which the present Rayen High


YOUNGSTOWN AND THE MAHONING VALLEY - 205


School building is located in the City of Youngstown, for a consideration of $25.00 an acre. Mr. Brownlee was a man of fine mental poise, of marked business acumen and of impregnable integrity in all the relations of life. He became one of the substantial men of the county, was successful in his well-directed activities as an agriculturist and stock-grower, and gave special attention to the raising of sheep, of which he kept at one time 300 head. In the reclaiming and developing of his farm and in his earnest support of progressive communal policies he contributed much to the advancement of his county, and he was one of the well known and highly honored citizens of Coitsville Township at the time of his death in 1886, at the venerable age of eighty years. He remained on the old home farm until the close of his life, and his widow was seventy-seven years of age when she passed away, she having survived him by several years and both having been earnest members of the Presbyterian Church at Coitsville. Of their eight children one daughter died at the age of fifteen years, and six attained to maturity. Margaret remained, unmarried, at the old homestead until her death at the age of fifty years ; Alexander went forth as a gallant young soldier of the Union in the Civil war as a member of the Nineteenth Ohio Volunteer Infantry, and he was one of a number of unfortunate victims who were killed by poison while in a hospital near Murfreesboro, Tennessee, he having been but twenty- three years of age at the time ; Janet, who became the wife of Emmett Marstler, died in 1916, at the age of seventy-six years ; James enlisted in the same company as did his brother Alexander, and at the same time, and he died in the same hospital as did his brother, though as a result of illness, he having been in his twenty-first year at the time ; Ranelds S. is a retired farmer and resides at Hubbard, Trumbull County; and William W., of this review, is the youngest of the children who reached mature years.


William Wellington Brownlee has remained from the time of his birth on the old home place, and in his independent activities as an agriculturist and stock-grower he has well upheld the high prestige of the family name, as has he also as a citizen. The local schools afforded him his youthful education, and he has never wavered in his allegiance to the great basic industries under the influence of which he was reared. Since coming into ownership of the old homestead he has added to the same by purchasing an adjacent tract of seventy-five acres, this latter farm being under the independent management of his son William. Mr. Brownlee has been specially successful as a stock grower, and for several years he marketed annually a goodly number of beef cattle, principally to supply local demands. For fully a quarter of a century he has controlled a substantial business in the buying and shipping of wool, and for the past decade he has been undoubtedly the leading wool buyer in the county. He has handled an average of 6o,000 pounds of wool annually, and incidentally has raised an excellent type of sheep on his farm. He is a stockholder in the banking institutions at Struthers, and is a man of prominence and influence in the community.


Mr. Brownlee has exerted a distinct and benignant force in connection with public affairs in Mahoning County, and has been called upon to serve in various offices of public trust and responsibility. His initial official service was in the capacity of school director, and in the early '90s he was elected trustee of Coitsville Township, a position of which he continued the incumbent two terms—or four years. While thus serving he initiated in the township the first decisive movement for the construction of good roads within its borders, and it was primarily due to his efforts that the township was bonded for the purpose of building four roads leading into Youngstown—about ten miles in all. This admirable improvement was effected within two years, and at the time when the bonding proposition was presented to the voters of the township only thirty-five votes were cast in opposition, though the proposed action provided for the issuing of bonds to the amount of $100,000. All citizens now realize that the expenditures were wisely made and have been of enduring value. After having been elected township trustee for a third term Mr. Brownlee resigned the office, and he was then elected one of the three directors of the county infirmary. Shortly after his induction into this office the infirmary buildings were destroyed by fire, but new buildings were forthwith erected, on a larger scale and with modern equipment and facilities. After serving four years as infirmary director, with Reese L. Jones and Daniel W. McDonald, both of Youngstown, as his associate directors, Mr. Brownlee was in 1912 made the regular republican candidate for the office of county commissioner, and the victory which attended his election demonstrated again the strong hold which he has upon popular confidence and esteem in his native county. He continued as' an efficient and valued member of the board of county commissioners for two terms, of two years each, and made a characteristic record for loyal and progressive service.


In 1878 was solemnized the marriage of Mr. Brownlee to Miss Ella Mars, who likewise was born and reared in Mahoning County and who is a daughter of the late John J. Mars. In conclusion is given brief record concerning the children of this union : John C. remained at the parental home until his death, at the age of thirty years; James, who married Miss Jennie Wilson, was a skilled employe in the service of a telephone company and was killed by electrocution by a live wire in 1914, when about thirty years of age ; William married Miss Bessie Fidler, and they reside on the farm adjoining that of his father, as intimated in a previous paragraph ; Donald, who was graduated in the high school and also took a course in a business college, has continued for the past several years to assist in the work and management of the old home farm ; Clifford is a prosperous farmer and dairyman in Coitsville Township and the maiden name of his wife was Mabel Cooper ; and Ray remains at the parental home with his brother Donald.








YOUNGSTOWN BOILER AND TANK COMPANY. While one of the very youngest giants in the Youngstown industrial district, the Youngstown Boiler and Tank Company has made a remarkable record in production as well as in volume of sales. It was organized


206 - YOUNGSTOWN AND THE MAHONING VALLEY


for the purpose of building tanks and steel plate construction, and in the first year of its existence the company did a business valued at $1,000,000, a record that few new companies have ever surpassed. At the present time this company manufactures probably go per cent of the large storage tanks sold by the oil, pump and tank companies of the country. An average of ten tanks are shipped daily from the Youngstown factory. An export trade has also been developed, much of the product being shipped to Cuba, West Indies and South American countries.


This company is one of the large users of iron and steel, working up and converting during the first year about 6,000 tons of steel plate, 400 tons of castings, 200 tons of rivets, and 500 tons of structural material.


On, the average 150 men of the highly skilled class have been employed. The great success of the organization is undoubtedly due to the technical skill and experience of the men at the head. Each of the officials and managers is an expert in his particular line, and the new company is largely made up of seasoned veterans drawn from other kindred concerns. The company has branch agencies in New York, Chicago, Philadelphia, St. Louis, Birmingham and Atlanta.


The Youngstown Boiler & Tank Company was organized April 25, 1919. The officers chosen were J. P. Keene, president ; W. R. Kirby, vice president; Charles R. Vogel, secretary and treasurer. The capital stock was $50,000, but on October 22, 1919, a reorganization was effected under the same name and with increase of capital to $100,000, which was increased in May, 1920, to $500,000. The officers chosen at that time and still on duty are: J. P. Keene, president; William H, Heywood, vice president and treasurer; William R. Kirby, vice president; Charles R. Vogel, secretary; while the other directors are Ralph Cornelius, John R. Rowland, W. J. Roberts and R. I. Ingalls.


James P. Keene, head of this industry, was born at Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, July 16, 1886, a son of Philip J. and Anna (Fox) Keene. His father, who is now a retired resident of Chicago, has spent the greater part of his life in steel plate construction. James P. Keene attended grammar and high schools at Philadelphia, and at the age of sixteen went to work in the engineering department of the Bethlehem Steel Company at Bethlehem, Pennsylvania. Subsequently he was in the steel plate construction department of the American Steel & Wire Company at Cleveland, and subsequently was assistant superintendent of the tank shop of the Allis-Chalmers Company of Chicago. For five years following he was on the road in erection work, and then became superintendent of the shops of the McAleenan Brothers at Pittsburgh. This experience and these responsibilities show that he was a highly competent man in the various branches of steel plate work. Eventually he embarked his capital and that of some associates in the Sharpsville Boiler Works Company at Sharpsville, Pennsylvania, and remained as general manager of that concern for four years.


Resigning, he came to Youngstown in December, 1918, and soon had the plans marching toward completion for the Youngstown Boiler and Tank Company. As president he has not only been the business head but the guiding technical genius in the industry.


Mr. Keene is a member of the Sharon Country Club, the Elks Lodge at Sharon, is a Knight Templar Mason and Shriner, and he and his wife are members of the Brown Memorial Methodist Episcopal Church of Youngstown. He married, June 18, 1910, Miss Effie Bigby, of Macon, Georgia. They have one son, James Philip, Jr.


William H. Heywood,. vice president and treasurer of the Youngstown Boiler and Tank Company, fits into the new organization as a master of the sales end of the business. For several years he was connected with the sales department of the Youngstown Sheet and Tube Company.


Mr. Heywood was born in Kearney, Nebraska, September 15, 1889. His father, Herbert J. Heywood, was a native of Canada. In early life he was a railroad man, but later engaged in the coal business and is now a member of the firm of W. A. Gosline & Company, Toledo, Ohio. He has been a resident of Toledo for twenty years. He married at Wichita, Kansas, Ida Miller, and William H. is the older of their two children.


For seven years William H. Heywood lived at Delphos, Ohio, attended public school there, and subsequently acquired a very liberal education, spending five years in the Miami Institute at Germantown, Ohio, until graduating in 1908, and then took the classical course in Harvard University, receiving his A. B. degree in 1912.


In September following his graduation Mr. Heywood came to Youngstown and entered the service of the Youngstown Sheet and Tube Company, at first as a mill worker, then in the order department, and subsequently in the sales department. He resigned from the Sheet & Tube Company in November, 1919, to give his special skill and experience to the Youngstown Boiler and Tank Company.


He is a member of the Youngstown Club, Youngstown Country Club, Chamber of Commerce, Youngstown Rotary Club, and is a Knight Templar Mason and Shriner. Mr. and Mrs. Heywood are members of the First Presbyterian Church.


October 15, 1914, he married Mrs. Fannie (Arms) Lomasney, daughter of Warner Arms of Youngstown. By a former marriage she has three children: Helen, David and Myron. Mr. and Mrs. Heywood have one daughter, Caroline Frances.


ROGERS. Among numerous individuals of the Rogers name who have achieved distinction in the life and affairs of Northeastern Ohio during the last century, three stand out conspicuously for their associations with Youngstown, Disney, Volney and Bruce Rogers.


Their grandparents were Thomas and Hope (Rossell) Rogers, who early in the nineteenth century left their home in Pennsylvania and sought a new location in the wilderness and on the frontier in Columbiana County, Ohio. Thomas Rogers entered the land comprised in his farm in Middleton Township at the Government land office at Steubenville, Ohio. Their son, James Rogers, was born in Columbiana County, Ohio, in 1812. He married


YOUNGSTOWN AND THE MAHONING VALLEY - 207


Elizabeth D. Jamieson, and they were the parents of eleven children, nine of whom reached mature years. Besides the three sons named above there were: Dip Rogers, a lawyer at Steubenville, Ohio, practiced in Hubbard, Ohio, for several years, and is one of Ohio's representative lawyers and has been very successful; Dr. Lycurgus Rogers, of Negley, Ohio ; Dr. Z. L. Rogers, of East Palestine; James L. Rogers and John H. Rogers, farmers in Middleton Township, Columbiana County, Ohio; and Minnie J. Randall of Negley, Ohio.


Disney Rogers was born on the old homestead farm in Columbiana County, December 19, 1844. He read law at what is now Lisbon, and after practicing his profession for some years at Mount Gilead, moved to Youngstown in 1872. For a number of years he was a law partner with his brother Volney. He was forceful, upright in character, and enjoyed the highest standing not only as a lawyer but as a citizen. For two terms he was prosecuting attorney for Mahoning County, and served one appointive term and one full elective term as judge of the Court of Common Pleas. For over twenty-one years he was moderator of the Trumbull Baptist Association. At Mount Gilead he married Ida S. Andrews, a daughter of his law partner. The only surviving son of Disney Rogers is James B., who lives in Kentucky.


Volney Rogers, who was born December I, 1846, and died December 3, 1919, while visiting in the West, also spent his youth on the home farm near East Palestine. He attended public schools and as a young man mastered the art of telegraphy. He was employed during the construction of a telegraph line on the old Turnpike from Pittsburg to Baltimore. When it was completed he was employed as operator for the State Legislature at the Pennsylvania capitol in Harrisburg. For four years he was a telegraph operator in Waynesboro and then studied law and prepared for his profession under his brother Disney. He began practice at Youngstown in 1871, and while in the office of city solicitor he codified the city ordinances. While not a brilliant advocate, he was well grounded in the fundamental principles and was considered a safe counselor and was the type of lawyer whose personal character secured him that confidence and esteem which are the source of the best satisfaction to a good and upright lawyer. He served two terms as City Solicitor. Volney Rogers was never married. He was a devout Presbyterian, and like other members of his family was a republican.


The big interest of his life and the source of the service for which he will be lastingly remembered in Youngstown is Mill Creek Park. He saw the possibilities of utilizing this picturesque and historic locality for public purposes as early as 1890. The process of destruction of the timber had already gone far. He obtained options on much of the land, and through his influence secured the passage of a bill through the Legislature known as the Township Park Improvement Law. With the assistance of his brother Bruce he began the improvement of the valley, and carried on the work which caused Mill Creek Park to be recognized as one of the finest scenic parks in Ohio. He combated every effort to destroy the beauties and real values of this valley. Through his efforts and those of his brother Bruce the project for using the basin as a city reservoir was abandoned. Through all the years he gave his services in a legal capacity without remuneration, and frequently neglected his own private business to safeguard the interests of the public. He was himself a nature lover and a rare student of birds, flora and of the great book of nature. He was author of a history of Mill Creek Park.


The services of such a man are frequently disregarded when set in contrast with more selfish and popular achievements. However, many Youngstown people appreciated his purposes and his work, and this appreciation was perhaps best expressed in the words of an editorial in the Telegram, quoted herewith :


"To speak a good word in memory of the late Volney Rogers is almost unnecessary, much as that tribute is deserved. Probably there is no person in Youngstown who does not know what the city and its individuals alike owe him for his thirty years' work in the •interests of the great Mill Creek Park if for no other reason. Eulogies, therefore, would be merely trite.


"In the instance of Mr. Rogers, the unusual happened when his work was recognized and a memorial planned in his honor even before his death. It is a work that has not been completed yet, but its success was long ago assured.


"Yet there is another form of memorial that might be erected to Mr. Rogers that would be more fitting even than one of brass or stone. It will cost nothing, but will be worth more than a million dollar' arch or statue. We refer to the preservation of Mill Creek Park.


"Volney Rogers might have made this place a great personal asset. Realizing its possibilities first, he might have capitalized these. Instead, he worked, almost alone, to dedicate this great outdoors place to the people of Youngstown. For many years past his work has been threatened. Just now a sewer is being driven through the park with little regard to saving the beauty of the place. Hungry real estate dealers are trying to capitalize it. There is a growing belief that the park was meant as a dumping place for ashes, tin cans and garbage and only unceasing vigilance can prevent this desecration. To exercise this vigilance is the best payment we could make Volney Rogers—public benefactor."


MY WALKS AND TALKS WITH

VOLNEY ROGERS


Written by H. W. Weisgerber, for the

Sunday Vindicator


The numerous walks and talks that I have had with Mr. Volney Rogers will ever remain as the choicest treasures of my mind; for it was the one thing—nature—that we enjoyed and had in common, that drew us together and held our friendship which ripened in the few years we knew each other.


It is about these walks and talks, with their side lines regarding the man and his sterling character, that I wish to write at this time, while they are still fresh in my mind, for while he has passed from us


208 - YOUNGSTOWN AND THE MAHONING VALLEY


in the bodily form, his spirit will continue to live in the hearts of a grateful people who will, I sincerely trust, cherish his memory and the work that he so valiantly performed in preserving for all time the beautiful Mill Creek Valley. As father of that scenic playground he will always be remembered, whether as has been suggested, the park ever bears his name or not. He was far too modest ever to think of having it called anything else than the name lie so dearly loved—"Mill Creek Park."


A WALK IN 1915


Our acquaintance dates from the summer of 1915 when I came over from Salem in order to take some pictures in Mill Creek Park and Mr. Rogers kindly acted as guide and pointed out the places which, according to his mind, formed the "pictures" in the park. It was during this first walk that we found that our tastes ran along the same line and in the same channel; we not only loved the beautiful scenery, but the trees, flowers and the birds; we compared notes on the glacial action and studied the rock formation; in fact, we found that we were of one mind regarding the works of nature.


It was during this first walk that I saw what loving care he had bestowed upon this strip of water worn valley; how he was annoyed by the carelessness of people in throwing paper and rubbish over the ground; he thought that people should help keep the place looking neat and as Nature had left it ; broken glass he abhorred, and he would pick up all that lay in his path; a stone in the driveway he would throw to one side; any noxious weed he pulled up so that it would not go to seed and thus spread its kind; in fact, any little attention that he could bestow upon anything that needed it, he would give before passing onward. It was this attention to minor details, something which could not well be delegated to others and which he did at the time he noticed it, that has made the park the beauty spot it is.


But this was not all : as we walked we talked; he told me of his struggles with this and that interest, with first one problem and then another; of the uphill work it had been and the money and time it had taken to accomplish that which we beheld in all its beauty. When we came to a beautiful vista he would stop and point out the interesting part of it and tell how he had ordered a tree cut here and another one there and the brush thinned out so that the picture could be presented to the eye as if enclosed in a frame. We would talk upon some subject when suddenly something would come to view or to our attention and we would break off and start upon the new object and talk about it ; sometimes it would be fully a half hour before we got back to the original question, and in most instances we never got back to it that day, there were far too many things to talk about.


A RARE FERN


It was on this first trip that we found a maidenhair spleenwort fern, one of the rare ferns in the park, growing on the face of a sandstone boulder that lay beside one of the paths in the gorge. It had grown into the freakish shape of a star, like a starfish. I obtained an excellent negative and for weeks after Air. Rogers used to guide his nature-loving friends to this little fern; then, one day he found that some vandal had destroyed it. He loved everything in the park, and months afterward when he told me about the destruction of the little fern, I detected a note of sadness in his voice; he could not understand why people would destroy that which he loved, especially since he and I had found it, and we, knowing its value as an oddity of nature, had left it for the enjoyment of others, who would pass that way.


It was on this first trip, too, that he showed the strong trait in his character for the observance of rules and regulations regarding the use of the park. We had reached the end of our journey, above the falls, where some men were working on the dam that forms the swimming pool at that place, and he talked with them and we proceeded up the stream to the Pool-of-the-Shadows where we found some young men who were violating the park rules in the taking of fishing bait; he called their attention to this fact and they began with insulting remarks and a disregard of his orders to stop, when he politely informed them that he was one of the park commissioners and that he would have them arrested; this frightened them so that they were read to quit and they all began to apologize for their ignorance in not knowing the rules.


A CHARACTERISTIC INCIDENT


It was not until after I came to Youngstown that I enjoyed other walks in the park with Mr. Rogers. In the summer of 1918, while I roomed on Lakewood Avenue, a ten minutes' walk from the Falls Avenue entrance, and with an extra hour of daylight in the evening which was then in vogue, I would occasionally call at the house of his brother, who was then spending the summer in a cottage in the park and inquire about the health of Mr. Volney Rogers and ascertain whether or not he had found anything new in the nature line. It was on one of these evenings, the first one, in fact, in which I had found him, that an amusing incident occurred which I will never forget. It showed how far business was removed from him when he was away from his office and how his life was centered upon the nature that is all about us. I was spending the evening in the park when I met a man who asked me if I knew where Mr. Rogers lived. I informed him that I was not sure of the house, but since he said that someone told him that it was a white one, that I would lead him to one and if that was not the place I would take him to the next. The first chanced to be the right one. I stepped back several paces so as not to interfere with any matter about which the stranger might wish to talk. Mr. Rogers came to the door, shook hands with the man, who, I think, said something about some business matters. He did not seem, however, to awaken Mr. Rogers' interest, for he came forward and reached for my hand and greeted me and said with enthusiasm that he had found a new plant which he wished to show


YOUNGSTOWN AND THE MAHONING VALLEY - 209


me and turned into the house to get it. He brought it out and we talked about it, then the subject changed, and I told him of a tree that I had found that evening near the lily ponds that was new to me; he went into the house after his hat and the three of us went walking toward the tree in question. It was the laurel-leaved oak, a new one to me, and near it was a new species of oak, a hybrid of the laurel-leaved that had been discovered by one of the botanists whom Mr. Rogers had invited at one time to list the plants of the park. All of this time the man who had come to see Mr. Rogers was kept waiting and was going with us from point to point and from object to object with nothing to do but listen to our talk on Nature. This kept up for over an hour and until nearly dark, when we came to the parting of the ways. Here we halted; I bade the gentleman "good-night" and not until then did Mr. Rogers give the man a chance to talk about the business that had brought him to the park. I cannot help smiling about this little incident every time it comes to mind. A few weeks ago, while I was standing in the diamond waiting for a Poland car to take me home, a man tapped me on the shoulder and asked if I were not the man whom he had met in the park that evening. I told him I was and that I felt sorry he had had to wait so long, whereupon he replied that he enjoyed our talk greatly, for it was about something that he did not hear discussed every day.


LOVED TO WALK IN THE PARK


How ready and willing Mr. Rogers was to take a walk and to talk about nature, the following incident will illustrate. It was about nine o'clock one Sunday morning, I had been out since sunrise, had been to the falls and returned and had just stopped at the house to inquire about his health; I had intended to pause but a few minutes, then return to my room and dress for church, but he had a shrub in one of the out-of-the-way corners of the park that he wished to show me, so after putting on his coat, hat and rubbers we started. After looking at the shrub we continued to go on; we went up one of the minor ravines that leads to the west and followed it to the end, where we came into a level field, and then returned by way of the Old Furnace Road and passed the Bear's Den section of the park. That morning we listened to sermons that were not uttered by man and to music that was not rendered by human voices; we communed with the God of Nature, we were reverent about it, too, and did not profane the day nor the hour by voice or act. On another occasion, late in the summer, we strolled about the park near his home, and on the rocky bed of the creek at high water we found a freak of nature in the form of a three-leaved bone- set plant; in all of his many years of nature study Mr. Rogers had never seen anything of this kind of boneset; it certainly was a "sport," one of the odd things that help make nature study so interesting. Mr. Rogers seemed to enjoy this rare find and we referred to it several times afterward. It was during one of these twilight talks that he informed me that as a young man he had studied telegraphy and had become acquainted with electricity, and he began to tell of the different "charges" of the fluid and illustrated by the lightning's stroke that had but a short time before played sad havoc with one of the largest hemlock trees on the hill sides, opposite his home, shattering the trunk only in certain places by jumping from place to place.


Last winter, after I had moved to the city and had settled in the south-east corner, near Pine Hallow and the Loveland Farms, I visited him at his office on Saturday afternoons and he would always inquire whether I had found anything new in nature. He seemed much interested in my discovery that Pine Hallow was the beautiful ravine that it is, and about the various things that I found from time to time; he always enjoyed the nature pictures that I showed him, and he and his brother Bruce identified for me the Hercules shrub, that I had known under a false name for years and could not find in the botany under the assumed name when I wished to check up on it.


To show how modest Mr. Rogers was it is only necessary to state that last winter when an article about a memorial in his honor had been printed, I was in his office and mentioned the fact, when, blushing like a school boy, he remarked that it was a matter about which he had been approached but over which he had no control. To show how reserved he was and how little he would talk of his accomplishments in Mill Creek Park it is only necessary to say that to me he would never say much about it while in his office; but how confidential he would become, always with a due amount of diffidence and reserve, whenever he was in that nature- spot he so dearly loved. There, amid familiar scenes, he would open his heart and talk as though he were pleading his case to some loved one. There he would speak amid the scenes that he loved and for which he had spent the greater part of his life that they might be preserved as a heritage for the people. After he had pleaded his last case for the preservation of the park from the bands of the spoilers and had lost, he was ready to leave the scenes of his life's labor and to spend the rest of his days far from the place where he had labored so long and faithfully, hoping that by change of surroundings he might forget. But other scenes and joys were not to be his, for such a man as Volney Rogers cannot live long away from home.


Bruce Rogers, now the only survivor of the trio of brothers who made Youngstown their home, was born December 26, 1854. He received a good education as a youth, taught country school before reaching his majority, and also learned telegraphy. While working as an operator he took up the study of landscape architecture and gardening. His practical knowledge of that profession led to his being called to Youngstown in 189o, and for twenty-seven years he was the able lieutenant of his brother Volney in beautifying and developing Mill Creek Park. He served as executive officer of that park. It was his technical ability that gave concrete expression to many of the cherished ideals of Volney Rogers.


January 1, 1880, Bruce Rogers married Mary A.


210 - YOUNGSTOWN AND THE MAHONING VALLEY


March, of Lisbon, Ohio. Their only child, Miss Ada March Rogers, is a graduate of Wellesley College. for two years was principal of the Hubbard High school and is now an instructor in the Rayen High School. Mr. Rogers is a member of the Baptist Church and in politics is a republican.


HENRY F. MCCRONE, one of the progressive business men and public spirited citizens of Struthers, represents a pioneer family of the Mahoning Valley.


He was born on the old home farm in Poland Township, two miles from Struthers, February 22, 1880, son of James B. and Sarah C. (Liddle) McCrone. His grandfather McCrone was of Scotch ancestry and an early settler in Coitsville Township, where James B. McCrone was born. The Liddle family was established in the Mahoning Valley by George Liddle, Sr., who was born and reared in England and settled in Poland Township as early as 1806. He had the experiences and performed the duties of a pioneer and died in advanced years in the late forties. Both he and his wife were earnest members of the Methodist Episcopal Church. He was the father of four children: George, Jr., William, Jane and Ann. The daughter Jane became the wife of William Baker, lived in Geauga County at the time of her death, and her husband subsequently married Margaret Kennedy, and they spent their last years at Poland Center in Mahoning County. Ann Liddle became the wife of John Boyer and died in venerable years in Canfield Township, their only son, Norman J., being now a resident of Ellsworth Township. William Liddle died in early manhood, leaving no children.


George Liddle, Jr., maternal grandfather of Henry F. McCrone, was born in Poland Township March 5, 1812, and died October 3, 1884. He spent his active life as a farmer. In 1841 he married Mary Elizabeth Kennedy, a sister of the Margaret Kennedy mentioned above, a daughter of James Kennedy and also a sister of Walker Kennedy, whose son James has become one of the prominent citizens of Mahoning County. Mary Elizabeth Kennedy was born in Coitsville Township July To, 1820, and died January 30, 1908. The children of George and Mary Elizabeth Liddle were : Sarah C., wife of James B. McCrone, was born May 10, 1845, and died at the age of fifty-five ; Margaret Jane is the wife of F. W. Bradley, of New Bedford, Pennsylvania; Edward B. Liddle lives on the old homestead in Poland Township; Lorena Eleanor lived with her mother in Struthers until her death ; Lenora L., twin sister of Lorena E. died at the age of twenty-three.


James B. McCrone spent his active life as a farmer and livestock dealer, and for a number of years was in the retail meat business, conducting a market at Middlesex and later at Struthers. He finally returned to his farm, but a short time before his death went to the home of his daughter at Canfield and died in two, at the age of seventy-three. His good wife passed away at the age of about fifty-five. Their children were five sons and one daughter : Mary, wife of John Callahan of Canfield; Elmer B., a livestock man in Colorado; Henry F.; Thomas Scott, who owns and operates a large cattle ranch near North Platte, Nebraska; Edward Dallas, who lives at Struthers; James Myron, manager of his brother Henry's business at Poland.


Henry F. McCrone acquired a public school education, learned the butcher's trade in the market of George Knox and subsequently worked in the market of William Stener at Lowellville. During portions of three years he had an interesting experience in Colorado engaged in the range cattle industry in the vicinity of Fort Morgan. In 1908, in partnership with his former employer, William Stener, he opened a meat market on Bridge Street in Struthers, and eighteen months later became sole owner. He has developed the business so that it has grown and increased many fold and is now one of the leading establishments for the handling of groceries and meats in this section of the county. Mr. McCrone moved his store to a specially remodeled building on State Street in May, 1918, and now has a large and well stocked and well equipped store, with five employes. Since 1914 he has conducted a branch grocery and market at Poland with his brother James in charge and with six employes. This business has grown and has an appreciative trade drawn even from some of the representative families of Youngstown.


Mr. McCrone is a democrat in politics, and he and his wife are members of the United Presbyterian Church. In June, 1911, he married Miss Rhoda Kearns of Lewistown, Pennsylvania.



CASSIUS E. CROSS, president of the Service Motor Truck Sales Company, has been a resident of Youngstown many years and was formerly a railroad man, but is best known in a business way through his extensive operations in real estate.


Mr. Cross was born on a farm in the Enon Valley of Lawrence County, Pennsylvania, April 16, 1866, a son of David F. and Mary (Young) Cross. His father, a native of Beaver, Pennsylvania, was a very expert workman in stone and brick and his services were employed all over Western Pennsylvania and Eastern Ohio. He helped build the Chauncey Andrews residence in Youngstown. His later years were spent on a farm in Lawrence County, where he died at the age of sixty-four, his wife passing away at seventy-two. They were members of the Presbyterian Church and he was a democrat. The Cross family has been in America for many generations.

Cassius E. Cross was one of the younger of ten children, eight of whom reached mature years. He finished his education with two years in high school at Mount Jackson. He was sixteen when he began learning telegraphy in the local office of the Pittsburg & Lake Erie at Wampum, Pennsylvania. Subsequently he was employed by the Baltimore & Ohio. He was still a boy when he came to Youngstown. He was stationed at Wurtemberg, and while there had a night shift and was paid $35 a month, his board costing him $8. He put in seventeen years at railroading, and when he left was assistant yardmaster.


Mr. Cross while working for the railroad took considerable interest in local politics and was elected and served two terms in the City Council from the Ninth Ward. He was on the legislation and finance


YOUNGSTOWN AND THE MAHONING VALLEY - 211


committees. Later he became secretary to the city commission, and is one of the few who have resigned from a political job.


His growing real estate and building business caused him to give up politics. His first associate in real estate was E. A. Hegg. They were the first firm to use automobiles in showing their customers about the city. While with the railroad Mr. Cross was drawing a salary of sixty-five dollars a month, and in spite of that low wage he managed to save $500, which he used as an advance payment on a $1,900 house. Since then he has bought and sold many pieces of Youngstown property, and has always realized some modest profit from every transaction. For years he carried on a building program averaging fifteen houses annually, and has thus contributed to the better housing situation in Youngstown. He bought from Emlin P. Thorn a parcel of land through which Breaden Street runs from Oak Hill Avenue to Hillman Street and built a number of houses along the thoroughfare. In February, 1919, Mr. Cross became president of the Service Motor Truck Sales Company, distributors of Service and Commerce trucks, also carrying on a general repair business. He is a member and trustee of the Central Christian Church, and is a democrat in national affairs, being independent locally.


Mr. Cross married Demonia Shiveley, who was born in 1868 and died September 19, 1916. She was born at Perkins Corners, on the Burkett place, which belonged to her father. Her parents were David and Rebecca Shiveley. Mr. and Mrs. Cross ha one son and two daughters. The son, Samuel G., is now associated with his father in business, is a graduate of the Ohio State University and was trained there for the army, receiving a lieutenant's commission. He was sent as an instructor to Camp Hancock, Georgia, being first in the Motor Truck Division at Blacksburg, West Virginia, and later with a Machine Gun Battalion. The daughters are Vera V. and Amber H., the former a graduate of the Rayen High and the latter now in the South High School.


PAUL BOYD HERRIOTT SMITH M. D. Among the men prominently identified with t e mmeec ical profession of the Mahoning Valley, as well as with the civic life of this region, few have gained a higher reputation for skill and dependability than Dr. Paul Boyd Herriott Smith of Lowellville, whose standing is unquestioned with all classes. He was born at New Bedford, Lawrence County, Pennsylvania, on the state line between Pennsylvania and Ohio, February 28, 1878, a son of James D. and Elizabeth E. (Buchanan) Smith. James D. Smith was born on the same farm as his son, and spent his life there, dying at the advanced age of eighty-five years. His wife, who was born at Burgettstown, Washington County, Pennsylvania, died at the age of sixty-seven years. This old farm has been sold, but during the lifetime of James D. Smith it afforded him ample opportunity for the expression of his ideas, and he devoted himself to it, never participating in public life. In his religious belief he found the creed of the United Presbyterian Church satisfying. He and his first wife had the following children: William

J., who lives near Ray, Pennsylvania; Albert E., who is a ranchman of Lawrence, Kansas; Ellis, who died at the age of fifty-nine years from the result of a street car accident, spent his life on the homestead; Lou, who is a farmer of Summit, South Dakota. By his second marriage the children were: Rev. T. F. B., a Presbyterian minister at Central City, Nebraska, who preached all through the Ma- honing Valley, and during the war spent eighteen months in the work of the Young Men's Christian Association, although not sent overseas; and Doctor Smith, who was the youngest born of all the children of his father.


Doctor Smith was graduated from the Grove City College of Grove City, Pennsylvania, in 1901, with the degrees of Bachelor of Arts and Master of Arts from the classical course, and he then took a three years' medical course at the Jefferson Medical College and also studied at the University of Maryland at Baltimore one year, being graduated from the latter institution in 1905, following which he served as interne in the hospital connected with the university one year, 1906. In September, 1906, Doctor Smith established himself in a general medical and surgical practice at Lowellville. and since coming here has allied himself with the County, State and National Medical associations. He belongs to the Chamber of Commerce and responds generously and promptly to all calls made on him for assistance in every improvement which has been inaugurated subsequent to his advent into this community. He is a champion of good roads, and led in the movement which has resulted in the building of the state road through this district. Not only has he served on the village council and school boards, but for four years was a member of the board on public affairs, and during that period assisted in securing for Lowellville electric light, water, sewerage and similar improvements. He is a director of the Lcwellville Bank and interested in other lines, for he is one of the most progressive of the men here, and believes in using his money and influence to build up business concerns. The Presbyterian Church has in him a member and elder. He belongs to the Poland Conntry Club, and is a Blue Lodge and Chapter Mason, a member of Buechner Council, St. John's Commandery No. 20, Knights Templar, belong to the Youngstown organizations of this fraternity, and also to Al Koran Temple of the Mystic Shrine, in the City of Cleveland.


On July 11, 1906, Doctor Smith was united in marriage to Annabel Kelso, of Brookville, Jefferson County, Pennsylvania, and they have three daughters, Nella L., Mary Eloise and Helen Leah. Mrs. Smith is an efficient worker in the various church societies and clubs. The residence owned and occupied by Doctor Smith was originally erected by J. N. Pence, now deceased, but Doctor Smith has rebuilt it and has one of the best homes in the village. Both as a physician and citizen Doctor Smith measures up to the highest standards of American manhood, and by his optimism, ready sympathy and skill wins warm friendships both in the sickroom and outside of it, and is recognized as one of the most forceful figures in his part of the Mahoning Valley.


212 - YOUNGSTOWN AND THE MAHONING VALLEY


WILLIAM H. MARSHALL. Numbered among the representative citizens of Youngstown is William H. Marshall, who has long been identified with the mercantile interests of this section of Mahoning County, and as owner and manager of an art store is carrying on a large and thriving business. A son of the late John Marshall, he was born June 29, 1877, in the building which he now occupies, his birth having occurred in the room which he uses as a work room. The building is located at the corner of Oak Hill Avenue and Marshall Street, the latter having been named in honor of the Marshall family.


John Marshall served as a drummer boy during the Civil war, and spent his last days in the Soldiers' Home, dying at the age of sixty-four years. The maiden name of his wife was Eliza Maria Clute, who died October I, 1915, aged seventy-nine years. Five children were born to them, of whom three are now living, William H., the special subject of this sketch; Cassie Thebald, wife of Charles Kellerman, of Meadville, Pennsylvania ; and Georgina, the wife of O. J. Hammond, formerly general freight agent of the Pittsburgh and Bessemer Railroad, and now traffic manager for the Goodyear Rubber Company at Akron, Ohio. Charles, the oldest son a molder by trade, died in Providence, Rhode Island, aged twenty-four years. Bertie passed away when but fifteen years old.


Completing his early education at the Front Street School, William H. Marshall began work for himself, and at the age of fifteen years entered the china store of J. W. Williams on West Federal Street. He subsequently accepted a position with V. J. Beuhrle, with whom he remained about four years. The ensuing six years Mr. Marshall was connected with the shipping department of the Carnegie Steel Company at the Ohio plant, but as the promotions in the plant depended upon the death rate, and the employes all seemed to be fairly healthy, he gave up his position and opened his art store.


Mr. Marshall had very limited means with which to start, his sole capital having been $100. With that meager sum, and a letter from one of Youngstown's prominent men, he put in a good stock of art goods and was far on the road to prosperity when the memorable flood of 1913 swept his stock of goods down the river. A leading citizen of Youngstown, now dead, urged Mr. Marshall to accept a loan of sufficient money to put him again on his feet. Taking a wise advantage of the offer, Mr. Marshall opened his present establishment, and has since met with gratifying success in his undertaking, his patronage being extensive and remunerative. He has accumulated considerable property, and six years ago built his present home, "Wilgert Lodge," which is acknowledged one of the beauty spots of the Mahoning Valley.


Mr. Marshall married, in 1906, Gertrude L. Crum, of Youngstown, Ohio, a most pleasant and estimable woman. Mr. Marshall is a member of the Kiwanis Club, a social organization and both Mr. and Mrs. Marshall are consistent members of Trinity Methodist Episcopal Church.


Mr. and Mrs. Marshall have had no children of their own, but they have taken the responsibility of raising two children, Eugene and Hazel Marshall, two bright children who have the freedom of a good Christian home, with every advantage that would have been theirs had they entered this home by birth.




ISAIAH W. JENKINS. The true western spirit of progress and enterprise is strikingly exemplified in the lives of such men as Isaiah W. Jenkins, one of Ohio's honored native sons, whose energetic nature and laudable ambitions have enabled him to conquer may adverse circumstances and advance steadily. He has met and overcome obstacles that would have discouraged a man of less determination and has won for himself not only a comfortable competency, but also a prominent place among the enterprising men of this locality. Such a man is a credit to any community and his life forcibly illustrates what energy and consecutive effort can accomplish when directed and controlled by correct principles and high moral resolves, and no man is worthier of specific mention in a volume of the province of the one at hand.

Isaiah W. Jenkins was born in Niles, Ohio, on April 25, 1861, and is the son of John and Margaret (Lovett) Jenkins, both of whom were natives of Wales. John Jenkins came to the United States in 1850, and at once upon his arrival he applied for citizenship papers. He was an ironworker, and was employed as a puddler in the Ward mills at Niles, and later in the Andrews mills. During the Civil war he was a soldier in the One Hundred and Seventy-first Regiment, Ohio Volunteer Infantry, and was wounded in the battle with General Morgan's forces at Cynthiana. He was an earnest republican in his political faith, a Christian in his religious belief and a member of the Independent Order of Odd Fellows. He stood courageously by his honest convictions on moral questions and was one of the two first men in Niles to vote the prohibition ticket. He died in 1911, when eighty-five years of age, and his wife passed away in 1885, at the age of sixty-three years. They became the parents of nine children, of which number six grew to maturity, and four are now living, namely: Mrs. John Evans, of New Philadelphia, Ohio; Mrs. Lewis Davis, of Niles, Ohio; William, of Niles, and Isaiah W. Two deceased children are Mary, who was the wife of Sidney D. Brooks, of Niles, and Lida, who was the wife of George Cross, of Ashtabula Harbor, Ohio.


Isaiah W. Jenkins received his elementary education in the public schools of Niles, after which he went to work in the iron mills. After eight years of strenuous labor there, and the practice of the most rigid economy, he entered the University of Michigan, at Ann Arbor, through which lie financed himself and took the complete course in chemistry. In 1885 Mr. Jenkins associated himself with Doctor Strickland, of Niles, in the drug business, and later was also in partnership with E. A. Wagstaff in the same line. Nine years later he came to Youngstown and opened a drug store on East Federal Street, where he still is located and where through careful attention to every detail of the business and courteous and prompt service for the public he has built up one of the best drug trades in Youngstown. He has been financially successful to a gratifying degree and has become inter-


YOUNGSTOWN AND THE MAHONING VALLEY - 213


ested in several other enterprises, being a member of the board of directors of the Guarantee Bankers' Mortgage Company, of Cleveland, of which he was one of the organizers and was a vice president, of the Cleveland National Fire Insurance Company. He is a director and stockholder in various other important business enterprises, including sugar refining interests.


In 1893 Mr. Jenkins was married to Harriet L. Hadley, the daughter of Thomas and Diana Hadley, of Niles, and they are the parents of a son, Hadley, who is associated with his father in business. Hadley is a graduate in pharmacy, having received his degree from the Ohio Northern University at Ada, Ohio. He was married to Susan Walker, the daughter of William Walker, and they have a son, Oliver W., living, and one, Charles Hadley, who died in childhood. Hadley Jenkins is a member of Western Star Lodge No. 21, Free and Accepted Masons and of Youngstown Chapter No. 93, Royal Arch Masons. e is also a member of the Youngstown Chamber of Commerce and in politics is a republican.


Politically the subject gives his support to the republican ticket, while fraternally he is a member of the Free and Accepted Masons, holding membership with the lodge in Niles, and the Knights of Pythias. He has been successful in business and respected in social life, and as a neighbor he has discharged his duties in a manner becoming a liberal- minded, intelligent citizen, his chief characteristics being energy, determination and honesty of purpose. Because of these qualities and his genial disposition he enjoys the good will and esteem of all who know him.


MICHAEL OBENDORFER. A prominent, prosperous, and eminently respected citizen of Youngstown, Michael Obendorfer, president and general manager of The Obendorfer Company, has been actively associated with the commercial interests of the city since entering his father's store as a clerk in 1871, nearly half a century ago, a longer period of time without doubt than any other individual can boast. A son of Tobias Obendorfer, he was born October 25, 1855, in Mercer County, Pennsylvania, in the vicinity of both Mercer and Sharon.


Tobias Obendorfer was born in 1830 in Bavaria, which became part of the German Empire in 1871, and early in life immigrated to the United States, located in Pennsylvania. Soon after his marriage he came with his wife to Youngstown, making the trip from Enon Valley, that state, in a stage coach, there having been no railroads at that time. He continued his work as a coal miner until 1871, when he opened a general store on East Federal Street, and built up an extensive trade in the mining districts surrounding Youngstown, including Church Hill, Weathersfield, Scripp Hill, Chestnut Ridge, and other near-by places, selling and delivering goods to the people there employed in the various mines. The store has since been moved to other locations, in 1878 to the corner of Federal and Basin streets, from there being moved to 361 East Federal Street. In 1909 the firm erected its present large and conveniently arranged establishment at 103o Himrod

Avenue, and has continued the sale of general merchandise on an extensive scale.


Tobias Obendorfer, the original proprietor of the business, died in 1899, his death being a loss not only to his family but to the firm and to the community in which he had lived and labored, his home having been on Wilson, Avenue. His wife, whose maiden name was Elizabeth Maier, was born in Bavaria in 1836, and died in Youngstown in 1905. They were charter members of each Saint Columba's and Saint Joseph's Catholic Church. Of the nine children born of their union three are now living, as follows : Michael, the subject of this sketch; Mary, widow of Fred Hardesty, of this city; and William, with the Youngstown Engineering and Foundry Company at Youngstown, Ohio.


Educated in Saint Columba's School and Saint Joseph's School, Michael Obendorfer entered his father's store in 1871, as previously mentioned, and by continuous application soon mastered every detail connected with the business, gaining a practical knowledge and experience that has been of inestimable value to him as president and manager of the large mercantile firm of The Obendorfer Company. A man of broad capacity and excellent business and executive ability, Mr. Obendorfer is also connected with various other enterprises of an industrial and financial nature. A member of the City Council from 1877 until 1891, he served on the committee on claims and finance and during the last year was vice president of the council. e has been a director of the City Trust & Savings Company since its organization, and is secretary of the Garland Block & Sand Company.


Mr. Obendorfer married Margaret Adams, a daughter of Theodore and Francisco Adams, who are now living in Struthers, her father being a venerable man of eighty-seven years. She was born in Hubbard, Ohio, the descendant of an old and honored family. Mr. and Mrs. Obendorfer are the parents of seven children, namely : Michael, Jr., secretary and treasurer of The Obendorfer Company; Minnie, wife of George Wasman, of Youngstown; Elmer J., formerly assistant state bank superintendent of Ohio, now with the Peninsular State Bank of Detroit, Michigan; Edward, who was in service during the World war, was ready to go overseas when his wife died, and he was transferred to the quartermaster's department at Camp Sherman, Ohio; Theodore, in his father's store; and Elizabeth and Katherine, at home. Mr. Obendorfer has always worked diligently, and has enjoyed the best of health, a boon that he credits to his habits of industry, and he has never needed the aid of glasses, his eyesight being as good as his health.


CAPT. RAYMOND V. DICKEY. The respect which should always be accorded the brave boys of the United States who left homes and the peaceful pursuits of civil life to give their services, and their lives if need be, in defense of the great principles for which this country entered the World war, is certainly due the gentleman to a brief review of whose life the following lines are devoted. He proved his love and loyalty to his government and the Allied cause in all kinds of situations, on the tiresome


214 - YOUNGSTOWN AND THE MAHONING VALLEY


marches, exposed to inclement weather, and amid the flame and smoke of battle, where the rattle of the musketry mingled with the terrible concussion of the bursting shell and the deep diapason of the cannon's roar made up the sublime but awful chorus of death. To them the world is under a debt of gratitude which it cannot pay, and in centuries yet to be posterity will commemorate their chivalry in fitting eulogy and tell of their deeds in story and in song. Among such as these is numbered the subject of this sketch, and the record he made while in the military service of his country is one of which he has just reason to be proud.


Raymond V. Dickey is a native son of the state now honored by his citizenship, having been born at East Liverpool, Ohio, on the 18th day of April, 1890. His parents, Edwin V. and Ninu (Ritchie) Dickey, were also born in this state, and are now living in Youngstown, where the father is associated with the Sheetz Lumber Company. He is the son of Isaac Dickey, an officer of cavalry under the command of Gen. John A. Logan during the Civil war. The Dickey family moved to Youngstown in 1910.


Raymond V. Dickey was reared in his native town and attended its public schools, graduating from the high school. He then became a student in the Western Reserve University, in which institution he was graduated from the course in pharmacy. Thereafter for a time he was in the drug business in Cleveland, Ohio, but in 1913 he came to Youngstown and opened a pharmacy for Doctor Swaney. Soon afterward he entered the employ of the Buick Automobile Agency in this city, with whom he remained until entering the military service of the United States. In 1914 he enlisted as a private in the Ohio National Guard, in which he at once proved his natural military qualifications to such a degree that on June 24, 1915, he was given a second lieutenantls commission, and on July 13, 1917, he was promoted to a captaincy. His first active field service was on the Mexican border, where he received experience which proved of great value to him in his subsequent service. He served first in Company M, Fifth Regiment, Ohio Infantry, which afterward became the One Hundred and Forty-Fifth United States Infantry, as a part of the Thirty-Seventh Division. Subsequently, in connection with Col, William P. Love, Maj. Wade C. Christy and Capt. Jesse E. Wells, Captain Dickey was ordered to recruit and organize the Tenth Regiment of Ohio Infantry, which was commanded by Col. Charles C. Weybrecht, who had served as adjutant-general of the State of Ohio. The Tenth Regiment was organized and sent to Camp Sheridan, at Montgomery, Alabama, where they remained in training for two months. This command was converted into Machine Gun Battalions One Hundred Thirty-Four, One Hundred Thirty-Five and One Hundred Thirty-Six, and as such they underwent intensive training until January, 1918, when they were sent to Camp Lee, Virginia, and later to Hoboken, New Jersey, where the Thirty-Seventh Division embarked on the Leviathan, and seven days later were landed at Brest, France. Captain Dickey remained on duty with the Thirty-Seventh Division until late in July, 1918, when he was transferred to the Twenty-Sixth ("Yankee") Division. He took an active part in the heavy fighting in the Argonne drive and remained in the front lines until, just prior to the armistice, he received a machine-gun wound and was gassed. As a result of these injuries he was classed as "B-2" and was sent to a classification camp for discharge on account of disability. He was moved from one classification camp to another and finally, on February 22, 1919, he was sent to Brest and returned to the United States on the battleship Connecticut, in command of 25o wounded men. They were twelve days in crossing and landed at Hoboken, where Captain Dickey received an honorable discharge on March 5, 1919.


The captain's brother, Harold C. Dickey, also saw active service on the Mexican border and received a first lieutenant's commission, but just when he was expecting to sail for France he was discharged from the service on account of disability.


In April, 1919, the two brothers formed a partnership and took over the Kissel Automobile Agency and are now operating two garages, one at 253- 255 West Boardman Street and one at 124 West Boardman Street. Energetic and industrious, they have already gained an enviable reputation as a progressive and enterprising firm and are enjoying a large and representative patronage. Although comparatively young in years, Captain Dickey's life has been a busy and successful one, and his record is eminently worthy of perusal by those who would learn the intrinsic essence of individuality and its influence in molding a successful career. Genial and approachable, he has a host of warm personal friends and enjoys to a marked degree the esteem and confidence of the entire community.




HERMAN F. DUESING. While success cannot be achieved without unflagging industry, the futility of effort is of ten noticeable in the business world and results from the fact that it is not combined with sound business judgment. Many a man who gives his entire life to toil, earnest and unremitting, never acquires a competence, but when his labor is well directed, prosperity always follows. My. Duesing is one whose work has been supplemented by careful management, and today he is among those who have triumphed over adverse conditions and won success. He is not only identified with various business interests of Youngstown, but has also in other ways been an active factor in the civic life of the city.


Herman F. Duesing was born in Germany on the 7th day of April, 1867, and is the son of Fred and Louise (Vogelsang) Duesing. The family came to the United States when the subject of this sketch was about two years of age, locating in New Castle, Pennsylvania, in 1869. The father was employed in the mills there until 1872, when he came to Youngstown and became janitor of the Covington Street school, retaining that position for fifteen years. Since that time he has been connected with the Brier Hill mills in various capacities and is now employed in the general offices of the company, working every day. He is now eighty years of age, and his wife, seventy-nine years. They are members of the Lutheran Church at Brier Hill. Of their six children, two sons and four daughters, Herman F. is the oldest.


YOUNGSTOWN AND THE MAHONING VALLEY - 215


Herman F. Duesing received his educational training in the Wood Street and Brier Hill schools, and at the age of fourteen years he entered the employ of Weller & Yagen, who operated a store at Brier Hill. This store was afterwards sold to Mr. Brenner and in 1890 became the property of the subject. Mr. Duesing started in business with a very limited cash capital, but he did have a good credit, and both were intelligently used, with very gratifying results, for he has been successful in all his efforts. For a number of years the business was incorporated as the Herman F. Duesing Mercantile Company, of which Mr. Duesing was president, but recently he has taken over the entire interests and the active management of the business. For some years he also served as general manager of the Simon Packing Company.


In 1892 Mr. Duesing was married to Bertha Bayer, the daughter of Captain John Bayer, and they are the parents of two children, Vera May, the wife of William G. Kuhlman, claim agent of the Youngstown Sheet and Tube Company, and Fred H.


Politically Mr. Duesing is a stanch supporter of the democratic party and has taken an active interest in local public affairs. e served with efficiency for nine years as a member of the Board of Education and also served two years as director of public service under Mayor Craven's second administration. Fraternally he is a member of the Masonic order, in which he has attained the Knight Templar degree in the York Rite and the thirty-second degree in the Scottish Rite; the Ancient Arabic Order Nobles of the Mystic Shrine; Lodge 55, Independent Order of Odd Fellows; Lodge No. 55, Benevolent and Protective Order of Elks, and Robert E. Johnson Lodge, Knights of Pythias. e is a member of Grace Lutheran Church, which he is serving as deacon. Mr. Duesing has acted well his part in life, and while primarily interested in his own affairs he has not been unmindful of the interests of others, as his efforts to advance the public good and promote the welfare of his fellow men abundantly attest. e is a splendid example of the virile, progressive, self-made man who believes in doing well whatever he undertakes, a man of keen discernment and sound judgment, broad minded and eminently fair and just in all his relations with his fellow men, and therefore he enjoys their confidence and good will.


WILLIAM LIGGETT, a retired resident of Lowellville, was born in Poland Township, February 3, 841, son of William and Rosanna (Jackson) Liggett. His father was a native of County Tyrone, Ireland, and came to the United States at the age of seventeen, soon finding his way to the country of Western Pennsylvania and Eastern Ohio. Later he had three of his sisters come over: Elizabeth, who married John Crawford and lived and died in Mahoning Valley; Jane M., who married Samuel Cross, of Butler County, where both died; and Mary, who died young.


William Liggett, Sr., learned the stone mason and brick mason's trade, was also a plasterer, and followed those occupations most of his years. About 840 he located at Lowellville. He had previously helped build the canal locks. He was one of the earnest members of the United Presbyterian Church, and a citizen of unquestionable patriotism. He died at the age of seventy-one. On December 5, 1826, he married Rosanna Jackson, who was born March 10, 1798, and died April 19, 1855. William Liggett, Sr., was born October 3, 1801. His second wife was Margaret, who died December 31, 1875, aged seventy-eight. The children of William Liggett, Sr., were: Joseph, born September so, 1828; James, born November 3, 1830; Nancy, born May 21, 1832; Jane, born February 15, 1834; John, who died in childhood; Margaret Ann, born August 4, 1838; and William, born February 3, 1841. The son Joseph lived at Lowellville, conducted a nursery on top of the hill, and died January 26, 1904. He married in 1864 Eliza Erwin, and they had no children. The son James married Harriet G. Richardson, and on January s, 1862, married his second wife, Isabel Sexton. He died November 28, 1915, and his wife, Isabel, on January 22, 1917. The two children of James by his first wife are John W., of South Dakota, and Mrs. Harriet Buchanan, of Grove City, Pennsylvania. James Liggett's children by his wife Isabel are Lizzie, Mina, Anna, wife of Lyman Stacy, Mary, Joseph and Samuel, twins. Nancy Liggett became the wife of Alexander Barclay, who was a carpenter at Youngstown, and she died January 18, 1904. Jane Liggett was married to Zalmon T. Matthews, of Kinsman, Trumbull County, and died March 8, 1913. Margaret Ann became the wife of John McClain, a miller at Lowellville, who afterward moved to Newcastle, Pennsylvania, where she died August 1, 1896.


William Liggett, Jr., as married February 24, 1876, to Elizabeth J. Jr.,Workman, who was born at Steubenville, Ohio, October 6, 1844. For forty years William Liggett conducted a carriage and wagon shop at Lowellville.


In 1863 he enlisted in Company E of the Second Ohio Cavalry, and saw some very strenuous service as a cavalryman in both the East and West. He was with the Federal troops operating in Tennessee and Missouri, also in Virginia, was with Sheridan in the Shenandoah Valley campaign, and also under Custer. Since 1901 Mr. William Liggett hag been living retired. He is a republican, was a charter member of old Reno Post at Lowellville, now discontinued; and he now attends the Post at Youngstown. William Liggett was made a Mason in 1870, and is affiliated with Western Star Lodge at Youngstown.


The two children of William Liggett are Gertrude M., who died July 6, 1908 the wife of Charles Stoner ; and David William, a mill man living at Lowellville.


JOHN ARMSTRONG COOPER, representing an old Mahoning County family, has his country home in Coitsville Township, four miles east of the Youngstown courthouse.

He was born in Coitsville, a mile and a quarter southeast of the village on the old David Cooper farm, March is, 1860, son of Robert and Catherine (Buchanan) Cooper. Robert Cooper was born on the same farm in 1827, and died November 12, 1896.


216 - YOUNGSTOWN AND THE MAHONING VALLEY


His parents were David and Rebecca (Armstrong) Cooper. David Cooper, a native of Ireland, was an early settler in Mahoning County. His farm was cut into five tracts for his sons John, David, William, Armstrong and Robert, and all these lands have since been sold out of the family. Robert Cooper remained on his portion until his death, and had increased his holdings to a hundred and fifty-four acres, having inherited fifty acres from his bachelor brother John. Robert's wife died in 1893, having been born in 1831. There were four children in the family, David Perry, father of Judge Dal Cooper ; Laura Rebecca, wife of N. B. Carlton, of Girard; Sarah Jane, who became a professional nurse and died at the age of fifty; and John A.


John A. Cooper lived at home until his marriage on December 24, 1885, to Eliza Jane Jackson, daughter of Joseph M. and Rebecca (Lorain) Jackson. She was born in Hubbard Township, and at the age of five years was taken by her parents to Coitsville Township, where her father conducted a farm, sawmill and coal bank. Joseph M. Jackson served as county commissioner at the time of the removal of the county seat from Canfield to Youngstown and during the construction of the Youngstown courthouse. At an earlier date in politics he was a green- backer, was a republican, and finally, feeling that the party had deserted him, he acted with the democrats. He was once candidate for sheriff and also was on the republican ticket for the Legislature. He died March 3, 1896, and his wife July 19, 1908.


At the time of his marriage Mr. Cooper rented a farm, then bought part of the Nicholas Jacobs share, a place on which he spent twelve years, following which he bought his father's old farm, but soon sold that and came to his present place. Mrs. Cooper inherited fifty acres from her father and together they added another eighty acres. The present farm contains only forty acres. For twenty years Mr. Cooper was a successful breeder of Red Polled cattle and exhibited his stock at many local and state fairs, winning some of the first honors, particularly in the New Jersey Fair. Mr. Cooper has never sought public office. He and his wife have two daughters. The older, Mabel Lorain, is the wife of Clifford Brownlee, and they live on a part of the Cooper farm. Their two children are Catherine and Ruth. The second daughter, Edna, is the wife of Leroy Campbell, a farmer and teacher, being principal of the schools at Scienceville. Mr. and Mrs. Campbell have one child, Elizabeth.




NELSON CRANDALL during his active lifetime was during his active lifetime was closely associated with many of the prominent business men of Youngstown, and his energies were strongly impressed upon some of the enterprises that are regarded as foundation stones in Youngstown's present greatness.


He was born January 4, 1826, and came to Youngstown at the age of twelve years. His parents, Israel and Pamela (Cook) Crandall, were residents of Chenango County, New York. The father was a wagon maker, and he and his wife in later years followed their children to Youngstown and died here.


Four married sisters were living in Youngstown before Nelson Crandall came. They were Mrs. Francis Barclay, Mrs. Joseph Barclay, Mrs. Ransford Percival and Mrs. Asel Medbury. Nelson Crandall lived in the home of Francis Barclay. The two Barclay brothers were local merchants and employed Nelson in their store. He also continued his education in the public school then on the Diamond, and attended a night school. After his early business training he opened a general store at Girard, where he was associated with William Crawford. When that store was destroyed by fire he entered the old Brier Hill Iron & Coal Company, and for many years was secretary and treasurer of that, one of the prominent industries of the older Youngstown. He became well known to Governor Tod and served as secretary of the Tod estate. Nelson Crandall, associated with enry Tod and John Stambaugh, in 1870 built the first Tod House. Mr. Crandall was active in business for nearly forty years, finally retiring from the Brier Hill Iron & Coal Company about 1884. In the meantime he had acquired a farm in the northern part of the present city of Youngstown, and part of this bears the name Crandall Park.


Mr. Crandall attended the Methodist Church, was a stanch republican, but had no inclination for the turmoil of politics. He possessed many friends, and the integrity of his character made him a real man in the community. He was affiliated with the Independent Order of Odd Fellows.

February 18, 1851, Mr. Crandall married Miss Sarah Stambaugh. Her father was the pioneer John Stambaugh. She died June 1, 1877. There were four children : Julia, who died in infancy, James Ford, Arabelle and Charles Nelson. The three survivors are unmarried and live together at Youngstown. Charles is a Knight Templar and thirty- second degree Scottish Rite Mason and a Shriner.


SIDNEY DELAMAR JACKSON, who was admitted to the bar in 1877, has for over forty years been one of Youngstown's hardest working lawyers. The sum of his work has been the real achievement and reputation as a lawyer. His career has not been brilliant or conspicuous at any one point, but has rather been a steady continuous output of sound legal talent and successful work in behalf of his clientage.


Mr. Jackson was born at Hubbard in Trumbull County, Ohio, April 9, 1855, a son of Joseph M. and Rebecca L. Jackson. His great-grandfather, Joseph Jackson, was born in Northern Ireland, and was an early settler in Mahoning County. The grandfather, John Jackson, was born in that county in 1800, was a cooper by trade and died in 1868. Joseph M. Jackson was born in 1828, was a farmer and lumberman, and was captain of Company C of the One Hundred and Seventy-First Ohio Infantry.


Sidney DeLamar Jackson spent his early life chiefly on a farm, attended country schools, the academy at Poland, and the Grand River Institute at Austinburg, was a teacher and studied law with Hon. D. M. Wilson at Youngstown. He was elected prosecuting attorney of Mahoning County in 1896. His first wife was Mary E. Cushing, who died in 1885. In 1890 he married Miss Lelia G. McBurney, a daughter of Henderson McBurney. The three chil-


YOUNGSTOWN AND THE MAHONING VALLEY - 217


dren of their union are Joseph H., Mary Lorain and Sidney DeLamar, Jr. Mr. Jackson is a republican in politics and has long been identified with civic and fraternal affairs in his home city.


HARRY L. ROWND is distinctively one of the representative business men of Youngstown, and today he is held in deservedly high esteem among the business men of his adopted city.


Harry L. Rownd, first vice president of the Republic Iron and Steel Company, is a native son of the old Buckeye state, having been born at Zanesville, Ohio, on October 27, 1867, and is the son of Robert M. and Susan E. (Thompson) Rownd. When he was about seven years of age the family moved to Columbus, Ohio, where he was reared to manhood and educated in the public schools. He then became a student in the Ohio Wesleyan University at Delaware, .and while there became a member. of the Greek-letter college fraternity Phi Delta Theta. For about three years after leaving college he was employed as a teller in the Clinton National Bank at Columbus, and followed this by several years employment with the Columbus Bridge Company.

In May, 1899, Mr. Rownd became identified with the Republic Iron and Steel Company, which had just been organized at Chicago. His record with this great corporation is a record of faithful service in every position occupied by him and of recognition of this loyalty by successive promotions. He was made assistant treasurer, followed successively by the offices of general auditor, secretary, secretary and treasurer, secretary and general auditor, and vice president and treasurer, while since 1916 he has occupied the position of first vice president. His success has been the reward of the application of mental qualifications of a high order to the affairs of business, combined with keen perceptions of mental activity that enabled him to grasp the opportunities that presented themselves. This he has done with success and, what is more important, with honor.


In 1890 Mr. Rownd was married to Cora Packard, of Columbus, Ohio, and to them have been born two children, Frank L. and Helen L. Mr. Rownd and his family are members of the Methodist Episcopal Church. Politically he is a stanch supporter of the republican party, with marked progressive tendencies, as are so many men today of that virile type of which Theodore Roosevelt was so splendid an example. Socially he is a member of the Youngstown Club, the Youngstown Country Club and the Duquesne Club of Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. Genial and courteous in his relations with others, he has the esteem of all persons connected with the company, and because of his success and his splendid personal qualities he is highly regarded by all who know him.


JOHN R. THOMAS. It is a pleasure to investigate `the career of a successful self-made man. Peculiar honor attaches to that individual who, beginning the great struggle of life alone and unaided, gradually overcomes unfavorable environment, removes one by one the obstacles in the pathway of success and by the master strokes of his own force and vitality succeeds in forging his way to the front and winning for himself a position of esteem and influence among his fellow men. Such was the record, briefly stated, of the late John R. Thomas, who at the time of his death in 1891 was one of the most highly respected citizens and business men of Youngstown.


John R. Thomas was born in Paris Township, Portage County, Ohio, on March 1, 1841, and was the son of William D. and Ann (Davis) Thomas, both of whom were natives of Wales. They immigrated to the United States in the '3os, three months being consumed in the long and tiresome trip by sailing vessel. They landed in this country in debt, unacquainted with the language and customs of the people, but with a firm determination to succeed. They first located at Kent, Ohio, where Mr. Thomas found employment with Mr. Kent, the founder of the town. By wise management and close economy they were enabled to save their means and eventually Mr. Thomas bought a farm in Paris Township, Portage County, where they passed the remainder of their days. It was there that John R. Thomas was born and grew to manhood. He married Hannah Johns, the daughter of 'Squire David Johns, who lived in the neighboring Township of Palmyra, where he held the office of justice of the peace and was a noted character of that period. John R. Thomas followed farming and cheese making for many years, in which he was successful, and there reared his family, consisting of five sons and four daughters. His great desire was to give his children better opportunities in life than the farm alone afforded, and with this in view he leased a basement on East Federal Street, Youngstown, on June 13, 1887, and opened a wholesale market for cheese, operating this market in connection with farming. His business judgment in this enterprise" was abundantly justified in the final outcome of the business so modestly begun. After his death the business was continued by his sons and has grown to be one of the largest wholesale grocery houses of Youngstown, being now conducted under the name of The Thomas Company. Politically Mr. Thomas gave his support td the democratic party, but was exceedingly liberal in his views and had no ambition for public office. He had an abiding faith in the future of the youth of the land and was an earnest and persistent advocate of both public and private schools. He possessed one quality characteristic of his nationality, namely, a fondness for and knowledge of music, and for many years conducted singing schools, having had between one hundred and one hundred and fifty pupils from the surrounding neighborhood, and he also rendered effective and appreciated service as church and Sunday school chorister. He was a man of deep moral convictions and was an earnest advocate of all that obtained for good citizenship. He was a member of no church, but professed a firm faith in the omnipotence of Deity. Fraternally he was a member of the Free and Accepted Masons. To him and his wife were born the following children : Seymour died at the age of twenty years. B. Frank will be mentioned in a later paragraph. Arnold D. married Elizabeth Gabriel and has two children, elen and John Elbert. Arnold Thomas drew up the by-laws and was the organizing president of the first successful Chamber of Commerce in Youngstown. Miriam L.


218 - YOUNGSTOWN AND THE MAHONING VALLEY


for sixteen years has been a teacher in the Rayen High School, having charge of the teaching of French. Anna B. is assistant librarian of the Youngstown Public Library. William D. married Bessie Foster and at present is chief engineer of the Bessemer Limestone Company. George B. is a graduate of Ohio State University and taught school ; he married Mary Wright and has two children, George B., Jr., and Hannah. He was a lieutenant in the United States service on the Mexican border and at the outbreak of the World war was employed by the Government on electrical specialties. It is a matter of record that he had more to do with the development and perfection of the instrument by which a submarine within sixteen miles could be located than any other one man. Amelia J. is a teacher in the Youngstown kindergarten schools. Tilla P. is a teacher of mathematics and French in the public high school at Summit, New Jersey. The mother of these children survives and is living in Youngstown. It is noteworthy that seven of the children in this family engaged in teaching school, all having received excellent educational advantages and all of them occupying eminently respectable positions in the community. The two oldest sons are now conducting The Thomas Company, which is now rated as one of the leading wholesale houses of Youngstown.


B. Frank Thomas has since the death of his father been the head of the family and has very successfully carried on the work founded by his father. His first employment was as a school teacher, and at that time he entertained an ambition to take up the study and practice of law. However, the growing need of his father for assistance in business determined him to abandon his plan and he devoted himself to the business. He possesses natural aptitude for commercial pursuits, and the splendid growth which the business has enjoyed of late years has been largely due to his sound judgment and progressive policy. Mr. Thomas is not selfishly bound up in his own business interests, but takes a deep interest in the general welfare of the community in which he lives, giving his support to every worthy movement tending to the upbuilding and improvement of the city in any way.


Mr. Thomas was married to Irma Brenner, and they have two children, Margaret L. and John H. He is a member of the Masonic fraternity, being past master of Western Star Lodge No. 21, Free and Accepted Masons ; past high priest of Youngstown Chapter No. 93, Royal Arch Masons ; past commander of St. John's Commandery No. 20, Knights Templar ; past thrice potent master of Youngstown Lodge of Perfection, and is a thirty-third degree member of the Ancient and Accepted Scottish Rite. He is a man of sociable and kindly nature and is popular with all who are associated with him, possessing the confidence and good will of the entire community.




WARNER H. SULLIVAN. When Mr. Sullivan came to Youngstown he brought with him a record of more than thirty years of practical, continuous and faithful service as a railroad man, almost entirely with the lines and divisions constituting the modern system of the New York Central lines. Mr. Sullivan is now superintendent of the Franklin Division of the New York Central Railroad at Youngstown.


His father was a railroad man before him, and the family record in all the generations is an honorable one. This branch of the Sullivans lived for several generations in Connecticut. The first to come to the Ohio Western Reserve was Rev. Potter Sullivan, a Methodist circuit rider, who traveled all over the counties of Northeastern Ohio, enduring the hardships and trials connected with the work of carrying the Gospel to the isolated communities.


Among his children was John G. Sullivan, grandfather of Warner. John G. Sullivan, who married a member of the Hopkins family, likewise pioneers of Ohio, was a farmer and lived at Geneva in Ashtabula County. His son, Charles H. Sullivan, was born in Pennsylvania and was reared by an uncle. Warner Hopkins. in Ashtabula County. He early took up railroading with the old Lake Shore and Michigan Southern Railway. He was on the division known as the Cleveland, Painsville & Eastern, at first as a brakeman and later as a conductor. At that time this branch of the Lake Shore was operated by five train crews. During the Civil war he was with the Ohio Artillery, was once surrounded by the enemy, but made his escape after spending weeks in swamps. At the close of the war he resumed his old position as a railroad man, and became one of the veterans in the service of the New York Central lines. He died at Erie, Pennsylvania, March 13, 191o. He acted independently in politics and was a member of the Methodist Church.


Warner H. Sullivan, one of the three children of Charles H. and Frances (Olmstead) Sullivan, was born in Geneva, Ohio, December 29, 1871. He spent most of his boyhood in Erie, Pennsylvania, attending grammar and high schools there. Circumstances and his own independent spirit put him early into the battle of life. At the age of sixteen he went to work for the Lake Shore and Michigan Southern Railway, and has been with that branch of the New York Central lines ever since. His first duties were as call boy in the yards at Erie, and successive stages in his promotion and service were as a numbertaker, train starter, in charge of coaling engines, locomotive fireman between Erie and Buffalo, freight brakeman between Erie and Cleveland (and during this time was "loaned" to the engineers department in charge of a large gravel pit), clerk and general utility man in the office of the superintendent of the Eastern Division, assistant yardmaster at Buffalo, and yardmaster and night general yardmaster at Buffalo ; yardmaster in charge of docks and terminals at Ashtabula Harbor, being on duty there during the reconstruction period ; at Chicago was trainmaster of the Western Division; was assigned trainmaster of the Toledo Division with headquarters at Toledo, and in the same position was moved to Cleveland, though assigned especially to the Cleveland terminals. From Cleveland Mr. Sullivan went back to his home city of Erie as assistant superintendent of the Erie Division, and on June 15, 1917, came to Youngstown as assistant superintendent in charge of operation of the Franklin Division. Since January, 1918, he has been superintendent of this division.


YOUNGSTOWN AND THE MAHONING VALLEY - 219


Though briefly stated, this is a record of service that entitled Mr. Sullivan to the high rank he enjoys among railroad men. e is a Knight Templar Mason and Mystic Shriner, and is a member of the Shriners' Club and the Youngstown Automobile Club. September 21, 'goo, he married elen E. Lennihan. Mrs. Sullivan died December 31, 1914, leaving one daughter, Margaret Frances.


RENICK M. BELL. The representative citizen of Youngstown whose name appears above has been distinctively the architect of his own fortunes, has been true and loyal in all the relations of life and stands as a type of that sterling manhood which ever commands respect and honor. He is a man who would have won his way in any locality where fate might have placed him, for he has sound judgment, coupled with great energy and business tact, together with upright principles, all of which make for success wherever and whenever they are rightfully and persistently applied. By reason of these principles he has won and retained a host of friends in whatever community he is known.


Renick M. Bell was born at Lyons, Kansas, on the loth day of December, 1873, and is a son of Josiah R. and Mary (Magoffin) Bell, both of whom were born and reared in the vicinity of Chillicothe, Ohio. Renick Bell received his education in the public schools of his native community. He was then variously employed for several years, and eventually reversed Horace Greeley’s advice, going East, so that at the time of the breaking out of the Spanish- American war he was employed as a shipping clerk in a brush factory at Toledo, Ohio. He enlisted and, became a corporal iu Company L, Sixth Regiment, Ohio Volunteer Infantry, with which he was sent to Cuba, being stationed at Cienfuegos when the war ended. He was then given his honorable discharge, but remained in Cuba thereafter some eighteen months, being employed as a civilian clerk for the United States Government. In 1901 he returned to the United States and found employment with the Babcock & Wilcox Company, boiler manufacturers at Barberton, Ohio, remaining there until 1909, except six months during which time he was sent by his company to the (then) Indian Territory, as secretary and treasurer of their subsidiary branch in that field. In 1909 Mr. Belt came to Youngstown and became connected with the General Fireproofing Company. His first relation with this well-known concern was as manager of the cost department, but since 1915 he has been the secretary and treasurer of the company. He is a man of more than ordinary business qualifications and has to a marked degree won the confidence and esteem of his business associates, as well as the good will and respect of the entire community.


In 1904 Mr. Bell was united in marriage with Lena Shafer, of Barberton, Ohio, and to them two daughters have been born, Elizabeth and Dorothy. Mr. Bell is a member and elder of the First Presbyterian Church and, socially, is identified with the Youngstown Country Club.


JOHN J. BRANT, auditor of the Youngstown Sheet & Tube Company and one of.the reliable and efficient men of his calling, has been a resident of Youngstown since 1892. He was born on a farm in Lawrence County, Pennsylvania, near Harrisburg, on January 10, 1865. He is one of seven children, five now living, who were born to the marriage of George Brant and Julia A. Harlan. The latter was a granddaughter of Jonathan Harlan, a soldier of the American Revolution, who came from Chester County to Lawrence County, Pennsylvania, about 1800, and Harlansburg was named in his honor. George Brant was born in Lawrence County, and spent the latter part of his life on a farm. In 1851 he went overland to California in search of gold, and had some wonderful experiences, as did the majority of those venturesome explorers. After eight years of hard work in which he sought to wrest a fortune from nature George Brant returned home by way of the Isthmus of Panama, and on his arrival in New York City had his first sight of a locomotive engine.


John J. Brant grew up on his father's farm and attended the public schools of his neighborhood. After leaving school he began working, for railroads and was thus engaged for five or six years, serving in various capacities, including that of telegrapher. In 1892 he became a clerk for the Union Iron & Steel Company at Youngstown, Ohio, and remained with that concern until it became a part of the Carnegie Company in 1899. Mr. Brant then engaged with the Republic Iron & Steel Company, but left it in 1902 to ally himself with the Youngstown Sheet & Tube Company, with which he has since been connected. For some years he has been auditor of this corporation and is one of its most "trusted and dependable men. Mr. Brant is a thirty-second degree Scottish Rite Mason, and also a member of Al Koran Temple of the Mystic Shrine at Cleveland, Ohio. He belongs to the Youngstown Club and is one of the best known men in the city.


On December 24, 1891, Mr. Brant was united in marriage with Miss Anna R. Sprinkle, of Youngstown, and they have three sons, namely : Arthur M., Howard J. and Frank H. The two older sons, Arthur and Howard, served in the World war, the former as a master engineer in the Chemical War Service; and the latter as a second lieutenant in the famous First Division, was for five weeks on the front line and was wounded while in the vicinity of Charpentry, France.


FRANK H. RAY. While his activities as a merchant have been closely identified with, the very modern period of Youngstown's commercial life, Frank H. Ray has some personal recollections of this section of Eastern Ohio strongly flavored with actual pioneer conditions and involving many of the old time pioneer personalities, including his own family connections, some of whom were among the very first settlers.


His father was William Ray and his grandfather was also William, of Scotch-Irish ancestry. Grandfather William Ray was born in Butler County, Pennsylvania, while William Ray, Jr., was born in the same county in 1825 and died in 1872.


William Ray, Jr., married Marietta Austin, who died in 1903. er maternal grandparents were Joseph and Charlotte Bishop, who after their mar-


220 - YOUNGSTOWN AND THE MAHONING VALLEY


riage in Maryland made the journey to Ohio on horseback, and stopped with relatives near Youngstown until they could build their log cabin. They were among the first settlers in their community. Joseph Bishop lived to the age of ninety-seven and his wife to eighty-eight.


Marietta Austin's father was Harmon W. Austin, who was born in New Haven County, Connecticut, in 1804. He had the genius of a typical Yankee and when he came to Ohio he paid the expenses of the trip selling Yankee notions on the road. He settled in Boardman Township of Mahoning County, and became a manufacturer of harness and brooms, supplying not only the local trade but taking boat loads of his commodities down the Ohio River to New Orleans. He died in 1851.


Frank H. Ray was born at Boardman, Ohio, December 3, 1852, and was the oldest son of his parents. As a boy he remembers a time when there was but one frame house between Cook's Corners and Youngstown, and when Youngstown itself was an unpaved country village, and when the most imposing buildings were hardly more than two stories. His early youth was spent at the historic and cultured Town of Poland, and from the public schools he finished his education in Poland Seminary. Mr. Ray spent many days of his boyhood and early youth wandering over the country. He enjoyed one of the typical sports of the time, coon hunting, and to this day retains a deep love of outdoor life. His father rebuilt the old Morse Mill at Poland, a mill that was patronized by farmers for miles around.


After leaving school Frank H. Ray clerked in a store and then, at the insistence of his father, learned the carpenter's trade. After completing his apprenticeship he returned to the store, later started a small business of his own, and after that went on the road as a traveling salesman. e realized his ambition to become the best salesman for his house, and when he retired in 1897 he became manager of the Valley Store. Mr. Ray in 1904 helped organize the Central Store Company of Youngstown, a concern that in fifteen years has become one of the largest mercantile corporations in the Mahoning Valley.


Mr. Ray married for his first wife Mary Elizabeth Dennison, daughter of William and Elizabeth P. Dennison, of Youngstown. He has two daughters. Helen Austin became the wife of P. C. Warren, living in Evanston, Illinois, and they have two children, Elizabeth and enry. Mary McMaster Ray married Robert D. Stitt, of Youngstown, Ohio, and they have one son, Frank Thomas Stitt. They live in California. In 1897 Mr. Ray married for his second wife Miss Gabrielle Lightner, of Youngstown.


TOD FAMILY. Some of the most extensive material interests and some of the leading personalities in the modern life of the Youngstown district are associated with the old and dignified Tod name. The life and character of several of the family, including Ohio's great war governor, David Tod, are set forth in detail on other pages. It is appropriate here to outline briefly the several generations of the family by means of which the relationship of various individuals may be more easily ascertained.


During the eighteenth century the Tod family lived in the shire of Perth, Scotland. Robert Tod was born and—spent his life there. e married Isabella Low. One of their children was David Tod, who was born in Perthshire and who came to America in 1746. He lived for some years at Suffolk, Connecticut. He married in 1772 Rachel Kent. They were the parents of six children, named George, Samuel, Isabella, John, Charlotte Low and David Low.


Among these children the history of Youngstown is chiefly concerned with George Tod, who was born December 11, 1773, and died at Brier Hill, Ohio, April 11, 1841. He graduated from Yale College in 1795, and for several years practiced law in New Haven, Connecticut. He first came to the Western Reserve of Ohio in 1800, and in 1801 moved his family to Youngstown, then a small collection of cabins on the eastern edge of the wilderness. In the year of his arrival, being a young man whose talents were easily identified, he was appointed secretary for the territory of Ohio by Governor St. Clair. In 1802 he was elected the first clerk of Youngstown Township. In 1804 he was chosen state senator from Trumbull County, and in 1806 was elected a member of the Supreme Court of Ohio by the Legislature. In that notable group of public leaders produced by the old Western Reserve the name and character of George Tod will always stand out conspicuously. During the War of 1812-he was commissioned major, was promoted to lieutenant-colonel, and for distinguished service at the battles of Fort Meigs and Sackett's Harbor was promoted to. colonel. After the war he resumed his law practice. He was elected and served one term as prosecuting attorney of Trumbull County, and in 1815 was elected president judge of the Third Judicial Circuit. He was on the Circuit Bench until 1829, and after that continued his extensive law business.


In 1797 Judge George Tod had married Sally Isaacs. Their seven children were Charlotte Low, Jonathan Ingersoll, Mary Isaacs, David, Julia Ann, Grace Ingersoll and George, Jr.


The career of Governor David Tod is the subject of a special article reserved for other pages. At this point should be noted only his descendants. David Tod married Maria Smith, and their seven children were Charlotte, John, Henry, George, William, Grace and Sallie. His son John married and had a son David and five daughters. George Tod was born in 1840, became a lawyer and was a Union soldier in the Civil war. William Tod, born July 30, 1843, died April 27, 1905. He was prominent in the Youngstown district in the foundry business. In 1869 he married Frances Barnhisel, and left two sons, David and Frederick.


HENRY TOD, a son of Governor David Tod, was born Thorn at Warren. Ohio, June 14, 1838, and died at Youngstown, February 20, 1905. He was one of the most conspicuous members of the Tod family in the upbuilding of the Youngstown industries. During his early twenties he had charge of the Brier Hill furnaces. In 1870, with John Stambaugh, Jr., he














YOUNGSTOWN AND THE MAHONING VALLEY - 221


built the old Tod House. In 1875 he helped organize the Second National Bank of Youngstown, and wisely and ably directed the institution as its first and only president during the twenty-nine years of its existence. After it was merged with the Firsl National Bank he became vice president of the latter. For nearly forty years he was a director of the Mahoning National Bank, for many years was vice president of the Brier Hill Iron and Coal Company, and supplied the financial genius for many leading industries of the Mahoning Valley. A man of wealth he was noted for his broadminded generosity, and the integrity of his character was worth as much to Youngstown's development as the extent of his financial capital.


May 26, 1869, Henry Tod married Dillie Pollock. She died December 28, 1878, the mother of two sons, John and Henry. On August 9, 1892, Henry Tod married Lucretia Van Fleet.


John Tod, a son of enry and Dillie (Pollock) Tod, was born in Youngstown, November 29, 1870, and upon him in recent years have rested many of the responsibilities involved in handling the Tod interests in this section of Ohio. e received his education at Brooks Military Academy in Cleveland and was a member of the class of 1894 of Cornell University. After leaving college he assisted in organizing the Falcon Bronze Company, and was its active manager six years. From 'got to 1904 he was secretary and treasurer of the Republic Rubber Company. In 1904 he was elected president of the American Belting Company. e is president of the Bessemer Limestone Company, of the Arrel Limestone Company, of the Youngstown Carriage Company, the David Tod Land Company, is first vice president of the Brier Hill Iron and Coal Company, a director of the First National Bank, Dollar Savings & Trust Company, Union Safe Deposit Company, the Republic Rubber Company, Brier Hill Coke Company, Youngstown Opera House Company, the Hood Company. all of these being prominent corporations at Youngstown. Mr. John Tod is also executor of the estates of David, Henry, George and Sallie Tod.


He is an active member and in 1914-16 was president of the Youngstown Country Club. On December 10, 895, he married Alice Thayer Wood, daughter of Colonel Frank and Alice Crawford Thayer Wood.


Henry Tod, a brother of John Tod just mentioned, was born in Youngstown, November 11, 1877. He was accidentally killed October 8, 1902. At that time he was assistant superintendent of the Brier Hill Iron and Coal Company. His life was unfortunately brief, but it gave him time to demonstrate unmistakable abilities as a business executive, and also that genius which seems to preside in the Tod family for making and acquiring friends.


WILLIAM TOD, whose place in the Tod family relationship has been elsewhere represented, being the youngest son of Governor David Tod, and a grandson of the founder of the family in the Western Reserve, George Tod, was a conspicuous figure in the founding and development of several industries that are the very cornerstone of Youngstown's commercial history.


He was born at Warren, Ohio, July 30, 1843, and finished his education at Columbus while his father was governor of Ohio. His early experience was that of a practical foundryman, and in the foundry business he laid the basis of his fortune. He was one of the original factors in the company which organized and built the foundry on the later site of the Youngstown Steel Casting Works. He was also associated with John Stambaugh in the Hamilton foundry. He was also a director of the Brier Hill Iron and Coal Company and was president of the William Tod Company.


In business affairs of magnitude he exercised those virile qualities and rugged strength which have been characteristic of the Tod family through the various generations. But he was also a man of intellectual pursuits, enjoyed good books, good society, and ever regarded his friendship as inviolable. He was a republican in politics, belonged to the order of Elks and was also a member of the Young Men's Club at Youngstown for many years.


In 1869 William Tod married Frances Barnhisel. Mrs. Tod still resides at the old family home at 238 Lincoln Avenue in Youngstown. William Tod died there April 27 1905;. They had two sons, David and Fred. The son David married Anna Stambaugh.


FRED TOD, the only survivor of the children of William Tod, has done much during his brief career to sustain the high reputation of the Tod family in business and social life.


He was born February 1, 1886, graduated from the Rayen High School of Youngstown in 1906, and prepared for college at Andover and in Princeton schools. He spent one year in the University of Michigan. For nearly ten years he has been a-hardworking Youngstown business man. He is a director of the Brier Hill Steel Company and assistant to its vice president. He is a director of the Commercial National Bank, the Youngstown Steel Company, the Brier Hill ,Coal and Iron Company, the Biwabic Mining Company, the Bessemer Limestone Company, the Brier Hill Mining Company and the Stambaugh-Thompson Company, also in the Youngstown and Northern Railroad Company, and Executor of the William and David Tod estates.


Mr. Tod is a member of the Youngstown Club, Youngstown Country Club, Duquesne Club of Pittsburgh, and Bankers Club of New York. April 19, 1913, he married Miss Marguerite Hubbard, daughter of A. T. Hubbard of Cleveland. They have three children: Marguerite, Sallie and Fred, Jr.


DAVID TOD was named in honor of his grandfather, Governor David Tod, and was a son of the late William Tod and Frances (Barnheisel) Tod. Biographies of his father, grandfather and other members of the family appear on other pages.


David Tod was born at Girard, Ohio, August 25, 1870. He was reared in Youngstown, and completed his education at Purdue University, Lafayette, Indiana, and in the Sheffreld Scientific School at Yale University, where he took a course in mechanical engineering. His college degrees and the high business and social position of his family did not prevent him from beginning his business career at the


222 - YOUNGSTOWN AND THE MAHONING VALLEY


very bottom. For a time he was a machinist's helper, and subsequently was employed by the Brier Hill Coal and Iron Company. Later his interests took on great diversity. He founded a building and supply business at Youngstown and a cement plant at Struthers. He was one of the promoters of the Interurban Railway connecting Youngstown, North Lima, Columbia and Leetonia, serving as president soon after the building of the road and continuing until his death.


Mr. Tod took an active part in public life. In this field he was distinguished for his fearlessness. When the public welfare required disinterested service, there a champion was found in David Tod. He never stopped to consider the strength and power of the enemy nor personal consequences, but threw himself into a fight with every ounce of vigor he possessed. His record in the Youngstown City Council, where he served from 1901 to 1906, and in the Ohio State Senate from 1909 to 1913, bears witness to his devotion to this ideal, that the public weal is paramount. In 1914 Mr. Tod was a candidate for the republican nomination for governor of Ohio, and had the span of his life been prolonged, might ultimately have followed his grandfather to this office.


Mr. Tod is remembered as a great lover of out door sports and fine horses. He developed Southern Park, where he maintained a stable and achieved more than local fame as an amateur reinsman.


Upon the death of his father in 1905 and the retirement of John Stambaugh, he succeeded to the presidency of the William Tod Company. The value of the great properties of that corporation were greatly enhanced under his administration, and were finally sold to the United Engineering Company.


His death left vacancies in the positions of director and vice president of the Commercial National Bank, the president of the Youngstown and Suburban Railway Company, director of the Bessemer Limestone Company, Brier Hill Steel Company, Stambaugh-Thompson Company, Southern Park Land Company, vice president of the David Tod Land Company, trustee of the David and George Tod estates, president of the Citizens New Company, president of the Youngstown Driving Club, and president of the Mahoning Sand & Stone Company, and director of the Ward Mail Company, These offices serve to suggest the close relationship Mr. Tod sustained to the commercial life of the Ma- honing Valley.


He was never an idler, and his energy and talents made him a powerful influence for the progress of the community. For a number of years he was a trustee of the Youngstown City Hospital and the Reuben McWilliam Free Library. During the war with Germany he was general chairman in Mahoning County of the American Protective League, and was also a member of the Ohio Council of National Defense. Socially he was a member of the Youngstown Country Club, Youngstown Club, the Elks and other fraternal organizations.


It is due the memory of David Tod that the following editorial should be quoted from the Citizen: "Perhaps the most outstanding characteristic of his life was his wholesome democracy and his utter dis like of sham, pretense or deceit. Although a wealthy man, he never allowed his wealth to interfere with his good fellowship toward all men, no matter how rich or how poor they might be. The man in overals meant just as much to him as the man in broadcloth. He took men for what they were, no matter what their circumstances. He met them on common ground, always as an equal, never as a superior. Naturally this attitude won him hosts of friends in all walks of life, and it is doubtful if another man in Youngstown possessed so many sincere admirers who cry out in anguish before the appalling, crushing fact of his death."


Mr. Tod died May 14, 1919. His domestic life was exceedingly happy. He married Anna Stambaugh, daughter of Captain and Margaret (Osborn) Stambaugh. Her mother was a cousin of President William McKinley and a niece of William Osborn, at one time an American consul in England.


TURHAN STACY. A life and character that deserve to be well remembered in the Mahoning Valley, particularly in the Lowellville community, are those of the late Turhan Stacy, who had more than ordinary obstacles to overcome during his career, mounted them successfully, and won the respect and admiration of a host of friends.


He was born at Lowellville, May 24, 1845, son of Thomas and Margaret (McGill) Stacy. His parents represented families among the earliest settlers in the Mahoning Valley. Part of Lowellville is built on the site of the old McGill homestead. Turhan Stacy's patents were in very modest circumstances, and he received little encouragement from home sources, and developed his career almost entirely on his own hook. He was one of the boy soldiers of the Civil war, serving nine months in the Eighty- Sixth Ohio Regiment.


He was married in 1871. Prior to that time he had worked in furnaces, and soon after his marriage he bought a farm and took his bride to an old log house. The original part of this farm contained fifty acres. His industry and good management enabled him to accumulate adjoining tracts until he had a hundred and eighty acres. He also owned a good residence at Youngstown. He built the house on the farm in 1881 and the substantial barn in 1888. On the farm which represented so much of his work and achievement he passed away June 2, 1937, at the age of sixty-two. His wife had died in 1899. He was affiliated with Tod Post of the Grand Army of the Republic at Youngstown, though at the beginning had affiliated with Reno Post at Lowellville. His three sons, all living on portions of the homestead, are Lyman, Melvin and Jesse.


Concerning his personal characteristics his family recalls his habit of saving every gold piece that came into his hands. Finally he had accumulated about 300 of them, representing a great deal of money. This treasure was once lost on the farm, but was soon recovered.


Lyman Stacy, a son of Turhan, was born April 15, 1872, at his grandfather's old home, on a farm adjoining the present Stacy place. His life has been spent on the old homestead and he was educated in the country schools. He operates a farm of a hun-


YOUNGSTOWN AND THE MAHONING VALLEY - 223


dred and thirty-two acres, including the original homestead of fifty acres. e has taken no active part in politics.


At the age of thirty-one he married Miss Anna Liggett, a native of Poland Township and daughter of James and Isabel Liggett, now deceased. er father was a farmer.



MELVIN STACY, who is one of the three sons of the late Turham Stacy, whose life and its achievements have been reviewed on other pages, is one of the enterprising farmers in Poland Township, his home being a mile and a half south of Lowellville and near the Pennsylvania state line.


He was born at Lowellville November 22, 1875, and grew up on his father's farm in that vicinity. He was educated in local schools, and for a year or so worked in the sheet and tin mills at Struthers.


September 17, 1899, he married Edith Carlon, daughter of William and Mary Ann (Gault) Carlon, of Lowellville. er father came from Pennsylvania, having served as a Union soldier with a Pennsylvania regiment, and for many years worked at his trade as a carpenter at Lowellville, where he died at the age of sixty-three, his life having been shortened by reason of the hardships of his army service. Mrs. Edith Stacy was born at Lowellville February 24, 1877.


Since their marriage, a period of over twenty years, they have lived on their farm of 133 acres, originally the Robert Goucher farm. Their home is a substantial brick house that has been standing for over half a century, having been erected in 1868. Mr. Stacy was associated with his brothers in f arming operations until Iwo, but since then has been directing his business alone. He is one of the farmers of the Mahoning Valley who have achieved a competence from the soil. Besides his farm he owns a residence at Youngstown and other property and is a director of the Lowellville Bank. e is affiliated with the Masonic Order and attends and supports the Presbyterian Church, while in politics he is a republican. Mr. and Mrs. Stacy have one son, Emmett, born March I, 1904.


FREDERICK C. BROWN, manager of the East Federal Street Branch of the Dollar Savings & Trust Company, is one of the sound financiers of Youngstown and a man held in high esteem by his associates. He was born in New York City on February 20, 1870, a son of Richard and Thalia (Newton) Brown. The family came to Canfield, the old county seat of Mahoning County, in 1877, and here the father died in 1887. He had been engaged in mercantile pursuits in New York City, and came to Canfield on account of failing health. His wife was a daughter of Judge Eben Newton, one of the famous oldtime jurists of Mahoning County.


Frederick C. Brown was reared on his grand- father's farm, and educated at the Northeastern Ohio Normal College, from which he was graduated in 1889. For the subsequent year he was engaged in teaching school, and then, coming to Youngstown, for two years was cashier for the Youngstown Street Railway Company. In 1896 he was elected city clerk, and served as such until 1900, resigning that office to accept the position of bookkeeper of the Wick National Bank. When this bank was merged into the Dollar Savings & Trust Company Mr. Brown became a teller in the new concern. In June, 1908, he was appointed manager of the East Federal Street Branch, and has held this position ever since. He is a member of the Westminster Presbyterian Church and the Young Men's Christian Association. For about ten years Mr. Brown was a member of the Sinking Fund Commission of Youngstown, and as such rendered valuable service to the city. In politics he is a republican and has always been active in his party.

 

On June 27, 1894, Mr. Brown was united in marriage with Miss Emma Creed, a daughter of John A. Creed, of Coitsville, Ohio, and they have one living daughter, Ethel C. Mr. Brown is a man whose noble life, kindly friendship and generous impulses make him true to every duty and to all his associates. His ideals of honor are of the highest and his numerous friends feel that a man of this character is a desirable addition to any community, and a valued member of any institution.


W. WILSON GALBREATH president of the Youngstown Pressed Steel Company, is one of the practical executives in this line of industry and is also a forceful factor in civic affairs. He was born in the Village of Darlington in Hartford County, Maryland, on December 8, 1882, a son of A. F. and Sarah (Wilson) Galbreath, who yet reside in that locality.


After attending the public schools of his native town, and being graduated from its high school course, W. Wilson Galbreath completed his educational training at Saint John's College, Annapolis, Maryland. A week after he left college he began working for the Baltimore & Ohio Railroad, and remained with that road in different capacities for over four years. In 1907 he came to Youngstown and became a salesman for the General Fireproofing Company, and rose rapidly, becoming purchasing agent, assistant to the president, and then sales manager of that corporation. Upon the re-chartering of the Youngstown Pressed Steel Company on November 1, 1917, Mr. Galbreath was elected its president, and through his genius as an organizer he has made it one of the large corporations of this industrial district.


Mr. Galbreath was united in marriage with Miss Natalie Cole, of Baltimore, Maryland, and they have one child, William Wilson Galbreath. Ever since locating at Youngstown Mr. Galbreath has taken hold of things with a dynamic energy, and every organization with which he has become associated has felt the force of his influence. The Chamber of Commerce, the Youngstown Club, the Youngstown Country Club, and various trade orders all have been energized by him, and so natural and spontaneous is this enthusiastic interest that he wins friends by it, instead of antagonizing his associates as some great organizers appear to do. Both he and his wife are members of the Presbyterian Church. Although practically a recent addition to the commercial life of Youngstown, he has accomplished much in the time he has lived here, and judging the future in the light cast by past events, is likely to develop his


224 - YOUNGSTOWN AND THE MAHONING VALLEY


business and personal connections to a still greater degree.






LUCIUS E. COCHRAN, who came to Youngstown in 1862, was for halt a century one of the most notable figures in the commercial life of the city and its environments. He came from a farm, entered business life without capital, and by sheer force of ability raised himself to rank among the commanding forces in industrial affairs.


He was born in Delaware County, Ohio, June 12, 1842. His grandfather, George Cochran, was a pioneer in the Western Reserve, having settled at Vienna, Ohio, in 1816. He had been a merchant in Pittsburg and continued in similar occupations in Ohio. The parents of Lucius E. Cochran were Robert and Nancy (Hummason) Cochran, who spent most of their years on a farm in Logan County. Both were members of the Christian Church, and they were the parents of four sons and three daughters.


Lucius E. Cochran supplemented his education in the district schools with a course in the Commercial College at Pittsburg, and had his first experience in a general store in that city. In 1862 he became bookkeeper for the firm of Andrews & Hitchcock at Youngstown. His industry and evident ability earned him promotion, and in 1867 he became a partner in the mercantile firm of Andrews Brothers & Company at Haselton, a suburb of Youngstown. In 1890 Andrews Brothers & Company was formed by the consolidation of The Niles Iron Company and Andrews Brothers. It continued under his management until 1892, when the corporation was formed known as The Andrews Brothers Company of which he was made president and general manager, continuing until 1899, when it was sold to the Republic Iron & Steel Company.


From the date of his coming to Youngstown until his death Lucius E. Cochran extended a more than average influence upon local affairs. Nearly all the big industries that have made Youngstown notable among Ohio cities bore the impress of his energies. He was president of the Youngstown Car Manufacturing Company, Youngstown Bridge Company, Youngstown Iron and Steel Roofing Company, Youngstown Pressed Steel Company, the Mahoning Motor Car Company, the G. M. McKelvey Company, the Edwin Bell Company, .and the Mahoning Valley Water Company; was vice president of the Commercial National Bank and the Morris Hardware Company, and was a director of the Youngstown Carriage and Wagon Company, the Ohio Steel Company, which he helped organize, and the Pittsburg, Cleveland & Toledo Railroad Company. He was a keen, capable business man, and in his success his personal integrity was unimpaired.


In 1868 he married Mary Isabella Brownlee, daughter of John and Leah (Powers) Brownlee. They were the parents of two sons, Robert B., who died at the age of thirty-two, and Chauncey A. Lucius E. Cochran was an unswerving republican in politics, and during his residence at Haselton in 1872 he was appointed by John A. J. Creswell, postmaster general of the United States, at a salary of $12 a year, postmaster of Haselton, Mahoning County, Ohio. Mr. Cochran in no way wanted this office but was appointed so he could appoint one William Campbell as assistant. Mr. Campbell being an old veteran of the Civil war and incapacitated for work Mr. Cochran took this means of giving Mr. Campbell employment, which office he held for many years. He was a member of the Memorial Presbyterian Church, and was a Knight Templar Mason and also a thirty-second degree Scottish Rite Mason.


His son, Chauncey A. Cochran, was for a number of years actively associated with his father in business and is a Youngstown citizen whose activities are still a vital factor in the community. He was educated in the public schools of Youngstown, attended a military academy in New York, and has had an active business career of more than a quarter of a century. He is a member of the Presbyterian Church of Youngstown, a republican, and is affiliated with the Masonic Order and various social clubs.


He married Miss Sarah E. Davis, daughter of Hon. John R. and Maria S. (Richards) Davis. Her father was a prominent man in Mahoning County, having represented his district in the State Legislature, was a soldier in the Civil war, afterward became a merchant at Youngstown and enjoyed a number of honors in official affairs. Mr. and Mrs. Chauncey A. Cochran have two children : Lucius D. and Esther Marie.


JOHN KIRBY, for sixty-two years a resident of Youngstown, and now general superintendent of the William B. Pollock Company, is a son of William and Catherine (O'Donnell) Kirby, and a grandson of Andrew Kirby. Andrew Kirby was a native of the town of Cashel in the county of Tipperary, Ireland, where he grew up and became a schoolmaster. His wife was an Adams, a daughter of a Presbyterian clergyman, and in 1845 they immigrated to the United States, locating first at Niagara Falls, New York, and there and later at Dunkirk, New York, Andrew Kirby manufactured and sold sun dials. He was later employed as a surveyor in the building of the Grand Trunk Railroad in Canada, and still later became boss on a construction train. He died in New York City in 1872.


William Kirby began working at an early age for a railroad, continuing in that line of endeavor for two years. In 1858 he came to Youngstown and was keeper for the Himrod Furnace Company from 1860 until the furnace was closed. He then retired, and died in 1896. He and his wife had eleven children, but only three of them are now living.


John Kirby was born on March 2, 1856, at Toronto, Canada, where his parents were then temporarily located. Although of foreign nativity, actually, he has never known other allegiance than to the United States. e grew up at Youngstown and attended the public schools on Wood and Front streets. When about fourteen years of age he began working in the rolling mills, and a year later, when fifteen, he entered the employ of the William B. Pollock Company, and has ever since continued in its employ. He has seen from practical observation the kaleidoscopic changes which have taken place in the


YOUNGSTOWN AND THE MAHONING VALLEY - 225


growth and development of the iron industry of the Youngstown district, and also those which have changed Youngstown from a small, inconsequential village to one of the modern, industrial, populous cities of the country. He served for three years as an apprentice in learning his trade of boiler maker, then worked as a journeyman for several years, and since then has been boss, assistant superintendent and general superintendent, the last named position being the one he holds at present. Few men in Youngstown know the history of the iron industry better than he, and no one is more thoroughly the master of his business. He has never taken any active interest in politics or other public matters except those which directly apply to his business. In religion he is a Roman Catholic.


John Kirby was married first, in 1878, to Martha Middleton, who died in 1884, leaving two sons, namely: Frank J., who is general shipper and yardmaster for the William B. Pollock Company; and William Ralph, who is a partner and general superintendent of the Youngstown Boiler & Tank Company. The second wife of Mr. Kirby bore the maiden name of Katherine ealey, and she has borne him eight children, namely : John H., Jane H., Katherine E., deceased, Eugene Porter. Mary G., Ignatius Andrew, Cecelia D., and Ella May, deceased.


WALTER E. WATSON, assistant general manager of the sales department of the Youngstown Sheet & Tube Company, is a man of strong will and resourcefulness, whose technical experience and business ability admirably fit him for the responsibilities of his position. He was born at Middletown, Pennsylvania, and remained there until he was about eighteen years of age.


In 1897 Mr. Watson was graduated from the Pennsylvania State Normal School at Shippenburg, and then entered the University of Pennsylvania, where he spent two years with the expectation of becoming a lawyer. In order to secure funds for his courses he had taught school, and for two years of this period he was instructor in the high school of Morrisville, Pennsylvania. In spite of the plans he had made, however, he altered them definitely in a few moments when he was offered a position in the sales office of the National Tube Company of Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, in 1900, and accepted this offer. For the subsequent ten years he remained with this corporation, and then left it to become assistant general manager of sales for the La Belle Iron Works at Steubenville, Ohio, remaining there until 1913, when he came to Youngstown to assume the duties of his present position. In addition to it he is vice president and a director of the Youngstown Steel Products Company, and a director of the Continental Supply Company, both subsidiary companies of the Youngstown Sheet & Tube Company. He belongs to the American Steel and Iron Institute, the Natural Gas Association of America, and the Chamber of Commerce of Youngstown. Socially Mr. Watson is a member of the Youngstown Club, and the Youngstown Country Club, the Duquesne Club of Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, the Oakmont Country Club and the Pittsburgh Athletic Association. For a number of years he has been a consistent member of the Presbyterian Church. In politics Mr. Watson is a stanch republican.


Mr. Watson married Caroline Wick, a daughter of enry Herr, of Alliance, Ohio, and widow of Charles J. Wick, of Youngstown, Ohio.


JOHN N. REESE, assistant to the second vice president irr char of the northern ore and coal mines of the Republic Iron & Steel Company, is a man whose rise in the confidence of his company and his fellow citizens is not only deserved but recognized, and he is numbered among the worth-while residents of Youngstown. He was born at Harrisburg, Pennsylvania, on October 16, 1877, a son of John M. and Caroline W. (Peters) Reese. John M. Reese was a native of Pennsylvania, of Welsh parentage, and for years was a railroad engineer, whose death occurred on July 22, 1919. During the war between the states he served as a private in the Union army. Mrs. Reese was born in Germany, and her death occurred on February 10, 1917.


John N. Reese attended the public schools of Harrisburg, Pennsylvania, after which he matriculated at Lehigh University, from which he was graduated in 1900, with the degree of Civil Engineer, and while securing it he also specialized in mining. He then entered the students' course of the Pennsylvania Steel Company, and became assistant superintendent of the blast furnace department in 1902, and the following year was promoted to be its superintendent. In 1906 Mr. Reese was made superintendent of the blast furnaces for the Pulaski Iron Company of Pulaski, Virginia, and in 1907 went to the Alabama Consolidated Coal & Iron Company at Gadsden, Alabama, as superintendent of blast furnaces. The next year Mr. Reese was made superintendent of blast furnaces, ore mines and limestone quarries for the Ivanhoe Furnace Company of Ivanhoe, Virginia, and then in 1908 he went with the Pennsylvania Steel Company as superintendent of the blast furnaces at Steelton, Pennsylvania. On September 20, 1911, Mr. Reese came to Youngstown as superintendent of the northern furnaces of the Republic Iron & Steel Company, and on April 1, 1917, was promoted to his present position.


On February 14, 1905, Mr. Reese was united in marriage with V. Claire Knouse, a daughter of J. H. Knouse, of Harrisburg, Pennsylvania, and they have three children, Evelyn Gertrude, Carolyn Ellen and John N., Jr. Mr. Reese belongs to Youngstown Club, the Engineers Society of Youngstown, Chamber of Commerce, and the Young Men's Christian Association. He is a thirty-second degree Scottish Rite Mason and a Shriner. The American Institute of Mining Engineers, the American Iron & Steel Institute and the Rotary Club also hold his membership, and he is past president of the latter organization. During the late war he was very active in war work, belonging to the different committees of the various organizations and the First Presbyterian Church, of which he is a member; and he held the rank of captain and quartermaster of the Youngstown Home Guards. Since casting his first vote Mr. Reese has been a republican. Carefully trained in both theory and practice, he is one of the most experienced men in his profession, and the service he


226 - YOUNGSTOWN AND THE MAHONING VALLEY


is rendering his corporation is of such a nature as to recommend him to further promotions as the years pass and the vacancies occur.





F. K. SMITH, M. D. The late Edward Augustus Smith was at the time of his death Warren's oldest merchant. It is probable that he was Ohio's oldest pharmacist.


The American ancestor of this branch of the Smith family was Richard Smith, who came from Lancastershire, England, settling first in Massachusetts colony and removing in 1639 to Long Island, New York, where he purchased land in Suffolk County, and there founded Smithtown. John C. Smith, father of Edward A. and a direct descendent from Richard, was born September 24, 1798, in New York City. He died there July 23, 1859. He was an early merchant and postmaster at Jamaica, Long Island, and he later served two terms as county clerk of Queens County, New York.


John S. Smith married Lucy Ann Hoyt, who was born at Danbury, Connecticut, October 16, 1805, and died the same month and day in 1872, her sixty-seventh birthday anniversary. She was the daughter of Lewis Hoyt, who was born at Danbury in 1782, a son of Asa Hoyt, who in turn was descended from Simon Hoyt, the American ancestor who came over from Somersetshire, England, to Salem, Massachusetts, in 1629, and settled at Windsor, Connecticut, in 184o, afterward settling permanently in Fairfield County, Connecticut.


Lewis Hoyt married on Sunday, September 23, 1804, Abigail Mygatt, who was born in 1785 in Connecticut. She was a daughter of Comfort Starr Mygatt, who brought his family from Connecticut to Canfield, Trumbull County (later the first county seat of Mahoning County), in 1808. With the Mygatts came Lewis Hoyt and his family.


Edward Augustus Smith was born at Jamaica, Long Island, July 21, 1827, and he died April 1, 1919, at Warren. When he was a boy seventeen years old he went to New York City to clerk in a dry goods store. In 1846 he came to Warren to take a position as clerk in the store of his uncles, the Hoyt Brothers, general merchants. He soon became manager of the drug department of that store, which had become more or less independent of the general store operated by the company. Eventually the firm became Hoyt, Smith & Company, later E. A. Smith & Company, and January 1, 1860, it became Smith, Stratton & Company.


In April, 1860, the store of Smith, Stratton & Company was destroyed in Warren's historic fire, and Mr. Smith moved into a rented store room on East Market Street, where he continued business until the construction of his own brick business block on East Market Street, erected on a lot which he had purchased in 1866. From that time until his death he conducted a drug business there. For many years he was a director in the First National Bank of Warren, now the Union Savings and Trust Company. He had many other business interests both at home and abroad, and he was always prominent in the affairs of the community.


Soon after coming to Warren Mr. Smith identified himself with Christ Episcopal Church, and for many years he was its oldest living member. He was an early vestryman, and in 1875 he was elected senior warden, a position he held the remainder of his days. His family recently presented Christ Episcopal Church with a fine pipe organ as a memorial of him. For many years Mr. Smith was a member of Warren Independent Order of Odd Fellows Lodge.


A newspaper clipping relates: "Mr. Smith never aspired to public office, and he never held a position of trust in the community, although he was at all times interested in those things which served to build up the community and community ideals. He was privileged to see Warren grow from a hamlet of 2,000 people to a city of 30,000, and he has seen one generation after another take its place in the business community. The men who were actively engaged in the business walks of life have been succeeded by their sons and grandsons in his time.


"Mr. Smith's long years of life have indeed been a rich heritage. Ever regular in his habits, industrious, ever watchful of the little things which tend to nourish the body, are perhaps factors which have enabled Mr. Smith to enjoy so many years of usefulness. His daily attention to his business affairs has been a matter of considerable importance. It has been only in recent weeks that he has not daily visited his store.


"When the Civil war broke out Mr. Smith was just engaging in business for himself, and permitting his clerks to enter the service he himself remained here to provide for his family and to assist in aiding the cause of the North in other ways than carrying a musket. The story is told of how when John Morgan was conducting his raid through Ohio, Mr. Smith hurried home to secure his shotgun, and joined the band of patriotic citizens who had gathered on the square to go out and meet Morgan if he came this way. The little band of citizens had not progressed far, however, before word was received that Morgan had been captured at Lisbon."


On May 5, 1857, Mr. Smith united in marriage with Laura G. Furman. She was born November 4, 1831, at Woodville, South Carolina. She was a daughter of Wood and Laura M. (Lyon) Furman. Wood Furman was born June 12, 1779, in South Carolina. e was a son of the Rev. Richard Furman, a native of Esopus, New York, and was descended from Josiah Furman, an early settler of Long Island, who in turn was descended from John Furman, the American ancestor of the family who came over from England and settled permanently on Long Island. Rev. Richard Furman was for many years pastor of the First Baptist Church of Charleston, South Carolina, and he was for a long time president of the National Baptist Convention. Laura Lyon was the daughter of James and the granddaughter of Mathew Lyon, who settled in Vermont prior to the Revolutionary war.


Mathew Lyon was an early publicist, and he was the first man arrested and convicted under the Alien and Sedition Act of Congress, his offense having been a published criticism of the Government. While serving his thirty days' imprisonment he was elected to Congress. After completing his term in Congress he and his son James removed to Tennessee, from which state he was again elected a member of Con-


YOUNGSTOWN AND THE MAHONING VALLEY - 227


gress. After completing his term as a member from Tennessee Mr. Lyon was appointed Indian agent for Indian Territory. He was there elected a territorial delegate to Congress, but he died before taking his seat. He was probably the only man in the history of the United States to be elected a member Of Congress from three different states.


James Lyon, son of Mathew, married Phila, daughter of Richard Risley and resided in Washington City while his father was serving in Congress. One of Richard Risley's three daughters married Judge Pease of Warren, and it was while visiting her Warren relatives that Mrs. Smith met her future husband. She survives. The children born to Mr. and Mrs. Smith are as follows : Dr. Frederick K., of Warren ; Edward S., of Warren; Mrs, James Brown, of Warren ; Mary A., of Warren; Cornelia G., of Warren. The last mentioned was for many years secretary and librarian of the Warren Public Library.


Frederick Kinsman Smith, M. D., son of the late Edward A. Smith, was born in Warren, Ohio, April 4, 1858, the date having fallen on Easter Sunday. He attended the Warren graded and high schools, and later graduated from Western Reserve College at Hudson, Ohio. He graduated in the class of 1879 at Western Reserve University, receiving his A. B. degree, and from the University of Michigan with the class of 1883, when he received the degree of M. D.


Doctor Smith entered upon the practice of medicine in 1883 in the copper region of the Upper Peninsula of Michigan, remaining there until 1893. He then began practice in Cleveland, remaining there until 1898, when he began practice in Warren, continuing as an eye specialist until 1918. He then rementired from active practice. Doctor Smith is past worshipful master of Old Erie Lodge No. 3, Free and Accepted Masons, is past presiding officer of Mahoning Chapter No. 66, Royal Arch Masons, a member of Warren Council No. 58, Royal and Select Masons, of Warren Commandery No. 39, Knights Templar, of Lake Erie Consistory, Scottish Rite (thirty-second degree), and of Al Koran Temple, Ancient Arabic Order Nobles of the Mystic Shrine, of Cleveland. e is a director of the Masonic Temple of Warren. e is a vestryman of Christ Episcopal Church, and a member of the Country Club.


Doctor Smith married Amelia, daughter of James Rosewarne, of Copper City, Michigan. Mrs. Smith was born in England.


ENSIGN N. BROWN, president of the Mahoning County Bar Association and former president of the Ohio State Bar Association, has been a Youngstown lawyer forty years. While a native of the old town of Canfield, he spent his early years in the East, and through his mother's family is related to some of the earliest as well as the most prominent pioneers of the Mahoning Valley.


Mr. Brown was born at Canfield, December 9, 1854, son of Richard and Thalia Fitch (Newton) Brown. His grandfather, Capt. John Brown, was an officer in the British Army and participated in the Battle of Waterloo. He came to the United States about 1840 and lived at Canfield, Ohio, until his death about 1860.


Richard Brown was also a native of England, where his father for several years was a farmer. Richard had only a limited education, but gained a great amount of knowledge during his many years of practical business experience. At the age of fourteen he was apprenticed to a draper and dry goods merchant, spending seven years in learning the business. He acquired a metropolitan experience in London and later in Paris, and about 1844 came to the United States. For a time he gave his services to two of the greatest mercantile houses of New York City, Lord & Taylor and A. T. Stewart. Subsequently he engaged independently in merchandising in New York, where he remained until 1877. His health having become impaired, in that year he returned to Canfield, Ohio, where he had found his wife, and he died at Canfield in 1888, at the age of seventy-one.


Comparatively few people know that one of the founders of the now world-wide institution of the Young Men's Christian Association at one time lived in Mahoning County. Mr. Brown, while in London, was associated with George Williams in organizing the first Young Men's Christian Association in the world in that city. Later Williams was knighted by Queen Victoria. After coming to the United States Richard Brown and others organized in New York City the first Young Men's Christian Association in this country and served as its first treasurer.


Thalia Fitch Newton, wife of Richard Brown and mother of the Youngstown lawyer, was a daughter of Judge Eben Newton. Judge Eben Newton was one ot e really distinguished lawyers, jurists and public leaders in Ohio during the first half of the nineteenth century. Born in Connecticut in 1795, he first came to Ohio about 1814, read law at Ravenna, and was admitted to the bar at Warren in 1823. For twenty years he was a partner of Elisha Whittlesey, long a member of Congress and at one time Comptroller of the Treasury of the United States. For a short time Judge Newton was in practice at Cincinnati, with Rutherford B. Hayes, afterward president of the United States, as partner. He was elected to the State Senate in 184o, resigning to take the office of president judge of the Third Judicial District. While in that office he had the distinction of holding the first session of the Common Pleas Court in the newly created Mahoning County in 1846. In 1850 he was elected to Congress, and during the Civil war was again a member of the State Senate. He was also president of two railroad lines in Northeastern Ohio, was prominent in agricultural circles, and helped train a number of young men for the law, including the great Ohioans Ben F. Wade, Joshua R. Giddings and others. Judge Newton married Mary S. Church, a daughter of Ensign Church.


Ensign N. Brown was reared in New York City, where he was educated in private schools. He had for his teachers two noted educators, Dr. George P. Quackenbos and Dr. Henry B. Chapin. Under the latter he was prepared for college, but failing eyesight compelled him to abandon his college career. For a number of years he was associated with his


228 - YOUNGSTOWN AND THE MAHONING VALLEY


father at New York in the business of importing laces and embroideries.


Mr. Brown returned to Mahoning County in 1878 for the purpose of looking after the property of Judge Newton, then in advanced years. At the request of Judge Newton he took up the study of law, finishing his reading with the firm of Van Hyning & Johnston. e was admitted to the bar in 1880, and until his mother's death in 1889 lived at Canfield, though practicing in Youngstown. His home has been in the latter city since 1889. Of late years Mr. Brown has specialized somewhat in mechanics' liens and building contracts, though still doing a general practice. He was elected president of the State Bar Association in 1918, and was chosen president when the Mahoning County Bar Association was organized in 1919. Mr. Brown is a Royal Arch Mason and a republican.


September 20, 1876, he married Miss Jeannette Cooper, a daughter of John Cooper, a New York City merchant. They have two children, Genevieve Newton and Bessie Hunt. The family are members of the Episcopal Church.


Mr. Brown has long been prominent not only in St. John's parish at Youngstown but in the diocese. e is present junior warden of the parish, and for twenty-five years has been delegate from the parish to the Ohio diocese. Since 1910 he has represented the diocese in four general conventions of the church. For years he has also been a member of the Committee of Canons of the diocese and a member of the Committee of Canons of the General Church, and for ten years has been one of the standing committee of the diocese. In the spring of 1920, the former chancellor having died, Mr. Brown was appointed Chancellor of the Diocese of Ohio and is now acting as such.


JACOB HYDE EWALT. As a banker and manufacturer Mr. Ewalt has had a dignified and useful career in Warren for over thirty years, and in that time has impressed his influence and enterprise upon several well known institutions.


He is a native of the Mahoning Valley and descended from two pioneer families, the Ewalts and the Leffingwells. The Ewalts settled originally in Howland Township of Trumbull County. The pioneer was John Ewalt, who took up a tract of Government land in that township about 1805. His son Jacob was born on the homestead in Howland Township in 1810. and lived eight decades, dying in 1890. He married in 1835 Lydia Maria Leffingwell, who died

in 1889. Her parents came from Connecticut at an early day and settled in Warren Township. A collateral connection of the Leffingwells were the Hyde family of Hyde Park, London, England.

lateral connection of the Leffingwells were the Hyde family of Hyde Park, London, England.


Jacob Hyde Ewalt was born at the Ewalt farm in Bazetta Township about four miles from the City of Warren November 12, 1856. e has always regarded it as his good fortune that his early life was spent in the country. e attended district school to the age of fifteen, and finished his education in the city schools of Warren. In 1877 Mr. Ewalt became a clerk in the old drug store of Col. H. G. Stratton at Warren, and after eight years left Colonel Stratton to become bookkeeper and shipping clerk for the Winfield Manufacturing Company. He has been one of the men who have developed that notable Warren industry, and in 1904 was made treasurer of the company and since 1917 has filled the offices of secretary and treasurer.


As a banker Mr. Ewalt was one of the organizers in 1889 of what is now the Trumbull Savings and Loan Company. He has served as vice president since 1909 and also as a director. He is a director in the. Western Reserve Furniture Company, in the Enterprise Electric Company, and the People's Ice and Cold Storage Company.


For the last twenty-five years Mr. Ewalt has been financial secretary of the Board of Trustees of the First Methodist Episcopal Church. He is a member of the Warren Board of Trade. Mr. Ewalt married Florence Taylor, daughter of the late Mathew B. and Adaline (Hapgood) Taylor. Her father was for many years cashier of the old First National Bank of Warren. Mrs. Ewalt died in 1899, the mother of one son and one daughter. The son, Jacob H., Jr., now secretary of the Gilder-Augstadt Coal and Supply Company, married May Holloway, of Warren, and they have a son, Richard Holloway, and a daughter, Jean. Charlotte Taylor Ewalt became the wife of Peter Webb Elliott, of Warren, and they had a daughter, Florence Ellen. Mr. Elliott died in 1916. On June 6, 1904, Mr. Ewalt was married to Ella Van Gorder (Ford) McWilliams, of Ashtabula, Ohio, and to this marriage one daughter has been born, Laura Ford Ewalt.


JOHN G. COOPER. The high traditions for public service which have been created for Northeastern Ohio as the result of the life and works of Joshua R. Giddings, Benjamin Wade, James R. Garfield, William McKinley and others elected by the people of this part of the state to represent them in Washington, have been maintained by John G. Cooper, congressman for the Nineteenth Ohio District, which is composed of Mahoning, Trumbull and Ashtabula Counties.


John G. Cooper began life with few of the advantages which his illustrious predecessors enjoyed, but by hard work, clear understanding of the needs and desires of the people and unswerving courage and determination to stand for what he believed to be right, Congressman Cooper has earned a nationwide reputation. Mr. Cooper was born in Staffordshire, England, in 1872, and came to the United States with his parents when only eight years old. The Cooper family settled in the Mahoning Valley of Ohio at a time when its possibilities as an industrial and manufacturing district first began to be appreciated.


John Cooper's school days ended when he was thirteen, at which early period of his life he went to work in the iron mills to help earn the daily bread for the family. A few years later he obtained a position as locomotive fireman in the employ of the Pennsylvania Railroad. He was promoted to engineer, in which occupation he was engaged when he became interested in politics. The young man observed what the republican protective tariff and economic policies did for the development and prosperity of his home community and became a repub-


YOUNGSTOWN AND THE MAHONING VALLEY - 229


lican. In 1wo he was nominated and elected to represent Mahoning County in the Ohio General Assembly, and was re-elected by an increased vote in 1912. His service in the State Legislature was so satisfactory that he was chosen as the republican candidate for Congress in the Nineteenth District in 1914 and elected easily. Mr. Cooper was re-elected in 1916, 1918 and 1920.


Congressman Cooper is a member of the important committee on interstate and foreign commerce of the House of Representatives. He was the first locomotive engineer or practical railroad worker ever elected to Congress, and his views on practical railroad and labor questions are very highly regarded by his colleagues in Congress. His firm stand in Congress against radicalism in the labor movement during the period of unrest which followed the war with Germany attracted wide attention and is believed to have been a strong factor in bringing about a satisfactory adjustment of labor troubles. Mr. Cooper's home is in Youngstown. He is married and has five sons.


JOHN JAMES MURRAY. In the many years that he traveled, John James Murray was known from coast to coast as an actor-manager, and his name has a high rank in the realm of minstrelsy, vaudeville and comedy. At Warren, where he has had his home for a number of years, Mr. Murray has also been prominent as a theatrical manager, and his name is also closely linked with other business and civic interests.


He was born in the City of Chicago April 7, 1867, son of James and Ann (Dempsey) Murray. His parents were natives of Ireland, and both died when the son was a boy. Since he was eleven years of age John James Murray has made his own way in the world. While acquiring a limited education in the parochial schools of Chicago, he sold newspapers on the streets and did other work. In 1881, at the age of fourteen, he first entered the amusement field, and for thirty-five years was active and successful in all the different lines of the show business, including the circus, minstrel, comedy and vaudeville, both as an entertainer and manager. He and his companies played in all the high class houses of the East and Middle West. In two Mr. Murray and Frank Mackey organized the firm of Murray & Mackey, and for several years owned and operated the largest popular priced shows on the road. Their show was a prominent feature at Warren during the Trumbull County Fair for many years. Mr. Murray leased the Warren Opera House in 1908 and produced all the high class attractions until 1917, since which time the operahouse has been devoted exclusively to moving pictures. In this field, largely due to the influence of Mr. Murray, only the finest film features have been presented to the people of Warren.


Mr. Murray is one of the most enthusiastic believers in the great future of Warren as an industrial and home center. He has associated himself with many of its enterprises, being a director in the People's Savings & Trust Company, a director in the Reserve Realty & Mortgage Company, a director in the Sunlight Electric Company, and a stockholder in other concerns.


During the war he turned over his personal talents and his resources to patriotic service and was active in the Liberty Bond, Red Cross and War Chest campaigns, and was chairman of the Trumbull County Labor Board. He is a charter member and director of the Rotary Club and the Buckeye Club and has been a member of the Order of Elks for thirty years, holding his membership in Elmira Lodge No. 62. He is also a member of the Warren Board of Trade.


November 26, 1887, Mr. Murray married Miss Florence Louise Long, a native of Cincinnati and daughter of Louis and Catherine (Madenbach) Long. Mr. and Mrs. Murray had three children, but the first two, Robert James and Florence, are deceased. The only living daughter, Margaret Florence, is now a student of the Ladies of Loretto Convent at Niagara Falls, Canada.


BERNARD MCMANUS. Out of a hard apprenticeship, early contact with work at meagre wages, and with the ripe experience and broader vision of his later years, Bernard McManus has come to that higher plane of business affairs where he is head of one of the best mercantile organizations in Youngstown, the B. McManus Company, known as "Youngstown's Greater Store for Women."


Mr. McManus was born in County Cavan, Ireland, in 1877, son of Thomas and Mary (MacManus) McManus. His father, now deceased, was also a native of County Cavan, for many years was a successful teacher, and he died at the age of eighty-eight on April 22, 1wo. His wife, Mary MacManus, as the name indicated, was of Scotch ancestry, born in Scotland, and died in 1884.


Bernard McManus, one of six children, attended school at home and was eighteen years of age when he came to the United States. His first home was in St. Joseph, Missouri. The means of earning a living for several months was selling the St. Joseph Gazette on the streets of that western city. At the same time he was diligently pursuing his studies in night school. After six months as a newsboy he entered the service of the Combe Printing Company of St. Joseph, at that time one of the largest printing establishments in the Missouri Valley. He continued his work in night school, and after about a year he and his brother, Thomas H., went to Newton, Kansas, and with a modest capital opened a stock of general merchandise. They were merchants in Kansas for fifteen years, and built up a large and flourishing business.


On leaving Kansas Mr. McManus started East, his contemplated destination being New York City. He stopped to visit at Cleveland, and his visit was turned into a stay of several years, during which time he had a profitable connection with The H. Black Company. At the same time he was making a thorough study of commercial conditions, and eventually his judgment led him to locate at Youngstown.


Mr. McManus came to Youngstown nine years ago and began business as a merchant on East Federal Street, subsequently moving to West Federal Street, and three years ago into the five-story building which the B. McManus Company now occupies, each floor devoted to a special department. Judicious


230 - YOUNGSTOWN AND THE MAHONING VALLEY


women shoppers all over Eastern Ohio know the McManus store. The spirit of the business is well described in the following words : "To make this exclusively and increasingly a store for women, where women will come intuitively for every article of ready-to-wear clothing they desire, is our reason for existence. To make our merchandise so good, so comprehensive, so satisfactory and to give the kind of courtesy and attention in service to which a woman feels entitled, is the inspiration we cherish. We call our store 'greater' not because of material bigness, but because of this all-inclusive idea actuating it, in the development of which we find our daily pleasure."


Customers also frequently see posted in different parts of the store the following notice : "Employes Attention : Our reputation with the people of Youngstown is in your hands. See that it is protected."


Mr. McManus is president of the company and is active manager, and is also the source of inspiration for the ideals and the spirit of service permeating the business. Mr. McManus is also vice president of the Moore-Lamb Construction Company. He is an active member of the Chamber of Commerce, the Poland Country Club, is a Knight of Columbus and with his family worships in St. Edward's Catholic Church. During the war he was liberal with his time and means in behalf of the various campaigns, and has been equally public spirited in promoting everything of benefit to Youngstown.


Just before going into business at Youngstown Mr. McManus married Miss Lena Madden, daughter of E. J. and Margaret Madden of Youngstown. They have three sons, Bernard, Jr., Edward and Thomas.



WASHINGTON HYDE, attorney and capitalist, is one of the leading men of Warren and the Mahoning Valley, and his counsel is sought on many matters of public interest as well as those connected with his profession. He was born on the farm owned by his parents at Farmington, Trumbull County, Ohio, May 7, 1847. His father, Julius E. Hyde, was also born on this farm, in 1825, he being a son of Eli Hyde, a native of New York State, of Yankee stock, who came to East Farmington, Trumbull County, Ohio, about 1818, and was one of the pioneers of that section of Trumbull County. He married Hannah Porter, a native of New York State, and a daughter of a Revolutionary war soldier. They were married in New York State at an early age and came soon afterward to Trumbull County, making the journey in an ox-cart.


The mother of Washington Hyde was Ann Oatley, and she was born in Bazetta Township, Trumbull County, in 1824, a daughter of William and Sophia Oatley, of Pennsylvania Dutch stock, her father having been a pioneer of Bazetta Township, he settling on a farm there about 1815.


Julius Hyde was a successful farmer and dairyman and was noted as a cheese maker. He died in 1898, his wife passing away in 1891. Earnest Christian people, they maintained membership in the Methodist Episcopal Church, and were very active in its good work.


Washington Hyde was reared on the farm, attended the old Western Reserve Seminary at West Farmington, Ohio, and was graduated from the University of Michigan in 187o, with the degree of Bachelor of Arts, and from the legal department in 1872, with the degree of Doctor of Laws. He was a classmate all through college with Judge William R. Day, of the United States Supreme Court, with whom he was also admitted to the bar in 1872, before the District Court at Ashland, Ohio.


Entering upon the practice of law at Warren in 1872 Mr. Hyde has continued in it. He served from 1880 to 1885, inclusive, as prosecuting attorney of Trumbull County, and was for many years active in republican politics. Mr. Hyde has other interests, having in 1898 been one of the organizers and incorporators of the Warren & Niles Telephone Company, of which he is president and treasurer and a director. This is now a $500,000 company, and is the only one now doing business in Warren in giving a telephone service, having bought out the Bell Telephone Company. He also organized and incorporated the King Furniture Manufacturing Company of Warren, of which he is president and treasurer, and he is also president and a director of the Warren Rubber Company of Warren.


Mr. Hyde was married in 1876 to Laura E. Tibbitts, of an old family, her mother having been a daughter of a brother of Moses Cleveland, the "father" of the City of Cleveland, Ohio. Mrs. Hyde died in 189o, leaving the following children : Jessie A., George C. and Charles W. In 1893 Mr. Hyde was married to Victoria Pinkard, who was born in Warren, and to them have been born the following children : Edward L., who is now a law student at the Ohio Northern University, is a veteran of the great war, having spent nine months in France with the One Hundred and Eighth Ammunition Train, American Expeditionary Forces ; Lillian 0., who is at home; and Clarence A., who was with the American Expeditionary Forces in France, was killed in active service in the Argonne drive just before the signing of the Armistice. He was a member of Company D, One Hundred and Forty-Fifth Regiment.


Mr. Hyde is a member of Old Erie Lodge No. 3, Free and Accepted Masons, and Warren Commandery No. 39, Knights Templar. The Warren Board of Trade holds his membership, and he is active in its operations. Professionally he belongs to the Trumbull County Bar Association and for five years was a member of its bar committee. For some years Mr. Hyde has been a member of the Youngstown Unitarian Church. A man of the highest standing in both professional and business circles, Mr. Hyde is admittedly one of the representative men of this section of the state, and a citizen who reflects honor and dignity upon his community and calling.


FRANK C. VAN WYE., who is carrying forward successful operations on the John Anderson farm in Weathersfield Township, Trumbull County, one mile west of the City of Niles, is a native of this township and a representative of a family whose name has been worthily linked with the history of Trumbull County for nearly a century. e was born on


YOUNGSTOWN AND THE MAHONING VALLEY - 231


the old pioneer homestead farm of his grandfather, Abram Van Wye, in Weathersfield Township December 2, 1849, and is a son of John and Adaline (Carlton) Van Wye, the former having been born in Pennsylvania and the latter having been a daughter of Peter Carlton, a pioneer settler at Girard, this county. Abram and Charity (Laird) Van Wye, grandparents of Frank C., were born and reared in Washington County, Pennsylvania, where their marriage was solemnized and where seven of their children were born, the Van Wye family, of Holland Dutch origin, having been founded in the Keystone state prior to the war of the Revolution, and the lineage of the Laird family tracing back to Scotch origin. In 1834 Abram Van Wye came with his family to Trumbull County and located in the midst of the forest in Weathersfield Township, where he obtained a goodly tract of land and reclaimed a productive farm along the Mahoning River. He died in his fifty-eighth year, and his wife passed away at the age of sixty years. Their children were Charles, John, Lydia (Mrs. Hiram Dunlap), Mary Jane (Mrs. John A. Hunter), Nancy (Mrs. Theodore DeForest), Catherine (died in childhood), Amanda (likewise died in childhood), William (killed at Ringgold, Georgia, while serving in the Civil war), Joseph W. (individually mentioned on other pages, where also is found further record concerning the family history), Darthula (Mrs. Charles P. Moore, of Bristolville, Trumbull County), Elmira (died at the age of twenty-two years) ; and Sabina (Mrs. Thomas Radcliffe, died at Warren, in 1919).


John Van Wye, after the death of his father, continued to be associated with his brothers in the management of the old home farm until 1863, when he sold his interest in that place and removed to Howland Township, where he purchased a farm that is now occupied by the Trumbull Steel Company and the Brier Hill Steel Company. There he owned more than 200 acres, the land extending to the Mahoning River. Not only the old canal, but also the first railroad in the county traversed this farm, and eventually Mr. Van Wye sold the right-of-way for five different lines of railroad which crossed his property. When the final sale of his old farm was made to the Trumbull Steel Company the tract still comprised about 200 acres. Here John Van Wye died at the venerable age of eighty-six years, his wife having passed away at the age of seventy years, their names meriting place on the roster of the honored pioneers of the county. Of their children the subject of this review is the eldest ; Mary is the wife of Reuben Templeton, of Braceville, this county; Lois is the widow of William S. Campbell and resides at Cambridge, Guernsey County, her husband having been a son of Rev. William Campbell, a pioneer Presbyterian clergyman ; Florence died in childhood; Olive is the wife of William Bolin, of Warren; Homer W. died in August, 1919, aged sixty years, he having been engaged in the livery business at Warren; John E., who was long in service as a railroad engineer on the Pennsylvania Lines, was a resident of Niles at the time of his death, in March, 1916; Gerry P., a patent attorney, is engaged in the practice of his profession in New York City; Benjamin C., a graduate of Harvard University, is now a member of the faculty of a college in the City of Cincinnati, he having previously been a teacher in the City of Boston, where his marriage occurred; and Lucy is the wife of William Brown, station agent for the New York Central Railroad at Hubbard, Trumbull County.


Frank C. Van Wye gained his early education in the common schools and remained at the parental home until he was twenty-four years old, when he married and established his home on the Isaac Troxell farm, which property he purchased and which adjoined his father's farm. He had ninety- three acres, but the area of the place was somewhat reduced when he sold a railroad right-of-way through the farm. He added to the original farm until he had 103 acres, and in 1916 he sold the entire property to the Briar Hill Steel Company as a site for its manufacturing plant. For eight years Mr. Van Wye served as a member of the Board of Directors of the County Infirmary, and he also gave effective service as trustee of his school district, his political allegiance being rendered to the republican party. After selling his old farm Mr. Van Wye finally purchased his present well improved place of forty-one acres, which extends across the former bed of the Mahoning River, the four-mile locks on the old canal having been on this farm, which was held for generations by the Anderson family. Of this property Mr. Van Wye sold twenty-seven acres to the Falcon Steel Company, whose mill has been erected here. Mr. Van Wye is living virtually retired, but takes satisfaction in giving a general supervision to the work of his attractive little farm, his entire life having been marked by close association with agricultural enterprise in his native county, where his circle of friends is coincident with that of his acquaintances. e was reared in the faith of the Methodist Episcopal Church and has been liberal in support of religious work. He is affiliated with the Masonic fraternity.


September 10, 1874, recorded the marriage of Mr. Van Wye to Miss Celestia A. Pearce, daughter of Newcomb and Mary (McConnell) Pearce, she haring been born on the old homestead of her maternal grandfather in North Jackson Township. To Mr. and Mrs. Van Wye have been born four children : Thaddeus I. and Mabel remain at the parental home; Mary is the widow of Charles Lodwick and resides at Niles; and Frank, a lawyer and civil engineer, is in the employ of the City of Cleveland in a professional way. After his graduation from the high school he completed a course in the law department of the University of Michigan and was admitted to the bar, he having been, as a civil engineer, employed for some time in government work with the Mississippi commission. December 2, 1919, on the seventieth anniversary of his father's birth, Frank Van Wye was united in marriage to Miss Jean Mahaffey, of St. Louis, Missouri.


ROBERT L. MCCORKLE since leaving school and takrng t e responsibilities of life has given all his time and energies to financial institutions in Niles, and has been actively identified with the Niles Trust Company since it was organized.

Mr. McCorkle was born at Lordstown in Trumbull


232 - YOUNGSTOWN AND THE MAHONING VALLEY


County June 8, 1878, son of Almon G. and Martha (Leitch) McCorkle. Family sketch appears elsewhere. His mother was a native of Ireland. The McCorkle family is an old and honored one in Trumbull County. It is of Scotch-Irish ancestry. When the Mahoning Valley was a wilderness

Robert L. McCorkle, great-grandfather of the Niles banker, ame here and employed his energies in developing a homestead. The family occupation as a rule has been farming. Almon G. McCorkle is still living at Lordstown, and all his five children are alive.


Robert L. McCorkle grew up in his native village, attended the public schools, the Warren High School, and at the age of nineteen became a messenger in the old City National Bank at Niles. Later he was made bookkeeper and teller. When that bank was consolidated with the First National he continued as teller in the new organization, and later assisted C. P. Wilson in winding up the affairs of the First National Bank.


The Niles Trust Company was organized in 1909, and since it opened its doors Mr. McCorkle has been treasurer. He has a number of other business interests at Niles. He is a republican in politics, is a Royal Arch Mason and a member of the Niles Club. May 1, 1902, he married Miss Anna Eaton, daughter of John W. Eaton. They have one son, John Almon,




THE PACKARD FAMILY of Warren has for three-quarters of a century been intimately associated with the history of the City of Warren and of the Mahoning Valley. A Packard was a pioneer in the settlement of the valley; a Packard was a pioneer in the commerce of Warren; and two Packards are pioneers of industry of this city.


The pioneer settler was William Packard, who was a native of Pennsylvania, born in Washington County, that state, on September 3, 1803. He settled at Austintown (then in Trumbull County), in 1825. Late in life he removed to Kern County, California, and died at Kernville on December 11, 1877, after having served for several years as judge of Kern County. The pioneer in the commercial history of Warren was the late Warren Packard, son of William. e was born at Austinburg (then Trumbull County) on June T, 1828, and died at Warren on July 28, 1897. The pioneers of industry of Warren are William D. and James W. Packard.


Warren Packard was without doubt one of the towering figures in the earlier history of Warren. While the Mexican war was still in progress he left the old farm at Lordstown, an ambrtious and energetic lad of eighteen years, to seek his fortune at the county seat of old Trumbull. All of his earthly possessions were literally contained in the proverbial cotton handkerchief as he trudged his way into town. Through the influence of his brother-in-law, the late Eli K. Weisell, he obtained a situation with Milton Graham, then operating the pioneer iron store of this section. For the first year after coming to Warren he attended school during the greater portion of his time, paying his board by doing chores nights and mornings, and on Saturdays driving Mr. Graham's team to Niles and Youngstown and buying for the store iron and nails in such quantities as would about cover the sales for the ensuing week. Those were the days of small things, as compared with the magnitude of present operations His duties included taking care of the team, one or two cows, sawing stove wood for the house and shop, and at the noon hour "tending store" while the boys went to dinner. His was a long day, lasting from 5 A. M. until 9 P. M., but that tireless, restless boy maintained the same hours from 1846 until 1897. The second year with Mr. Graham, young Packard received $too, his board included, and upon that amount he could give but slight attention to dress, the boys and society in general ; but that troubled him but little. Five years later Mr. Packard was the sole owner of the original Graham store, and also the hardware store started a year or two later in opposition to the Graham store by Charles Reuben Harmon. The store of Thomas H. Morely was likewise taken in by the far-reaching enterprise of Mr. Packard. Thus, in 1863, Mr. Packard found himself the owner and successful manager of the largest iron and hardware business operating between Cleveland and Pittsburgh. He pushed trade with phenomenal vigor and also marketed the bulk of the products of the Spear Planing Mill and the Packard, Hull & Company, of which he was principal owner.


In addition to the above industries Warren Packard purchased extensive timber tracts in Pennsylvania and in some of the southern states, and actively engaged in the manufacture of lumber, establishing numberless modern sawmills on his various properties. Enormous quantities of his products were used in the building of the old Atlantic and Great Western Railroad (now the great Erie system), and in later years millions of feet of his lumber products were consumed in- the operation of that now famous trunk-line. Mr. Packard also had invested $100,000 in the old Packard & Barnum Steam Forge & Rolling Mills at Warren, and it was while he was the executive head of that concern that he was one day summoned to New York City by Jay Gould, the then presiding genius of the Erie Railway. At their meeting in Mr. Gould's office the "Wizard of Wall Street" informed Mr. Packard that he desired a half interest in the Packard & Barnum Steam Forge & Rolling Mills and, in return for the same he agreed that all of the scrap-iron of the Erie Railway would be exclusively sold to Mr. Packard's company, and said to Mr. Packard, "You can weigh the scrap yourself." The proposition was attractive and would no doubt have been a very profitable one, but it did not appeal to Mr. Packard, and the deal was never consummated. Mr. Packard's embarkation into the manufacture of iron was not made at a propitious time, as many of the iron mills were at that time being operated at a loss, and as a result of those conditions he lost practically the full amount of the $200,000 which he invested. During the same decade he supplied the sum of $100,000 with which the firm of W. & A. J. Packard built and stocked the "Hardware Block" at Youngstown. This business was successfully operated until the approach of the panic of 1873 brought a rapidly declining market for all metal goods, and that, together with a disastrous fire, caused a large financial loss to Mr. Packard. About 1865 Mr. Packard became the largest owner in the Austin Flagstone Company, which investment yielded


YOUNGSTOWN AND THE MAHONING VALLEY - 233


him handsome returns. During Mr, Packard's busy career he accumulated more than one fortune, for with but few exceptions all of the enterprises to .which he gave his personal attention were successful; but through indorsements made for his associates he sustained losses that would have overshadowed to the grave less strong men ; nor did he follow the example of many other leading men of the Mahoning Valley who, having met with reverses during the panicky days immediately preceding and following the year 1873, sought relief through the bankruptcy courts; he merely bent his energies to recuperation and to the achievement of even greater results, and again succeeded through his own efforts, settling in full all of his obligations.


In 1867 Mr. Packard made a tour of Europe with his brother John, and while in England laid a broad foundation for importing hardware direct, which branch of his business he continued with increasing profit and volume until tariff laws turned the trade to our own shores. In 1874 Mr. Packard, three brothers and others spent the winter on the Pacific coast, and while the trip was intended for recreation purposes, Mr. Packard's commercial instinct led him to improve the opportunity and secure valuable trade connections. During the last twenty years of his splendid activity Mr. Packard thoroughly enjoyed his vacations at Chautauqua Lake, where he built the first cottage at Lakewood, New York, now dotted with 300 summer homes. With associates he purchased the farm upon which this delightful little village is located, and he never ceased to boom the region.


In September, 1852, Mr. Packard was married to Sylvia Camp, a daughter of the late Alanson Camp, of Warren. They had two sons born to them, namely: Harry, who died at the age of ten months, and Rollo, who died at the age of two years. His wife passed away in December, 1856, aged twenty-three years. In November, 1860, Mr. Packard was married to Mary E. Doud, and they became the parents of five children. She was born in Mendham, Morris County, New Jersey, and died at Warren on November 2, 1896.


Warren Packard was a man of broad vision and optimistic views, and through these characteristics he was able to carry out to magnificent completion plans others would not dare undertake. He was one who never learned that the word failure had a place in the language. When he met with reverses he faced them boldly and ofttimes turned them into success simply through his own grit and determination to "make good." The example he set and the influence he exerted are still reflected in the lives and works of not only his own sons, but those of other men who have taken up the responsibilities of the industrial and commercial life of the Mahoning Valley. To know Mr. Packard and have the privilege of associating with him was to receive a mental tonic and bracing inspiration, and there was probably no man in the Mahoning Valley who was held in higher esteem by his fellow citizens than the late Warren Packard, one of the most efficient and public-spirited business men this region has ever produced.


WILLIAM DOUD PACKARD, son of Warren and Mary E. (Doud) Packard, was born at Warren on November 3, 1861, and has practically spent his entire life in this city. He was educated in the public schools and at Ohio State University.


Early in life Mr. Packard gave evidence of having, to a marked degree, inherited his father's business genius. As a boy he and his brother James W. sold papers and established and operated a small printing office in their home, and with earnings thus accumulated paid the expenses of a visit to the Centennial Exposition at Philadelphia in 1876. He also learned telegraphy in his youth, and in later days was given an opportunity to make practical use of that knowledge.


Immediately after leaving college Mr. Packard took a position as bookkeeper and salesman in his father's hardware store, and when the latter became agent at Warren for the American Union Telegraph Company and the U. S. Express Company, young Packard became express clerk and telegraph operator. Later he was telegraph operator and conducted a news stand at his father's hotel at Lakewood, Chautauqua Lake, New York. He still later was identified with his father in the planing-mill at Warren as junior member of the firm of W. Packard & Son.


Upon the organization of the Packard Electric Company at Warren in woo Mr. Packard .became an executive of that concern, continuing with the company during that period while the Packard automobile was in course of development ; and as manager of the sales department of the Packard Motor Car Company he developed that part of the organization to an unusual degree. Upon the sale of the company to Detroit interests, and the removal of the company to that city, Mr. Packard retired from participation in all business affairs.


In 1911 he promulgated his plans by the purchase of a tract of fifty-five acres, of land on Mahoning Avenue and lying along the beautiful Mahoning River. This land he presented to the city to be used only for park purposes upon the condition that the city would undertake its development and perpetual up-keep. This latter arrangement was consummated by Mr. Packard only by the exercise of patience, perseverance and tact. The taxpayers desired Packard Park, but were loath to accept taxation for its development and up-keep, and in bringing his project to fruition Mr. Packard accomplished an undertaking second only in vital importance to the establishment of the park—an undertaking which was absolutely necessary for the establishment and maintenance of the park for the coming generations of Warren people. When the work of laying out and development of the park began Mr. Packard took charge as engineer, donating his services, and for the next three or four years he was fully and happily occupied with his work. Not being a voting citizen of Warren, Mr. Packard does not hold a place on the board of park trustees, at the same time, however, he has always, and does now, dominate the actions of the board with the full consent of all concerned.


Packard Park is the principal "show-spot" of the city and is of inestimable value to Warren, giving it


234 - YOUNGSTOWN AND THE MAHONING VALLEY


a delightful recreation spot along one of the attractive water courses of the valley. In donating the park and assisting in preparing it for public use Mr. Packard has reared a monument to himself and his family of greater actual value than the mightiest granite column ever set up to commemorate a person or an event. Not only is this park enjoyed by those now living, but it will be handed down as a priceless heritage to generations to come, who as they enjoy its many sylvan beauties will have cause to remember the founder and be grateful for his unselfish benevolence.


JAMES WARD PACKARD, son of Warren and Mary E. (Doud)) Packard, was born at Warren on November 5, 1863, and was educated in the public schools and at Lehigh University and graduated with the degree of Mechanical Engineer with the class of '84.


Mr. Packard's mechanical and inventive genius, together with his capacity for close application to the object in hand, have won him national recognition as an engineer, while his work as a pioneer in the development of the automobile has gained him a world-wide fame.


After leaving college, in the summer of 1884, Mr. Packard entered the shops of the Sawyer-Mann Electric Company at New York as a "dollar-a-day" man. Subsequently he was made assistant superintendent of the plant, and so continued for a number of years. Then, in 1890, after having gained a practical knowledge of the electrical industry, Mr. Packard returned to Warren and engaged in the manufacture of incandescent lamps under the firm name of the Packard Electric Company, which concern was not only the pioneer in that line in that city, but was the direct cause for Warren becoming the center for the manufacture of electric lamps. This pioneer company was but a modest affair at its inception, for capital was scarce and local interest and support were limited. In fact, had Mr. Packard not been able to interest outside capital it is doubtful if the young company would have been able to progress very far and certainly its progress would not have been rapid, and Warren might have been deprived of one of its largest and most beneficial industries of the present day. So the successful establishment of the Packard Electric Company was really the beginning of the transformation of the City of Warren with its then population of 5,000 into the industrial center of today, with a population of 30,000.


Mr. Packard was the president, general manager and guiding genius of the Packard Electric Company, and to him was due its success, for it was he who supplied the inventive genius and mechanical skill and enlisted the financial support which made possible its success. The Packard Electric Company later sold its business to the General Electric Company, but retained its corporate name and a part of its plant. Subsequently both the name and business were sold.


Mr. Packard has always worked along the lines of both invention and the development and application of methods of inventions already on the market. e early became interested in gasoline-driven vehicles, and before any of them were on the market he had made drawings along those lines. Later he purchased one of the first American made "horseless carriages" to come on the market, and his genius recognizing the great possibilities in its crude motor, he began experimenting along the lines of invention and development, and produced a finished automobile which ultimately became the "Packard" car of today.


Upon the organization of the Packard Motor Car Company, Mr. Packard became its president and general manager. A time came in the history of the company, however, when to assure needed expansion outside capital must be secured, and Mr. Packard induced a number of capitalists of Detroit to become interested. This resulted, in 1902, in the removal of the plant to Detroit, Mr. Packard continuing as president. Later he was made chairman of the board of directors of the company, a position he.held until April, 1915, when, desiring to retire from all active business affairs, he resigned, but retains his financial interest in the corporation.

Mr. Packard has maintained his summer home at Lakewood, Chautauqua Lake, New York, where he recently built a fine country residence, but still has his winter home at Warren. He belongs to the Engineers' Club of New York City, the Union Club of Cleveland, the Detroit Club of Detroit, and in point of membership is one of the oldest members of the Automobile Club of America, of New York City.


Mr. Packard was united in marriage with Elizabeth A. Gillmer, a daughter of Judge Thomas I. Gillmer of Warren. Mrs. Packard is a graduate of Vassar College.


GERARD C. CHIRICHIGNO. Identified with one of the leading industries of Mahoning County, Gerard C. Chirichigno, of Youngstown, has met with pronounced success in his career, and as general manager of the Youngstown Wire & Iron Company is a prominent factor in advancing the manufacturing interests not only of the firm by which he is employed but of the city and county. A son of Anthony and Louisa Chirichigno, he was born in 1890 in Italy. His parents came with their family to the United States many years ago, locating first in Pittsburg, 1896, but later settling in Youngstown, where the father engaged in the baking business on South Watt Street for upwards of twenty years.


A good student, anxious to learn, Gerard C. Chirichigno attended school regularly during his boyhood days, and later worked throughout his vacations in various structural iron plants. After his graduation from the Rayen High School, with the money thus earned Mr. Chirichigno entered the mechanical engineering department of the University of Pittsburg, from which he was graduated with the class of 1915, after which he was employed in the engineering department of the Carnegie Steel Plant and in the Petroleum Iron Works at Sharon, Pennsylvania, and later accepting a position with the Youngstown Wire & Iron Company he was sales manager for three years.


In 1919, when the company was reorganized, Mr. Chirichigno became a stockholder and the general manager, a position of great responsibility, which he is filling to the entire satisfaction of the firm and to its large patronage. The company, which makes a


YOUNGSTOWN AND THE MAHONING VALLEY - 235


specialty of structural and ornamental iron works, has recently moved to more commodious quarters, being very advantageously located in the old Sennett plant at Sycamore & Andrews Avenue. Mr. Chirichigno's brother Michael, a graduate also of the Rayen High School, returned to Youngstown in the summer of 1919 from France, where he was in service during a part of the World war.


Mr. Chirichigno married June 3o, 1919, Miss Angelina Parillo, of Girard, Ohio.




RUDOLF C. KURZ. Practical industry, wisely and vigorously applied, never fails of success. It carries a man onward and upward, brings out hrs individual character and acts as a powerful stimulus to the efforts of others. The greatest results in life are often attained by simple means and the exercise of the ordinary qualities of common sense and perseverance. The everyday life with its cares, necessities and duties, affords ample opportunities for acquiring experience of the best kind, and its most beaten paths provide a true worker with abundant scope for effort and progress. The record of Mr. Kurz is that of a man who by his own unaided efforts worked his way from a modest beginning to a place of affluence and influence in the business world, and today he enjoys the unbounded confidence of his fellow citizens of Youngstown.


Rudolf C. Kurz was born in Prussia on February 26, 1855, the son of August and Caroline (Stark) Kurz. August Kurz was a professional soldier and was a member of the Household Guard of Emperor William I of Germany. Eventually he sold his holdings in Germany and brought his family to the United States in 1866. He at once came to Youngstown and entered the employ of Parish & Nash, cabinetmakers. He afterwards worked in George Dingledy's mill and lumber yard, which were located on Basin Street; still later he worked for Lindsay & Boardman. With the money he brought from Germany he bought a comfortable home, where he lived until his death, which occurred in 1877, at the age of sixty-nine years. His widow died in 1879, when sixty-eight years of age. They were members of the Lutheran Church and were held in high esteem by those who knew them. They were the parents of twelve children, of whom those living are Rudolf C., and Pauline, of this city, the widow of William Hulzwhart.


Rudolf C. Kurz attended school in Germany, completing his common school studies in the old Woods Street school in this city, doing chores at the time and attending C. H. Andrews' horse. His first employment after he left school was in the old Brown-Bonnell mill, when eleven years old, packing nails, under Ned Jones ; beating nail plates, under Dick Ferguson; on rolls, under Dan Reibel, while among his other bosses were Frank Brown, Jack McDonald, Sam Fellows and Leonard Black, all of whom were well known among the iron men of that day. After four years in the iron mill Mr. Kurz applied himself to learn the blacksmith and wagonmaking trade with Siegfried & Lemley, their shop standing on the present site of Deibel's butcher shop on Federal Street. After completing his apprenticeship he with his brothers Ernest and Albert opened the shop now owned and operated by the subject and under the firm name E. Kurz and Brothers, and soon did a large and prosperous business. They also operated a harness and saddlery business on Phelps Street, where the Equity Saving & Loan Company is now located. Mr. Kurz was wisely economical and soon found himself getting ahead financially. He was a wise believer in real estate as an investment medium, and as he was able he made purchases of properties which have proven wise and profitable investments. His first purchase was the property where the Kurz hardware store is now located on Federal Street, and on that street he now owns ten store buildings, and among other properties owned by him is the oldest building in the city, the old schoolhouse. He is now rated as one of the largest individual property owners in Youngstown, and he is authority for the statement that he has never lost a cent on any real estate investment he has made. He has always been a hard worker, but has been blessed with splendid health and has enjoyed his work. He is now erecting a fine residence on Wick Avenue, and he expects to close his shop on the day he is sixty-five years of age.


Mr. Kurz has long occupied an enviable place in the esteem of his fellow citizens. He was twice elected a member of the city council, each time by tremendous majorities, and has been urged to accept other public offices, including that of mayor, but he has no ambition in that line and has steadfastly refused to become a candidate. Mr. Kurz is a trustee in the City Trust & Savings Bank, a trustee in the Equity Savings & Trust Company and a stockholder in the Peoples Bank of East Youngstown, Ohio.


In 1880 Rudolf C. Kurz was married to Amelia Krum, who was born near Bessemer. Springfield Township, this county, and to them were born five children, namely: Charles, who is manager of the Kurz hardware store; Clara, who is the wife of John Helcer, of Youngstown; Edward, who is in the grocery business on Wilson Avenue, this city; Harry is in the city engineer's office, while his twin sister, Carrie, is the wife of Ralph Smith, who is located at Omaha, Nebraska, as sales agent for the Truscon Steel Company. Mr. and Mrs. Kurz are members of the Lutheran Church. He is a democrat in politics.


WILLIAM WILSON is a civil engineer by profession and for thirty years has been actively connected with the building /trades of the Mahoning Valley. Some of the most important surveys in the valley testify to his achievements and the facilities of the organization with him.


Mr. Wilson early in life was employed by James Mackey, who for years stood in first rank of the civil and construction engineering profession in Eastern Ohio. Later he was associated with Charles Mackey, a son of James Mackey. This association continued until the death of Charles Mackey. Mr. Wilson was civil engineer for Niles about twelve years, resigning in the year 1907. At the present time he is engineer for Girard, Hubbard and Lowellville, and also has a very large private practice in Youngstown. A few of the more important surveys handled by this association were for the Union Iron & Steel


236 - YOUNGSTOWN AND THE MAHONING VALLEY


Company plants (now Carnegie), the Republic Rubber Company, the Pollock Boiler Company, the General Fireproofing Company, the Truscon Steel Company, the Stambaugh Building, the First National Bank Building, the Wick Building, the Mahoning National Bank Building, the Home Savings & Loan Building, McKelvey Building, Ohio Hotel Building and many others.


Mr. Wilson is a member of the Youngstown Engineers Club, the Ohio Engineering Society, the American Association of Engineers and the American Water Works Association.


WALTER LEE KAUFFMAN, credit manager of the Youngstown Sheet & Tube Company, has been intimately connected with the iron and, steel industry of this city for over thirty years.

He was born in Mechanicsburg, Cumberland County, Pennsylvania, August 9, 1860. He had an older brother, Percival Coover, who was born in 1857, and a sister, Edith Belle, who was younger. He was early educated at Lauderbach Academy at Philadelphia and the Cumberland Valley Institute at Mechanicsburg. Afterward he learned the trade of printing at the Thomas Printing House in Mechanicsburg, Pennsylvania, and then entered Dickinson College, Carlisle, Pennsylvania, class of 1882.


His father, Levi Kauffman, was a prominent banker in Mechanicsburg, Pennsylvania, collector of revenue for the Fifteenth District of Pennsylvania during President Lincoln's administration, and one of the organizers of the republican party and very active in its affairs. The mother, Ann Elizabeth Coover, was a daughter of John Coover, Esq., a prominent merchant in Mechanicsburg. She was the granddaughter of Hon. George Coover (Kober), an extensive land owner of Southern Pennsylvania, who was a member of the Continental Congress that elected Washington president.


Walter Lee Kauffman left college and was connected with the American Tube & Iron Company, Middletown, Pennsylvania, from January, 1881, to May, 1886, when he removed to Youngstown, Ohio, to take charge of the offices of the Youngstown Mills of the same company, which were then just building, and later was made manager, and continued with them until the plant was purchased by the National Tube Company on June I, 1899, and was known as their Youngstown department, afterwards becoming a subsidary company of the United States Steel Corporation, when he was made manager, and continued as such until July I, 1908, at which time the plant was abandoned and dismantled. e then was connected with the Ohio Iron & Steel Company and the Carbon Limestone Company of Youngstown, Ohio, until February T, 1909, when he became credit manager of the Youngstown Sheet & Tube Company, Youngstown, Ohio, one of the largest steel manufacturing industries of the country.


He has always been a republican in politics, is a member of the First Presbyterian Church of Youngstown, a member of the Sigma Chi college fraternity, and is also a Mason. He is fond of golf and all outdoor sports; has always been prominent in club life, and is a member of the Youngstown Club, and the Youngstown Country Club of Youngstown, Ohio, and of the Duquesne Club of Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. His residence is 748 Bryson Street, Youngstown, Ohio.


FREDERICK H. MUNKELT. Few industries of the world surpass in importance that of the iron and steel, and among the firms of consequence in this wide field is the Petroleum Iron Company of Sharon, of which Frederick H. Munkelt is a director and the assistant sales manager.


Although he is a native of England, born in London May 13, 1886, he was but eight years of age when brought by his parents, Julius A. and Charlotte E. (Brown) Munkelt, to the United States. It was as the American representative of Winsor & Newton, an artist supply material firm of London, England, that Julius A. Munkelt became identified with the life and interests of this country. Both he and his wife are now living in Brooklyn, New York.


It was also in the City of Brooklyn that their son Frederick H. attained to manhood's estate and graduated from high school in February, 1903. He then matriculated in Dartmouth College, from which he was graduated in 1908 with the degree of B. S., and in 1909 Dartmouth conferred upon him the degree of C. E. Following this college training Mr. Munkelt went to Elmira, New York, where he was assigned as draftsman with the American Bridge Company, and in the fall of 1910 severed his interests there to join the estimating and designing department of the American Bridge Company in New York City. During his connection with that organization he served in various capacities and gained an excellent knowledge of the fundamentals of the iron industry.


In 1914 Mr. Munkelt came to Youngstown, Ohio, the city in which his interests have since been centered and in which he has gained a foothold in the business world. He at once became identified with the Petroleum Iron Works Company of Sharon, Pennsylvania, as a salesman, and from October, 1914, until July, 1915, represented this company in the oil fields of Oklahoma, Texas and Kansas. From April, 1916, until April, 1917, inclusive, he has charge of the St. Louis office of the corporation; from May, 1917, until January, 1919, represented his company at Washington, D. C., in an important capacity during the war, also representing the Steel Fabricators of the United States at the same time, and since then he has served as assistant sales manager of the Petroleum Iron Company, and is a director also of the Petroleum Iron Works Company of Ohio. Mr. Munkelt is an associate member of the American Society of Civil Engineers and the Thayer Society of Civil Engineers, the latter an organization of Dartmouth graduates from the civil engineering course, and is a member of the Kappa Sigma college fraternity and of the Youngstown Chamber of Commerce.


On the 12th of April, 1916, Mr. Munkelt was married to Miss Jessie F. Pounds, of Brooklyn, New York, and to them has been born one daughter, Elizabeth Gertrude. The family are members of the First Presbyterian Church.


JAMES ELLSWORTH HEASLEY. Twenty-five years of active business           connection constitue the record of


YOUNGSTOWN AND THE MAHONING VALLEY - 237


James Ellsworth easley as a resident of Warren. In later years his energies and means have been drawn into a number of enterprises, but the basis of his business was his trade as a plumber and he is still proprietor of the Warren eating & Plumbing Company.


Mr. Heasley was born in Lawrence County, Pennsylvania, about ten miles east of Youngstown, on June 24, 863. His parents, Elias P. and Josephine (Davis) Heasley, were both born in Mercer County, Pennsylvania, the Heasleys being of remote German ancestry. Elias Heasley spent his active life as a farmer in Lawrence County and died there in May, 1900, at the age of sixty-three. He is survived by his widow, who is now in her eighty-first year.


James E. Heasley left the farm when about nineteen years of age and coming to Youngstown served an apprenticeship of four years to learn the plumber's trade under Montgomery Thompson. His first independent venture was his partnership with William Burnett, under the name Burnett & easley, plumbers, but after a year he sold out to his partner and removed to Sharon, Pennsylvania, where he was foreman of the Leslie & Naylor Plumbing Company three years.


On coming to Warren irl 1894 Mr. Heasley bought the stove and hardware business of James Reed & Son, and with William N. Henderson established the firm of Henderson & easley, hardware merchants and plumbers. He was an active associate in this enterprise, selling out in 1906 to Mr. enderson and then confining his entire attention to plumbing, wilh a shop on South Park Avenue. A year later his business was removed to the Masonic Building on East Market. In two, having purchased the old Judge Hutchins property at 228 East Market Street, Mr. Heasley established the Warren Plumbing & Heating Company there, its present location. More recently, in 1918, he thoroughly remodeled that property by building a brick garage, the rear part of which is three stories, on ground 6o by no feet, the one-story show room in front being 100 by 20 feet.


In 1917 Mr. Heasley with William Loveless built the "L. & H." Block, the initials indicating the names of the builders. This is a three-story brick building, 6o by 65 feet on a lot 120 by 6o feet, and contains three storerooms below and ten apartments above. Mr. Heasley has also used his capital to construct a number of residences in different parts of the city. He is a director of the People's Savings & Loan Company of Warren.


Other associations with his home city are as a member of the Warren Board of Trade, Old Erie Lodge No. 3, Free and Accepted Masons, Warren Commandery No. 39, Knights Templar, Al Koran Temple of the Mystic Shrine at Cleveland, Mahoning Lodge of Odd Fellows and Warren Lodge of Elks. December 22, 1896, Mr. Heasley married Mary A. Henderson. They have a son and daughter, William P. and Justina. William P., born February 12, 1900, during his senior year in the Warren High School enlisted in the Medical Reserve Corps, and saw one year of service and duty at a base hospital iN France. Since his honorable discharge he has pursued his college career at the Ohio Wesleyan University at Delaware. The daughter, Justina, born July 1, 1904, is now a member of the junior class of the Warren High School. Mr. Heasley is a member of the First Methodist Episcopal Church.


J. CLYDE CAMPBELL, While not a veteran in years, it rs doubtful rf any man in Youngstown has had a more varied and active connection with the steel interests of the Mahoning Valley than J. Clyde Campbell. For a number of years Mr. Campbell has been employment manager of the Youngstown Sheet and Tube Company.


He was born at Hubbard, Ohio, April 16, 1877, and thus grew up in a district of steel mills and industrial life. He is one of the surviving children in the family of six born to Alexander Campbell and Caroline Veach. His mother is now deceased. His grandfather, Hugh Campbell, was an early settler in this section of Ohio. Alexander Campbell was for many years a useful and honored citizen of Trumbull County. He was a school master affectionately remembered by many in that county, and for a number of years was principal of the Hubbard schools. He also served as mayor of Hubbard and for four years was a county commissioner of Trumbull County. His present home is over the state line at Sharon, Pennsylvania, where he lives retired.


J. Clyde Campbell grew up in Hubbard and is a graduate of the high school of that town. At the age of twenty years he went to work for the Mahoning Valley Iron Company at Youngstown as weighmaster and shipping clerk in the blast furnace. Two years later he was made storekeeper, and subsequently assistant paymaster. Upon the organization of the steel trust he was transferred to the district office at Youngstown of the Republic Iron and Steel Company. He was in the freight and purchasing departments, and subsequently was sent to Alexandria, Indiana, and to Springfield, Illinois, to remove Bessemer mills which, were part of the interests of the great merger. Later he was employed in the order department of the Republic Iron and Steel Company at Youngstown. A year later he resigned and went to Girard, Ohio, in the mill order department of the Carnegie Steel Company. Since February, 1902, his home has been at Youngstown and his connection with the Youngstown Sheet & Tube Company continuous. For ten years he was assistant paymaster, for two years was in the cost department, and since 1914 has been employment manager, a post of great responsibility and calling for all the tact and experience of Mr. Campbell.


He is a republican in politics and is a Royal Arch Mason. July 19, 1902, he married Miss Gertrude Paisley, of Youngstown, daughter of Robert A. and Mary (Porter) Paisley. They have one son, Robert A., always known in the family as Bob. Mr. and Mrs. Campbell are members of the First Presbyterian Church.


OWEN DAVID MORGAN. The late Owen D. Morgan ws closely identified with the business, civic and social life of the Mahoning Valley for over thirty years, and at the time of his death he was one of the best-known and highly esteemed men in the entire valley. During his active business career he met with success out of the ordinary, overcame all


238 - YOUNGSTOWN AND THE MAHONING VALLEY


difficulties, and became one of the really worthwhile men of the community. e was a self-made man in the truest sense of that term, for he began life as an apprentice, mastered his trade, went into business on his own account and succeeded, aided only by his inherent qualities of heart and mind—an ambition to succeed, industry and perseverance, backed up by absolute integrity and sound judgment.


Mr. Morgan was born in South Wales on April 6, 1858, the son of David and Jane (Bowen) Morgan. David Morgan brought his family over from South Wales in 1860 and located in Youngstown. A few years later he removed to his farm in Hubbard, Trumbull County, and was a farmer for a number of years, then returned to Youngstown, in which city he and his wife passed their declining years.


Owen D. Morgan was a child of two years when the family came to the United States. His early days were spent in Youngstown and on his father's farm in Hubbard. After leaving school he served an apprenticeship at the carriage and wagon-maker's trade, and worked at the trade for a number of years, or until he had gained sufficient experience to get into business on his own account.


In 1889 Mr. Morgan came to Warren and established a carriage and wagon shop in partnership with Gotlib Lemley, under the firm name of Morgan and Lemley. Later Mr. Lemley sold his interest in the business to enry Siegfried, who later sold out to the late William A. Williams, Mr. Morgan's brother- in-law. Under the firm name of Morgan and Williams the business was developed substantially and became one of the prominent industries of Warren. However, with the advent of the automobile, the firm became sales agents for the Overland car for a territory embracing nine counties, and that business was successfully carried on by Mr. Morgan and Mr. Williams until 1917, when both partners retired from active business, Mr. Morgan removing to Pasadena, California, in search of health.


Mr. Morgan was also associated with Mr. Williams in the organization of the Warren Realty and Trust Company, and served as treasurer of that corporation for some time. He also held other important business interests in Warren, but for several years had not been active in the management of any enterprise.


In 1886 Mr. Morgan was united in marriage with Miss Mary Morris Griffith, who was born in Tallmadge, Summit County, Ohio, the daughter of Thomas and Mary (Morris) Griffith, natives of South Wales. When Mrs. Morgan was a child of six months the family removed to Youngstown, where for a number of years Mr. Griffith was engaged in the real estate business, and in which city he and his wife died. Thomas and Griffith streets in Youngstown were named in honor of Mr. Griffith.


Mr. Morgan was a member of Central Christian Church and Old Erie Lodge of Masons of Warren.


After their removal to California Mr. and Mrs. Morgan returned to Warren on annual visits, and it was while on one of these visits that Mr. Morgan's death occurred on May 27, 1920, his death coming as a shock to the entire community.


The life of Mr. Morgan was so unselfish, so useful and so placid, and his personality was so genial, so kind and wholesome, that he won the regard of all with whom he had business dealings and the esteem of all with whom he came in contact in any relation. Warm hearted, generous and genial, he gained and held the true friendship of many men, men who regarded his friendship as a blessing and mourn his passing away. A faithful friend, a fond husband, a true man, a good citizen, are the terms applied to the man and his deeds.




CHESTER CURTIS WALLER, M D. During his residence in the Mahoning Valley the professional distinctions associated with Chester C. Waller are due almost altogether to his exceptional abilities and skill as a surgeon. He was in the general practice of medicine for a number of years before coming to the Mahoning Valley and locating at Warren, where his rare equipment and talents have earned him special recognition in the difficult field of surgery.


Doctor Waller is a native of Northern Vermont and represents an old American family, his branch of the family having been pioneers in Northern Vermont. His great-grandfather, Joseph Waller, presided over the first divine meeting for worship in that section of the state. enry C. Waller, father of Doctor Waller, was born in Vermont, in early life was a farmer and later was a merchant at Irasburg, where he died in 1879. e was very active and influential in the Grange. Henry C. Waller married Josephine Bogue, a native of Northern Vermont. She survived her husband only four months. er father, Virgil P. Bogue, a Vermont farmer, had a family of three sons and five daughters, all the sons becoming physicians, while one daughter married a Physician. The great-uncle of Doctor Wallet of Warren was Dr. R. G. Bogue, who was one of the early medical men in the City of Chicago. Doctor Waller is one of four sons, being the oldest of the family. His brother, Henry A., for the past fourteen years has been superintendent of the Providence and Dandleson Street Railway Company. Halley T. is secretary of the Young Men's Christian Association at Akron, Ohio, and president of the board of education of that city. Percy C. is a physician in Vermont.


Dr. C. C. Waller was born at Irasburg, Orleans County, Vermont, March 14, 1872. As a boy he lived in the rugged environment of a Vermont farm. He attended district schools, also the Vermont Methodist Seminary at Montpelier, and spent one year in the study of medicine at the University of Vermont. Another year he was in the medical department of Dartmouth College, and his third and final year was spent at the Baltimore Medical College, now the medical department of the University of Maryland. He graduated there with the M. D. degree in 1898. Doctor Waller spread his medical work among these three schools from conscious intention and not as a result of circumstance. It was his desire to get the advantages of the methods and come in touch with the able men of all three institutions.


Doctor Waller practiced for fourteen years in his home town in Vermont. Early in his career he dis-


YOUNGSTOWN AND THE MAHONING VALLEY - 239


covered a special aptitude for surgery and neglected no opportunity to specialize in that line. For a number of years he was a regular attendant at the surgical clinics held in Montreal, Canada, a city only ninety miles from his home town. In 1912 Doctor Waller located at Lyndonville, Vermont, where he began specializing in surgery. At the same time he was affiliated with the Brightlook and St. Johnsbury hospitals. After considerable investigation Doctor Waller determined to locate at Warren, and his home has been in that city since October 1815. From the first he confined his work largely to surgery. The preceding four years he had given all his spare time to research study and attendance at the hospitals and clinics.


Doctor Waller was commissioned a captain in the Medical Reserve Corps, May 16, 1917. He was ordered to active duty the 28th of June and nine days later assigned administrative work. September 4, 1917, he was assigned to the Seventy-sixth Division at Camp Devens, Massachusetts, in command of the Regimental Detachment of the Three Hundred and First Infantry. March 23, 1918, he was commissioned major in the Medical Corps, and on July 6th was ordered to France with the above organization. September 23, 1918, he was made division sanitary inspector and assigned to the office of division surgeon. November 5th he was made acting division surgeon by special order No. 92, paragraph 14, at headquarters of the Third Depot Division, American Expeditionary Forces, American Post Office No. 773. He was continued in that capacity until the completion of the transfer of officers and men of the Seventy-sixth Division, and then, on November 29, 1918, was requested by the chief surgeon of the intermediate section to take station at Navarre, France, with the Nineteenth Engineers (Pennsylvania Railway outfit), the purpose of which assignment was to expedite sanitary measures in the checking of typhoid and diarrhea. diseases that had been defying all efforts to eradicate since the preceding January. A promise was given him at the time, as a reward, of an immediate transfer home. This promise materialized December 24, 1918, when he received home orders. He was honorably discharged at Camp Mills, New York, April 28, 1919, and on the 5th of June following resumed his work at Warren.


Aside from rendering patriotic service to his country, Doctor Waller looked upon the army service as an opportunity for valuable surgical experience, but his special genius for administrative work caused his various assignments as above noted, and, as a matter of fact, lie handled only a single case of surgery all the time he was in the army, that being aU emergency appendicitis operation. Since returning from France Doctor Waller has limited his practice to surgery and diagnosis.


Doctor Waller is a member of the Trumbull County and Ohio State Medical societies and of the American Medical Association, and is affiliated with Carroll F. Clapp Lodge Free and Accepted Masons, it Warren, the Warren Lodge, Knights of Pythias, Warren Lodge of Elks, and the Warren Rotary Club.


Doctor Waller married Grace M. White, daughter of Charles C. and Miranda White, of North Troy, Vermont. Mrs. Waller died in 1911, the mother of three children : David Wilkie, born rn 1903; Gerald Charles, born in 1907; and Geraldine Rosamond, born in 1908.


In 1913 Doctor Waller married his present wife, who was Emily Waller, a distant relative and a childhood friend, a woman of rare attributes, who has assumed the maternal care of the doctor's children.


JOHN MCKENZIE HENDERSON. One of the agencies that has contributed most to the volume of the automobile business at Warren is the Henderson Motor Car Company, of which John M. Henderson is general manager and treasurer. Mr. Henderson has been exceptionally successful in the automobile field, though he came to it from the field of art. For a number of years he was a well known teacher of music, with a studio at Cleveland.


Mr. Henderson was born at Youngstown, April 21, 1878, son of William and Justina (McKenzie) Henderson. His parents were born in Scotland, and about a year and a half after their marriage they came to the United States and located at Youngstown. William Henderson was identified with the Brown-Bonnell plant at Youngstown as foreman in the puddling department for over thirty years. He died in March, 1914, at Youngstown, where his wife is still living.


John M. Henderson acquired a public school education at Youngstown. He early evinced special talents in music and largely by his own efforts acquired a liberal musical education. For eight years he was a student under some of the best instructors in New York City. His professional career began in 1907 as director of music at Simpson College, Indianola, Iowa, where in addition he taught vocal four .years. He then returned to Ohio, establishing a studio in Cleveland, where he remained five years. During that time he was head of the music department at Hiram College.


Mr. Henderson gave up his profession in 1916 to enter the automobile business. His first location was at Niles, where he was president of the Henderson Motor Car Company. A year later the business was removed to Warren. This company now handles and distributes the Overland and Willys-Knight cars and the Garford trucks, and has rolled up an imposing aggregate of business for those well known makes.


Mr. Henderson is president of the Trumbull County Automobile Trades Association, is a member of the Warren Automobile Club and the National Automobile Club. He is also active in the Warren Board of Trade, the Warren Rotary Club, and is affiliated with Carroll F. Clapp Lodge of Masons, the Royal Arch Chapter and Warren Lodge of Elks.


Mr. Henderson married Miss Jane Caldwell, daughter of James and Belinda (Connor) Caldwell. er parents were natives of Ireland. Her father was long a resident of Youngstown and built the monument in the Square in that city. For that work compensation to him was delayed thirty-five years. Mr. and Mrs. enderson have three children: Bruce Pauley, Dorothy Virginia and Louise Caldwell.


240 - YOUNGSTOWN AND THE MAHONING VALLEY


HARRY S. SMITH. One of the successful businessmen and popular citizens of Warren is Harry S. Smith, who has been closely identified with the affairs of the city for over twenty years, during which time he has worked his way up from journeyman to owner of one of the leading plumbing and heating concerns in this part of the Mahoning Valley.


Mr. Smith is a native of this valley, and is in the fourth generation of his family here. His paternal great-grandfather was one of the earliest settlers of the valley, and his grandfather, William Smith, was born here. His father, William A. Smith, was born at Petersburg, and is at the present time engaged in carpentering and cabinet making in Youngstown. His mother, Caroline (Felker) Smith, daughter of John P. Felker, was born at New Springfield, and died in 1904.


Harry S. was born at New Springfield, Mahoning County, on March 29, 1873. He was educated in the Youngstown public schools, and in that city he served an apprenticeship at the plumbing trade with the old firm of Stambaugh & Thompson. After finishing his three years' apprenticeship he worked for the old firm as journeyman until 1900, in which year he came to Warren and worked as a journeyman for two years, and in 1902, being ambitious to have a business of his own, he opened a small shop on West Market Street. He began in a small way with limited capital, but his skill as a workman and his business and personal qualities were soon recognized, and his business grew rapidly. In order to obtain quarters to accommodate his increasing business, he removed to the Masonic Temple Building on East Market and Pine streets, and in 1907 he formed a partnership with the late F. F. Childs, under the firm name of Smith & Childs, plumbers, and gas-fitters. In 1916, upon the death of Mr. Childs, the entire business was taken over by Mr. Smith, which by now has grown into one of the largest plumbing and steam-heating concerns in this section of Ohio, with offices, show rooms and work-rooms at 27 North Pine Street.


Mr. Smith is active and prominent in his business and has been honored by the trade associations. He is past president of the Ohio State Association of Master Plumbers, and is president of the Mahoning Valley Master Plumbers' Association. He is a member of the Warren Builders' Exchange, of the Warren Board of Trade and of the Warren Rotary Club. He is a member of Old Erie Lodge No. 3, Free and Accepted Masons, past eminent commander of Warren Commandery No. 39, Knights Templar, and belongs to Cleveland Consistory (thirty-second degree) Scottish Rite.


Mr. Smith married Bertha E. Boynton of Youngstown and both of them are members of the First Methodist Episcopal Church.




HALSEY WILLARD TAYLOR. The credit and responsibility belong to Mr. Taylor for giving Warren one of its most prosperous and distinctive industries, the extensive plant which today manufactures many types of drinking fountains, known generally to the trade as the Puritan Fountains, all made from the designs and under the patents owned and controlled by Mr. Taylor.


Mr. Taylor has spent most of his life in this section of Ohio. He was born at Pickering, Missouri, February 18, 1877, and was about one year old when his parents, Alfred C. and Josephine L. (Sturgill) Taylor, came to Ohio and settled at Leavittsburg in Trumbull County. His father was a native of New York State and his mother of Missouri. The family lived at Leavittsburg about sixteen years, Alfred 'Taylor being local agent of the Erie Railroad. He was one of thousands attracted to the opening of the Cherokee strip in Oklahoma Territory in 1892, and his family followed him to the west. Alfred Taylor died there in 1893, and the widowed mother and her children then returned to Leavittsburg. In the spring of 1893 they moved to Warren.


Halsey W. Taylor acquired his education in the public schools of Leavittsburg. At the age of fourteen he found an opening for work in the foundry of the Neracher Sprinkler Works at Warren, now known as the Grinnell Company. Every night and morning he walked back and forth from his home in Leavittsburg to the plant, but later found work nearer home at the Erie Railway transfer at Leavittsburg. Then after the western experience of the family and their return to Warren, Mr. Taylor found employment for six years in the old Warren Stove Works, which plant, doubled in floor space, Mr. Taylor recently bought and it is now the home of his own company. On leaving the Warren Stove Works he became an employe of the Packard Electric Works, and was with that industry for sixteen years, thirteen years of that time as shop superintendent.


In the meantime Mr. Taylor had been exercising his inventive genius by working out some ideas and plans of his own. With N. A. Wolcott of the Packard Electric Company, and Evan J. Thomas, he completed the organization of the Halsey W. Taylor Company in September, 1913, Mr. Thomas withdrawing shortly afterward. This company was founded for the purpose of manufacturing a patented drinking fountain designed by Mr. Taylor. On November 1, 1919, Mr. Taylor acquired Mr. Wolcott's interest and is now sole owner of the business. e manufactures the Puritan drinking fountain under his own invention and patents, and has made several of the most valuable improvements in sanitary drinking fountains. During the World war he was the only manufacturer who succeeded in meeting the exacting requirements of the Government for a sanitary drinking fountain to be used in the Government cantonments and naval training stations. His fountain was adopted over many competitors, and fountains manufactured in his plant at Warren were used in the various cantonments, naval training stations and aviation camps in France.


This business has been one of steady growth and development. At the beginning only one type of fountain was manufactured, but at the present time the output consists of from thirty to forty sizes, forms and types, all of them designed by Mr. Taylor. He now has contracts with some of the chief interests in the country requiring this product. There has been a proportionate increase in the plant at Warren. until now it utilizes 34,000 square feet of floor space, with fifty skilled laborers in the plant, and today this company is the largest exclusive manufacturer of sanitary drinking equipment in the world.


YOUNGSTOWN AND THE MAHONING VALLEY - 241


Mr. Taylor is a member of the Warren Rotary Club, the Board of Trade, Benevolent and Protective Order of Elks and the Country Club. He and his family are members of the First Baptist Church. e married Miss Laura J. McComb, of Warren, daughter of William C. and Elizabeth (McGregor) McComb. They have four children, Halsey Willard, Jr., Laura Evelyn, Velva Effie and Ann Eleanor.


WALLACE ANDREW LYNN. The strong and efficient administration of municipal affairs under the present able regime of Mayor McBride has brought general satisfaction to the people of Warren. One of the able members of the mayor's cabinet is the director of safety, Wallace Andrew Lynn.


Mr. Lynn has spent most of his life in Warren, and has always shown much capability in everything he has undertaken. He was born in Warren Township, about five miles from the city, on May 18, 1877, son of George F. and Mary (Kibler) Lynn. His father was born in Cornersburg, Mahoning County, and when a boy his father, Peter Lynn, moved to Warren Township. Mary Kibler was born in Warren Township south of Leavittsburg. er father, George Kibler, was a native of Germany and at the age of fourteen came with his parents on a sailing vessel, and after a 142 day's on the water landed in this country and subsequently established a home in Trumbull County. George F. Lynn and wife, are still living on the home farm, the former in his sixty-sixth year and the latter at the age of sixty-nine.


Wallace Andrew Lynn grew up on a farm, was educated in district schools, and at the age of eighteen left home and came to Warren. He learned the trade of blacksmithing with the firm of Klippel & McCrackin. After three years at Warren he established a shop of his own at Rosemont in Mahoning County, remained there three years, and then returning to Warren bought the shop where he had learned his trade. He has since developed a profitable and extensive business, both in general blacksmithing and in horseshoeing.


Mr. Lynn is a member of Old Erie Lodge No. 3, Free and Accepted Masons, Trumbull Lodge No. 186 of the Moose and the American Insurance Union. He is a member of the Masonic Club. e assumed his duties as director of safety for the City of Warren on January I, 1920.


Mr. Lynn and family are members of the First Reformed Church. He married Alice Toot, who was born at Lordstown, daughter of John and Mary (Bailey) Toot. Mr. and Mrs. Lynn have four children : Harold, who was born in 'goo and is now in the employ of the Second National Bank at Warren; Gertrude, born in 19o4; Kenneth, born in 1907; and Mildred, born in 1915.


GEORGE TAYLER HECKLINGER began his fourth successive term as city auditor of Warren on January I, 1920. Besides these official duties he is now and has for a number of years been one of the well qualified lawyers of Trumbull County. He has found the rewards of his profession in the same locality where he has spent his life and where his family have lived for many years.


Mr. Hecklinger was born at Warren, February 1, 1875, son of Martin and Adaline (Tayler) Hecklinger, His grandfather, Martin Hecklinger, brought his family to the United States in 1856, locating first in Youngstown and later in Warren, where he was a merchant. Martin Hecklinger, Jr., was born in France in 1848 and was about eight years of age when he came to Ohio. For many years he was an active factor in the manufacturing and industrial life of Warren, but has lived retired since 1918. e and his wife are highly respected citizens of Warren. Adaline Tayler was born at Warren in 1851. er father, Matthew B. Tayler, was for many years cashier of the old First National Bank of Warren.


George Tayler ecklinger was reared in Warren, attended the public schools and graduated in 19o4 from Mercersburg College in Pennsylvania. He read law with his uncle, J. J. Sullivan, now of Cleveland, then of Warren, and was also a law student in the University of Pennsylvania, graduating and receiving his LL, B. degree in 1906. e was admitted to the bar that year and was soon busy with a growing practice in his native city. Mr. Hecklinger was first elected city auditor in 1914, and has been chosen his own successor three times.


He does his part as a good citizen, is a member of the Warren Board of Trade, and affiliated with Old Erie Lodge No. 3, Ancient Free and Accepted Masons, Warren Chapter No. 66, Royal Arch Masons, Mahoning Lodge No. 69 of the Independent Order of Odd Fellows, and Warren Lodge No. 295 of the Elks. He is also a member of the First Methodist Episcopal Church. January 24, 1900, Mr. Hecklinger married Miss Cathryne Vogeley. Her father, William Vogeley, is a member of the Vogeley Oil Company of Pittsburg.


MYRON SEATON CURTIS was born at Washington, District of Columbia, October 29, 1888, a lineal descendant of the old Curtis family of Scituate, Massachusetts. His grandfather, Charles T. Curtis, was a civil engineer, and during the Civil war had charge of the construction of Cabin John's Bridge, the historic aqueduct erected by the government near Washington, which was at that time the longest single-span stone bridge in the world. His parents are William T. S. Curtis and Mary (Barnard) Curtis, residing at Chevy Chase, Maryland.


Mr. Curtis was educated at George Washington University as a chemical engineer and came to Youngstown in 1911. He entered the works of the Youngstown Sheet & Tube Company, and has been connected with that company since that time, being now special agent. He was married in November, 1913, to Nellie, daughter of John R. and Etta (Bowman) Squire, of Youngstown, and resides at 278 Redondo Road, Youngstown.


Mr. Curtis is a member of the American Iron & Steel Institute, the American Society for Testing Materials, the Youngstown Club, the Youngstown Country Club and the First Presbyterian Church.


WILLIAM FLETCHER EDWARDS, one of the leading business men of Warren, has been identified with the manufacturing interests of the city since 1893. He has on many occasions during these years demon-


242 - YOUNGSTOWN AND THE MAHONING VALLEY


strated his readiness to cooperate with and support any project that seemed to him to promise good for some phase of the affairs of the city, and by his public spirit and his industrial effort has had an important part in the progress of Warren during the last generation.


He was born at Niles, Trumbull County, Ohio, July 6, 1873, the son of John F. and Nancy (Martin) Edwards, and grandson of Samuel Edwards, who was one of the pioneers of the Mahoning Valley. The Edwards family is of British origin, but has had residence in America for many generations. Early the family appears to have been in Virginia, but Benjamin Edwards, great-great-grandfather of William F., lived in Butler County of the State of Pennsylvania, and there his son John was born. Samuel, son of John, was also born in Butler County, Pennsylvania, the year of his birth being 1812. He was quite a young man when he came into Ohio and settled in the Mahoning Valley at Niles, Trumbull County. He endured the privations that fell to the lot of the average pioneer, and he was evidently a man of strong purpose, for whatever hardships came to him he met and overcame them, or the family has had connection with Niles since he first settled there. John F. Edwards, his son, and the father of William F., was born in the family homestead at Niles. He was for many years employed in the iron mills at Niles, and when he retired from business in 1892 he removed to Warren, where he lived for the remainder of his life, which ended in 1900. He married Nancy Martin, daughter of Benjamin Martin, a Kentucky planter. She was born in Lexington, Kentucky, and died in 1905, in Warren, Ohio, although for the greater part of her life she had lived in Niles, Trumbull County, Ohio.


William Edwards, son of John F. and Nancy (Martin) Edwards, spent his early life in his home town, attending the public schools of Niles. His first employment was in the clothing store of J. L. Hudson, Detroit. In the same year, however, he became an employe of the Detroit Steel and Spring Company, working in the Detroit plant of the company. For several years he was employed in the Old Mill at Niles, Ohio, and with the Reeves Brothers Boiler Works in that city. In 1893 he came to Warren with Mr. A. R. Hughes and Benjamin W. Edwards, his younger brother, the three in that year organizing and establishing in Warren a manufacturing plant which is now known as the Warren City Tank and Boiler Company. In 1908 the business had reached such dimensions that with a view to further rapid expansion corporate powers were secured, and as an incorporated concern the enterprise took the name of the Warren City Tank and Boiler Company, of which Mr. William F. Edwards is vice president. He has taken active part in the management of the company since its inception, and much of its present standing among American boiler plants is due to the business ability of Mr. Edwards.


He is a member of all Masonic bodies, belonging to Old Erie Lodge No. 3, Free and Accepted Masons, to Warren Commandery No. 39, Knights Templar, to Lake Erie Consistory, thirty-second degree Scottish Rite, and to Al Koran Temple of the Mystic Shrine. He also is affiliated with the War ren Lodge of Elks. Socially he is a member of the County Club, Cleveland Athletic Club, Old Colony Club, which last named organization maintains quarters in leading hotels of large cities expressly for the accommodation and comfort of its members who might be visiting in those cities.


Mr. Edwards married Meda, daughter of Noah Vest, of Missouri. The late distinguished United States Senator Vest of Missouri was a member of the family to which Mrs. Edwards belongs. To Mr. and Mrs. Edwards have been born three children: Helen J., born May I, 1903; Harold W., born December 20, 1904; Arthur M., born December 19, 1905.




CHARLES C CHRYST. If Charles C. Chryst had never accomplished anything more than the carrying out of his successful campaign in favor of good roads in Trumbull County his name would be enshrined among the worth-while citizens of the Mahoning Valley. He has always been an enthusiast on this subject, to which he has given thorough and practical attention, and has managed to communicate some of this enthusiasm to his fellow citizens with very gratifying results, as those passing over the fine roads constructed under his administration as road commissioner testify upon all occasions.


Charles C. Chryst was born on the old Chryst homestead in Weathersfield Township, Trumbull County, on September 12, 1856, and is descended from one of the old and prominent families of the Mahoning Valley. Solomon R. Chryst, his father, was born at Lordstown, Trumbull County, in 1833. a son of Jacob Chryst. Jacob Chryst was born in the vicinity of Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, a son of the original American ancestor who came here from Germany at the close of the eighteenth century and settled in Pennsylvania. Leaving the Keystone State, Jacob Chryst came to the Mahoning Valley sometime between 1817 and 1820, settling rn Lordstown Township when that section was a forest. He bought considerable land, became a successful farmer, and lived to reach his eighty-eighth year.


Solomon Chryst moved into Weathersfield Township, where he was engaged in farming and the buying and selling of stock for many years, becoming known all over Trumbull County as a man of irreproachable character and as a worthy citizen. Later on in life he moved to Warren and

lived there in retirement until, his death in 1909. He married Elizabeth Johnson, who was born on the Johnson farm in Duck Creek neighborhood, and died at Warren in 1880. Her parents came to Trumbull County from Connecticut.


Charles C. Chryst on the old homestead and was educated at the public schools, Hiram College and Allegheny College at Meadsville, Pennsylvania, leaving the latter institution, however, before he was graduated so as to take advantage of a good business opening. In 1874 he engaged in a grocery and provision business at Warren, and continued it until 1879, when he returned to the farm and was associated with his father in the stock business until he was thirty- five years of age. In 1888 he re-entered the gro-


YOUNGSTOWN AND THE MAHONING VALLEY - 243


cery and provision business at Warren, expanding it into a public market, which he sold at a good figure in September, 1918. In 1893 Mr. Chryst became interested in the hotel business at Warren as senior member of the firm of Chryst & Roach, they taking over the Park Hotel at that time. In 1910 they became the owners of the Colonial Hotel and have since then operated both properties, which are the two leading hostelries of Warren. In the same year that they secured their second hotel, these partners organized the Warren Provision Company which was incorporated with Mr. Chryst as president, but this company went out of business in 1918.


Mr. Chryst is regarded, and justly so, as the "father of the good roads" in Northeastern Ohio, as it is due to his efficient efforts that the present system of macadam roads was inaugurated in Trumbull County, where the first roads of that kind in this part of Ohio were built. The beginning of this era had its inception in the plan of Mr. Chryst to provide some kind of a path along the public highways for the use of the bicyclists. In 1903 he was appointed by the board of county commissioners a member of the first board of highway commissioners under the new highway laws which went into effect that year. Entering enthusiastically into the project Mr. Chryst gave generously of his time, money and influence and accomplished great things, so that at the expiration of his four years the county commissioners declined to let him withdraw as highway commissioner, and he served an additional two years, or until he positively refused further appointment. During his administration there were built in Trumbull County 250 miles of bicycle path and fifty-eight miles of macadam roads, a record not easily forgotten.


Mr. Chryst is a man of large and varied affairs, and among other things is a member of the board of directors of the Western Reserve National Bank of Warren, and was one of the original members and first directors of the Warren Board of Trade. Mr. Chryst was married to Elizabeth Qualey, who was born at Elmira, New York, a daughter of Simon and Mary Qualey, both of whom died at Warren, where they had lived for many years.


Aside from what he has done in the matter of good road building, and in providing Warren with up-to-date hotel accommodations, Mr. Chryst has accomplished much for the community. He has upheld the Board of Trade in all of its plans for the development of the city, freely giving of his time and means to consummate all movements for the general welfare.


Broad-minded and progressive, genial and warmhearted Mr. Chryst holds the friendship of his business and social acquaintances, while his many traits of character make of him an ideal friend and citizen. He is of a rugged nature, firm in his opinions, which, though sometimes may be wrong, he always frankly states when occasion requires, and his viewpoint is always received with respect, for the very reason that all who know him realize that he is conscientious in his views and beliefs. He has the courage of his convictions, but is not an opinionated or obstinate man, and is always ready to concede sincerity to the opinions of others.


RALPH RAYMOND SPEAK recorder of Trumbull County, was born at Cleveland, Ohio, on January 25, 1891, a son of John R. and Jennie (Moreland) Speak, the former of whom was born in Scotland in 1853, a son of John Speak, also a native of Scotland. The mother of Ralph R. Speak was also born in Scotland, the year of her nativity being 1861. The parents were married in Scotland and came to the United States shortly after their marriage, locating at Cleveland, Ohio. John R. Speak was chief engineer of trans-Atlantic ships, sailing all of the seven seas, but after his arrival at Cleveland he followed the machinist trade until 1903. In that year he moved to Warren, and in 1906 to Niles, where his death occurred on April 30, 1917. His wife died at Cleveland in 1897.


The early days of Ralph R. Speak were spent at Cleveland and Niles, and he was educated in the public schools of these two cities, later taking up a general business course in a school of correspondence. He began his business career when he was a boy of thirteen years with the Sterling Electric Company of Warren, where he was office boy for one year. e then went to East Mecca, Ohio, and attended school, working for his board and clothes. Then he returned to the Sterling Electric Company of Warren, but lived at Niles, and rose to be final inspector with that company when he resigned to go to the Glass Works at Niles in a clerical capacity. He remained with that concern until he left on September I, 1917, to assume the duties of county recorder, to which office he had been elected in November, 1916. He was re-elected to the same office in November, 1918 and was re-nominated in 1920 without opposition in the primaries. Mr. Speak is a member of Warren Benevolent and Protective Order of. Elks No. 295, of which he was exalted ruler in 1919. e is a member of the Buckeye Club of Warren, the Loyal Order of Moose of Niles, and the Niles Chamber of Commerce, and is one of the energetic young business men of both Warren and Niles. He is a member of First Christian Church of Niles.


JUDGE DAHL BUCHANAN COOPER, Of Struthers, Ohio, was born September 19, 1880, in Coitsville, Mahoning County, Ohio, which was likewise the birthplace of his father the late David Perry Cooper. His grandfather, Robert Cooper, was of English descent, his father having come from England to the United States with his family, locating first in Maryland, and from there migrating to Coitsville, Ohio.


David P. Cooper spent the earlier years of his life in Coitsville, where he followed the trade of a blacksmith and wagon maker. Moving later to Struthers, he established a carriage gear-wood manufactory, which he managed successfully until his death, which occurred in 1909, at Saint Louis, Missouri, having been caused by a street car accident. e was then in the prime of life, having been but fifty-three years of age. e married Mary A. McClelland, a daughter of Capt. David McClelland, who, serving as an officer during the Civil war, lost his life on the Stone River battlefield. Both he and his wife united with the Presbyterian Church when young, and she is still a


244 - YOUNGSTOWN AND THE MAHONING VALLEY


faithful and active member. Fraternally he .belonged to the Independent Order of Odd Fellows, and politically he was an independent democrat, seeking like his son, the judge, better things rather than a stringent alignment to party lines. Four children were born of the union of Mr. and Mrs. David P. Cooper, as follows: Dahl B., with whom this brief sketch is chiefly concerned; Ralph M., of Struthers, is with the Republic Iron & Steel Company; Mary, who became the wife of Hugh Hamilton, passed to the life beyond in 1911 ; and David P., Jr., who died in 1904, aged six years. The mother born in 1858, resides at 263 Poland Avenue, Struthers, Ohio.


Acquiring his elementary education in the public schools of Coitsville and Struthers, Dahl B. Cooper was graduated from the Rayen High School with the class of 1899. Continuing his studies in Ohio, he took a full course at Oberlin College, receiving his diploma in 1903. Going then to Cambridge, Massachusetts, he entered the law department of Harvard University, from which he was graduated in 1907. Being admitted to the Ohio Bar, he immediately began the practice of his profession in Youngstown, being associated in partnership with J. F. Williams, Jr., with whom he was associated until his election to the judgeship. In 1918 Mr. Cooper was elected on a non-partisan contest to his present position as judge of the Court of Common Pleas for a term of six years, and is performing the duties of his office to the entire satisfaction of all concerned.


Judge Cooper married, August 5, 1915, Ruth G. Creed, a farmer and dairyman at Struthers, and they are the parents of two bright, interesting children, Betty Louise and William Perry. The Judge and Mrs. Cooper are worthy members of the United Presbyterian Church. Fraternally the judge belongs to the Knights of Pythias. From 1909 until the election of 1918 Judge Cooper was manager of all the dry campaigns in Mahoning County.




ALBERT GUARNIERI has been a resident of Warren over thirty years. e is one of the most prominent and successful men in Trumbull County of Italian birth and parentage. He retired from his active responsibilities as a merchant recently, and for a number of years past has used his resources for the buying and development of many valuable parcels of real estate in Warren.


Mr. Guarnieri was born at Neirone, near Genoa, January 1, 1866, son of Salvatore Guarnieri. In 1887 he crossed the ocean to New York City and came directly to Warren, where his brothers John and Paul were in business. John Guarnieri is now deceased and Paul is a resident of Ashtabula, Ohio. Albert's first employment was with his brother John, who then operated a fruit stand at the corner of Market and Main streets. After two years, having been able to accumulate a modest capital, he established a fruit stand of his own at the corner of Market Street and Park Avenue. The next important advance in his business progress came in May, 1896, when he opened a confectionery store at 33 East Market Street, also continuing his fruit stand for a time. He built up a large confectionery business, eventually making it both wholesale and retail, and it was at his place of business that he could be found almost daily until September, 1919. when he turned over the confectionery establishment to his son, Albert, Jr., and his daughter, Mrs. Louise and her husband, Joseph Scarnecchia.


Mr. Guarnieri accepted this relief from his long continued business activity as an opportunity for a well-deserved rest. He returned to the old home in Italy in the fall of 1919, and remained until the spring of 1921.


Mr. Guarnieri has always regarded his citizenship in America as permanent, and has invested the great bulk of his resources in Warren real estate. His first land purchase in the city was the property at 13 South Pine Street. Later he bought the corner property at 15 South Pine, and established his home there. In 1908 he bought the Gunglefinger home at 305 East Market Street, and that has been the Guarnieri residence for the past twelve years. His first acquisition of business property was 19 South Park Avenue, a lot upon which he erected in 1917 a business block known as the Basso Block, named in honor of his wife. Following this he acquired at 18 South Main Street another business block, and in association with the well-known Warren real estate man, James P. Garghill, he acquired the old Russell Hotel at the corner of Main and South streets. Mr. Garghill later sold his interests to Arthur Lamberti of Youngstown, a cousin of Mr. Guarnieri. Mr. Guarnieri bought at 126-128 East Market Street the site of the old William Ritezel home, and erected there a very substantial three-story terra cotta brick block, known as the Guarnieri Block. The building is so constructed that additional floors may be added. The first floor of the building as it stands is occupied by a large furniture store, the second by offices, while the third is divided into apartments. Mr. Guarnieri owned a lot with 70-foot frontage on Main Street in the City of Niles, but sold this property at a sacrifice in order to promote the building of the William McKinley birthplace memorial, which occupies part of the lot. Mr. Guarnieri and Arthur Lamberti bought the old Stanford residence property on East Market Street, and leaving the residence intact, improved part of the ground with two temporary storerooms. Another purchase of these two associates 'is the Gilmore home on East Market Street, ground on which they plan the erection of another business block. Mr. Guarnieri erected in 1919 business blocks on South Park and South Pine streets, and he is individually the owner of at least fifteen residence properties in Warren. In his real estate operations Mr. Guarnieri may be said to be a good buyer and poor seller, since he still holds title to all the property he has acquired at different times, being attracted rather by stable investments than by possibilities of speculation.


Mr. Guarnieri is also a stockholder in the Columbian Fire Insurance Company of Detroit, and the Jamestown, New York, Telephone Company. He is a Knight of Columbus and with his family a member of St. Mary's Catholic Church. Mr. Guarnieri married Mary Basso, who was born in the same village as her husband and came to this country in 1885, joining relatives at Cleveland, in which city Mr. and Mrs. Guarnieri were married.


Their son, Lewis Lawrence Guarnieri, is one of



YOUNGSTOWN AND THE MAHONING VALLEY - 245


the prominent young members of the Trumbull County bar. e was born at Warren July To, 1896, graduated from the Warren High School in 1914, and from the law department of the Catholic Unversity of America at Washington in 1918 with the degree LL. B. He also received two degrees, Master of Laws and Master of Patent Laws, from the Georgetown Law School of the District of Columbia. He passed the bar examinations in June, 1919, and in July of the same year was admitted to the Ohio bar and began practice at Warren. He is a member of the Trumbull County Bar Association, the Board of Trade, St. Maryls Parish and the Knights of Columbus. He is also affiliated with two college fraternities, Epsilon Lambda and Sigma Chi, • and is active in the membership of Warren Lodge No. 295, Benevolent and Protective Order of Elks.


THEODORE J. ARTER, who has charge of the Standard Oil interests at Youngstown, is a member of a family which for three successive generations has been continuously identified with some phases of oil production in Ohio and Western Pennsylvania.


Mr. Arter, who has been the Standard Oil representative at Youngstown since 1909, was born in Columbiana County, Ohio, in 1867, son of Theodore and Susan (Pritchard) Arter, and grandson of David Arter. David Arter, of Columbiana County, owned several profitable oil properties in the early days. e was a native of Ohio. Theodore Arter went to Cleveland in 1869, and was associated with that group of interests at Cleveland which now comprise the Standard Oil Company. For many years he was in the cooperage department, and had much of the responsibility of a large and growing industry devoted to the making of barrels and tanks for the storage and conveyance of oil.


Theodore J. Arter attended the Central High School at Cleveland and at the age of eighteen entered the service of the Standard Oil Company. For a time he had charge of the shipping department of the refinery at Cleveland. The corporation's business at Youngstown, of which he has had responsible charge for the past ten years, comprises a large and extensive plant, which was first established on the Erie Railroad between Champion and Walnut streets, but in 1914 was moved to the Pennsylvania tracks at Poland Avenue. Four acres of ground are devoted to the storage tanks, equipment and office buildings and warehouses.


Mr. Arter is a member of the First Presbyterian Church, is a Royal Arch Mason and Elk, and a member of the Rotary and Youngstown clubs. In 1893 he married Miss Gertrude Phelps, of Kingsville, Ohio. They have three children: Capt. Theodore Arter, Jr., Jean B. and Adelbert. The son Captain Theodore received his commission in an officers' training camp, was in the aviation department, and for a time was commander of the Langley Field in Virginia.


WELLS L. GRISWOLD. There are some individuals who always seem to have the inclination and find the opportunity to attend to good works whether of a public or private nature. Wells L. Griswold, trust officer of the Dollar Savings and Trust Company, is pre-eminently of this class. He belongs to the group of able citizens whose civic interest is equal to their business enterprise, and who are devoting their energy to the advancement of municipal affairs. A man of broad education and fine, sympathetic nature, he is admirably fitted to be identified with the progressive guard of such a city as Youngstown.


Mr. Griswold is a native of Ohio, having been born in Ashtabula County, August 13, 1868, one of three children of Henry F. and Susanna (Laird) Griswold. The Griswolds have been in this country since 1629, and farming, the principal occupation of its members, occupied the attention and energies of Henry F. Griswold. Wells L. Griswold was reared in an agricultural atmosphere on the home farm, and in his boyhood attended the district schools for the rudiments of his education. Later he went to New Lyme Institute at South New Lyme, Ohio, where he completed the course under Dr. Jacob Tuckerman, subsequently matriculating at Oberlin College, from which he was graduated with the degree of Bachelor of Philosophy in 1894, and received his master's degree later. During this scholastic career he taught school, thus helping to defray the expenses of his education. For seven years following his graduation from Oberlin he was superintendent of schools at Collinwood, Ohio, now a part of Cleveland, and in 1901; came to Youngstown, where for ten years he was principal of the Rayen School. In 1911 he became trust officer of the Dollar Savings and Trust Company, and this position he has since filled.


Mr. Griswold has been prominently identified with many important movements. For some time he has been treasurer of the Mahoning Chapter of the American Red Cross, and during the period of the great war held a like position with the Mahoning War Chest, to which was subscribed $2,165,000. He was treasurer, also, of the Youngstown Base Hospital Fund, and chairman of all five of the Mahoning County (including Youngstown) Liberty Loan campaigns. His record is that of a useful, patriotic and public-spirited citizen who has contributed generously of his abilities and energies to those things which have assisted in developing higher education, better morals and public-spirited citizenship.


Mr. Griswold was married July 3, 1895, to Miss Louise Fitch, of Hastings, Minnesota, and they have three children: Francis F., Katharine L. and Alice Louise. Mr. and Mrs. Griswold belong to the First Presbyterian Church of Youngstown, of which he has for years been an elder. He is a member of the Youngstown Club, the Youngstown Country Club and the Youngstown Chamber of Commerce.


ABRAHAM KAMENETZKY. A fine representative of the enterprising and energetic young men who come from a foreign land to this country of great opportunities, Abraham Kamenetzky has already obtained a secure position among the prosperous merchants of Youngstown, and as an active member of the R. & K. Specialty Company is ably assisting in advancing the mercantile interests of the city. A native of Russia, he was born August 15, 1885, in Lithuania, where the days of his boyhood and youth were spent. His parents, David and Ida Kamenetzky, immigrated


246 - YOUNGSTOWN AND THE MAHONING VALLEY


from Lithuania to the United States in 1901, locating in Cleveland, where both are still living, the father being successfully engaged in the hardware business.


Brought up and educated in his native land, Abraham Kamenetzky, following in the footsteps of his parents, came to Ohio in 1904, arriving in Cleveland on August 14th. A short time later he entered the employ of I. Shapiro & Sons, wholesale dealers in house furnishings, and .remained with that firm as clerk and salesman forl a number of seasons. Coming to Youngstown in 1911, he established the Youngstown Notion & Specialty Company, which he managed alone for two months. Entering into partnership in 1912 with Louis Regenstreich, he organized the R. & K. Specialty Company, which has been exceedingly prosperous, its trade being extensive and constantly increasing in volume and in value.


Mr. Kamenetzky married, in December, 1912, Hattie J. Halper, of Cleveland.








FRANK F. BENTLEY. Among the men of the Mahoning Valley whose careers as business men and citizens reflect credit upon the community is Frank F. Bentley, of Warren and Niles. As a manufacturer he has been closely identified with the industrial history of Niles for twenty years, and as a citizen he has been prominent in the civic and social affairs of Warren for almost the same length of time.


Mr. Bentley is descended from one of the very earliest families of the Mahoning Valley, a family which has figured prominently in the history of the Valley for four generations, from pioneer days down to the present time, and Benjamin Bentley, great-grandfather to the present generation, was the pioneer. He was a native of Connecticut, born in 1756, and came to Western Pennsylvania near the close of the eighteenth century, settling in the then wilderness where the present City of Sharon stands. In 1806 he removed to Trumbull County and settled on his farm on North Centre Road, in what is now Brookfield Township, and he built the first frame barn in this section of Ohio. He died on his farm in October in 1818.


James Bentley, son of Benjamin, and grandfather to the present generation, was himself a pioneer of the Mahoning Valley. He was born at Sharon, Mercer County, Pennsylvania, in 1798, and was the first white child to be born in the Shenango Valley. He came into Trumbull County wtih his parents in 1806, and grew to manhood on the family homestead in Brookfield Township. He was prominent in the affairs of his township, and served as justice of the peace for a number of years. He took the census of the south half of Trumbull County in 184o, before Mahoning County was organized. He was prominent in Masonry, and the charter for old Hartford Lodge was secured through his efforts. At the time of his death he was probably the oldest Mason in Ohio. He married Temperance Buttles, who was born in Connecticut, and came with her parents, Benoni and Mary Buttles, Brookfield Township in 1817.


Anson G. Bentley, son of James and Temperance Bentley, and father to the present generations, was born on the Bentley farm in Brookfield on December 25, 1824. His early life was spent on his father farm during summers and going to school of winters. In 1853 he gathered together his possession. and started for the gold fields of California. He located in Nevada City, where he remained for five years, meeting with satisfactory results. He returned to the old home in Brookfield in 1858, but soon thereafter he settled in Youngstown, where became prominent in business affairs. He conducted a lumber business for one year, and for a number of years he was interested in the flour milling business. He assisted in the organization of the First National Bank of Youngstown in 1863, which bank was the third one chartered under the National Banking Act. Mr. Bentley was for many years vice president and a director of the First National.


In 1869 he removed to the City of Niles, where with two associates he established the banking house of Wick, Bentley and Company. In 1879 that association was succeeded by the banking house of A. G. Bentley and Company.


On August 15, 1858, Anson G. Bentley was united in marriage wtih Mary Amelia Ingraham, who was born in New York State, the daughter of the Rev. Samuel W. Ingraham, a Methodist minister, who removed from Chautauqua County, New York, to Brookfield. Mr. Bentley died in 1901, his widow surviving him until 1915.


Frank F. Bentley, son of Anson G. and Mary Amelia Bentley, was born at Youngstown on July 28, 1867. He is a product of the Mahoning Valley and his entire life has been spent within its limits.


Mr. Bentley attended the public schools of Niles and as a young man he learned the plumbing and tin-smith trades and worked at them in Niles for twelve years, during which time he established a business of his own. In association with his brother Anson J., Mr. Bentley organized and incorporated the Ohio Galvanizing and Manufacturing Company, of which he became president and so continues. The business has been developed from year to year until at the present time the Ohio Galvanizing and Manufacturing Company is one of the important industrial enterprises of the valley, with trade connections ramifying the valley and extending into other states.


Mr. Bentley has had his home at Warren since 1908, and he has played a very public-spirited part in the affairs of this city ever since. He organized the Warren Automobile Club, was its first president, and his administration of the club's affairs during the World war gained the organization particular distinction. This club became one of the chief units in all lines of patriotic and war work in Trumbull County, and its methods were quickly adopted by automobile clubs all over the country. In June, 1920, he was elected president of the Ohio State Automobile Association, an organization comprising all of the automobile clubs of the state, totaling a membership of over 40,000.


Mr. Bentley was also the organizer of the Warren Rotary Club, and one of the directors for several years. He is a member of the Country Club and of the Youngstown Club, and is active in the Warren Board of Trade and the Niles Chamber of Commerce.


Mr. Bentley's success in business has been won


YOUNGSTOWN AND THE MAHONING VALLEY - 247


by progressive methods, close application and strict integrity, backed up with fine executive ability and a genius for organization. His prominence as a citizen is due to his keen interest in the affairs of the city and a willingness to at all times give his time and means to promote the interests of the community. His sterling characteristics have gained and held for him the warm friendship of many and the admiration of all who know him.


Mr. Bentley married Joan Walsh, who was born iU Youngstown, the daughter of Patrick Walsh, an old-time resident of that city.


ROBERT H. JACOBS. Thoroughly conversant with the lumber business, familiar with all its requirements, both for its safe conduct and its further advancement, Robert H. Jacobs, of Youngstown, is eminently fitted for the responsible positions of vice president and general manager of the Union Wholesale Lumber Company, positions that he is ably and satisfactorily filling. He was born June 29, 1874, in Youngstown, which is also the birthplace of his father, Orrin Jacobs, whose birth occurred in 1842. His mother, whose name before marriage was Malvina Gerwig, was born in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, in 1847, but was brought up and educated in Youngstown, where both she and her husband are still residing.


Having received his diploma at the Rayen High School in 1893, Robert H. Jacobs read law for two years, obtaining legal knowledge that has since been of value to him. From 1896 until 1900 he was recorder in the mill of the Ohio Steel Works, and the ensuing five years, in partnership with B. M. Campbell, dealt in real estate, doing business principally in South Side lands, opening up and subdividing all land from Williamson Avenue to, and including, the South High School property. When the Jacobs . Lumber Company was incorporated in 1906 Mr. Jacobs was made treasurer. In 1916 that firm sold out to the Union Wholesale Lumber Company, which at that time also absorbed the Youngstown Lumber Company, the Iron City Lumber Company, the B. C. Tibbetts Lumber Company, the G. N. Reed Lumber Company, of East Youngstown, the W. H. Palmer Lumber Company and the Lowellville Lumber Company. Mr. Jacobs was prominent in organizing the Union Wholesale Lumber Company, which was accomplished in April, 1916, and of which he was made treasurer. In January, 1919, he had the honor of being elected vice president and general manager of the concern, which is one of the largest and most important of its kind in the county or state, its operations at the present time being confined to the lumber business.


Mr. Jacobs is also officially connected with various other concerns, being a director of the Harvard Lumber Company of Cleveland, Ohio ; secretary and treasurer of the Jacobs Realty Company, which handles land at Stop 25 on the Youngstown and Sharon street car line; treasurer of the Jacobs Lumber Company; and a director of the Commercial National Bank.


Mr. Jacobs married, in 1908, Miss Florence Ferver, of New Wilmington, Pennsylvania, who was graduated as a nurse from the Youngstown City Hospital in 1907. Mr. and Mrs. Jacobs have three children, namely : Helen Harris, Baler Campbell and Marjorie.


WILLIAM G. DINGLEDY in the last year or two has important and thriving industry at Hubbard as a lumber dealer and manufacturer of builders' supplies. While he is comparatively new in this community he has had almost a lifelong experience in lumber manufacture, being a member of the well known and prominent Dingledy family of Youngstown, who have been lumbermen and contractors going back to the early days of the city.


William G. Dingledy was born at Youngstown September 16, 1883, son of George H. and Mary (Peters) Dingledy. The late George H. Dingledy was a man of distinct achievement in the citizenship of Youngstown, born in Hesse-Darmstadt, Germany. He came to the United States about 1854, learned the carpenter's trade in Buffalo, and in 1863 came to Youngstown, drawn hither by the presence of some old friends. Beginning with almost no capital, and while employed at his trade, he opened a lumber yard about 1865, entered the contracting business, and continued that line until about 1900. He built up a large and prosperous lumber business. both as a dealer and manufacturer. George H. Dingledy died at Youngstown August 22, 1899, and he had used his opportunities to such advantage that his estate was one of the largest probated in the county up to that time. He had served a term in the City Council and was otherwise active in good citizenship. Besides his yards he operated planing mills and manufactured practically all the sash, door and other interior finish required in his own contracting business and to supply other contractors and builders. The old Dingledy home is on Summit Avenue in Youngstown. Mary Peters, the wife of George H. Dingledy, is still living at Youngstown and was brought from Germany as ,,a child by her parents, Mr. and Mrs. John C. Peters, who became farmers in Boardman Township. George H. Dingledy was a charter member and for many years actively affiliated with the Martin Luther Church on Wood Street in Youngstown. He and his wife had a family of five sons and two daughters: Henry J., a Youngstown contractor ; Caroline, wife of Charles S. Schumtz, a resident of Youngstown but manager of a cement plant at Bessemer, Pennsylvania; William G.; Carl F., a salesman living at Youngstown; Fred, a Youngstown real estate man; George H., Jr., a farmer ; and Marie, wife of L. Calvin Jones, who is in the insurance and bond business at Youngstown.


The business established by the late George H. Dingledy continued as the Dingledy Lumber Company until May, 1919, when it was sold to the Sharp Lumber Company. William G. Dingledy practically grew up in the business and had its active management from 1915 until it was sold in May, 1919. At that date he came to Hubbard and bought the Enterprise Box Company, and is now sole proprietor of the business, which his ability and experience have made an important asset of Hubbard's commercial affairs.


February 22, 1905, Mr. Dingledy married Isabel Leslie, daughter of J. S. Leslie, a Hubbard Town-


248 - YOUNGSTOWN AND THE MAHONING VALLEY


ship farmer. Mrs. Dingledy was born in Hubbard Township and was nineteen years of age at the time of her marriage. They have two children, a daughter, Leslie, now attending school, and a son, William P.


DAVID J. RAND. While industrial trouble has, at times, brought loss and disturbance to many large tailoring establishments at Youngstown and other points, it is a source of personal satisfaction to David J. Rand of this city that he has had no business interruptions of this kind during his many years of management. Mr. Rand is a member of the well known tailoring firm of Guttridge & Rand, of which he is secretary and general manager, having climbed step by step to this responsible place in the business world through his own industrious efforts.


David J. Rand was born in Galicia, Austria, in December, 1879, a son of Hyman and Rosie (Field) Rand, both of whom died in Austria, where the father was a small farmer. When David was thirteen years old he came to the United States and joined his uncle, Alec Field, in New York City. His first position was elevator boy in a business building, but soon afterward he began as an apprentice with a large tailoring firm, where he continued as bench tailor for several years. In to01 he went to Chicago, where he was a tailor for a time in a big tailoring establishment, going from there to Cleveland. In that city he worked in various shops, but had not made up his mind to settle permanently in that city, when he was engaged as a tailor by a local tailoring concern of Youngstown. After one year in that capacity he was promoted to be manager of the tailor shop, a position he continued to hold with the greatest efficiency for six years. Here he gained much experience that has been useful to him ever since. In 1908 Mr. Rand bcame a silent partner in the firm of Guttridge, Corll & Company, and when Mr. Corll subsequently sold his interest, the firm became Guttridge & Rand, Mr. Rand becoming secretary and general manager. He has numerous additional business interests. e was one of the organizers and is a director of the Mill Creek Land Company ; is interested in the United Printing Company of Youngstown; is a director of the Charter Sales Motor Company of Youngstown, and officially or otherwise is concerned in important commercial activities in other directions. When Mr. Rand was entrusted with the management of the tailor shop department of the local company he was only twenty- three years old, and the tact and judgment with which he performed his duties was creditable to him as an executive as well as fellow workman. In the same spirit of justice he has been able to control large bodies of men and is held in high regard by all of his employes.


In August, 1903, Mr. Rand was married to Miss Emma Friedman, a daughter of Moses Friedman, of Youngstown, and they have two children, Arnold and Marion. Mr. Rand and family belong to the Hebrew congregation Rodef Sholem Temple. He is identified with many benevolent organizations and is an ardent supporter of movements in behalf of the Jewish Welfare Board. He is a member of the Youngstown Chamber of Commerce and as an ap pointee of this body has served with much efficiency on a number of committees. Fraternally he is identified with the Elks and the Knights of Pythias. When Mr. Rand came to the United States he left three brothers in Austria, all of whom he induced to join him. One of these, Samuel, is deceased, but Isadore and Harry are in his employ at Youngstown.




W. MANNING KERR. In writing of the industrial development of the Mahoning Valley, during the last decade it is interesting also to write something of the careers of the men whose efforts have made possible this remarkable development, and one of these men is W. Manning Kerr, president and treasurer of the Ohio Corrugating Company of Warren.


Mr. Kerr is a product of the Mahoning Valley, and has spent his entire life among the haze and smoke of the valley. He is descended from two pioneer families of Trumbull County. His paternal grandfather, Zachariah Kerr, was a native of Pennsylvania, from whence he came to Ohio in early clays and became an early settler of New Niles, and for whom "Kerr's Corners" were named. He operated a sawmill for a number of years at Kerr's Corners, and there he also served as justice of the peace for many years. The maternal grandfather, John Cessna, was also an early settler at Kerr's Corners, he also having come to Ohio from Pennsylvania.


James M. Kerr, father of W. Manning Kerr, was born at Kerr's Corners in 1859, and for over forty years was an engineer on the Erie Railroad. He married Linnie Cessna, who was born at Kerr's Corners. Both parents of W. Manning are still living, the father having retired from railroading in 1914.


W. Manning Kerr was born on the Cessna homestead at Riverside, just outside of the city limits of Niles, on March 2, 1882, and was educated in the Niles High School and at the Warren Business College. In 1902 he began his business career as collector and stenographer for the City National Bank of Niles. When the. Dollar Savings Bank of Niles was organized Mr. Kerr became assistant cashier of that bank, and was later made assistant secretary and treasurer, and so continued until in January, 1915, at which time he resigned from the bank to become president and treasurer of the Ohio Corrugating Company at Warren, which company he had organized, and which has grown into one of the largest steel barrel plants in the United States.


Mr. Kerr is still interested in the banking business, and has important connections with several of the well-known financial institutions. He is a member of the hoard of directors of the Trumbull Savings & Loan Company of Warren, and the Trumbull Banking Company of Girard. He is also a director in the American Zinc Products Company of Greencastle, Indiana, and a director of the Fort Smith Spelter Company of Fort Smith, Arkansas.


He is a member of the Warren Board of Trade and the Niles Chamber of Commerce, and he belongs to the Warren Country and Niles clubs, and to the First Methodist Episcopal Church of Niles, of which city he is a resident.


Mr. Kerr may be termed a self-made man, for he owes his position in the industrial and banking world to his own efforts, backed tip with ability, application and his ambition to succeed.


YOUNGSTOWN AND THE MAHONING VALLEY - 249


ISAAC G. MONROE who was recently appointed street superintendent of the City of Youngstown, Ohio, has been active in more than one phase of the affairs of that city during recent years. For fifteen years he was a responsible official of the Republic Iron and Steel Company, and for many years has taken close interest in political affairs in Youngstown. He has been a factor of influence in republican circles in the city, and it was mainly through his efforts and initiative that a body of citizens formed association to urge Mayor Warnock to accept nomination for mayoral office, in the republican interest.


He was born in Putney Township, Belmont County, Ohio, August 5, 1880, the son of Capt. William and Melvina (Fish) Monroe. William W. Monroe followed maritime occupations; and during his later years was a captain of steam boats trading between Pittsburg and Cincinnati. e died in 1887, while still in his early prime, being then only thirty-seven years old. Capt. William W. Monroe and his wife were both members of the Church of the Disciples, and were the parents of four children. The children, in order of birth, were: Harry B., who now lives in Florida, but who formerly was an ironmoulder in the Youngstown mills; Hattie M., who married Albert P. Deafenhaugh, of Bellaire, Ohio ; Isaac G.. the subject of this article, and regarding whom more follows ; and Edward S., who has had responsible connection with many of the leading American circus organizations, and has now settled in York, Nebraska.


Isaac G. as a young boy attended school in Bellaire, Ohio, but the death of his father in 1887 seriously interfered with the plans of his parents for his education. e was only seven years old when his father died, and at the age of eight years was obliged almost to earn his own living, which he did by selling newspapers. He was only eleven years old when he began working 'steadily in a glass factory, and at thirteen he entered the Bessemer department of an iron works. He has been connected with the iron and steel industry ever since, or at least until he became a member of the city administration. A fortunate dismissal, the cause of which he did not know, induced Isaac G. Monroe to come to Youngstown to seek employment with the Republic Iron and Steel Company. He was readily given a position, and one of greater consequence than that from which he had been discharged, and he has ever since remained in the service of the Republic Company. Since he first came, in 1905, Mr. Monroe has received many promotions, and until he was appointed to the municipal office he held a responsible position in the converting department, and there is every reason to suppose that should he at any time relinquish his city appointment and desire to again resume his old connection with the Republic Company he would he gladly reinstated in his former office of responsibility.


Mr. Monroe is affiliated with many fraternal organizations, being a member of the Western Star lodge of the Masonic order, belonging to both the Scottish and York Rites, and also to the Independent Order of Odd Fellows, and the Junior Order of United American Mechanics.


In political affairs he has always given staunch allegiance to the republican party, and of late years has come somewhat prominently to the fore as an organizer. e was especially interested in initiating the movement by which Mayor Warnock was induced to enter the contest for mayoral office ; and it may be assumed that Mr. Monroe was equally as effective in gaining support for the mayor in the actual contest. Although he also has gained office in the administration of Mayor Warnock, there is not much reason to suppose that he is not amply fitted for such office. As a matter of fact, he is generally known in Youngstown as a man of distinct capability, which of course is but to be expected of a man who in a life of only thirty-nine years has spent more than thirty years in business affairs. He is still an active, aggressive man, in the early prime of life, and is popular, so that he will probably find good scope for public service in future years.


Mr. Monroe was married in 1910 to Margaret Isabel, daughter of Thomas and Margaret (Sunday) Slater, of Syracuse, New York.


MATHEW LOGAN was one of the forceful men of the Youngstown district for a long period of years. His business as a railroad and street contractor identified him with many phases of modern development, and his name is also intimately associated with public affairs in Mahoning County.


He was born in the state of New York March 15, 1828, and died April 15, 1902. His parents, Hugh and Rose (McKenna) Logan, were natives of County Londonderry, Ireland. Hugh Logan, a blacksmith by trade, came with his family to America in 1827, and for a number of years lived in Greece Township, Monroe County, New York, Where Hugh died in 1849 at the age of sixty-two. His widow survived until 1866 and was seventy-two years of age at the time of her death. Both were devout members of the Catholic Church.


Fourth among the children of his parents, Mathew Logan grew up and achieved his early successes in business and public affairs at Rochester, New York. He acquired a public school education, and during school vacations gained his first knowledge of public contracting while water boy to workmen engaged on public construction. He apparently had a natural faculty for doing large construction work and handling men, and as a contractor his business steadily expanded. In the spring of 1862 he moved to Greenville, Pennsylvania, and the following November came to Youngstown to take charge of the railroad works of William Mather. With the exception of about eighteen months spent in Columbiana County, Youngstown was his home the rest of his life. ere he became widely known in the building and improvement of streets, in the construction of railroads, and was a man of unquestionable integrity in both private and public life.


He was a democrat in politics, was always keenly interested in political issues, and his influence was far reaching. Among other positions he was called upon to fill was that of sheriff of Mahoning County, while for four terms he was mayor of the City of Youngstown. While a resident of Rochester, New York, he was United States Marshal of the Western