(RETURN TO THE TITLE PAGE)




History of Stark County - 1


CHAPTER I


PHYSICAL BASIS OF DEVELOPMENT


A GREAT WATER-SHED AND GLACIAL BORDER-DRAINAGE BASINS OF THE COUNTY GREAT PREHISTORIC RIVER-ANCIENT LINES OF DRAINAGE- PRESENT- DAY TOPOGRAPHY-DIVERSIFIED SOIL-ARTIFICIAL FERTILIZATION AND DRAINAGE-WOODLAND FARMS FIRST OPENED CARBONIFEROUS STRATA OF STARK COUNTY-THE MASSILLON COAL SEAM MASSILLON SANDSTONE-THE LIMESTONES-THE FIRE CLAYS-SOIL INDUSTRIES, THE GREATEST.


In the course of the following narrative it will become evident that the section of Northeastern Ohio within which its political area now lies is a borderland of intense interest to the student, the scholar and the man of practical affairs. First comes Nature with her store-houses filled to bursting with raw materials, then the scientist who roughly charts them and analyzes them, and then the farmer and the manufacturer, who turns them to the sustenance, the comfort and the opulence of mankind. At this point in the historic narrative it is necessary to tell what the observer and the scientist have discovered as to Nature's work and methods in preparing the way for the advent of man in the section under review.


ON GREAT WATER-SHED AND GLACIAL BORDER


Stark County is on the great divide or water-shed between Lake Erie and the Ohio River, and the distinct terminal moraine marking the southern bounds of the prehistoric glacier which spread its soil accumulations over two-thirds of Ohio passes through Stark County just below

Canton ; its general course is northeast from Brown County, in the val-


2 - HISTORY OF STARK COUNTY


ley of the Ohio, through Stark and Columbiana counties into Western Pennsylvania.


Not only is the edge of the moraine, or border of the great glacier, distinctly imprinted on the landscape, but special varieties of soils and vegetables indicate the southern boundary of its progress. More specifically, the moraine passes southwesterly through Columbiana, Stark, Wayne, Richland, Holmes, Licking, Fairfield, Ross, Highland, Adams and Brown, crossing the Ohio River into Kentucky, but returning to the north side of the river in Southeastern Indiana. As a result of this temporary obstruction of the Ohio, the waters of the incited glacier are believed to have been dammed so as to form a large lake, including the valley proper as far east as Pittsburgh. The barrier, or moraine, in Southwestern Ohio, appears to have given way in such a manner as to periodically reduce the level of the waters. Such a mode of retreat would explain the successive terraces that border the main streams of the Ohio at the present time.


DRAINAGE BASINS OF THE COUNTY


The notable drainage basin of Stark County is the valley of the Tuscarawas, which, as a branch of the Muskingum, is tributary to the Ohio. Only the northerly sections of the county are in the edge of the Lake Erie basin. In most parts the surface deposits are such as indicate that they have been transported from a distance, and it is only on the hills of the southern townships that the soil has been derived from the decomposition of the underlying rocks.


GREAT PREHISTORIC RIVER


There are numerous physical indications that the county was formerly traversed from north to south by a distinct line of drainage. This is imperfectly represented by the Tuscarawas River, but it is plainly written on the face of Nature that that noble stream is but a rivulet compared with the flood that once flowed from the lake basin into the ancient valley of the Ohio. The records of this great prehistoric river are seen in the deeply excavated channels now filled with gravel in the Tuscarawas Valley between Canton and Massillon. The borings for coal made in that portion of the county revealed the fact that that stream is running far above its former bed, and that it does not accurately follow its ancient valley. The old waterway is in many places filled with gravel and so thoroughly obliterated as to give to the untrained observer little indication of its original course. But a few facts which have developer; in the


HISTORY OF STARK COUNTY - 3


surface geology of Stark County have traced it with fair accuracy. The borings made for coal east of the present river in Lawrence ar d Jackson townships were carried below its bed without reaching solid rock; instead, heavy beds of gravel were found to occupy a broad a id deep valley lying east of the present water-course. From Fulton to Millport, and thence to Massillon, these borings were continued, in some cases through more than one hundred feet of drift deposits. As the rock is exposed on both sides of the river at Massillon and Millport, it is seen that the river is running on the west side of its ancient trough, and though it has a rocky bottom at that point, real bed-rock has not been found at a considerably greater depth. Just how deep the ancient valley of the Tuscarawas was in that section of the county, it is difficult to even conjecture, but it is at least known that salt wells bored at Canal Dover, Tuscarawas County, have been sunk 175 feet below the surface of the stream before the rocky stratum was reached.


ANCIENT LINES OF DRAINAGE


Another, and perhaps the most important of the ancient lines of drainage runs between Canton and Massillon. Half way between these points, rock comes near the surface and coal has been worked in the vicinity. Explorations have shown that nearer Massillon is a ridge of rock which lies between valleys—that through which the Tuscarawas flows and another, completely filled with gravel, between Massillon and Canton.


Between Massillon and Navarre, the main road or pike lies for the most part upon a terrace, or moraine, the surface of which is seventy-five feet above the river. This terrace is part of a plateau, which extends in some places more than a mile east of the Tuscarawas, and is composed of gravel and sand. On the other side of the river the rock comes to the surface and has been quarried. It is evident, therefore, that the ancient river channel passed under the terrace. Below Navarre, the river crosses to time eastern side of its primitive valley, striking its rocky border on the Wetmore tract. There the gravel beds, which fill the old valley, are on the west side of the river.


PRESENT-DAY TOPOGRAPHY


A large portion of Stark County is high and rolling, with an altitude of from 350 to 750 feet above Lake Erie, its eastern portion reaching up on the divide between that body and the Ohio River. Nearly all the streams run southward. After the Tuscarawas River, the largest stream in the county is the Nimishillen Creek, which, with its western and eastern


4 - HISTORY OF STARK COUNTY


branches, drains the northern and northeastern portions of the county. The Sandy is a fine stream flowing through the eastern sections and the Tuscarawas drains the western townships.

Ohio is a state deficient in small lakes, the counties which lie along the water-shed, like Stark, being the most favored in that regard. Among the little gems of water within the borders of the county are Congress Lake, which is cut by the northern line, and Meyer 's Lake, a few miles northwest of Canton, which also extends into Plain Township. The shores of both these lakes have been much improved within late years, so that they have become quite popular resorts for pleasure seekers and


LAKESIDE COUNTRY CLUB HOUSE, MEYER'S LAKE


clubs. In their vicinity are found not a few basins, now filled with peat and marl, which go to show that the present county was even more of a lake region than it is now.


DIVERSIFIED SOIL


Naturally, the soil is diversified. About three-fourths of the county, including the eastern, southern and western portions, may be called clay and gravel; the northeastern portion has a heavy subsoil of clay, while the Valley of the Sandy has a soil of sandy loam which is highly productive. The surface soil of the whole county is composed of vegetable mold. On the rolling or hilly portions of the county, the soil is thin and light. In the valley or bottom lands, the soil varies from a few inches to several feet in depth.


HISTORY OF STARK COUNTY - 5


ARTIFICIAL FERTILIZATION AND DRAINAGE


Clay underlies the surface soil throughout almost the entire county, and varies in thickness from a few inches to two feet. It absorbs water slowly, and prevents the water from sinking too rapidly into the gravel subsoil ; it also retains the manures and other fertilizers, and is, in many ways, the basis of Stark County's agricultural wealth. Both artificial fertilization and artificial drainage have largely supplemented natural advantages. Lime, phosphates and the rotation of crops, as well as the introduction of cattle, hogs, sheep, chickens and other fowl upon deteriorated lands, are various means by which Stark County has maintained a high agricultural standard. As a large portion of the county lies high, with good natural drainage, artificial means have not been resorted to so generally as in more marshy districts. Most of the artificial drainage has taken place in the nothern sections, within the area of the Lake Erie basin. The old Cranberry swamp, or marsh, is the best known of the early lowlands. Tile draining, as a .rule, has been adopted as a means of carrying off the surface water, and not to improve the character of the soil.


Within the past twelve or fifteen years considerable ditching has been done in such northern townships as Marlboro, Plain and Lawrence; so that now there are probable over 200 miles of established ditches in the northern part of the county. The longest and perhaps the most important work of that kind was the seven-mile ditch extending from Congress Lake, Stark County, to Randolph, just over the Portage County line, on the northeast shores of that body of water. The so-called Reed Ditch is also in Marlboro Township ; the Swartz Ditch at Middle- branch and the Zimmer ditch near New Berlin, are in Plain Township, while the Fox Lake Ditch is in the neighborhood of Canal Fulton, Lawrence Township. It is said the Congress Lake Ditch has already reclaimed some 2,000 acres of land. It is the joint charge of Stark and Portage counties.


WOODLAND FARMS FIRST OPENED


The first settlers in Stark County found a country thickly covered with a heavy growth of timber. As wood, both for building and fuel, was considered the prime requisite for permanent settlement, the forest tracts were the first to be settled ; but as the land had to be cleared before it would yield crops, the pioneer found that he could not depend upon a livelihood from his farm until some five years of hard work had been applied to it. In the meantime the fare furnished by the abundance


6 - HISTORY OF STARK COUNTY


of game and wild fruit was eked out by small purchases of corn and wheat from the older settlements.


With such an abundance of timber and the lack of foreign demand, the early tendency was to recklessly denude the land, in order to reach productive soil as quickly as possible. There was quite an extent of


AN OLD-TIME RAIL FENCE


prairie land in the county, known as the Canton plains, and running through the townships of Jackson, Perry, Canton and Bethlehem; but the plain county was long avoided as undesirable in comparison with the timber tracts, which were considered, when cnce cleared, as greatly excelling in "strong" and productive soil. Fortunately, the discovery of coal and its use as fuel as early as 1806 retarded the destruction of the timbered areas until such time as the settlers had come to realize their natural and economic value.


HISTORY OF STARK COUNTY - 7


CARBONIFEROUS STRATA OF STARK COUNTY


Below the surface of Stark County, below its soil and drift deposits, ranging frcm ten to 100 feet, and, when the regular strata are broken, sometimes coming to the surface, are various mineral riches, which have been quarried, manufactured and built into the growth and prosperity of the county. Nature laid them down in the following general order:


Strata

1. Soil and drift deposits

2. Shales and sandstones of barren coal measures found in hilltops of Osnaburg, Paris, Nimishillen and Washington

3. Buff limestone, Osnaburg and Paris

4. Black-band iron ore, Osnaburg and Paris

5. Coal No. 7, same localities as No. 4

6. Fire clay

7. Shale and sandstone, sometimes containing a thin coa seam near the middle hills of Washington, Nimishillen Paris, Osnaburg and Sandy ; hilltops of Pike, Bethlehem and Sugar Creek

8. Coal No. 6, same localities as No. 7

9. Fire clay

10. Gray and black shales, with iron ore near base

11. Coal No. 5, southern and eastern portions of the county

12. Fire clay

13. Shale and sandstone, sometimes with thin coal

14. Putnam Hill limestone

15. Coal No. 4, upper limestone seam

16. Fire clay

17. Shale and sandstone, sometimes with thin coal and limestone

18. Zoar limestone

19. Coal No. 3, lower limestone coal

20. Fire clay

21. Shale and sandstone, sometimes with thin coal at base .

22. Massillon sandstone, sometimes with thin coal at base. . .

23. Gray or black shale

24. Coal No. 1 (Massillon coal)

25. Fire clay

26. Shaly sandstone

27. Conglomerate

No. of feet

10 to 100


30 to 50

1 to 6

1 to 10

1 to 3

1 to 3


75 to 100

2 to 6

2 to 5

40 to 60

2 to 3

2 to 5

20 to 50

1 to 4

1 to 6

1 to 5

20 to 50

1 to 4

1 to 3

1 to 8

50 to 60

30 to 100

5 to 50

1 to 6

1 to 5

30 to 50

20 to 50


8 - HISTORY OF STARK COUNTY


The strata mentioned in the foregoing table all belong to the carboniferous system and, with the exception of a limited area in the northwestern corner of the county, where the conglomerate appears, its entire area is occupied by the coal measures.


THE MASSILLON COAL SEAM


The coal measures of Stark County are composed, as usual, of sandstone, limestone, shale, fire clay and coal ; the last named comprise seven seams. The lowest, or No. 1, known as the Massillon, or Briar Hill seam, is by far the most valuable in the series and one of the most important in the state. Largely through its productiveness the industries of Canton, Massillon and Alliance were substantially founded.


The Massillon coal seam, being generally cut by the Valley of the Tuscarawas, forms a great number of outcrops in the western part of the county, where most of the earlier mines were opened. As the dip of all the rocks in the county is southeast, it passes out of sight east of the Tuscarawas Valley, and along the eastern margin of the county it is at least 200 feet below the surface. It would thus appear to underlie nearly all the county, but it happens here, as in Summit and Mahoning counties, that the coal lies in limited basins. The supply has therefore been somewhat uncertain, and its value for manufacturing purposes not as great as if it could be mined from regular and traceable seams.


Notwithstanding which, the so-called Massillon Coal District has proven to be one of the most productive in Ohio, must of the product going to Cleveland and Western Pennsylvania and much being utilized by the iron and clay industries of Canton, Alliance, Massillon and Louisville. It is well adapted to a variety of uses—for blasting purposes, steam generating, manufacture of gas and for household fuel. It contains little sulphur and ash and possesses high heating power.


The production of coal in Stark County amounts to about 450,000 tons per annum. In the centennial edition of the Canton Repository, published in September, 1909, appeared the following from the pen of Anthony Howells, ex-consul to Cardiff, Wales, and a native of the tight little island across the water. His father was a coal operator in Wales, he worked there as a boy picking and shoveling coal, and was the pioneer in the Massillon field, in which he opened twelve mines in forty years. Mr. Howells' story, or rather history of the development of the famous coal field, is both interesting and authentic. It is as follows:


"In the one-hundred-year story of Stark county's development mineral coal has been a potent factor. Blessed by a fertile soil from which spring all the necessities for the existcnce of man and

beast, Stark county


HISTORY OF STARK COUNTY - 9


has had an extra blessing in the rich storehouse of coal beneath its surface, the utilization of which has made scores of Stark county farmers on whose lands deposits were found independently wealthy, has made Stark County a highly prosperous, industrial community, and has given employment to thousands.


"It is only rarely that a territory is found such as Stark, where both the soil and the coal deposits are rich. Illustrations are near at hand. Mahoning county, which owes its supremacy in the iron and steel industry to its coal deposits, is admittedly one of the poorest agricultural counties in the state. On our west is Wayne county, ranking up with Stark county as a farming community, but without large manufacturing interests, due unquestionably to the non-existence of mineral coal within its borders.


"Without the coal deposits Canton, Massillon, and Alliance at the end of the first centennial of the county, would not be the proud cities they are.


"Our big coal field is the Massillon district, one of the most important in Ohio, producing a purer quality of coal than is found in any part of the state, except that which is produced from the same strata in Mahoning and Trumbull counties. Massillon coal as a domestic coal has no superior in the United States.


"As soon as the Ohio canal was opened, a small quantity of coal was shipped by boat to Cleveland, from Middlebury, now East Akron, and from the Bridgeport mine, near Massillon. This supply was used for steam on lake boats.


"The first large shipping mine was known as the Chippewa mine, within a mile of Warwick station on the Baltimore and Ohio Railroad, its first operator being William Philpot, a Welshman from South Wales. That mine, placed in operation in the forties, was alike profitable to the land owner and to the operator. In it the Leahy family, the Sullivan family, and other families were virtually brought up ; and one of its most distinguished workers was General Patrick Collins, afterwards mayor of Boston, and general consul to London under President Cleveland. He worked in the mine as a boy, being a nephew of the elder Leahy.


"The demand for coal in those days, of course, was light, but its stimulation came when wood was no longer obtainable for fuel purposes. New mines were opened. Rhodes & Card, of Cleveland, became prominent as operators in the Massillon district, operating the well-known Willow bank mine. Another early operator was Charles Clark.


"When the Civil war broke out there was an unprecedented demand


10 - HISTORY OF STARK COUNTY


for coal. J. P. Burton, the Crawford Coal Company, and James Mullins, now a resident of Wooster, entered the field.


"All coal mined in the district was carried by canal boat to Cleveland until 1870, when the C., L. & W. Railroad, now a branch of the Baltimore & Ohio, was laid. From then on rails carried the coal to various parts of Cleveland, and as it was no longer necessary to cart from the canal docks in Cleveland, the cost of handling the commodity was cheapened.


"Massillon coal is found in pots or basins. Ages ago this section was submerged by sea, and it is my belief that these basins we find today are the remains of marshes which formerly lined the shore of this great body of water, now unknown. These basin deposits are sometimes close together, sometimes a mile apart, and generally are in groups or clusters. In area the pots run from five to seventy-five acres, but it is never profitable ordinarily to attempt to develop less than a twenty-acre basin.


"The area of Massillon coal commences at the extreme west end of Stark county, follows through Lawrence township to Tuscarawas, which has more coal than any township in the county, extends into parts of Jackson, Perry, Bethlehem and Sugar Creek townships and ends at Beach City. In all of the drilling south of Beach City no Massillon coal has been found."


As stated in Mr. Howells' article, most of the mines in Stark County are located in Tuscarawas Township. The bulk of the shipments are sent to Northwestern Ohio, also much is shipped to Western Pennsylvania, Michigan and Indiana.


MASSILLON SANDSTONE


In Stark County it is somewhat more bituminous than the coal of the same seam in the Mahoning Valley. It is usually overlaid by a few feet of shale, and above this is found a massive sandstone. The stone of this stratum—known as Massillon sandstone—varies considerably in different localities, but much of it affords excellent building material, as well as good grindstone. A light variety of this stone is ground up and the sand used in the manufacture of glass.


THE LIMESTONES


At a distance of from 150 to 200 feet above the Massillon coal (No. 1) occurs the lowest of the two limestone seams which traverse Stark County, as most other coal-bearing sections of the state. Coal No. 3 is sometimes absent, sometimes has a thickness of a few inches, and rarely becomes of economic importance. From twenty-five to fifty feet above it occurs the second limestone coal. This is well developed in Stark


HISTORY OF STARK COUNTY - 11


County and in some cases has considerable value. In the subterranean, rocky ridge, which lies between the valley of the Tuscarawas and the old channel west of Canton, both the limestones referred to, and sometimes both limestone coals, may be seen, the upper one only of workable thickness.


THE FIRE CLAYS


Of late years especially, the limestones of Stark County have been utilized not only for building purposes, but in roadmaking and even for purposes of soil fertilization and reinvigoration, while the fire clays, half a dozen strata of which have been traced through the various carboniferous formations extending to a depth of 700 or 800 feet, have proven of great value. Not a small proportion of the industrial output of the county has come from these strata in the form of brick, and building and paving blocks. To such an extent has this industry grown in Stark and other counties as to retard and, in many instances, to suspend the quarrying of natural building and paving stone.


SOIL INDUSTRIES THE GREATEST


But, when all has been said, the greatest and most enduring material development of the county, based primarily on the products of Nature, has had its origin in the allied industries devoted to agriculture, horticulture and the raising of live stock. As in all new countries, where homes are made, they are always the first activities to be put in motion, the coming chapter is devoted to a record of their founding and growth in Stark County.